You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR inconsistencies
November 22 2026 7.45pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAR inconsistencies


twist Flag Miami, Florida 17 Jun 18 5.25am

So i have watched all the game except Russia/Saudi Arabia.

France got a VAR decision in their favour, and rightly so.
But Argentina had a definate penalty that did not get VAR'd, as did Peru early on in their game.
Both times, replays show absolute penalty.

So, begs the question, what are those 6 guys in ref shirts in front of TV's behind the dugout actually doing ?

 

YT Flag Oxford 17 Jun 18 7.04am

Originally posted by twist

So i have watched all the game except Russia/Saudi Arabia.

France got a VAR decision in their favour, and rightly so.
But Argentina had a definate penalty that did not get VAR'd, as did Peru early on in their game.
Both times, replays show absolute penalty.

So, begs the question, what are those 6 guys in ref shirts in front of TV's behind the dugout actually doing ?

They are doing what is typical of all football officialdom; they are demonstrating incompetence.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Pussay Patrol Flag 17 Jun 18 10.44am

I think the idea is that the ref has ultimate control as they always have done, VAR is only there if the ref did not see an incident clearly enough and needs a second opinion.

I don't wanna see some nobody behind a screen making refereeing decisions, the France penalty was contentious even with VAR so it should be up to the ref, you can't have conflicting opinions

Also I see alot of players remonstrating with refs to look at the replays, that's a road we don't wanna go down, if the ref didn't have the ultimate say, you would see it more often I feel?

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Stuk Flag Top half 17 Jun 18 12.14pm

The biggest gripe I've got about it (until England play no doubt) is the inconsistencies of what people call it. It's V. A. R., not var you pleb Rio Ferdinand.

They both got a penalty anyway, and both missed them, so no big deal. I don't think Argentina should've had one if it's the supposed handball you're referring to?

 


Optimistic as ever

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 17 Jun 18 4.00pm

Milovojevic slapped in the face intentionally. reviewed by VAR, no action. 2 mins later Serbia played barely touches a guys face in play. VAR- booking . No sense

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 17 Jun 18 6.36pm

Maybe the players and their feigning and simulation have to take some of the blame? I am convinced that a lot of players practice "being fouled" and "self fouling" to win a penalty. Ronaldo v Spain: in my opinion no pen. Kane against Lpool, Vardy v Arsenal in Leicester winning season other examples of players tripping themselves.

I have a solution: twofold: pen only if there is a goal scoring chance, bans, and proper bans if repeated, for offenders. VAR to be relentlessly used for reviewing and banning offenders.

Originally posted by twist

So i have watched all the game except Russia/Saudi Arabia.

France got a VAR decision in their favour, and rightly so.
But Argentina had a definate penalty that did not get VAR'd, as did Peru early on in their game.
Both times, replays show absolute penalty.

So, begs the question, what are those 6 guys in ref shirts in front of TV's behind the dugout actually doing ?


 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 17 Jun 18 7.06pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Maybe the players and their feigning and simulation have to take some of the blame? I am convinced that a lot of players practice "being fouled" and "self fouling" to win a penalty. Ronaldo v Spain: in my opinion no pen. Kane against Lpool, Vardy v Arsenal in Leicester winning season other examples of players tripping themselves.

I have a solution: twofold: pen only if there is a goal scoring chance, bans, and proper bans if repeated, for offenders. VAR to be relentlessly used for reviewing and banning offenders.



I agree.

This feigning and diving is awful. France were shocking. Absolutely terrible. It’s cheating. End of.


Edited by BarEagle (17 Jun 2018 7.07pm)

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 18 Jun 18 9.53pm

Two clears penalties tonight. Not too short of all-in-wrestling. VAR working well.......

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 18 Jun 18 10.10pm

Still seems to me a lot of decisions are 50/50 which not sure is what VAR should be for?

One positive has been that is hasn't taken long for decisions to be made or really disrupted he game.

No idea why the Kane fouls weren't given - you can be sure they would be in the Premier league for example.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 19 Jun 18 3.23pm

Originally posted by Stuk

The biggest gripe I've got about it (until England play no doubt) is the inconsistencies of what people call it. It's V. A. R., not var you pleb Rio Ferdinand.

They both got a penalty anyway, and both missed them, so no big deal. I don't think Argentina should've had one if it's the supposed handball you're referring to?

As I was saying. It seems we're not allowed it.

 


Optimistic as ever

matthau Flag South Croydon 20 Jun 18 10.49pm

I can deal with var at the World Cup, what is now starting to irritate me is the constant talk about it from commentators and studio pundits, it’s now more prevalent than the game itself and that to me is damaging. They need to lighten off on the subject a bit now and not spend the whole show treating it as more important than the any goal mouth incidents etc

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 21 Jun 18 8.26am

my look on VAR in the world cup is, the refs you have out there, have had very little experience with the system,not sure but i think we have used it more here than abroad have,
so biggest tournament in the world and we are using it as a training ground not good,
So its not the refs fault for how they use it completely, FIFA have to take the lions share of the blame for using a system that refs are still trying to understand the roll VAR plays in matches

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Jun 18 10.09am

Question on how VAR works.

There seems to be quite a few officials in the VAR room. So what happens if the referee misses a possible penalty?

Who decides to tell the referee to look again? What happens if they disagree amongst themselves? Does it have to be unanimous or is it just one person who makes the call? This might explain why the Harry Kane incident was not referred if the VAR team could not agree amongst themselves?

 


One more point


You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR inconsistencies