You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman signings
November 16 2026 7.06am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Freedman signings


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 23 Jul 18 12.21pm

Not done particularly well have they, sorloth looked as though he may have something, but at Oxford on Saturday he looked of the pace, jaroslaw jach, hardly been seen and now rumoured to be on the move to turkey, and then erdal rakip, what happened to him.?
Anyone who watches the under 21s may have opinions, I would be interested to hear them, and if they think any of these are likely to feature for the first team.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Jul 18 12.39pm

Originally posted by collier row eagle

Not done particularly well have they, sorloth looked as though he may have something, but at Oxford on Saturday he looked of the pace, jaroslaw jach, hardly been seen and now rumoured to be on the move to turkey, and then erdal rakip, what happened to him.?
Anyone who watches the under 21s may have opinions, I would be interested to hear them, and if they think any of these are likely to feature for the first team.

In a way you can make only really scrutinise the Serloth signing as the others were virtually free. If the club decides on bargain basement then it’s not really the scout(s) fault.

 


COYP

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 23 Jul 18 12.51pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

In a way you can make only really scrutinise the Serloth signing as the others were virtually free. If the club decides on bargain basement then it’s not really the scout(s) fault.

DF is the Sporting Director and we have a Chief Scout Tim Coe - its their job to scout and recruit and I cant see much success at the moment. None of the players they have brought in have cut much with Roy who I believe has much more experience in assessing players than these two. Shouldn't have they asked his opinion first??
I can believe we don't have the money. We been in the PL for a few years and have just off loaded a lot of salaries...

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 23 Jul 18 12.54pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
In a way you can make only really scrutinise the Serloth signing as the others were virtually free. If the club decides on bargain basement then it’s not really the scout(s) fault.

I'm the other way round. Its the scouts job. It looks very poor outside looking in.

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 23 Jul 18 1.04pm

Erdal Rakip was only a loan so we can let them off with that one.

They need a rocket up their arse though, perhaps they don't realise the window closes earlier now and they only have two weeks left?

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 23 Jul 18 1.14pm

Of course, there is always the scenario that they are scouting good players but Palace won't pay the money.

 

BelfastEagle Flag 23 Jul 18 1.15pm

Jach was rumoured to have cost £3m not even good enough for the bench.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Jul 18 1.16pm

Originally posted by kevlee

DF is the Sporting Director and we have a Chief Scout Tim Coe - its their job to scout and recruit and I cant see much success at the moment. None of the players they have brought in have cut much with Roy who I believe has much more experience in assessing players than these two. Shouldn't have they asked his opinion first??
I can believe we don't have the money. We been in the PL for a few years and have just off loaded a lot of salaries...

It’s not that we have no money. More that we can’t and aren’t going to completely replace salaries recently removed with an equal total coming in. Same with transfers. We won’t be spending £45 mil or close to it. This has been done to death on other threads.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Jul 18 1.17pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

Of course, there is always the scenario that they are scouting good players but Palace won't pay the money.

Yep.

 


COYP

FairweatherEagle Flag London 23 Jul 18 1.22pm

How many good signings have we made under Coe, do people rate him? Have not got a great impression of him, but maybe that's wrong.....

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 23 Jul 18 1.23pm

Sørloth was talked up by Roy when he was signed.

Seemed at the time that one was a Roy signing...

Although granted the others haven’t done any good either..

 

Jacey Flag 23 Jul 18 1.24pm

Originally posted by BelfastEagle

Jach was rumoured to have cost £3m not even good enough for the bench.

Jach is apparently off to Turkey having failed to make the grade and Sorloth needs Roy to work his considerable talents to mould him into something resembling a Premiership striker.

Time will tell if he will succeed at this level.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 23 Jul 18 1.25pm

January was a very strange transfer window, mainly bcos the official statements from the club did not match their actions - clearly wages have got a bit out of control and they spent big when Sam kept us up and needed to rein spending in - if they'd explained that big emergency spending was not viable given that the squad would improve enough once injured players returned, fine. But all the noises were that we were going to get front line players in while we had that mammoth injury crisis. Two of the three who came in were clearly not Roy's choice (Rakip and Jach) and if you include Sorloth that was three players brought in ready-made for a season in the Championship. It doesn't look like they're all singing from the same hymn sheet, the unstable nature of the market makes it difficult to predict and prepare so a bit of leeway needs to be allowed, and Roy's said money's tight - hopefully we can get a half decent midfielder in along with the return of Loftus Cheek and we'll be OK - add Antonio to that and we'd be positively thriving. Freedman showed what a good football brain he has when he was our rookie manager, but I get the feeling that he doesn't work that well with Roy - something does not quite add up, probably money's a bit tighter than the board like to admit and we're just trying to stay in the prem for three or four seasons before the new stand is up and paid for and then we can talk of mid-table seasons instead of constant surival battles, which for us would be that dangerous concept: 'the next level'.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 23 Jul 18 1.39pm

Originally posted by steven_t92

Erdal Rakip was only a loan so we can let them off with that one.

They need a rocket up their arse though, perhaps they don't realise the window closes earlier now and they only have two weeks left?

Haha, that rocket needs to go up the arse of Parish, Steve. Parish knows when the window closes as that is the day he actually signs players now.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 23 Jul 18 1.43pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Jach is apparently off to Turkey having failed to make the grade and Sorloth needs Roy to work his considerable talents to mould him into something resembling a Premiership striker.

Time will tell if he will succeed at this level.

There needs to be a steward's enquiry on what on earth we were doing signing this player. Can we not loan this guy out in case our scouts are actually worth their salt (and he actually can play).

He has looked awful. Why did we sign this guy?

Rakip, Sorloth and Jach. What a window.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

KAOS Flag In a tree 23 Jul 18 2.05pm

We had to bring in someone to appease the masses and that's as good as we could do at the time. Thank Christ Wilf recovered from his injury otherwise we'd be watching these 3 stooges every week in the championship! Be thankful ... lol

The main stand is going to compromise transfer dealings for the next few seasons. Bigger clubs than us have done the same in pursuit of developing their grounds so we just have to take it on the chin and take our chances. Luckily we have a cunning old fox in uncle Roy and if anyone can sail us through choppy waters in the next 24 months, it's him!

As for DF's scouting ability ....
I wouldn't trust him to make me a cup of tea let along anything else when it comes to CPFC! He's an odd one ...

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 23 Jul 18 2.11pm

While in the Premier League, the only successful signing we've made from outside England is Luka (and Cabaye, though of course he had already played in the Premier League).* Our whole scouting department seems almost entirely useless if we struggle this badly to find anyone who hasn't already clearly established themselves in the Premier League.

*And the only other player who might arguably be called a success is Souare, who has never convinced me of his ability to be a first-choice PL left-back.

 

Jacey Flag 23 Jul 18 2.43pm

Originally posted by KAOS

We had to bring in someone to appease the masses and that's as good as we could do at the time. Thank Christ Wilf recovered from his injury otherwise we'd be watching these 3 stooges every week in the championship! Be thankful ... lol

The main stand is going to compromise transfer dealings for the next few seasons. Bigger clubs than us have done the same in pursuit of developing their grounds so we just have to take it on the chin and take our chances. Luckily we have a cunning old fox in uncle Roy and if anyone can sail us through choppy waters in the next 24 months, it's him!

As for DF's scouting ability ....
I wouldn't trust him to make me a cup of tea let along anything else when it comes to CPFC! He's an odd one ...

In all fairness to Dougie, he unearthed and signed some incredible players for us while in the Championship,which provided the basis of the squad that was promoted to the top tier a few years back.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 23 Jul 18 2.51pm

As I recently posted on another thread - 6 consecutive seasons in the Premier League and yet nothing seems to have improved in the scouting of players.

Add to that the consistent difficulty in doing transfer business in a timely fashion.


DF claimed that Sorloth was Roy's original target on the day the window opened in January, but even that deal was only done at the very last minute.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Mr Fenandes Flag 23 Jul 18 2.56pm

Originally posted by Jacey

In all fairness to Dougie, he unearthed and signed some incredible players for us while in the Championship,which provided the basis of the squad that was promoted to the top tier a few years back.

Bolasie! Best bit of business since the Clinton Morrison/Andy Johnson deal (which I still find amazing that turned out to be the deal it did, especially buying CM back for half the price a couple of years later... slightly off subject)

 


Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'!
All episodes available FREE here: [Link]

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman signings