This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Striker options for the new season
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
PatrickA London 25 Jul 18 3.39am |
|
|
We go into the new season with question marks over all three centre forwards, 1) Benteke doesn’t seem to suit Roy’s narrow 4-4-2 formation which requires mobile strikers that will close down defenders and run the channels 2) Wickham has not featured in the pre season games and looks some way off a first team return.I can’t see him back in the early weeks of the season as a minimum 3) It’s early days but Sorloth looks short at this level. It would not be a surprise if Roy starts the season with how he finished last season with Zaha and Townsend up front, in particular if another midfielder is brought in. This may be ok short term but is not sustainable over the season.
|
Palace Hero Melbourne, Australia 25 Jul 18 7.26am |
|
|
If it is okay over the short term, why isn't it sustainable over a season?
Perhaps Zaha carries his end product from last season into the next as a striker and forms an effective partnership with Townsend. With Benteke adding depth to the forward ranks and some good luck with fitness/signings, perhaps this is the way forward.
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 25 Jul 18 7.59am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
We go into the new season with question marks over all three centre forwards, 1) Benteke doesn’t seem to suit Roy’s narrow 4-4-2 formation which requires mobile strikers that will close down defenders and run the channels 2) Wickham has not featured in the pre season games and looks some way off a first team return.I can’t see him back in the early weeks of the season as a minimum 3) It’s early days but Sorloth looks short at this level. It would not be a surprise if Roy starts the season with how he finished last season with Zaha and Townsend up front, in particular if another midfielder is brought in. This may be ok short term but is not sustainable over the season.
Why is this formation not sustainable going forward. I thought it resulted in some of the best football I have ever seen played by a Palace team in the near 50 years I have been watching. Let’s also see who we bring in.
|
Woolsy Essex 25 Jul 18 9.28am |
|
|
Keep the formation, just sell Benteke and buy/loan another striker or two - simples!
|
Bangell Oxford 25 Jul 18 9.49am |
|
|
I agree that our striker options aren't good enough, especially with something approaching 50m and 200k p/w in wages spent on the three.
|
Pete53 Hassocks 25 Jul 18 12.38pm |
|
|
I still fear Wilf will move on (I pray he doesn't) which means the Zaha/Townsend option up front has gone.
That leaves the cupboard rather bare, unless we get someone new in, or, Tekkers ups his game and Sorloth turns out to be the new Murray, neither of which I would put much money on. At this stage I see no point in even bringing Wickham into the equation.
Of course if Wilf stays then things look rosier...
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 25 Jul 18 12.51pm |
|
|
Our form was great at the end of last season. Dabbling is the last thing we want to do unless we don't have suitable players to play this way. Hoping to see this come through this season like Pards first 2 seasons (but without the shocking decline in the 2nd part of the season). A full season not struggling would be great, something that hasn't really happened since we have returned to the PL.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
pompeyeagle Relocated to Shropshire 26 Jul 18 8.44pm |
|
|
I thought Daly was getting close to making a breakthrough last season. What happened to him? I’m guessing he hasn’t lived up to expectations.
|
PatrickA London 27 Jul 18 7.20am |
|
|
The Townsend/Zaha combination did work at times last season and the football played by the team was good. However, two key components of that team (Loftus-Cheek and Cabaye ) are not at the club. Cabaye was essential for his linking of the play with fellow midfielders and ball retention. Loftus Cheek gave the team a lot of attacking power and skill coming in from the left and linked very well with Zaha and PVA. I don’t think the system would work as well without this quality or players of equivalent ability. Furthermore, Townsend is willing but does not convince as a striker or look a goalscoring threat. The central point remains that in the current squad a lot more is going to be required from Benteke,Sorloth or Wickham.
|
michaelpearce grays 27 Jul 18 7.54am |
|
Originally posted by pompeyeagle
I thought Daly was getting close to making a breakthrough last season. What happened to him? I’m guessing he hasn’t lived up to expectations.
he is only 18 give him chance he maybe another little gem
|
Eaglecoops CR3 27 Jul 18 8.53am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
The Townsend/Zaha combination did work at times last season and the football played by the team was good. However, two key components of that team (Loftus-Cheek and Cabaye ) are not at the club. Cabaye was essential for his linking of the play with fellow midfielders and ball retention. Loftus Cheek gave the team a lot of attacking power and skill coming in from the left and linked very well with Zaha and PVA. I don’t think the system would work as well without this quality or players of equivalent ability. Furthermore, Townsend is willing but does not convince as a striker or look a goalscoring threat. The central point remains that in the current squad a lot more is going to be required from Benteke,Sorloth or Wickham.
I might be amongst the minority here but I thought RLC didn't bring huge amounts to the team last year even though he looked superb at times. He certainly isn't as big a loss as Cabaye whose contribution can't be overstated. I know his legs were starting to go last year but he was still a class player.
I don't have too many worries about our forward line and believe Jimmy Mc or at a push Schlupp can play in RLCs role but I am worried about our central midfield. We need Drinkwater on loan and we need to buy another 1 or 2 central midfielders, perhaps the two Max's that are available or Kouyate. If you look at the games we struggled in last year it was when Cabaye went off or got tired and there wasn't enough strength in the middle of the park. We have full backs in AWB and PVA who when linking up with Zaha/Townsend will frighten any PL defence but we MUST shore up the midfield.
|
Palace03 27 Jul 18 9.01am |
|
|
What about Kaikai? Has been banging them in over pre season, give him a shot! And Schlupp has played as I striker before with Leicester! Why not give him a go if need be! Sell Benteke, just doesn’t try enough, don’t mind rubbish players even if they still try! I reckon Sorloth will come good tho! Maybe not world class, but when have we ever been that really?
|
Frickin Saweet South Cronx 27 Jul 18 11.00am |
|
Originally posted by Bexley Eagle
Why is this formation not sustainable going forward. I thought it resulted in some of the best football I have ever seen played by a Palace team in the near 50 years I have been watching. Let’s also see who we bring in.
If playing without a recognised striker is the next 'thing' in football then Roy is lightyears ahead of Pep and co, who are still favouring centre forwards. Gosh what dinosaurs. It may have produced some great football, but it's sad that we have to resort to a makeshift system because we can't sort out our well-known personnel issues.
|
YT Oxford 27 Jul 18 11.17am |
|
|
Striker options:
Option 1. Convey ‘exhibit a’ (ball) in to ‘exhibit b’ (onion bag) and everyone will be happy,
Option 2. Fail to convey exhibit a in to exhibit b and everyone will be unhappy, but you won’t be dropped (all that much) because the alternatives are either injured or are even worse than you are.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
dp Tunbridge Wells 27 Jul 18 11.28am |
|
|
I reckon that teams will learn to play against the no strikers tactic before too long. So I agree that this is not sustainable in the long term.
I also reckon that we will sign another striker before too long, and Benteke will come good this season.
So no need for doom and gloom.
|
Terry Ven 27 Jul 18 2.48pm |
|
Originally posted by dp
come off it my granny has got better ball comtrol than benteke has how many times did we see him put threw on goal last season only to see the ball bounce off him and he is as slow as my gran to!
I reckon that teams will learn to play against the no strikers tactic before too long. So I agree that this is not sustainable in the long term.
I also reckon that we will sign another striker before too long, and Benteke will come good this season.
So no need for doom and gloom.
|
YT Oxford 27 Jul 18 2.50pm |
|
|
Terry Ven, is your gran under contract, and what are her wage demands likely to be?
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
Goldfiinger Just down the road 31 Jul 18 9.06pm |
|
|
Options are:
Zaha Wickham Kaikai Sørloth Benteke
Zaha is already on fire and looking to carry his end of season form in to the new year.
Wickham appears to have his worse days behind him.
Kaikai is scoring for fun so should definitely make the squad.
Sørloth got a goal and some good words from Wilf after about effective partnership forming.
Benteke is Benteke...
I’d rather stick with those 5 than take a loan and help finish someone else player.
Get the midfield right and these 5 should be left to fight it out between them I say.
|
pssguy 31 Jul 18 9.44pm |
|
|
It will be interesting to see if they start Wickham against Toulouse after what sounds like a good hour in the Boreham Wood game
Hard to see any of Sorloth, Wickham or Benteke lasting the full 90 minutes against Fulham
|
pompeyeagle Relocated to Shropshire 31 Jul 18 10.26pm |
|
Originally posted by Goldfiinger
Options are:
Zaha Wickham Kaikai Sørloth Benteke
Zaha is already on fire and looking to carry his end of season form in to the new year.
Wickham appears to have his worse days behind him.
Kaikai is scoring for fun so should definitely make the squad.
Sørloth got a goal and some good words from Wilf after about effective partnership forming.
Benteke is Benteke...
I’d rather stick with those 5 than take a loan and help finish someone else player.
Get the midfield right and these 5 should be left to fight it out between them I say.
Totally agree. There’s no point spending money on any more strikers, we’ve got enough already.
|