You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Quality of commentary and punditry
November 22 2026 7.45pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Quality of commentary and punditry


PatrickA Flag London 19 Aug 18 1.43pm

I should start by stating that I am an older supporter and long term football fan, so perhaps my view could be deemed old fashioned.
However, I am dismayed by the deterioration of quality in commentary and punditry in media outlets.
I remember commentators such as Peter Jones and Mike Ingham who were serious, informative and knowledgeable.
Now everybody wants to be a comedian, indulge in ‘banter’and the match itself is almost a sideshow.
So many ex footballers seem to have taken a career in the media as an easy living but don’t offer any added value and they can’t be objective for fear of criticising ex teammates.
It’s got to the stage where I have to watch with the sound down and skip the punditry sections.

 

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 19 Aug 18 5.46pm

As soon as I saw the title of your topic I thought of Peter Jones, a great commentator. Others who I remember on the radio, not necessarily the commentator but worked beside them are Jimmy Armfield & Bryon Butler but where both great at what they did.

I haven't listened to a football match on the radio for a while, just bits & pieces of it.

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

the.universal 19 Aug 18 5.51pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I should start by stating that I am an older supporter and long term football fan, so perhaps my view could be deemed old fashioned.
However, I am dismayed by the deterioration of quality in commentary and punditry in media outlets.
I remember commentators such as Peter Jones and Mike Ingham who were serious, informative and knowledgeable.
Now everybody wants to be a comedian, indulge in ‘banter’and the match itself is almost a sideshow.
So many ex footballers seem to have taken a career in the media as an easy living but don’t offer any added value and they can’t be objective for fear of criticising ex teammates.
It’s got to the stage where I have to watch with the sound down and skip the punditry sections.

Personally I think punditry has come on leaps and bounds within only the last 5 years or so. Neville has taken it to the next level.

Commentary for me is much the same as it ever was.

 


Vive le Roy!

chris123 Flag hove actually 19 Aug 18 5.54pm

I agree - the only sport I still really enjoy listening to is the cricket on Sky or TMS.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 20 Aug 18 10.14am

The post match analysis on Match of the Day is like listening to paint dry

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford


You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Quality of commentary and punditry