You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Change of formation?
November 16 2026 6.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Change of formation?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
SamCPFC17 Flag Croydon 26 Aug 18 9.29pm

Back from the game - really didn't think we were too bad, just far too profligate in front of goal.
However, I'm really beginning to think that with Meyer & Kouyate signed (and Loftus-Cheek no longer around), we should switch back to a 4-3-3.
Having Loftus-Cheek out on the left last season meant that we had a really potent attacking threat which Schlupp, as hard as he does work, just can't provide. We looked far more dangerous when we did eventually switch to a 4-3-3 for the last 20 mins, with Zaha & Townsend off Benteke, and Meyer, Luka & Macca in the middle - maybe we should start like this next week against the Saints?

 

PatrickA Flag London 26 Aug 18 9.38pm

I agree and many of the fans I know also would support this.
Don’t think it will happen as Roy likes a narrow 4 in midfield to avoid being outnumbered there and when attacking he tends to use the full backs to provide width.
I think 4-3-3 could help Benteke( or whoever was the central striker) but it would mean Wilf would have to track back more.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 26 Aug 18 10.06pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I agree and many of the fans I know also would support this.
Don’t think it will happen as Roy likes a narrow 4 in midfield to avoid being outnumbered there and when attacking he tends to use the full backs to provide width.
I think 4-3-3 could help Benteke( or whoever was the central striker) but it would mean Wilf would have to track back more.

I guess it all comes down to who the opposition is and how they are setting up. We did look more effective in the last 20 mins with a 4 3 3
but they were defending a lead at that point so their mind set had changed. It is not that simple as phases of the game changes the requirements of the play. I do think a front three will suite Benteke and whilst it is easy to criticise him in fairness he is not getting the service. I think our squad this season is going to enable us to change our formations and styles in a more effective way than last season so I am hopeful of a more effective season. cOYP

 

The Royster7 Flag Peterborough 26 Aug 18 10.15pm

Why oh why is Hennesey still between the sticks. He spends most of his time when threatened fluffing around and very rarely makes solid decisions. A howler for the second goal and generally the defence is back to early 17/18 season. Oh how we missed Wan Bisaka,m he is a shining light for the Eagles who will, I am afraid continue to have their wings clipped. Up Front, Benteke is still a waste of good cash. I don't rate him at all for the price. Ih while i'm at it. Wickham ? I'm guessing he'll have an arm problem next. He's hurt everything else and not played for 2 seasons. Is he still being paid?

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 26 Aug 18 11.01pm

I agree, you have to use the players you have in the formation which suits them. At the moment it feels like square pegs in round holes. Get wilf back on the wing and Meyer in midfield with luka and macc.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 26 Aug 18 11.34pm

The problem is that 4-3-3 puts a lot of responsibility on the central striker, and Benteke and Sorloth don't look capable of shouldering that responsibility.

I think Meyer will simply take Schlupp's place on the left side of a narrow 4.

 

SamCPFC17 Flag Croydon 26 Aug 18 11.40pm

Originally posted by Bangell

The problem is that 4-3-3 puts a lot of responsibility on the central striker, and Benteke and Sorloth don't look capable of shouldering that responsibility.

I think Meyer will simply take Schlupp's place on the left side of a narrow 4.

Yeah I agree this is more likely - I guess Roy only really wants us to go 4-3-3 if we're behind in games

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Aug 18 12.09am

Don't think for a moment he would deploy it but there is the possibility of going 3-5-2 with Kelly,Sakho and Tomkins as the back three, AWB and PVA as wing backs,Milivojevic,McArthur and Meyer in midfield and a combination of Zaha/Townsend/Ayew as the front pairing.
No Benteke !

Edited by Willo (27 Aug 2018 12.11am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Aug 18 12.11am

.

Edited by Willo (27 Aug 2018 12.12am)

 

sprites Flag Auckland 27 Aug 18 5.27am

Originally posted by The Royster7

Why oh why is Hennesey still between the sticks. He spends most of his time when threatened fluffing around and very rarely makes solid decisions. A howler for the second goal and generally the defence is back to early 17/18 season. Oh how we missed Wan Bisaka,m he is a shining light for the Eagles who will, I am afraid continue to have their wings clipped. Up Front, Benteke is still a waste of good cash. I don't rate him at all for the price. Ih while i'm at it. Wickham ? I'm guessing he'll have an arm problem next. He's hurt everything else and not played for 2 seasons. Is he still being paid?

Hennesey's been mustard for about 10 games now.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 27 Aug 18 9.33am

almost all our best performances last season came with Wilf and Andros up front but we seem to have forgotten this. we have enough midfield options to revert to this.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Chubskip Flag 27 Aug 18 10.59am

Our problem still rests with our inability to keep regular clean sheets. We remain weak down our right side without WBS and Tompkins. We need to reinforce the defence as we seem to lose defenders to injury to regularly. Ward and Kelly playing together weaken our defence as they are not good enough to start. So changing the system may not be sufficient if we defend as poorly as we did for their two goals Sunday.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 27 Aug 18 11.50am

Blimey, we loose 2 games on the trot, one against a very good liverpool, and one that we should have been 2=0 up af half time, then we're beaten by a freak goal, and suddenly we need to change the formation.
What we need is too bring in the players we bought. We need more creativity through told middle - meyer, we need a big strong box to box midfielder - Kouyate, and most if all we need a centre forward who csn put thd ball in the back of thd bet - Ayew.
Personally I think if you put thsee 3 into our formation, well have one hell of z team

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 27 Aug 18 12.14pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Blimey, we loose 2 games on the trot, one against a very good liverpool, and one that we should have been 2=0 up af half time, then we're beaten by a freak goal, and suddenly we need to change the formation.
What we need is too bring in the players we bought. We need more creativity through told middle - meyer, we need a big strong box to box midfielder - Kouyate, and most if all we need a centre forward who csn put thd ball in the back of thd bet - Ayew.
Personally I think if you put thsee 3 into our formation, well have one hell of z team

Bang on, decent striker 1-0 in the 1st half and the Hornets would of had to start thinking. I'm really hoping that Tekkers and Roy isn't another Puncheon and Pards scenario.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 29 Aug 18 6.53am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

almost all our best performances last season came with Wilf and Andros up front but we seem to have forgotten this. we have enough midfield options to revert to this.

^^^
This...with bells on. Brighton, Leicester et al.

 


Spirit of 1974

Xchurch Eagle Flag Christchurch 29 Aug 18 10.11am

Originally posted by SamCPFC17

Back from the game - really didn't think we were too bad, just far too profligate in front of goal.
However, I'm really beginning to think that with Meyer & Kouyate signed (and Loftus-Cheek no longer around), we should switch back to a 4-3-3.
Having Loftus-Cheek out on the left last season meant that we had a really potent attacking threat which Schlupp, as hard as he does work, just can't provide. We looked far more dangerous when we did eventually switch to a 4-3-3 for the last 20 mins, with Zaha & Townsend off Benteke, and Meyer, Luka & Macca in the middle - maybe we should start like this next week against the Saints?

Agree the change of formation allowed us to bring Meyer into the fold who took up a similar position how Punch used to. I think we actually wen 4-2-3-1, which for me is how we should start again on Saturday.

GK Hennesey
RB AWB
CB Sakho
CB Kelly
LB PVA
CM Mili
CM Macca
LW Townsend
AMC Meyer
RW Zaha
CF Benteke


 


Hopkin looks to curl one!

Mstrobez Flag 29 Aug 18 10.34am

I think what people miss in this constant desire for a change of formation, and for Wilf to be back wide, is that Roy’s 442 is an extremely versatile system and often changes throughout the course of a game. The 442 is only rigid in a defensive sense, and I personally think it’s spot on when we’re defending.

The reason Wilf plays as a “forward”, and I use the word “forward” rather than “striker” as he has the freedom to move all accross the front line, is to free him of the shackles of defensive responsibility and allow him to just focus on attacking. This is 100% the right idea when it comes to Wilf, even if he should be drifting wide more often against certain opposition. He had the same issues centrally last year against Watford at home.

How many times last season did we see Townsend start on the right and RLC on the left of the 4. But when we were in attacking scenarios, Townsend advanced into an attacking right winger, Wilf drifted left and RLC shifted more centrally. That was a fundamental premise of Roys system. So effectively in attacks we were playing 4-3-3 a lot of the time anyway.

It’s also the reason I think Meyer should take RLC’s spot in the team and not Cabaye’s. Because in attacks we need him to act as the creative midfielder in the side, as opposed to the defensive engine Cabaye was converted to in his later years.

I think people are getting too bogged down on formations and Wilfs “position”, when the reality is the team and Wilf have the freedom to rotate throughout the game anyway. The problem may be, that in certain games, Wilf isn’t drifting away from the centre often enough. But I for one don’t want to see the days return of Wilf having to track back 50 yards every time the opposition attacks. His days as a defensive winger are over, he’s too good for his game to to be restricted by rigidness and defensive responsibility. He’s our main man.

Edited by Mstrobez (29 Aug 2018 10.37am)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 29 Aug 18 11.21am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I think what people miss in this constant desire for a change of formation, and for Wilf to be back wide, is that Roy’s 442 is an extremely versatile system and often changes throughout the course of a game. The 442 is only rigid in a defensive sense, and I personally think it’s spot on when we’re defending.

The reason Wilf plays as a “forward”, and I use the word “forward” rather than “striker” as he has the freedom to move all accross the front line, is to free him of the shackles of defensive responsibility and allow him to just focus on attacking. This is 100% the right idea when it comes to Wilf, even if he should be drifting wide more often against certain opposition. He had the same issues centrally last year against Watford at home.

How many times last season did we see Townsend start on the right and RLC on the left of the 4. But when we were in attacking scenarios, Townsend advanced into an attacking right winger, Wilf drifted left and RLC shifted more centrally. That was a fundamental premise of Roys system. So effectively in attacks we were playing 4-3-3 a lot of the time anyway.

It’s also the reason I think Meyer should take RLC’s spot in the team and not Cabaye’s. Because in attacks we need him to act as the creative midfielder in the side, as opposed to the defensive engine Cabaye was converted to in his later years.

I think people are getting too bogged down on formations and Wilfs “position”, when the reality is the team and Wilf have the freedom to rotate throughout the game anyway. The problem may be, that in certain games, Wilf isn’t drifting away from the centre often enough. But I for one don’t want to see the days return of Wilf having to track back 50 yards every time the opposition attacks. His days as a defensive winger are over, he’s too good for his game to to be restricted by rigidness and defensive responsibility. He’s our main man.

Edited by Mstrobez (29 Aug 2018 10.37am)

433 or 451, however people choose to view it, gives us a midfielder to cover behind Wilf or Andros anyway. It's still our best formation but Roy won't change it permanently until he's confident with it.

 

The_postman Flag Forest Row 29 Aug 18 11.26am

Agreed. Roy likes to deploy two blocks of 4 when defending with the front 2 applying a press. With the ball, Townsend pushes forward effectively making it a front 3. Schlupp stays narrow to keep contact with Luka and Jimmy Mac. The width on the left is provided by PVA bombing forward to provide crosses or link up with Wilf. I think that replacing Schlupp with Meyer will improve our transition from defending to counter-attacking as he has a better passing range and like RLC, he keeps the ball well.

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 29 Aug 18 11.29am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

<snip>

Bang on. Formations are very fluid during games, especially in attack. They are only rigid in defence, because that's where they need to be for clarity's sake.

 


[Link]

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Change of formation?