You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > No better than Charlton
November 16 2026 6.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

No better than Charlton


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
laddo Flag london 07 Oct 18 8.07am

We're all guilty of this. Back in early 2000s Charlton had a great run in the top flight. The man who got them there (Alan Curbishley) built a solid squad who more than held their own. As a palace fan, watching their successes was a tough pill to swallow.

However, their fans started to get itchy feet. They wanted European football. They wanted progress. They hounded Curbishley out and within a few years their dream became a nightmare.

Quite frankly, we're in danger of doing the same. There is no such thing as mid-table mediocrity in the premier league, if you're playing in one of, if not the best, leagues in the world, just being part of the party is decent.

We all want to see the club progress but this staleness at the minute can also be pointed to our inflated expectations. I'm very worried about this season but think we're all responsible quite frankly,

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 07 Oct 18 8.27am

Sorry Laddi but don't agree, if Eiropean football comes about through progress then we deal with it and the increased revenue it brings which, hopefully would be re-invested in new players.
Based on where we finished last season, we should have kicked on this campaign. We haven't and why?
No replacement for RLC who was a key part of our midfield and Meyer has yet to show that he is the one taking over from Cabaye.
No out and out goal scoring centre forward with too much reliance on Zaha. Desparately short of quality centre half cover.
All this adding up to a very underwhelming start, sorry but should be a Selhurst Park fortress and it is clearly not. We have lost our way and we only have ourselves to blame and by this our ambition with the players to match, one poor example being Ayew. In this division you cannot simply scrape by, money needs to be spent as Wolves showed the results of yesterday. Must shake off the "little old Palace mentality" and set the bar high.

 


Bring back Brolin

laddo Flag london 07 Oct 18 8.38am

Which is exactly what Charlton fans were saying.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

palace chick Flag South Croydon 07 Oct 18 8.40am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Sorry Laddi but don't agree, if Eiropean football comes about through progress then we deal with it and the increased revenue it brings which, hopefully would be re-invested in new players.
Based on where we finished last season, we should have kicked on this campaign. We haven't and why?
No replacement for RLC who was a key part of our midfield and Meyer has yet to show that he is the one taking over from Cabaye.
No out and out goal scoring centre forward with too much reliance on Zaha. Desparately short of quality centre half cover.
All this adding up to a very underwhelming start, sorry but should be a Selhurst Park fortress and it is clearly not. We have lost our way and we only have ourselves to blame and by this our ambition with the players to match, one poor example being Ayew. In this division you cannot simply scrape by, money needs to be spent as Wolves showed the results of yesterday. Must shake off the "little old Palace mentality" and set the bar high.

Think I agree more with this than the first comment. I’m certainly not wanting Hodgson out like Charlton did with Curbishley. However, by not spending more on quality players to replace Cabaye/Cheek with have gone backwards. We are now struggling because those that came up other than Cardiff have spent big and are better than us. I see only Huddersfield and Cardiff being rightly below us. Newcastle might be equal with us as 3rd from bottom material? If you want to stay in this league you have to keep up with the others around the mid table who spend to stay in this division. Plus you need confidence in the team and organisation when playing against stronger teams/squads to pull off unexpected results. We lack this as well at this time. Hopefully that will change and we have a better than recent times transfer window in January?

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 07 Oct 18 9.09am

keep reading we havent replaced Cabaye or RLC
one Meyer comes in to replace one of them younger for older, as for Rlc he was a loan player who done well, ,tell me were we can buy a replacement for him without paying over 30 million because thats what he his worth

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 07 Oct 18 9.30am

Mentioned on the TV last night that we need to buy in the Jan window to survive in the PL. When have we heard that before?

Need to get the best out of the players we have who draw their big pay cheques whether they are pi$$ poor or not. They ARE currently pi$$ poor!

So for starters, how about investing in some coaching staff who really do know what they're doing and can get our players playing to their full potential?

Edited by Henry of Peckham (07 Oct 2018 9.44am)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Oct 18 9.50am

Originally posted by laddo

Which is exactly what Charlton fans were saying.

And what Steve Parish himself has said.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

SwordFish Flag Peasmarsh,East Sussex 07 Oct 18 9.57am

Originally posted by laddo

We're all guilty of this. Back in early 2000s Charlton had a great run in the top flight. The man who got them there (Alan Curbishley) built a solid squad who more than held their own. As a palace fan, watching their successes was a tough pill to swallow.

However, their fans started to get itchy feet. They wanted European football. They wanted progress. They hounded Curbishley out and within a few years their dream became a nightmare.

Quite frankly, we're in danger of doing the same. There is no such thing as mid-table mediocrity in the premier league, if you're playing in one of, if not the best, leagues in the world, just being part of the party is decent.

We all want to see the club progress but this staleness at the minute can also be pointed to our inflated expectations. I'm very worried about this season but think we're all responsible quite frankly,

Top post laddo totally agree.
I’ve never witnessed so much drivel from our supporters it’s quite frankly embarrassing expecting and demanding more. One day, we will get relegated and these idiots will go back to following the big 6 on their sofas week in week out and we will have 14000 die hard supporters and selhurst again, I’m starting to miss that,

Edited by SwordFish (07 Oct 2018 9.58am)

 


“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Oct 18 10.05am

Every season the primary ambition for the club is to retain it's place in the Premier League - the race to 40 points if you like. Anything else is a bonus.

I have no issue with that and nor do most Palace fans that I know.

'' mid table mediocrity '' - bring it on !

It would just be more enjoyable if that can be attained without the annual battle to achieve it. Indeed that was the club's stated ambition this season. Already that is looking beyond us.


 


Old, Ungifted and White

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 07 Oct 18 10.12am

Look at stoke and West Brom getting relegated!! Who would’ve thought they would’ve gone down, they both seemed to have got themselves established with fairly high finishes, especially stoke.Swansea had a good side for a year or two and ended up slipping through the trap door because they started looking up and stopped concentrating on staying in the division

No-one outside the big 6 is safe, in my opinion we should always be concentrating on staying up and if we click and have a decent season then it’s a bonus, then we just start again next season with the same mentality, just geting to the 40 points mark is still a good season for us, especially how things are now.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 07 Oct 18 11.00am

Originally posted by monkey

Look at stoke and West Brom getting relegated!! Who would’ve thought they would’ve gone down, they both seemed to have got themselves established with fairly high finishes, especially stoke.Swansea had a good side for a year or two and ended up slipping through the trap door because they started looking up and stopped concentrating on staying in the division

No-one outside the big 6 is safe, in my opinion we should always be concentrating on staying up and if we click and have a decent season then it’s a bonus, then we just start again next season with the same mentality, just geting to the 40 points mark is still a good season for us, especially how things are now.

Totally agree with this. This time last year, we had three points and Stoke, Swansea and West Brom all had 8-10 points and would have been looking forward to thinking about how high they might be able to finish.

The one certainty is that there is no certainty who will be relegated right now. I am certain that Roy will be looking at staying up as a priority and anything else will be a bonus, and it is really wearing how (yet again) many posters are relegating us already.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 07 Oct 18 11.16am

Originally posted by dp

Totally agree with this. This time last year, we had three points and Stoke, Swansea and West Brom all had 8-10 points and would have been looking forward to thinking about how high they might be able to finish.

The one certainty is that there is no certainty who will be relegated right now. I am certain that Roy will be looking at staying up as a priority and anything else will be a bonus, and it is really wearing how (yet again) many posters are relegating us already.

we’ve blown our chance of getting a few points on the board before our run against the big boys, but we only had 5 points going into our home game v stoke at the end of November last season, and with Huddersfield, Newcastle and Cardiff all without a win, we ain’t down yet!!!

Edited by monkey (07 Oct 2018 11.17am)

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 07 Oct 18 12.17pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Every season the primary ambition for the club is to retain it's place in the Premier League - the race to 40 points if you like. Anything else is a bonus.

I have no issue with that and nor do most Palace fans that I know.

'' mid table mediocrity '' - bring it on !

It would just be more enjoyable if that can be attained without the annual battle to achieve it. Indeed that was the club's stated ambition this season. Already that is looking beyond us.

In all my time supporting this club, I can scarcely remember a season when there wasn't at least some degree of anxiety involved. This season is turning out to be no different.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 07 Oct 18 12.46pm

Originally posted by SwordFish

Top post laddo totally agree.
I’ve never witnessed so much drivel from our supporters it’s quite frankly embarrassing expecting and demanding more. One day, we will get relegated and these idiots will go back to following the big 6 on their sofas week in week out and we will have 14000 die hard supporters and selhurst again, I’m starting to miss that,

Edited by SwordFish (07 Oct 2018 9.58am)

Its about time you learned not to generalize, not ALL supporters talk drivel. and not ALL are idiots. your insulting thousands of intelligent and rational supporters,

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 07 Oct 18 1.03pm

Originally posted by monkey

Look at stoke and West Brom getting relegated!! Who would’ve thought they would’ve gone down, they both seemed to have got themselves established with fairly high finishes, especially stoke.Swansea had a good side for a year or two and ended up slipping through the trap door because they started looking up and stopped concentrating on staying in the division

No-one outside the big 6 is safe, in my opinion we should always be concentrating on staying up and if we click and have a decent season then it’s a bonus, then we just start again next season with the same mentality, just geting to the 40 points mark is still a good season for us, especially how things are now.

Not entirely correct. They sold/lost their best players and failed to fill them. If we are struggling to fill the midfielders boots at the moment dread to think how we could manage if Wilf goes.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

KAOS Flag In a tree 08 Oct 18 3.59pm

Not as easy as it sounds, buying a quality forward ... especially when you have the redevelopment of the Main Stand looming at 100 million +

We've spent a fair bit on transfers and wages but just chosen badly and been sold a donkey here & there ... we took our chances and are now regretting some of them.

Every season in this division will be a struggle for Palace until we get some rich investors like Wolves. The Yanks have stumped up some cash but not to the level some of us might have expected. Perhaps if we didn't have plans for the main stand we'd see more investment in the squad but we can't expect it all ...

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 08 Oct 18 4.39pm

People are annoyed that the performances this season aren't measuring up to those of last season or the potential of the squad. I haven't heard anyone calling for Roy to be sacked or demanding European football - mainly just anxiety that we're not picking up enough points or playing well enough to attain survival.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 08 Oct 18 4.46pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Not as easy as it sounds, buying a quality forward ... especially when you have the redevelopment of the Main Stand looming at 100 million +

We've spent a fair bit on transfers and wages but just chosen badly and been sold a donkey here & there ... we took our chances and are now regretting some of them.

Every season in this division will be a struggle for Palace until we get some rich investors like Wolves. The Yanks have stumped up some cash but not to the level some of us might have expected. Perhaps if we didn't have plans for the main stand we'd see more investment in the squad but we can't expect it all ...

Well said. Spot on, as usual.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 10 Oct 18 5.36am

god damn this club hates ambition...

have we not earned to right to expect something more than a relegation battle? We've been put through the ringer every year more or less and for once we thought we could feel relatively secure in the summer and aim for the top half or so with a settled squad and manager but yet again are being disappointed as players underperform. Yet again, we're stood like lemons in Selhurst while some scruffy Northern mutants rock up, have a lovely old time and take 3 points home while it pisses down

why is it such a crime to demand more? We don't ask for much do we? Even Parish said we should start thinking bigger

Edited by iheartcpfc (10 Oct 2018 5.36am)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Oct 18 6.27am

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

god damn this club hates ambition...

have we not earned to right to expect something more than a relegation battle? We've been put through the ringer every year more or less and for once we thought we could feel relatively secure in the summer and aim for the top half or so with a settled squad and manager but yet again are being disappointed as players underperform. Yet again, we're stood like lemons in Selhurst while some scruffy Northern mutants rock up, have a lovely old time and take 3 points home while it pisses down

why is it such a crime to demand more? We don't ask for much do we? Even Parish said we should start thinking bigger

Edited by iheartcpfc (10 Oct 2018 5.36am)

Yup bang on.
Look bournemouth for an ie.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > No better than Charlton