You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Stupid question about penalty taking
November 22 2026 7.45pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Stupid question about penalty taking


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
OhthisbloodyPC Flag 21 Oct 18 8.54pm

Obviously, I've never played at top level football

Possibly some of you have

Can anyone explain the logic of this popular trend for tapping it down the middle of the goal?

I'm guessing top footballers are clever enough to blast the ball into the top corners.

Am I being naive?

Patronising put downs are most welcome

As will advice from people who are good at football

I just want some enlightenment

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Oct 18 9.00pm

I'm s*** at football but not bad at pattern recognition.

Of the last 5 Palace penalties I've seen hit like that one three have been saved. 2 Milivojevic, 1 Benteke. Milivojevic and Benteke have each scored one with feeble effort like that. In one case City nearly scored directly from our own penalty and we also got Puncheon carted off and laid up for nine months so that was a real result.

Of the last 7 Palace penalties I've seen whacked at 100 mph straight at one of the corners of the goal 7 have gon in. All Milivojevic.

Seems clear enough to me.

Edited by chateauferret (21 Oct 2018 9.02pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Oct 18 9.03pm

If you're going to hit it down the middle it has to go high, so it misses the diving goalkeeper.

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Oct 18 9.05pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

If you're going to hit it down the middle it has to go high, so it misses the diving goalkeeper.

The last player I saw try that was Puncheon and it went f***ing high all right.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Bangell Flag Oxford 21 Oct 18 9.11pm

Luka's mind is shot to pieces lately and I can only imagine that he hesitated about what he was doing while he was running up.

 

mattteo Flag 21 Oct 18 9.15pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Luka's mind is shot to pieces lately and I can only imagine that he hesitated about what he was doing while he was running up.

Then don't have him take penalties anymore!

 

IMpalace Flag London 21 Oct 18 9.21pm

Hitting penalties down the middle is not itself an issue. If you hit it anywhere around halfway up the goal or higher it very rarely doesn’t go in as keepers normally dive. You don’t need to hit it in the roof, just not low!! If you hit it low and down the middle the keepers trailing leg is highly likely to save it.

It amazes me that Luka has now missed two (city and today) low down the middle when it’s such a low percentage penalty vs middle/high which is almost never saved. Infuriating.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 21 Oct 18 9.30pm

Did anyone see Wickham run in the 5 minutes he was on? Completely pointless sub. Got to be honest, I’m starting to question our management

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 21 Oct 18 9.31pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Then don't have him take penalties anymore!

I'm not in charge, mattteo

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 21 Oct 18 9.36pm

Pickford is a renowned penalty stopper, it was on Milo's mind for sure, so he went middle, would have worked if it was 2 feet higher...

 

timmyb Flag Banstead 21 Oct 18 9.53pm

Just been reading the section on penalty taking/ game theory in Soccernomics.

Suggests the best takers need a thoroughly randomised policy of where they place their kicks.

Pickford messes with game theory by being a thoroughly unorthodox stopper. His world cup save looked all wrong....went with the wrong hand etc...but the key thing is, he kept the ball out of the goal..rather like he did today.

For all of that, Luca is the best taker we've had for years. We can allow him one miss a season.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Oct 18 11.00pm

Originally posted by timmyb

Just been reading the section on penalty taking/ game theory in Soccernomics.

Suggests the best takers need a thoroughly randomised policy of where they place their kicks.

Pickford messes with game theory by being a thoroughly unorthodox stopper. His world cup save looked all wrong....went with the wrong hand etc...but the key thing is, he kept the ball out of the goal..rather like he did today.

For all of that, Luca is the best taker we've had for years. We can allow him one miss a season.

He went down the middle against Man C last season and that was also saved.
I don't think anyone else on the field at the time has taken penalties for us.

 

calgarycpfc Flag Calgary 21 Oct 18 11.09pm

...sometimes you bottle it, sometimes it doesn’t go where you want. I think Luka wanted it to go to the keepers right but got it all wrong. So much of it comes down to confidence, and that we are lacking.

 


Always look on the bright side of life

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 22 Oct 18 5.24am

Originally posted by spartakev2

If you're going to hit it down the middle it has to go high, so it misses the diving goalkeeper.

This it... chances are the keeper is never going to stay stationary in the middle to catch a ball chest high...

However, keepers do their homework and watch run ups, like boxing, they study body positioning and they can pretty much work out by the takers foot work where they are going.

Now, even harder, takers can study the keeper on video to see if they react a certain way to certain styles - so to almost double bluff.

In reality there is probably an area where the keeper cannot reach the ball, regardless - but the prospect of hitting that spot every time, under pressure is tough.

I would say the safest bet, as wide as you can, at head height.

But the margins are so fine and i bet a lot just aim for just off centre... placing it only works if you can bluff.

 


This was once a quality forum....

A89M Flag Streatham 22 Oct 18 8.58am

Originally posted by spartakev2

If you're going to hit it down the middle it has to go high, so it misses the diving goalkeeper.

Yup, exactly this. Keepers always tend to dive, so as long as you lift the ball when going down the middle the keeper really stands no chance (see Stanislas's penalty against us).

Luka did similar against City which I could forgive due to the circumstances, last minute pen, against the top team in the league. This one not so much, it was an exact replica and something I thought he would of learnt from. Showed a lack of confidence in both penalties but for very different reasons..

 

chateauferret Flag 22 Oct 18 7.38pm

Originally posted by timmyb

Just been reading the section on penalty taking/ game theory in Soccernomics.

Suggests the best takers need a thoroughly randomised policy of where they place their kicks.

Pickford messes with game theory by being a thoroughly unorthodox stopper. His world cup save looked all wrong....went with the wrong hand etc...but the key thing is, he kept the ball out of the goal..rather like he did today.

For all of that, Luca is the best taker we've had for years. We can allow him one miss a season.

He had two last season because letting Benteke take it instead of ypu counts as a fluff.

Seriously though last season Milivojevic' mental strength was immense and this seaaon - well I have a fiestier six-month old kitten.


Edited by chateauferret (22 Oct 2018 7.42pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 18 7.45pm

Originally posted by A89M

Yup, exactly this. Keepers always tend to dive, so as long as you lift the ball when going down the middle the keeper really stands no chance (see Stanislas's penalty against us).

Luka did similar against City which I could forgive due to the circumstances, last minute pen, against the top team in the league. This one not so much, it was an exact replica and something I thought he would of learnt from. Showed a lack of confidence in both penalties but for very different reasons..

Yes I agree.

When coaching young keepers, they are told that when they dive in a penalty situation they need to extend their leg as Pickford did so as Milivojevic found it, if you shoot low down the middle there is every chance chance that the ball will hit the keeper's outstretched leg.

 

timmyb Flag Banstead 23 Oct 18 4.36pm

Originally posted by Willo

He went down the middle against Man C last season and that was also saved.
I don't think anyone else on the field at the time has taken penalties for us.

So he has missed one a season.

Without being too nerdy on the game theory stuff, this does keep keepers guessing. If by hitting an occasional one down the middle, he then scores every penalty he hits left or right, his stats stay pretty high. Pickford has said he got a bit lucky and nearly broke his foot saving it in unorthodox fashion.

I still struggle to think of a better Palace penalty taker...AJ in 2004 / 05 perhaps. Still have nightmares about standing on the Holmesdale watching Bright, Wright and Pembo all miss in the same game.

 

General Flag 28 Oct 18 10.47am

If you can’t kick it in the top corner from 12 yards you are not a footballer in my opinion. Your an athlete.

Right footed - goalkeepers top left.
Left footed - goalkeepers top right.
No way the keeper saves it 999 times out of 1000.

Nerves? Nope not valid your paid to kick a ball. Whether it be near the corner flag or kick off or penalty spot. If you can’t kick a ball properly when it’s needed you ain’t a baller. Your an athlete. Or go see a psychiatrist and explain why after 20 years of kicking a ball you feel pressure kicking a ball. They will cuddle you!
Do I feel pressure connecting a socket up-no. Crossing a road-no. Cutting an avocado-no. I know you’ll say it’s not the same but these guys been kicking a ball for how many damn years!!
Makes me so mad watching dead penalties.
Il bet anyone upto £1000 if they want a challenge. Hire a goalie and a pitch I’m there.
And I snapped my Achilles in 2015 and ain’t played a game since. Or taken a penalty. Or felt the ‘pressure’ of a cup final penalty (4/4 scored) or a penalty shoot out to avoid relegation knowing 12 people will lose their job as you’ll lose semi-pro status.
But I’m up for a challenge with pressure equal to what our players feel as pressure.
£1000 loss to me is more pressure than kicking a ball with zero repurcussions. Oh fans are angry. CPFC lose points. Relegation and I have to transfer to another club and area. Ooohhh noooo poor millionaires.
Or I can’t afford food and entertainment for a month!
Absolute joke!!
Grrrr!! Haha

 

timmyb Flag Banstead 28 Oct 18 3.26pm

Good strength from Luca today.

Still our best penalty taker.

Who'd have thought we would be the ones to end the goons' winning run?

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Stupid question about penalty taking