You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > James McClean...No Poppy Required
November 22 2026 7.45pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McClean...No Poppy Required


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 30 Oct 18 1.07pm

well, being a gram or two lighter, he may run faster over 95 minutes.


what are your thoughts ?

a pacifist hero standing up against unbridled imperial corporate militarism ?
or
a 'Ra t0sser just being difficult to stir up sectarian sh1t ?

or both, or neither ?

personal thoughts.
We should honour the fallen on all sides of WW1 and WW2. But not do anything to encourage the next war starting next week somewhere..again for the umpteenth time.


korea, falklands, belize, iraq, afghanistan, syria, ...the list seems endless.

McClean is a Catholic from Derry. Much background baggage there for sure. Condemn or condone him ? probably neither.

is he a Nelson Mandela/Ghandi or is he a Martin McGuinness ?

your thoughts ?


[Link]

Edited by PalazioVecchio (30 Oct 2018 1.12pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

DanH Flag SW2 30 Oct 18 1.18pm

That it's a personal decision to wear one or not. One he's articulated well and should be respected.

And that this is not news every single year.

Edited by DanH (30 Oct 2018 1.18pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Oct 18 1.20pm

He explained his stance in a WBA programme whilst he was playing for them :

“People say I am being disrespectful but don’t ask why I choose not to wear it,” McClean wrote.

“If the poppy was simply about World War One and Two victims alone, I’d wear it without a problem.

“I would wear it every day of the year if that was the thing but it doesn’t. It stands for all the conflicts that Britain has been involved in. Because of the history where I come from in Derry, I cannot wear something that represents that.”

Edited by Willo (30 Oct 2018 1.20pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 30 Oct 18 1.37pm

I will be selling poppies again next week as I have done for the last few years.

I have no problem with him or even Corbyn for not wearing one it is a matter of personal conscience.

I do have a problem with people and organisations that object to me wearing one.

 


One more point

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 31 Oct 18 7.44am

Saw a letter he wrote to (I think it was to the Wigan chairman ) that explained very well why he couldn't wear a poppy.

All to do with the troubles in NI and Bloody Sunday in Derry where he was from...made sense from his perspective

 

MKGlazier Flag Milton Keynes 31 Oct 18 8.26am

I would maybe respect his decision if he played international football for his own country, Northern Ireland. Just another hypocritical b****** !!

 

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 31 Oct 18 9.35am

Originally posted by MKGlazier

I would maybe respect his decision if he played international football for his own country, Northern Ireland. Just another hypocritical b****** !!

He regards himself as Irish and plays for the ROI. All Irish people (including those from Ulster) can get Irish citizenship.

You may not agree with it, but I fail to see how it is hypocritical? It seems to me that his actions are completely consistent with his stated views.

Also, you would "respect his decision" not to wear a poppy? Is it now mandatory, everyone must wear a poppy or suffer the consequences.

Surely this is something people should be free to opt into, not something expected by default, which people should get hounded for if they opt out of?

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 31 Oct 18 9.52am

its londonderry actually


 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 31 Oct 18 10.19am

Originally posted by Badger11

I will be selling poppies again next week as I have done for the last few years.

I have no problem with him or even Corbyn for not wearing one it is a matter of personal conscience.

I do have a problem with people and organisations that object to me wearing one.

Completely agree with this and good for you for selling poppies mate.

Out of interest, have you experienced any first hand resistance to selling them yourself?

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 31 Oct 18 10.34am

Originally posted by Badger11


I have no problem with him or even Corbyn for not wearing one it is a matter of personal conscience.

I do have a problem with people and organisations that object to me wearing one.


And I have a problem with television companies, all of whose on-screen employees seem with one accord - and three weeks ahead of Armistice Day - to start wearing a poppy. Some years ago the BBC vehemently denied that it put out an edict on this issue, but it's hard not to think that some "moral" pressure is exerted. As stated above, and by others on this thread, wearing a poppy is - or at least should be - a matter of personal choice - which is one of the things that our ancestors fought for.

 

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 31 Oct 18 11.55am

Originally posted by JRW2


And I have a problem with television companies, all of whose on-screen employees seem with one accord - and three weeks ahead of Armistice Day - to start wearing a poppy. Some years ago the BBC vehemently denied that it put out an edict on this issue, but it's hard not to think that some "moral" pressure is exerted. As stated above, and by others on this thread, wearing a poppy is - or at least should be - a matter of personal choice - which is one of the things that our ancestors fought for.

Totally agree. It's akin to saying you don't love Palace for not standing when the crowd sing "stand up if you love Palace". Or if you don't like/share that facebook post that says "we think child rapists are bad, share/like if you agree" it means that you don't think child rapists are bad. Let people wear a poppy if they choose to and don't demonise those that don't.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 Oct 18 12.08pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Completely agree with this and good for you for selling poppies mate.

Out of interest, have you experienced any first hand resistance to selling them yourself?

No I haven't, there again it is Bromley high street. The council and the shops make a big effort normally the trees and lamppost have large poppies. I am not sure I would like to do it in Lewisham where the council makes no effort at all.

Generally either people ignore me (fair enough) or buy one and say nice things about the troops. I am not an aggressive tin rattler / chugger I cannot stand them. Like most volunteers i stand quietly and out of the way, you have to come to me if you wish to buy otherwise just keep on walking.

If anyone is interested in volunteering go to the British Legion website and they will put you in touch with your local organiser. It is only a stint of 2 hours I think I can find the time as I am retired although I appreciate if you work it is not so easy.

 


One more point

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 31 Oct 18 2.24pm

It is and should always be personal choice. It does seem odd that everyone on TV decides to wear one.

McClean probably is a bit of a **** but not for his decision on wearing a poppy.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 31 Oct 18 3.39pm

Originally posted by topcat

It is and should always be personal choice. It does seem odd that everyone on TV decides to wear one.

McClean probably is a bit of a **** but not for his decision on wearing a poppy.

I dare say there is more than a little pressure on them to do do.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 31 Oct 18 4.44pm

Jon Snow doesn't. He does on remembrance day in a personal capacity but won't allow himself to be forced to by some TV producer.

McClean not wearing one is not news anymore.

 


Optimistic as ever

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 31 Oct 18 6.52pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Jon Snow doesn't. He does on remembrance day in a personal capacity but won't allow himself to be forced to by some TV producer.

McClean not wearing one is not news anymore.

Wasn't it a few years back in a exhibition match he turned the other way for the national anthem?
Of course I can understand his reason for the poppy & possibly the National Anthem, but he appears to have no problem taking the Queens shilling (so to speak)

 


Pro USA & Israel

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 04 Nov 18 2.14pm

A few years ago a german player chose not to wear one , i think robert huth , he did nt get any hounding like McClean got , personal choice and i respect why he doesn't

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Nov 18 2.29pm

Matic wasn't wearing a poppy yesterday.

 

General Flag 09 Nov 18 7.52pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Wasn't it a few years back in a exhibition match he turned the other way for the national anthem?
Of course I can understand his reason for the poppy & possibly the National Anthem, but he appears to have no problem taking the Queens shilling (so to speak)

Just one question why do you say it’s the queens?
And I don’t begrudge anyone earning what 300 times what he could if he played in Ireland if it’s possible over here.
I’d go there for that salary increase!

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 10 Nov 18 12.50am

As others have said... His decision... I actually wish that every November we don't give him airtime... In my opinion he's an average footballer and most probably a closet IRA supporter...

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > James McClean...No Poppy Required