You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Disconnect between scouting department and Roy
November 16 2026 6.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Disconnect between scouting department and Roy


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
PatrickA Flag London 01 Nov 18 11.01am

I’m only speculating but it seems to me that there is disconnect between what Roy wants and the players who are actuall brought in.
Guita Rakip Jach ,Sorloth,Meyer,Ayew have made minimal if any impact or not even be selected.
Kouyate has been used as he is an experienced Premier player and more in keeping with the type that I think Roy would like.
It was telling at the beginning of the season when discussing the squad and Roy said that the scouting department had said rather than send Kai Kai and Williams out on loan again he should use them as part of the squad.
Well he obviously doesn’t think they can contribute as he doesn’t even really involve them in the league cup fixtures.
Observing from the outside it looks a mess.

 

Harborough Eagle Flag Market Harborough, Leicestershire 01 Nov 18 11.45am

We dont seem to hear much from Freedman but I guess that is because what could he say other than he is looking for transfer targets all the time !. Watching the game last night and looking at Hodgson's face despite him saying that those players needed game time and was not dissappointed, the two did not tally. He looked to me really frustrated and grumpy.
I also think that he does not want some of these players so watch the January window.

 


Red and Blue though and through (more than 50 years)

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Nov 18 12.12pm

I want Freedman to be involved at the club.....but perhaps in another role..... perhaps the transfer target success he had at Palace as manager was due to another influence....Popovic perhaps?....because at Bolton the transfers were poor and Forest afterwards weren't impressed.

Whatever the case, something isn't right at the scouting through to transfer selection model....because outside of the 'no brainer' transfer targets of proven quality.....the transfers have been poor.

No 'Jedinaks' being brought in for sure.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2018 12.14pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 01 Nov 18 6.36pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

No 'Jedinaks' being brought in for sure

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2018 12.14pm)

Luka?

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 01 Nov 18 8.20pm

If you want to hear SP's take on recent transfer windows listen to FYP Podcast 268 :

[Link]

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Midlands Eagle Flag 01 Nov 18 8.38pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I want Freedman to be involved at the club.....but perhaps in another role..... perhaps the transfer target success he had at Palace as manager was due to another influence....Popovic perhaps?....because at Bolton the transfers were poor and Forest afterwards weren't impressed.

Weren't they both under transfer embargos?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Nov 18 8.49pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Weren't they both under transfer embargos?

I believe he had left Bolton before they were under a transfer embargo.He did sign a lot of players at Bolton including quite a few on Loan.One of his loan signings was Danny Butterfield from Southampton.

There was a transfer embargo when he was at Nottm For but he was able to bring in a few players on loan.He also brought in a couple of 'Frees' including defender Matt Mills who played under him at Bolton.

Edited by Willo (01 Nov 2018 8.52pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Nov 18 8.51pm

I have heard Steve P’s take on transfer activity from the podcast.
I think he has been excellent for Palace on the whole and welcome his positivity around the club.
However, the fact remains that of the last 7 signings only Kouyate seems a likely starter under the current manager.
It is difficult to put a positive spin on this.
This points an alarming disconnect between the objectives of the scouting department and the requirements of Roy.
It is evident that the two players who Roy wanted to retain - Sakho and Cabaye - left the club.
Now it may be they would have left anyway, but it seems evident that Roy does not trust the players brought into the squad as alternatives.

 

chateauferret Flag 01 Nov 18 8.56pm

I think it's more of a disconnect between the scouting department and reality. We get the odd nugget and an occasional £30m splurge diluted by a veritable flood of raw sewage. But TBF our inability to close signings hardly helps. No window closes without at least one decent-looking deal collapsing for a stupid reason.

Edited by chateauferret (01 Nov 2018 8.57pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

TheExpatEagle Flag 01 Nov 18 9.05pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

Luka?

Which was before Freedman came back to the club and said to be an Allardyce suggestion.

 

chateauferret Flag 02 Nov 18 9.41am

Originally posted by Harborough Eagle

We dont seem to hear much from Freedman but I guess that is because what could he say other than he is looking for transfer targets all the time !

Hmm.

Si tacuisses professus mansisses.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 02 Nov 18 9.57am

I have long felt that managers here get frustrated with the transfer policy. Of our last 7 managers before Roy, 3 of them (Allardyce, Pulis, Freedman) have quit the club rather than being fired with Holloway also leaving by mutual consent. Seems like a very high proportion to me for a top flight club.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Username Flag Horsham 02 Nov 18 10.35am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I have heard Steve P’s take on transfer activity from the podcast.
I think he has been excellent for Palace on the whole and welcome his positivity around the club.
However, the fact remains that of the last 7 signings only Kouyate seems a likely starter under the current manager.
It is difficult to put a positive spin on this.

This points an alarming disconnect between the objectives of the scouting department and the requirements of Roy.
It is evident that the two players who Roy wanted to retain - Sakho and Cabaye - left the club.
Now it may be they would have left anyway, but it seems evident that Roy does not trust the players brought into the squad as alternatives.

I'm not sure that's entirely fair. I think a lot of the recent transfer activity has been about improving depth and not necessarily replacing starters.

We're not that far removed from our midfield alternative being Jordon Mutch. Now we have a bench that could have Kouyate, Meyer and Riedewald on there (depending on who starts obviously). Similarly, in goal we now appear to have two good options.

Not all of the transfers have worked, particularly up front Sorloth and Ayew haven't provided what we needed so there is still work needed there. However I can see the logic in trying to sign players who can contribute but aren't necessarily going to be starters every week.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Username Flag Horsham 02 Nov 18 10.42am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

I have long felt that managers here get frustrated with the transfer policy. Of our last 7 managers before Roy, 3 of them (Allardyce, Pulis, Freedman) have quit the club rather than being fired with Holloway also leaving by mutual consent. Seems like a very high proportion to me for a top flight club.


I don't see how you can throw Freedman and Allardyce in there with Pulis. All three were very different situations. Freedman left us for what he saw as a better opportunity and for more money, but he was backed here. Similarly, Allardyce was given the money to spend in January and backed by Parish.

It was only really Pulis that seemed to have issues, but I do think that transfers are often an easy smokescreen for an exiting manager to use to blame the owners/board for their departure. Even if there was friction of transfers, I'm still pretty happy that we re-signed Wilf instead of signing Crouch as I believe Pulis wanted?

If anything, a few of the problems we still have are from the backing that was given to Pardew where he was probably given too much freedom in both incoming and outgoing deals.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Painter Flag Croydon 02 Nov 18 10.48am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

I have long felt that managers here get frustrated with the transfer policy. Of our last 7 managers before Roy, 3 of them (Allardyce, Pulis, Freedman) have quit the club rather than being fired with Holloway also leaving by mutual consent. Seems like a very high proportion to me for a top flight club.

This says more about their ability as managers, its the easy route to keep buying and hope get a gem. Managers are employed to coach and improve current players, some obviously cant do that.
Saying that, we were the highest spenders outside the top 8 up until last summer.

Edited by Painter (02 Nov 2018 10.49am)

Edited by Painter (02 Nov 2018 10.49am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 18 10.51am

Originally posted by Username


I don't see how you can throw Freedman and Allardyce in there with Pulis. All three were very different situations. Freedman left us for what he saw as a better opportunity and for more money, but he was backed here. Similarly, Allardyce was given the money to spend in January and backed by Parish.

It was only really Pulis that seemed to have issues, but I do think that transfers are often an easy smokescreen for an exiting manager to use to blame the owners/board for their departure. Even if there was friction of transfers, I'm still pretty happy that we re-signed Wilf instead of signing Crouch as I believe Pulis wanted?

If anything, a few of the problems we still have are from the backing that was given to Pardew where he was probably given too much freedom in both incoming and outgoing deals.

I do get the impression that if we had Crouch up front at the present time instead of Sorloth or Ayew we might look more threatening in attack.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 02 Nov 18 10.57am

Originally posted by Username


I don't see how you can throw Freedman and Allardyce in there with Pulis. All three were very different situations. Freedman left us for what he saw as a better opportunity and for more money, but he was backed here. Similarly, Allardyce was given the money to spend in January and backed by Parish.

It was only really Pulis that seemed to have issues, but I do think that transfers are often an easy smokescreen for an exiting manager to use to blame the owners/board for their departure. Even if there was friction of transfers, I'm still pretty happy that we re-signed Wilf instead of signing Crouch as I believe Pulis wanted?

If anything, a few of the problems we still have are from the backing that was given to Pardew where he was probably given too much freedom in both incoming and outgoing deals.

If you reread SP’s quotes from the time, he implied very strongly that Freedman left through ambition and felt Bolton were a better bet to be promoted...

[Link]

Pulis definitely left as he felt the club didn’t match his ambition, though don’t me wrong I’m certainly not on his side. Allardyce claimed he was retiring and lasted 6 months until a bigger club came along.

Possibly a series of coincidences but it just strikes me, as I said, that recently we have had more managers walking out on us than any similar clubs that spring to mind.


 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Username Flag Horsham 02 Nov 18 10.58am

Originally posted by Willo

I do get the impression that if we had Crouch up front at the present time instead of Sorloth or Ayew we might look more threatening in attack.


But without Wilf...

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 02 Nov 18 12.37pm

Originally posted by Painter

This says more about their ability as managers, its the easy route to keep buying and hope get a gem. Managers are employed to coach and improve current players, some obviously cant do that.
Saying that, we were the highest spenders outside the top 8 up until last summer.

Edited by Painter (02 Nov 2018 10.49am)

Edited by Painter (02 Nov 2018 10.49am)

Good point. How many signings within our recent stay in the PL have actually developed ? Difficult to name a huge amount beyond the likes of Wilf and he like AWB were nurtured here.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Nov 18 8.13pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Good point. How many signings within our recent stay in the PL have actually developed ? Difficult to name a huge amount beyond the likes of Wilf and he like AWB were nurtured here.

Not many clubs really have got that return on youth since manures Becks and giggs etc

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Disconnect between scouting department and Roy