You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Diving
November 22 2026 7.45pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Diving


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
MrCParrot Flag Taunton 03 Dec 18 7.21am

Look at this article . So it's ok to dive now?

Keith Hackett
Son penalty decision right despite the lack of contact

If you want to know how difficult it is to be a top-flight referee, then yesterday’s game between Arsenal and Tottenham was the perfect example, and particularly Mike Dean’s decision to award Son Heung-min a penalty for a challenge by Rob Holding.
On first view, I thought it was a penalty, as did Mike. Holding slides in front of his opponent and appears to catch him. Mike was excellently positioned, took his time and pointed to the spot.
However, television replays showed Holding did not touch Son, with the Tottenham forward going to ground far too easily. But what makes this decision so difficult is that you could argue it is still a penalty even though no contact has been made. Law 12 states that a direct free-kick is awarded if a player makes a challenge “considered by the referee to be careless, reckless or using excessive force”.
Nowhere does it mention contact must be made. We have seen players sent off for two-footed challenges where they make no contact, but the intent is clear.
Holding’s challenge was desperate and, as a result, careless. He made no contact because Son took evasive action rather than because he took any care to avoid his opponent.
Mike was also correct to penalise Jan Vertonghen for handball and award Arsenal a penalty, while the defender was fortunate to only be shown a second yellow rather than a straight red for his challenge on Alexandre Lacazette.
Then there were the celebrations and the tussle that followed Eric Dier shushing the Arsenal fans. I would expect Mike to put in his report anything that potentially incited the crowd, as that clearly did (and as Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang did, too). I felt he dealt with the situation well.
Overall I think Mike did well and deserves great credit. It’s one of the toughest fixtures and he handled it more than capably.

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Dec 18 10.31am

Originally posted by MrCParrot

television replays showed Holding did not touch Son, with the Tottenham forward going to ground far too easily.

Law 12 states that a direct free-kick is awarded if a player makes a challenge “considered by the referee to be careless, reckless or using excessive force”.
Nowhere does it mention contact must be made.

I wonder how a court of law would interpret it. They could well say that any challenge that doesn't make contact can't be careless or reckless and it certainly can't be using excess force if no contact is made.

Along the same lines if I went to punch someone and missed could I be prosecuted for GBH?

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 03 Dec 18 2.00pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I wonder how a court of law would interpret it. They could well say that any challenge that doesn't make contact can't be careless or reckless and it certainly can't be using excess force if no contact is made.

Along the same lines if I went to punch someone and missed could I be prosecuted for GBH?

I've never heard anybody ever mention this rule before in either defence or prosecution of a dive. It makes the whole situation a complete farce as everyone that dives can always claim they were just avoiding a collision. Its madness.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 03 Dec 18 7.42pm

For many years I've felt that two footed or studs showing challenges should be regarded as dangerous play even if the player cleanly wins the ball and felt if this happens play should continue but the offending player is shown the red card for dangerous play.

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 04 Dec 18 7.25am

Originally posted by PALACE FOR EVER
For many years I've felt that two footed or studs showing challenges should be regarded as dangerous play even if the player cleanly wins the ball and felt if this happens play should continue but the offending player is shown the red card for dangerous play.

No arguments from me on that one. I think we need to call out the lack of media attention when the bad tackle or dive comes from one of the top six.
Son this week, Hazard two dives in a row last week and of course Felliani tackle on Luka last week. This gives legitimacy to poor refereeing.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Fatherken Flag 04 Dec 18 9.16am

Wait till VAR comes in then all players who dive will get a yellow card [ except Man U ]

 

chateauferret Flag 27 Dec 18 2.49am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Diving t***' by Midlands Eagle

Does anyone else think Salah should be referred to the simulation panel for another obvious dive today?

Supplementary question: what would hapoen if Zaha did the same thing?

FFS.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 27 Dec 18 7.45am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Diving t***' by Midlands Eagle

He certainly made the most of it but there was contact albeit minuscule so it was given. Think the penalty law at times is too much in the attacking sides favour as any contact now seems to be a penalty which shouldn’t be the case. Defenders should be allowed a little physical contact as long as it isn’t dangerous.

Saying that Zaha has exaggerated a few penalties in his time such as Man City at home so we can’t get too loud on this. Every premier league team has a diver/player who goes down too easily

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 27 Dec 18 8.11am

Mo Salah dived yesterday. They said it on motd. It's also in the Telegraph.

Let's hope the FA throw the book at the cheat.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 27 Dec 18 10.22am

Originally posted by MrCParrot

Mo Salah dived yesterday. They said it on motd. It's also in the Telegraph.

Let's hope the FA throw the book at the cheat.

Parrot

No action.
One rule for the reds, one rule for the toffees.

Pathetic

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

chateauferret Flag 27 Dec 18 12.21pm

Surprise f***ing surprise.

Mohamed Salah: Liverpool forward faces no FA action over Newcastle penalty - [Link]

 


============
The Ferret
============

Cannonball Flag High in the Ozarks. 27 Dec 18 6.56pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Surprise f***ing surprise.

Mohamed Salah: Liverpool forward faces no FA action over Newcastle penalty - [Link]

The FA are doing their best to make sure Loserpool become champions.

 


Touch my coffee and I will slap you so hard even Google won't be able to find you.

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 27 Dec 18 7.07pm

apparently once var comes in next season this should stop

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

samprior Flag Hamburg 28 Dec 18 2.19am

[Link]

Seems very strange. The statement that there was contact didn't seem to matter for Niasse when he dived against us. In both cases there was contact but it was unrelated to the fall. Both clear dives but different punishments.

There's a whole bunch of rules which make absolute no sense. The non review when a yellow card is given is an absolute farce. Wilf being booked against Watford a few seasons ago for 'diving' when after the game Mariapa comes out and says he fouled him. Then this season the Capoue 'tackle' absolute joke. The no review on yellow cards often results in incorrect punishment and potential to build unfair repuatations.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 18 8.53am

Originally posted by samprior

[Link]

Seems very strange. The statement that there was contact didn't seem to matter for Niasse when he dived against us. In both cases there was contact but it was unrelated to the fall. Both clear dives but different punishments.

There's a whole bunch of rules which make absolute no sense. The non review when a yellow card is given is an absolute farce. Wilf being booked against Watford a few seasons ago for 'diving' when after the game Mariapa comes out and says he fouled him. Then this season the Capoue 'tackle' absolute joke. The no review on yellow cards often results in incorrect punishment and potential to build unfair repuatations.

Without giving this any thought as to the implications and after consuming copious amounts of alcohol last night in the company of family I am thinking that maybe consideration could be given to allow appeals for a yellow whereby 2 yellows have resulted in a sending-off.If there has been a clear and obvious error by the referee in awarding one or both yellows then it seems unfair that a team should suffer a player not being available for a match.

Maybe once my head has cleared I will consider that this suggestion is a load of old hogwash !

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 28 Dec 18 9.03am

Originally posted by thegreatlardino

apparently once var comes in next season this should stop

It won't help but it will improve.
The only thing I read from a ref viewpoint was that the touch on Salah was completely mindless. Salah was clean past him and the touch unnecessary.

The punishment did not fit this crime however and Salah dived in my opinion and I guess most others minds.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 28 Dec 18 8.20pm

Be interesting to see the reaction from Klopp and co if Liverpool give away a vital penalty for a foul like that in the important game against Man City next week...

Yes there was contact but Salah went down very easily - he doesn't always do that!

I think the fact the Newcastle player did try to grab him saved Salah as the ref would say there was intent from the defender to foul.

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 29 Dec 18 10.00am

Originally posted by Superhorns3

Be interesting to see the reaction from Klopp and co if Liverpool give away a vital penalty for a foul like that in the important game against Man City next week...

Yes there was contact but Salah went down very easily - he doesn't always do that!

I think the fact the Newcastle player did try to grab him saved Salah as the ref would say there was intent from the defender to foul.

Well he went down very easily in the game against us. He leapt off Sakho's foot like a salmon trying to get upstream, he also fell conveniently after losing control of the ball before AWB fouled him. He dives.

I was listening to the Guardian podcast and they actually said that it had really crept into defending too. Some of the worst dives are by the back 4. It is quite amusing to see them throwing themselves around the pitch.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 18 10.26am

The 'Diving' debate invariably relates to incidents which occur in and sometimes on the edge of the penalty area with players accused of exaggerating the contact and going to ground far too easily.

In other areas of the pitch one witnesses players plummeting to the ground after minimal contact yet these players are not accused of any simulation and "Drew a foul" is the narrative.How many times do you see a player being challenged by a player behind him and with barely a hand being placed on him he goes to ground ?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Dec 18 10.54am

Originally posted by Superhorns3

Be interesting to see the reaction from Klopp and co if Liverpool give away a vital penalty for a foul like that in the important game against Man City next week...

Yes there was contact but Salah went down very easily - he doesn't always do that!

I think the fact the Newcastle player did try to grab him saved Salah as the ref would say there was intent from the defender to foul.

No chance of the scousers conceding a dodgy penalty, this season is all set up for them to win the league.
I think Salah has done it on numerous occasions but being the media darling he gets way with it.
If that was a penalty there should be 20odd every game.
Happy New Year Superhorns3 (except on the 12th)

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Diving