You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > An appeal to Wilf
November 16 2026 6.31am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

An appeal to Wilf


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
briandavis Flag Udon Thani 23 Dec 18 12.53pm

I’m probably flattering myself that Wilf might read this, but hope he does. I’m sure he’s heard this from many coaches and advisers before, but just hope that from a now near 70 year old fan of perhaps 60 years now living in Thailand, it might be a bit ‘different’.

Great win yesterday, fantastic effort by everyone and wonder goal by Andros. I fell into bed at midnight here, ‘bubbling’. But, you know what spoiled the occasion slightly was seeing you losing it yet again and getting booked, having just finished a suspension. Look, nobody loves you more than me; fair to say Palace would not be in the position it is without your great contribution in your time at the Club. We all know you get fouled, but the opponent isn’t penalized, but there are occasions when you’re appealing for something that isn’t there. This gets you frustrated, but often you annoy the referee with your reaction and, of course, the fans of the opposition, who get on your back. Your rash challenge leading to the booking was typical. Complaining or subsequent fouling is unlikely to help, indeed it’s a distraction to your game you don’t need. Get on with it.

It’s about time to mature, keep your temper, let your skills do the talking, hurt the opposition and help your own team. I’m convinced this would make you an even better player.
I send this with the best intentions, as a Palace and Zaha fan and hope you grasp that.
Love you mate. Wish you a happy Christmas and great New Year.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 23 Dec 18 1.06pm

I've been saying it for a while: the club needs to get a sports psychologist in to work with Wilf if he's going to realise his potential.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 23 Dec 18 1.19pm

They used to say the same about Rooney. He done alright

Agree he needs to be more savvy. But you can’t take that away from him. It’s part of his make up.

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 23 Dec 18 1.37pm

Brian - there was something in it, he was fouled twice but the ref missed it. Monstermunch I agree 100%. In my view Rooney's game declined when Fergie coached the edge out of it.

I don't think he needs a shrink but he needs to find a way to manage his anger and edge better when it is starting to get counter productive.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Dec 18 2.46pm

maybe Wilf's anger should be more in his boots and less in his mouth.

but what would i know ? what advice can an armchair beer drinker offer to a professional athlete ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

YT Flag Oxford 23 Dec 18 3.01pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

They used to say the same about Rooney. He done alright

Agree he needs to be more savvy. But you can’t take that away from him. It’s part of his make up.

You beat me to it. I was going to cite Eric Cvntona.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 23 Dec 18 3.08pm

I know that this has been said so many times that it hardly needs repeating - opponents foul him not only because "he's just too good for you", but because they know he'll lose his cool, he'll sulk, get thrown off his game, frequently get carded, and in general become less effective. Yes, a psychologist should be given a chance to try and sort him out. I remember (I'm extremely old) someone saying that when Stanley Matthews found himself against a clogger, it simply increased his determination to make a fool of the culprit.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 23 Dec 18 3.48pm

As frustrating as it is that Wilf gets booked for what's become his trademark foul, I think it's impossible to eradicate it without him losing an edge to his game.

I think it's the price of doing business in this instance.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 23 Dec 18 7.28pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

As frustrating as it is that Wilf gets booked for what's become his trademark foul, I think it's impossible to eradicate it without him losing an edge to his game.

I think it's the price of doing business in this instance.

I disagree. It’s a real weakness for him and recently it’s got worse.

Christiano Ronaldo was the same at United when he was young. Got lumps kicked out of him every match and was petulant. He’s eradicated it from his game and became the worlds best player. Wilf gets kicked no more than Hazard but Hazard can handle it.

Skilful players will get the physical treatment, simple. He needs do something about it as he’s letting himself down at the moment and it’s affecting his form. Must driving Hodgson mad. Sports psychologist sounds like a sensible idea.

 

merganser Flag 23 Dec 18 10.43pm

Shouldn’t one of his team mates exert a calming influence ?

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 24 Dec 18 8.08am

He a bright young man with an edge he'll learn his own way on this.I know its frustrating for us old buggers but wern't we just the same sometimes. Granted our Wilf is a specieal talent we will just have to take the great with the not so great and be greatful he is still with us.

Edited by johnmcormick8 (24 Dec 2018 8.09am)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 Dec 18 11.23am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

I disagree. It’s a real weakness for him and recently it’s got worse.

Christiano Ronaldo was the same at United when he was young. Got lumps kicked out of him every match and was petulant. He’s eradicated it from his game and became the worlds best player. Wilf gets kicked no more than Hazard but Hazard can handle it.

Skilful players will get the physical treatment, simple. He needs do something about it as he’s letting himself down at the moment and it’s affecting his form. Must driving Hodgson mad. Sports psychologist sounds like a sensible idea.


Well I would be very surprised if Wilf had not had any contact with a sports psychologist if it was deemed worthwhile by the myriad of managers he's played under !


I think the comparison with Hazard throws up one significant difference - Hazard gets most of the free kicks / decisions in his favour. Wilf patently doesn't.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Stuk Flag Top half 24 Dec 18 12.16pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

I disagree. It’s a real weakness for him and recently it’s got worse.

Christiano Ronaldo was the same at United when he was young. Got lumps kicked out of him every match and was petulant. He’s eradicated it from his game and became the worlds best player. Wilf gets kicked no more than Hazard but Hazard can handle it.

Skilful players will get the physical treatment, simple. He needs do something about it as he’s letting himself down at the moment and it’s affecting his form. Must driving Hodgson mad. Sports psychologist sounds like a sensible idea.

The same Ronaldo who got sent off for pulling someone's hair earlier this season?

I agree with Neillo. Hazard and Ronaldo both get given far more decisions in their favour than Wilf does.

 


Optimistic as ever

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 24 Dec 18 1.42pm

Originally posted by Stuk

The same Ronaldo who got sent off for pulling someone's hair earlier this season?

I agree with Neillo. Hazard and Ronaldo both get given far more decisions in their favour than Wilf does.

They do get more decisions for sure. But do you think that’s possibly because Wilf is constantly whinging, flapping his hands about and occasionally goes down too easily?

He’s the sort of player who would piss off a referee and get decisions against him. I’m confident that if he was less petulant he would win more free kicks/penalties. After speaking out he’s become an easy target for opposition and it’s clearly affecting his game.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 24 Dec 18 2.07pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

They do get more decisions for sure. But do you think that’s possibly because Wilf is constantly whinging, flapping his hands about and occasionally goes down too easily?

He’s the sort of player who would piss off a referee and get decisions against him. I’m confident that if he was less petulant he would win more free kicks/penalties. After speaking out he’s become an easy target for opposition and it’s clearly affecting his game.

No. I think it's because they play for "bigger" teams and are both considered international superstars.

Referees aren't there to get pissed off, they're supposed to make each decision on merit alone. The ref got it wrong which led to his frustration, if they can do it me why can't I do it them?

 


Optimistic as ever

Glazier#1 Flag 24 Dec 18 2.20pm

Originally posted by johnmcormick8

He a bright young man with an edge he'll learn his own way on this.I know its frustrating for us old buggers but wern't we just the same sometimes. Granted our Wilf is a specieal talent we will just have to take the great with the not so great and be greatful he is still with us.

Edited by johnmcormick8 (24 Dec 2018 8.09am)

 

Glazier#1 Flag 24 Dec 18 2.22pm

Wilf may be many things and I love him as a palace legend but bright would not be the first adjective that springs to mind.


 

GlaziertoEagle Flag Coventry 24 Dec 18 2.22pm

If you neuter a dog it doesn't have the same drive or energy as it used to.

 

merganser Flag 25 Dec 18 10.42pm

If Wilf plays v Cardiff, it’s a far bet he’ll get a right whacking.
It’a a Neil Warnock side after all.

 

leejaneagles Flag 25 Dec 18 10.53pm

Look at Wilf's recent form, pictures of his leg in a temporary cast (even if just to protect it during rest) and hobbling off at City and it's clear to see the man is injured or at the very least playing through pain.

I actually think when Wilf is on fire and you can tell there's nothing niggling him he doesn't seem to get as wound up or booked himself for losing his head.

I genuinely think the Man City thing was a player that has been asked to play with a knock, agreeing to do it because he wants his team to win so badly and knows we only really stand a chance with him in the team and he gets hacked yet again and the Ref does nothing.

I don't blame him. We may complain about a 1 game suspension now but I fear it's a matter of time before he gets Luke Shaw'd and then we'll realise him fighting his corner and getting booked is better than him having his career ruined because Referesss do not look after him.

There's another thread on the forum asking should we sell Wilf. I think it's absurd but for his own health he should certainly move to a Chelsea or City. The fat refs of the Premier League will suddenly wrap him in cotton wool.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > An appeal to Wilf