You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 6.31am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Block E (LOCKED)


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
fan Flag Caterham 29 Jan 19 6.27pm

The last discussion was locked but issue wont go away.
I want to know how the supporters who sat in blocks D and F of the LH found it last Sunday. From where I was sitting [Main Stand] looked like a lot of flag waving and bouncing!

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 29 Jan 19 7.21pm

Was just next to it in D and thought it was great. Really spread across the whole Holmesdale at times as well with us all still singing as the players left the pitch.
Hopefully the club see that and work out a way to move all the singers to the middle of the stand in time for next season like they did on Sunday

 

Sparkeagle Flag 29 Jan 19 8.00pm

would be nice to have a positive thread on it not overtaken by the unfortunately affected by the move, as someone very keen to be involved i loved it on Sunday, really excited not just for next season but the overall hopeful future of a completely bouncing lower tier. HF have done a great job and the band pre match although before my time were great and i really enjoyed it, hopefully this is the start of people looking forward to the future.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 29 Jan 19 8.26pm

I was in E, row 13 and it was superb. Still can’t speak. It’s is clearly for the best and it was great to see so many people supporting the idea. It will take a bit of time for it to be as effective for league games.

My fear is that those at the back of F and D will need to stand when the action is in the near corner flags, although I think D stand anyway.-

The ideal scenario would be for safe standing to become legal, turn the entire lower tier into safe standing and those who want to sing/stand will gradually congregate around the HF. At that point, once SS has been passed, HF should move to the front of E so everyone behind can follow their lead.

Didn’t answer your question on D/F though, sorry!

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 29 Jan 19 8.56pm

I was in block F row 22 and was 3 seats along than my normal one. There wasn’t many of my normal friends who I sit with as seats were sold before they could get them. Thought the atmosphere was very good but I had to stand for the full match. Normally I sit and just stand occasionally when an attack is on my far right and others stand which means I need to. Wouldn’t like to stand every match though and I’m reluctant to move elsewhere as those I sit with for league matches would find it difficult to get so many seats together elsewhere plus it wouldn’t be easy to arrange as most of us are just together for home matches and don’t really know each other outside of the home games. Also my friend who sits a row in front of me (part of the larger group of us) is 10 years older than me - I’m 62 - has bad knees (ex postman) and couldn’t stand all match and therefore went elsewhere at halftime so that he could sit down. Even though atmosphere was better (don’t like drum though) I would rather have a working seat to watch the majority of the match unlike last Sunday. Would rather the fanatic went back to previous block A but I’m sure those around the ground that can see the fanatics feel differently?

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 29 Jan 19 11.42pm

Originally posted by palace chick

I was in block F row 22 and was 3 seats along than my normal one. There wasn’t many of my normal friends who I sit with as seats were sold before they could get them. Thought the atmosphere was very good but I had to stand for the full match. Normally I sit and just stand occasionally when an attack is on my far right and others stand which means I need to. Wouldn’t like to stand every match though and I’m reluctant to move elsewhere as those I sit with for league matches would find it difficult to get so many seats together elsewhere plus it wouldn’t be easy to arrange as most of us are just together for home matches and don’t really know each other outside of the home games. Also my friend who sits a row in front of me (part of the larger group of us) is 10 years older than me - I’m 62 - has bad knees (ex postman) and couldn’t stand all match and therefore went elsewhere at halftime so that he could sit down. Even though atmosphere was better (don’t like drum though) I would rather have a working seat to watch the majority of the match unlike last Sunday. Would rather the fanatic went back to previous block A but I’m sure those around the ground that can see the fanatics feel differently?

I hear your issue. What stand will you move to when the lower holmesdale inevitably becomes safe standing? Do you reckon you'd move to the upper or could you stand for 90 mins with a rail in front of you to lean on. Genuinely interested what people will do.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 29 Jan 19 11.54pm

Originally posted by Dean_CPFC

I hear your issue. What stand will you move to when the lower holmesdale inevitably becomes safe standing? Do you reckon you'd move to the upper or could you stand for 90 mins with a rail in front of you to lean on. Genuinely interested what people will do.

Where will you go when the HF demand your seat and you don't qualify as one of them?

Will you go and stand on your own in the Sainsbury's end bouncing around like tigger, happy that you've been shafted for the greater good?


Genuinely interested in what people will do when it's them and not others having their seats taken.

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 30 Jan 19 12.18am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Where will you go when the HF demand your seat and you don't qualify as one of them?

Will you go and stand on your own in the Sainsbury's end bouncing around like tigger, happy that you've been shafted for the greater good?


Genuinely interested in what people will do when it's them and not others having their seats taken.

I'm not talking about the fanatics, read my post. I'm talking about safe standing/rail seating!

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 30 Jan 19 7.48am

Originally posted by Dean_CPFC

I'm not talking about the fanatics, read my post. I'm talking about safe standing/rail seating!

When is safe standing scheduled to be implemented?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 30 Jan 19 9.04am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Where will you go when the HF demand your seat and you don't qualify as one of them?

Will you go and stand on your own in the Sainsbury's end bouncing around like tigger, happy that you've been shafted for the greater good?

Genuinely interested in what people will do when it's them and not others having their seats taken.

Here we go again :rolleyes:

If you genuinely want to know (like you say) then go and read the other thread as there are pages and pages on just that subject

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 30 Jan 19 10.54am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

When is safe standing scheduled to be implemented?

As soon as Spurs open their stadium. It's already installed and ready to go

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 30 Jan 19 11.14am

Originally posted by Dean_CPFC

As soon as Spurs open their stadium. It's already installed and ready to go

This isn't true. They've future proofed the stadium and have cautioned season ticket holders that their section might, in future, be subject to converting to safe standing. This has to go through government first and has a few barriers to overcome first.

I'm not sure it's particularly becoming to say "I appreciate your concern" to a long term season ticket holder and then imply that they're going to have to stand anyway or move so what are they going to do about it, when the facts of the matter don't support this.

The only reason they would have to move seats is if they are forced to during another seat grab by the HF.

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 30 Jan 19 11.21am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

This isn't true. They've future proofed the stadium and have cautioned season ticket holders that their section might, in future, be subject to converting to safe standing. This has to go through government first and has a few barriers to overcome first.

I'm not sure it's particularly becoming to say "I appreciate your concern" to a long term season ticket holder and then imply that they're going to have to stand anyway or move so what are they going to do about it, when the facts of the matter don't support this.

The only reason they would have to move seats is if they are forced to during another seat grab by the HF.

Stop trying to twist it back to the fanatics.
Spurs stadium seats are legal because the latest green guide says barriers in front of seated accomodation are now legal. Don't believe me? No problems, we'll see when they open their stadium next month.

It's all changing, the lower tier will be safe standing very soon! I assume that's all part of the plan to maximise the effect of the singing section (which was a real success btw against spurs)

Some big exciting changes coming!

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 30 Jan 19 11.25am

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 30 Jan 19 11.34am

Thanks, I'd missed this development. I'm all for safe standing, so if this trial proves successful then it could be a game changer. How does this effect the legislation on the matter? The tweet says that this option is viable now, but I don't think that's correct.

Taking it at face value, it shows how poorly the club and the HF have handled the matter. If safe standing is becoming a legitimate go-to option, why not announce the intention to implement it and let those who want to remain seated choose to vacate? The integration of the HF into the vacated seats would have been organic rather than randsomed.

 

dorking Flag 30 Jan 19 11.54am

If allowed, the back half of the Lower tier should be rail standing.

Those currently in the back half should have the option to stay there if they are happy to stand all game.

Fans in the front half of the lower tier who want to stand all game should be able to swap with those in the back half who want to sit.

Everyone's a winner

Happy days.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 30 Jan 19 11.55am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Thanks, I'd missed this development. I'm all for safe standing, so if this trial proves successful then it could be a game changer. How does this effect the legislation on the matter? The tweet says that this option is viable now, but I don't think that's correct.

Taking it at face value, it shows how poorly the club and the HF have handled the matter. If safe standing is becoming a legitimate go-to option, why not announce the intention to implement it and let those who want to remain seated choose to vacate? The integration of the HF into the vacated seats would have been organic rather than randsomed.

As usual you are trying to become the centre of attention by niggling. It doesn't matter who takes the collateral damage.

So let's be clear. The HF did not make any decision apart from to stop attending games as an active group. They requested a move to the centre of the LH.

For everything else the club is responsible, as it has said itself on multiple occasions.

In my opinion the HF has handled itself - if indeed it can be considered unitary - with great aplomb.

The HF did not 'demand my seat' or 'move me out'. In fact when I approached individuals within the HF they were extremely welcoming and not at all desirous of me leaving my seat to make way for other HF members.

I suggest you disaggregate your arguments.

My understanding to date is that the club does not believe safe standing is an available option. Rail seats can be fitted but at the moment they can't be used as standing positions. Wolves have put in some rail seats as a proof of concept in an unused area.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 30 Jan 19 12.11pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

As usual you are trying to become the centre of attention by niggling. It doesn't matter who takes the collateral damage.

So let's be clear. The HF did not make any decision apart from to stop attending games as an active group. They requested a move to the centre of the LH.

For everything else the club is responsible, as it has said itself on multiple occasions.

In my opinion the HF has handled itself - if indeed it can be considered unitary - with great aplomb.

The HF did not 'demand my seat' or 'move me out'. In fact when I approached individuals within the HF they were extremely welcoming and not at all desirous of me leaving my seat to make way for other HF members.

I suggest you disaggregate your arguments.

My understanding to date is that the club does not believe safe standing is an available option. Rail seats can be fitted but at the moment they can't be used as standing positions. Wolves have put in some rail seats as a proof of concept in an unused area.

Thanks for this, so safe standing isn't enevitable then?


 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 30 Jan 19 12.14pm

Originally posted by dorking

If allowed, the back half of the Lower tier should be rail standing.

Those currently in the back half should have the option to stay there if they are happy to stand all game.

Fans in the front half of the lower tier who want to stand all game should be able to swap with those in the back half who want to sit.

Everyone's a winner

Happy days.

Seems a sensible suggestion.

Another poster has said that rail seating doesn't facilitate standing and the club doesn't support it though.

This raises another question: I thought that the council and the club had an ongoing dispute about the HF due to health and safety concerns.

What happens if they move and the powers that be (PL, FA, local authority etc) lean on the club to enforce seating?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 30 Jan 19 12.34pm

The Government review on matters including safe standing was due to conclude at the end of 2018. I do not believe anything has been published.

As all of the football authorities support the concept, it would seem likely the Government will give ground.

I see no reason you can't use rail seating in the seated position at the moment.

I believe the club has considered fitting rail seating and have seen nothing to say it doesn't support it as a concept.

I am unaware of a difference of opinion between the club and the council on having a singing section within the Lower Holmesdale. Or indeed any specific issues related to the HF. I look forward to someone enlightening me.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic