You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player ratings v Man Utd
November 16 2026 6.31am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player ratings v Man Utd


Rogers Don Flag Horsham 27 Feb 19 10.55pm

Guaita 5
Ward 7
Kelly 6
Tomkins 6
Van Arnholt 2
McArthur 5
Luka 6
Schlupp 6
Townsend 7
Batshuayi 5
Zaha 6

Meyer 8
Kouyate 5
Benteke 4

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

gerry theagle Flag newbury 27 Feb 19 11.58pm

That's about right but would have given Schlupp 8,and a bit harsh on PVA.

 

merganser Flag 28 Feb 19 12.04am

Could Guaita have done better with any of their three goals?

I believe Wayne H might have saved at least a couple of them.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 28 Feb 19 12.09am

Originally posted by merganser

Could Guaita have done better with any of their three goals?

I believe Wayne H might have saved at least a couple of them.

See Guita fun fact thread,

 

GlaziertoEagle Flag Coventry 28 Feb 19 12.46am

What did PVA do to deserve a 2?

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 28 Feb 19 1.05am

Originally posted by merganser

Could Guaita have done better with any of their three goals?

I believe Wayne H might have saved at least a couple of them.

No way, jose.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 28 Feb 19 6.57am

Guaita 6.5 Felt a bit flappy for their second. Don't fault him for 1 or 3. But he let 3 goals in and, beyond that, did nothing amazing.

PVA 5 My main criticism would be his forward play. He's capable of much better and needs to show it. As a defender he's just a little reticent and last night was no different.

Ward 6 A head-down player who played a head-down game. Given their first came down his side I feel he could perhaps be faulted but need to watch it back. Got a few good blocks in. A point for getting his goal, since none of our forwards can.

Kelly & Tomkins 5 Not quite sure what happened with goals 1 or 2 in terms of their culpability or otherwise so a shared rating.

Schlupp 4.5 A head-down player who played a head-down game. A friend watching on telly in Oz told me he could be faulted - arguably - for all their goals. Missed a good chance and his passing is too basic.

McArthur 6 A McArthur type game. Busy, lovely cross in the 1H but up against quality opposition

Luka 6 Similar to McArthur...A Luka-type game.

Wilf 6.5 Lively but ultimately too isolated because Sclupp & PVA couldn't feed him in useful situations.

Batshuayi 5.5 Needs to show a lot more

Townsend 6 See McArthur & Luka

Subs Meyer 7 Showed for the ball, great in possession, vision. Reconnected Wilf to the team. Deserves to start over Schlupp. Should drive at teams more. It's in his locker.

Kouyate n/a

Observations...we edged the half chances. The media might say it was comfortable, but for me it was fairly even in terms of dangerous moments. goals 1 & 2 were poor, goal 3 was us not reorganizing when PVA went off. we missed Sakho and AWB a lot.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (28 Feb 2019 7.26am)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 28 Feb 19 7.55am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Guaita 6.5 Felt a bit flappy for their second. Don't fault him for 1 or 3. But he let 3 goals in and, beyond that, did nothing amazing.

PVA 5 My main criticism would be his forward play. He's capable of much better and needs to show it. As a defender he's just a little reticent and last night was no different.

Ward 6 A head-down player who played a head-down game. Given their first came down his side I feel he could perhaps be faulted but need to watch it back. Got a few good blocks in. A point for getting his goal, since none of our forwards can.

Kelly & Tomkins 5 Not quite sure what happened with goals 1 or 2 in terms of their culpability or otherwise so a shared rating.

Schlupp 4.5 A head-down player who played a head-down game. A friend watching on telly in Oz told me he could be faulted - arguably - for all their goals. Missed a good chance and his passing is too basic.

McArthur 6 A McArthur type game. Busy, lovely cross in the 1H but up against quality opposition

Luka 6 Similar to McArthur...A Luka-type game.

Wilf 6.5 Lively but ultimately too isolated because Sclupp & PVA couldn't feed him in useful situations.

Batshuayi 5.5 Needs to show a lot more

Townsend 6 See McArthur & Luka

Subs Meyer 7 Showed for the ball, great in possession, vision. Reconnected Wilf to the team. Deserves to start over Schlupp. Should drive at teams more. It's in his locker.

Kouyate n/a

Observations...we edged the half chances. The media might say it was comfortable, but for me it was fairly even in terms of dangerous moments. goals 1 & 2 were poor, goal 3 was us not reorganizing when PVA went off. we missed Sakho and AWB a lot.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (28 Feb 2019 7.26am)

Could he have stuck his foot out for the third ?
Was very close to him .

Very good summary.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 28 Feb 19 9.13am

Originally posted by GlaziertoEagle

What did PVA do to deserve a 2?

Nothing! That's the point ... LOL

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Feb 19 9.53am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Could he have stuck his foot out for the third ?
Was very close to him .

Very good summary.

I think De Gea would have used his feet.He grew up playing Futsal and uses Futsal techniques when saving with his feet.Saves a lot with his feet.

 

eagles4lyf Flag croydon 28 Feb 19 10.07am

give schlupp a break, he had a good game, every week someones putting the blame on to schlupp when hes been a decent player for us. yesterday he was getting stuck in finding passes. PVA has been playing bad for the last month, something needs sorting there. meyer showed his class. we miss AWB , don't really understand the 3rd sub but still.

 


EAGLESSSSSSSSSSSSS.......
'BELIEVE TO ACHIEVE'

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 28 Feb 19 10.29am

Originally posted by eagles4lyf

give schlupp a break, he had a good game, every week someones putting the blame on to schlupp when hes been a decent player for us. yesterday he was getting stuck in finding passes. PVA has been playing bad for the last month, something needs sorting there. meyer showed his class. we miss AWB , don't really understand the 3rd sub but still.

I thought he was our best player yesterday.

PVA has been pretty poor all season, compared to the excellent last season.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 28 Feb 19 10.31am

Originally posted by eagles4lyf

give schlupp a break, he had a good game, every week someones putting the blame on to schlupp when hes been a decent player for us. yesterday he was getting stuck in finding passes. PVA has been playing bad for the last month, something needs sorting there. meyer showed his class. we miss AWB , don't really understand the 3rd sub but still.

I see why Roy plays him: energy and a bit of a goal threat. I simply think we have better options. Specifically Meyer.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 28 Feb 19 12.32pm

I thought Van Arnholt was a complete waste of space last night. His positional play as a defender was pathetic and he made no runs forward, which is his strength, hence a 2.

Schlupp, on the other hand, worked his socks off in midfield and was very effective. Unfortunately, he also can't defend and went missing in the box for two of the goals.

Gaita got his positioning all wrong for the second goal, even though it was an excellent finish from Lukaku.

Meyer simply has to start, but in a more advanced role.

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

viveasheagle Flag perth 28 Feb 19 1.24pm

I actually thought Luka was off his game - misplaced quite a lot of passes but given his usually consistency can give him 1 bad game. Jimmy Mac played well in an even first half and Max played great when he came on.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player ratings v Man Utd