You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > VAR v Watford
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAR v Watford


timmyb Flag Banstead 14 Mar 19 5.17pm

Not a big fan of VAR on the whole.

However, could be a distinct advantage for us v Watford.

Their repeated challenges on Wilf will come into closer focus - remember the challenge on Andros by the Grimsby lad in the 3rd round game that got upgraded from yellow to red card.

There are bound to be penalty shouts in the box that will also get greater attention...hopefully revealing that our man really isn't the diver they make him out to be.

So for once I'm glad the VAR will be available.
Had we had it last Saturday, Knockaert would have been off in the first minute.

 

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 14 Mar 19 5.47pm

I am not going to hold my breath on this one, Sod’s law will kick in and we will get jimmy Mc sent off and Wilf will give a penalty away.
But COYE would be great to get to Wembley again

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 14 Mar 19 8.04pm

I'm a fan of it and agree with the OP... Hopefully it will stop them getting away with kicking lumps out of Wilf!!

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 14 Mar 19 8.45pm

We will have to be careful as well, not just them. Luka needs to be a bit less enthusiastic with some of his tackles and Dann if he plays will have to try to find another way to defend corners without hanging on to someone’s shirt.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 15 Mar 19 5.58am

Originally posted by timmyb

So for once I'm glad the VAR will be available.
Had we had it last Saturday, Knockaert would have been off in the first minute.

And Dann would have conceded a penalty

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 15 Mar 19 6.02am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

And Dann would have conceded a penalty

Once VAR is in full swing next season i reckon for a few weeks it will be like xbox fifa.
The prem is so quick compared to other leagues already with it.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 15 Mar 19 12.28pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

And Dann would have conceded a penalty

Not necessarily. Who knows what would have happened if Knockaert had correctly been sent off.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Midlands Eagle Flag 15 Mar 19 1.26pm

Originally posted by topcat


Not necessarily. Who knows what would have happened if Knockaert had correctly been sent off.

We managed to concede 3 goals against ten men when we played Brighton at their place so perhaps if Knockaert had been sent off we would have lost by more than we did

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Mar 19 1.29pm

Originally posted by timmyb

Not a big fan of VAR on the whole.

However, could be a distinct advantage for us v Watford.

Their repeated challenges on Wilf will come into closer focus - remember the challenge on Andros by the Grimsby lad in the 3rd round game that got upgraded from yellow to red card.

There are bound to be penalty shouts in the box that will also get greater attention...hopefully revealing that our man really isn't the diver they make him out to be.

So for once I'm glad the VAR will be available.
Had we had it last Saturday, Knockaert would have been off in the first minute.

..You basically just summed up the reason for it and how it would help us, so why do you not like it on the whole?
It will rid the league of Watford.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Mar 19 1.39pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

We managed to concede two goals against ten men and one against twelve which being the first goal was extremely pivotal to our performance when we played Brighton at their place so perhaps if Knockaert had been sent off we could have caused them more problems by having less of them in our face defending.

EFA

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Mar 19 1.55pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

And Dann would have conceded a penalty

The game would have been a lot different, they would have had to change their attacking ideas utterly, we probably still wouldn't have scored in open play because they would have defended us to death and they would've booted the ball up field even more and if Murray (hadn't been subbed with the sending off) had been there with Tomkins farting about they could have caused even more problems!

Ten men ruins football, instead the team who is fouled should be allowed to bring on another player so 12 against 11 and that will not ruin it for the fans.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 15 Mar 19 4.11pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink


EFA

Please don't edit my quote in a such a ridiculous manner otherwise I might have a closer look into who you really are

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 16 Mar 19 6.49am

In recent weeks I’ve become very anti VAR.

The decision to award Man Utd a penalty was madness. In the Ajax and Barcelona games, there were unnecessary reviews which took 4 minutes to confirm the goals. It’s slowing down the game and momentum and it seems every crucial decision is being over reviewed.

It will help Palace vs Watford, simply because Zaha should win about 40% more penalties than he does. Even though it helps Palace, I’m against it. Ruining our game. Refereeing injustice is part of the drama in football. The technology is not being used effectively.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Mar 19 8.07am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

In recent weeks I’ve become very anti VAR.

The decision to award Man Utd a penalty was madness. In the Ajax and Barcelona games, there were unnecessary reviews which took 4 minutes to confirm the goals. It’s slowing down the game and momentum and it seems every crucial decision is being over reviewed.

It will help Palace vs Watford, simply because Zaha should win about 40% more penalties than he does. Even though it helps Palace, I’m against it. Ruining our game. Refereeing injustice is part of the drama in football. The technology is not being used effectively.

Do you not think players turn their backs to make themselves bigger purposely then? it almost worked didn't it ..it is cheating and it was a clear penalty.

Refs don't dish out injustice, they are fooled by dramatics.
Clattenburg not included.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 Mar 19 11.16am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Please don't edit my quote in a such a ridiculous manner otherwise I might have a closer look into who you really are

More threats, you really are a bully aren't you. Maybe you should relinquish your moderators role and just become another abusive poster.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 16 Mar 19 3.57pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Do you not think players turn their backs to make themselves bigger purposely then? it almost worked didn't it ..it is cheating and it was a clear penalty.

Couldn’t disagree more.

I have seen various post match analysis of the incident and no one seems to agree it was a penalty and to be perfectly frank, virtually everyone seems think the total opposite and are astounded and appalled that it was given as a penalty. As was said at the time, it is unlikely that anyone who has ever played the game would consider that to be a penalty, let alone a clear one!

The fact that you also think the second RMA goal in their game at Levante was also a penalty tells me that you are either just on a complete wind up or would be potentially the worst referee the game has ever seen

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 16 Mar 19 5.11pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Do you not think players turn their backs to make themselves bigger purposely then? it almost worked didn't it ..it is cheating and it was a clear penalty.

Refs don't dish out injustice, they are fooled by dramatics.
Clattenburg not included.

No I don’t, not at all. It’s a very natural reaction to turn away when blocking a shot. No one wants a shot to hit them in the bollocks/stomach/face.

I agree they are fooled by dramatics, it’s cheating by players and needs to be stamped out. As I said on the previous VAR thread, a better solution for this would be to actually enforce the retrospective diving bans. We see dives go unpunished every week on MOTD.

VAR was introduced to avoid referee clangers. This can be achieved by giving captains 1 review per game. If their review is correct, it’s reinstated. This would stop every bloody incident being reviewed for 3/4 minutes and would keep the game flowing.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > VAR v Watford