You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Question - Cardiff or Brighton?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Question - Cardiff or Brighton?


Page 1 of 14 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
paperhat Flag croydon 08 Apr 19 4.20pm

With all the "Liverpool are going to choke" news going thru the media over the past few weeks and the scenes of indignation and surprise of various presenters when faced with Man Utd fans who'd happily see their team lose if it meant Liverpool not winning the Prem title, another question arises, much closer to home.

Following our win at Newcastle and our almost safety, if it came to us playing Cardiff in our penultimate game and in the event of a Cardiff win, they stayed up, relegating Brighton, which one of us would be on the pitch first to score the own goal? Seriously - would you take a Palace defeat, knowing we were safe no matter what if it meant that result sent the Seagulls down?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Lyons550 Flag Shirley 08 Apr 19 4.27pm

Of course...with 3 own goals to ensure it I hope!

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Apr 19 5.08pm

Originally posted by paperhat

With all the "Liverpool are going to choke" news going thru the media over the past few weeks and the scenes of indignation and surprise of various presenters when faced with Man Utd fans who'd happily see their team lose if it meant Liverpool not winning the Prem title, another question arises, much closer to home.

Following our win at Newcastle and our almost safety, if it came to us playing Cardiff in our penultimate game and in the event of a Cardiff win, they stayed up, relegating Brighton, which one of us would be on the pitch first to score the own goal? Seriously - would you take a Palace defeat, knowing we were safe no matter what if it meant that result sent the Seagulls down?

Clearly a history lesson required

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 08 Apr 19 5.09pm

Absolutely. As I'm sure they would if the situation was reversed.

 

est1905 Flag 08 Apr 19 5.17pm

Originally posted by paperhat

With all the "Liverpool are going to choke" news going thru the media over the past few weeks and the scenes of indignation and surprise of various presenters when faced with Man Utd fans who'd happily see their team lose if it meant Liverpool not winning the Prem title, another question arises, much closer to home.

Following our win at Newcastle and our almost safety, if it came to us playing Cardiff in our penultimate game and in the event of a Cardiff win, they stayed up, relegating Brighton, which one of us would be on the pitch first to score the own goal? Seriously - would you take a Palace defeat, knowing we were safe no matter what if it meant that result sent the Seagulls down?

I have no doubt Brighton would roll over if it meant us going down. Just like Pompy did a few years back so the Saints went.
I'd be indifferent I think. Would see it as a win win. If we won I'd be glad the team showed integrity. If we lost I'd try not to look too hard at the performance and be bouyed by the Seaweed's demise.

I'd much rather play them occassionally in the cups than have them in the same league as us anyway. Despite their lovely new stadium I still consider them a smaller club than us. They are at the moment at the absolute peak of their potential whereas we are above them and even non Palace fans that know football agree we are underperforming.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Apr 19 6.55pm

Originally posted by est1905

I have no doubt Brighton would roll over if it meant us going down. Just like Pompy did a few years back so the Saints went.
I'd be indifferent I think. Would see it as a win win. If we won I'd be glad the team showed integrity. If we lost I'd try not to look too hard at the performance and be bouyed by the Seaweed's demise.

I'd much rather play them occassionally in the cups than have them in the same league as us anyway. Despite their lovely new stadium I still consider them a smaller club than us. They are at the moment at the absolute peak of their potential whereas we are above them and even non Palace fans that know football agree we are underperforming.

I am informed that their Training Centre is also very impressive,containing 15 pitches and various training areas and they have submitted plans to extend it.Sadly their infrastructure is far better than ours. But they are below us in the table !

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 09 Apr 19 9.14am

Although 'rivals' I don't consider them a threat and despite the results not going our way this season would regard them as a shoe in as one of the 3 weaker teams needed each season to keep us up


They could of course creep up behind us if we are caught with our pants down but in general would like to keep them where we can see them and thats in or around the bottom .

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 09 Apr 19 10.08am

Originally posted by Willo

I am informed that their Training Centre is also very impressive,containing 15 pitches and various training areas and they have submitted plans to extend it.Sadly their infrastructure is far better than ours. But they are below us in the table !

I suppose that we could have a new stadium and state-of-the-art training facilities if our owners chucked in £300m+, interest free, with no expectation of seeing it again?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Apr 19 10.45am

Chuck the game, no questions asked, but instead of a performance similar to Watford away or spurs away we’ll probably really go for it like we do when the season is winding down, only Cardiff won’t be in a Leicester type position, who we’ve played twice with their minds on holiday.

 


COYP

The Dolphin Flag 09 Apr 19 10.53am

Sadly I can't see Cardiff getting enough points because I would love to see Brighton relegated.
However I still want us to beat Cardiff at their place so we can finish as high up the table as possible!

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 09 Apr 19 11.52am

Would love us to roll over if it meant Cardiff leapfrogging Brighton. I don't believe it would happen though as players and management too professional. League position & money are at stake.

 

Rainforest Flag London England 09 Apr 19 11.59am

What the Cardiff forum thinks:

[Link]

 

Tipp_Eagle Flag Tipperary 09 Apr 19 12.26pm

send the brighton b******s down , w***ers .

 


oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.

Terry Ven Flag 09 Apr 19 2.58pm

Sadly I can't agree that they are at the peak of their potential. Even if hopefully they did get relegated they have got a long term strategy and infrastructure (new ground, new training complex, new youth set-up, a feeder club in Belgium) in place that means that they likely to keep developing. Sadly in comparison we have a drawing of a new stand.

Originally posted by est1905

I have no doubt Brighton would roll over if it meant us going down. Just like Pompy did a few years back so the Saints went.
I'd be indifferent I think. Would see it as a win win. If we won I'd be glad the team showed integrity. If we lost I'd try not to look too hard at the performance and be bouyed by the Seaweed's demise.

I'd much rather play them occassionally in the cups than have them in the same league as us anyway. Despite their lovely new stadium I still consider them a smaller club than us. They are at the moment at the absolute peak of their potential whereas we are above them and even non Palace fans that know football agree we are underperforming.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Apr 19 4.19pm

Can they do a Leicester (did they win something like 5 of their last six and stay up)? Seems unlikely but it has happened. We all know that away fans do not necessarily have the best of times in Wales, yet I can't help but prefer Cardiff over Bright*n. Warnock is his hilarious best too, while I have never personally enjoyed Hughton's interviews.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Terry Ven Flag 11 Apr 19 4.46pm

I can't like Warnock; he's a swivel-eyed Brexiteer for a start. And frankly Cardiff fans are up there with the most obnoxious and aggressive in the Prem. I'm never going away there again.

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Can they do a Leicester (did they win something like 5 of their last six and stay up)? Seems unlikely but it has happened. We all know that away fans do not necessarily have the best of times in Wales, yet I can't help but prefer Cardiff over Bright*n. Warnock is his hilarious best too, while I have never personally enjoyed Hughton's interviews.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 11 Apr 19 6.24pm

Originally posted by Terry Ven

I can't like Warnock; he's a swivel-eyed Brexiteer for a start. And frankly Cardiff fans are up there with the most obnoxious and aggressive in the Prem. I'm never going away there again.

Well done, you've turned this into another political thread. I also am a 'swivel eyed Brexiteer. What say you now?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

crvenaeagle Flag 12 Apr 19 11.10am

Just checked the remaining fixtures, ohhh man is it gonna be close, some real entertainment for the end of the season. Fingers and bollocks crossed eh?!

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 13 Apr 19 3.22am

I want Brighton down, all day every day... jealous of their set up, they have got it good compared to us. However, i like Warnock, i don't like how Cardiff have handled themselves of late.
Cardiff next season will be under a new manager and odds on to go down so yeah.... Brighton down now, Cardiff next year.

 


This was once a quality forum....

jeeagles Flag 13 Apr 19 10.32am

Brighton down please. Looks very unlikely even through we gifted them 6 points this season.

Rivalry aside, they have a better set up and more potential than Cardiff too, so will pose more of a threat next season.

Not sure what the current view of of Chris Houghton down there. They've played badly for months. Players and fans alike must be getting sick of him.

 

Page 1 of 14 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Question - Cardiff or Brighton?