You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Modern CPFC. Would you have signed up for it?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Modern CPFC. Would you have signed up for it?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
TheBigToePunt Flag 21 Apr 19 6.51pm

This doesn't even take into account today's fine win at Arsenal:

[Link]

If you look up the previous five seasons we've been in the league, the tables looks similar.

The team has been a counter attacking one since Freedman put it together in the championship, making us better suited to away wins than home ones (drastically so, plainly) and every attempt since then to change playing style has led to burnt fingers.

Personally, if 8 years ago I'd have been offered promotion followed by six years of what's on the link, including a cup final, a new training ground and new main stand on the way, I'd have bit your hand off. Just take a minute to think back to where we actually were.

At the same time, most of us watch the team at home of course, and it hasn't always been easy.

So, honestly, would you have taken what we got? Would you prefer to see them winning championship home games? Would you be happy with another few years of the same?

Makes you think. Well, it's made me think anyway, but then I've had a beer on account of the great away win today...

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 21 Apr 19 7.00pm

The Premier League was always our target. To remain in it and continue to be part of it was always our Holy Grail. However, now we seem to think either our grail is sullied or we'd like a couple of diamonds added to it.
I suppose, we are not really competing for anything so it all seems a bit flat. If we had a decent squad, I would enjoy a cup run - or dare I say it - away games in the Europa League or something different to spice it up.
A couple of summer signings could add interest - hopefully we can make a couple of decent signings. I won't hold my breath. Currently, would not be optimistic for next season.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 21 Apr 19 9.12pm

I think we’ve become victims of our own success. Like the above, the dream was to get to the Prem, now we’ve achieved it and been here so long it’s become a bit dull. Mid table obscurity is not a fun place to be, my interest switched off about 6 weeks ago and that’s never happened.

There is so much negativity around. People on some threads are even criticising Hodgson which is frankly mind blowing. He’s the ultimate gent and has us firing. It’s the best Palace team I’ve ever seen. Possibly 50 points this season.

Atmosphere is getting gradually worse as there is a sense of entitlement now. Tourists wearing a half and half scarves.

Perhaps the next dream is Europa League/winning a cup. Would I change the last 8 years... undecided. Beating Brighton in the playoffs and Puncheon scoring in the cup final will stay with me forever, but the Championship was more fun.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 19 9.50pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

I think we’ve become victims of our own success. Like the above, the dream was to get to the Prem, now we’ve achieved it and been here so long it’s become a bit dull. Mid table obscurity is not a fun place to be, my interest switched off about 6 weeks ago and that’s never happened.

There is so much negativity around. People on some threads are even criticising Hodgson which is frankly mind blowing. He’s the ultimate gent and has us firing. It’s the best Palace team I’ve ever seen. Possibly 50 points this season.

Atmosphere is getting gradually worse as there is a sense of entitlement now. Tourists wearing a half and half scarves.

Perhaps the next dream is Europa League/winning a cup. Would I change the last 8 years... undecided. Beating Brighton in the playoffs and Puncheon scoring in the cup final will stay with me forever, but the Championship was more fun.

‘Hodgson has us firing.’ Are you sure?

I understand why Parish wants Hodgson and thinks he’s good for us from a business angle compared to some of the managerial errors there have been at other clubs, but having us firing? Really? You may have convinced yourself of this somehow.

Atmosphere has gradually got worse because of the length of time we’ve been here but also because of the nature of the football. There’s little excitement. And mid table obscurity. Again, really? It’s only at the end of the season when catch opposition winding down that we propel ourselves up the table to 11th-12th. Before then we’re hovering just above or in the relegation zone or relegation battle at best.

Again, I completely understand why Parish is likely to stick with Hodgson until Hodgson can’t or doesn’t want to continue but I can’t pretend it’s not boring. I’ll still pay my money but I’m bored and don’t have the passion or excitement I’ve always had.

In answer to the original question, yes, I would’ve signed up for it. Counter attacking football is modern day equivalent of long ball or Coppell type whack it to Wright or Bright from wherever you think you can pick them out. We do now play with more possession but Roy can’t make it effective without the quality of RLC or 3 high quality offensive players behind the forward, but then he doesn’t play to the forward’s strengths and then the problems of how and why the players we’ve signed are here. A lot of disjointed stuff as usual. Being in a full Selhurst be the best is better than a half empty one with about 100 home fans instead of loads more Palace fans and tourists but I understand the frustration of the tourists.

 


COYP

midlandspalace Flag kidderminster 22 Apr 19 11.59am

I suspect that people's views on this will vary according to their age and length of support for Palace. There will be some who have no experience of being in the top division until this spell. It is hugely understandable that they would like us to kick on.

All I would say to them is look what happened to many of the clubs of our size who thought they were "established", then tried to "kick on", such as Charlton or Bolton.

For those of us with a longer perspective (I have been watching since 1963) this is the first time we have had so many years in the top flight. Previously we had four years from 69-73, being thrashed every week by other London teams especially (watching The Big Match with Brian Moore was a nightmare). We had the occasional high, such as beating Man Utd 5-0 in Dec 72, but we still got relegated that season, and the one after for good measure.

We then had two seasons with "the team of the 80s", so tragically ruined and broken up by Venables, and slipped down two divisions again.

The late 80s/early 90s spell was a highlight, Wright/Bright, cup final, finishing 3rd, almost a team full of internationals, but we still slipped away after 4 seasons.

After that the yoyo existence, up/down/up down etc .

So, we have now had six full seasons in the top flight, and this season have beaten four of the top ten away from home. We won at Manchester City, the moneybags team, the only team to take even a point from there. We won at Arsenal, for the first time in 25 years. I know the home form has been disappointing, but this is nirvana compared with the past.

Be careful what you wish for, and enjoy it whilst you have it.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 22 Apr 19 12.26pm

Originally posted by midlandspalace

I suspect that people's views on this will vary according to their age and length of support for Palace. There will be some who have no experience of being in the top division until this spell. It is hugely understandable that they would like us to kick on.

All I would say to them is look what happened to many of the clubs of our size who thought they were "established", then tried to "kick on", such as Charlton or Bolton.

For those of us with a longer perspective (I have been watching since 1963) this is the first time we have had so many years in the top flight. Previously we had four years from 69-73, being thrashed every week by other London teams especially (watching The Big Match with Brian Moore was a nightmare). We had the occasional high, such as beating Man Utd 5-0 in Dec 72, but we still got relegated that season, and the one after for good measure.

We then had two seasons with "the team of the 80s", so tragically ruined and broken up by Venables, and slipped down two divisions again.

The late 80s/early 90s spell was a highlight, Wright/Bright, cup final, finishing 3rd, almost a team full of internationals, but we still slipped away after 4 seasons.

After that the yoyo existence, up/down/up down etc .

So, we have now had six full seasons in the top flight, and this season have beaten four of the top ten away from home. We won at Manchester City, the moneybags team, the only team to take even a point from there. We won at Arsenal, for the first time in 25 years. I know the home form has been disappointing, but this is nirvana compared with the past.

Be careful what you wish for, and enjoy it whilst you have it.

That's a far too sensible and reasoned post for this forum!!

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 22 Apr 19 12.36pm

Yes I would sign up again and I am as addicted as ever. The home form obviously has been disappointing lately but could possibly get better with a couple of right fit signings. I would add that away games have a completely different feel and perhaps more people should travel a bit more to give a more balanced feel to things. I know some tickets are hard to get but the Arsenal tickets were available for ages and even if we had lost it would be an ok day out but it was in fact fantastic and keeps me coming back for more.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Apr 19 1.10pm

Originally posted by midlandspalace

I suspect that people's views on this will vary according to their age and length of support for Palace. There will be some who have no experience of being in the top division until this spell. It is hugely understandable that they would like us to kick on.

All I would say to them is look what happened to many of the clubs of our size who thought they were "established", then tried to "kick on", such as Charlton or Bolton.

For those of us with a longer perspective (I have been watching since 1963) this is the first time we have had so many years in the top flight. Previously we had four years from 69-73, being thrashed every week by other London teams especially (watching The Big Match with Brian Moore was a nightmare). We had the occasional high, such as beating Man Utd 5-0 in Dec 72, but we still got relegated that season, and the one after for good measure.

We then had two seasons with "the team of the 80s", so tragically ruined and broken up by Venables, and slipped down two divisions again.

The late 80s/early 90s spell was a highlight, Wright/Bright, cup final, finishing 3rd, almost a team full of internationals, but we still slipped away after 4 seasons.

After that the yoyo existence, up/down/up down etc .

So, we have now had six full seasons in the top flight, and this season have beaten four of the top ten away from home. We won at Manchester City, the moneybags team, the only team to take even a point from there. We won at Arsenal, for the first time in 25 years. I know the home form has been disappointing, but this is nirvana compared with the past.

Be careful what you wish for, and enjoy it whilst you have it.

Almost exactly the way I see it with just a small difference.

Some of those that want us to '' kick on '' simply do not understand the broader picture but instead are content to just lay blame on Roy Hodgson and / or Steve Parish when it suits them. Even yesterday's win was met with yet more criticism rather than focusing on the positives.

I suspect that if we finished in that Holy Grail position of 8th for a few seasons in a row they would then complain about the lack of progression above that.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Apr 19 1.14pm

Originally posted by midlandspalace

I suspect that people's views on this will vary according to their age and length of support for Palace. There will be some who have no experience of being in the top division until this spell. It is hugely understandable that they would like us to kick on.

All I would say to them is look what happened to many of the clubs of our size who thought they were "established", then tried to "kick on", such as Charlton or Bolton.

For those of us with a longer perspective (I have been watching since 1963) this is the first time we have had so many years in the top flight. Previously we had four years from 69-73, being thrashed every week by other London teams especially (watching The Big Match with Brian Moore was a nightmare). We had the occasional high, such as beating Man Utd 5-0 in Dec 72, but we still got relegated that season, and the one after for good measure.

We then had two seasons with "the team of the 80s", so tragically ruined and broken up by Venables, and slipped down two divisions again.

The late 80s/early 90s spell was a highlight, Wright/Bright, cup final, finishing 3rd, almost a team full of internationals, but we still slipped away after 4 seasons.

After that the yoyo existence, up/down/up down etc .

So, we have now had six full seasons in the top flight, and this season have beaten four of the top ten away from home. We won at Manchester City, the moneybags team, the only team to take even a point from there. We won at Arsenal, for the first time in 25 years. I know the home form has been disappointing, but this is nirvana compared with the past.

Be careful what you wish for, and enjoy it whilst you have it.

With absolutely no respect for your lack of ambition born from a personal fear of failure, none of that is relevant.

Be careful what you wish for is a self fulfilling prophecy. As is enjoy it whilst it lasts.

You seem certain in your own mind that we will go down eventually, what a bleak outlook. Why bother supporting Palace through all those years of s***e just to wait for the day that the bad times return? Shades of Stockholm syndrome.

In fairness, I agree, relegation is coming so we should enjoy negative football and 4 home wins a season whilst we can. Eventually we will go back down with an incompetent board and mediocre manager kept in jobs by fans with small-team mentality. I predict next season. Then it's not a case as "be careful what you wish for", more "what might have been".

And as for this: look at Charlton bull s***, can we all have more respect for ourselves than to keep trotting this out? f*** Charlton, their history has absolutely no baring on our future.

If we're going to trot out irrelevant and unrelated club histories to compare our own ambitions against, why not Barcelona?

We could be the next Barcelona as much as we could be the next bloody Charlton. It's all about attitude.
7 years is not an achievement. We are an established premier League team. Let's kick on.
Anything other than top 8 next season and a trip to Wembley is failure.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Apr 19 1.17pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Almost exactly the way I see it with just a small difference.

Some of those that want us to '' kick on '' simply do not understand the broader picture but instead are content to just lay blame on Roy Hodgson and / or Steve Parish when it suits them. Even yesterday's win was met with yet more criticism rather than focusing on the positives.

I suspect that if we finished in that Holy Grail position of 8th for a few seasons in a row they would then complain about the lack of progression above that.

Absolutely!

Nothing wrong with ambition.

You and the fear mongers would still be saying "remember Charlton". I know which mindset I'd rather have.

Pathetic.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 22 Apr 19 1.51pm

Mid-table obscurity is indeed dull. Imagine being an Everton fan! Year after year of 9th place finishes. I've often wondered how they (the fans) do it.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Apr 19 2.03pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Absolutely!

Nothing wrong with ambition.

You and the fear mongers would still be saying "remember Charlton". I know which mindset I'd rather have.

Pathetic.

Nothing wrong with ambition ? I couldn't agree more. I've been ambitious in my professional life and I've done ok.

But it has to be realistic .

Charlton are often quoted as it's the most memorable example of a club of then similar size. A friend of mine was on the Board when Curbishly was ousted because of people like you demanding more without having a clue as to the difficulties associated with doing so. If you hadn't noticed, the effects of that decision are still being felt at Charlton today.

For Palace the first priority is to stay in the Premier League. Win that race to X number of points and then push on. I'm willing to bet that is the same at a good number of other clubs. Then you have those with massive financial means - West Ham, Everton, Leicester and Wolves that have ' achieved ' little more than upper mid table. Only Watford have been the exception and they have 7 points more than us. In theory we could end the season on that number or not far adrift.

If that's not good enough for you and your ambitions, you do have a choice as you well know.

Anyway, it's actually pointless trying to debate anything with you because you have your own agenda and do not respect any other views other than your own.

Now that is pathetic.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Apr 19 2.22pm

I was hooked as a 9 year old so there wasn't much choice for me.

If I were only now looking at Football and deciding what club to support....when you take geographic out of it the biggest aspect for me would be the stadium.

On that ground (forgive the pun) Palace probably wouldn't get the vote. If I lived in London it would probably be Spurs.

But I'm Palace, win, lose or draw and that's pretty much full stop.

Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Apr 2019 2.23pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Park Road Flag 22 Apr 19 2.32pm


Modern CPFC. Would you have signed up for it?

I didn't choose Palace as my team, by default Palace chose me...

As for Modern CPFC - no different to the old one...

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Apr 19 2.35pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Nothing wrong with ambition ? I couldn't agree more. I've been ambitious in my professional life and I've done ok.

But it has to be realistic .

Charlton are often quoted as it's the most memorable example of a club of then similar size. A friend of mine was on the Board when Curbishly was ousted because of people like you demanding more without having a clue as to the difficulties associated with doing so. If you hadn't noticed, the effects of that decision are still being felt at Charlton today.

For Palace the first priority is to stay in the Premier League. Win that race to X number of points and then push on. I'm willing to bet that is the same at a good number of other clubs. Then you have those with massive financial means - West Ham, Everton, Leicester and Wolves that have ' achieved ' little more than upper mid table. Only Watford have been the exception and they have 7 points more than us. In theory we could end the season on that number or not far adrift.

If that's not good enough for you and your ambitions, you do have a choice as you well know.

Anyway, it's actually pointless trying to debate anything with you because you have your own agenda and do not respect any other views other than your own.

Now that is pathetic.

Oh dear o dear.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 22 Apr 19 2.44pm

It's a bit frustrating seeing that table - even an average home season would have seen us in 7th at the moment.

Anyway, for me the Championship comparison always comes back to the Hillsborough game. You can look at crap 1-0 home defeats to Plymouth where you don't have a shot and wonder what you're doing watching football. Hillsborough though was the epitome of excitement - everything on the line. It was fun as hell, but in a really sick way.

I wouldn't want us to undervalue what this current period is doing for the club. Had we not gone up, with our infrastructure (ground, training ground) we'd be nowhere in the Championship now. There's clubs that still outclass us on those fronts.

Once we've got that side of the club invested in, we'll be set up for the future in a way we could have only dreamed of. It is fun to watch a team that has the ability to pick up 7 points at the Etihad, Old Trafford and the Emirates. Annoying at home, but hopefully we can swing that around and enter the next phase of the club's history.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

midlandspalace Flag kidderminster 22 Apr 19 3.11pm

I wasn't at Hillsborough but I was at Stockport, waiting listening to the radio for the final whistle to go at Huddersfield.

For those who accuse me of "lack of ambition", as far as the top tier is concerned there is top 6 and the rest. there is currently a 15 point gap between 6th and 7th place. We are "the rest". Burnley finished 7th last season and almost got relegated this. Southampton finished 8th twice and have struggled since. Everton spent £150 million trying to break into the top 6 and ended up appointing Allardyce to stop them getting relegated.

It is impossible for a normal club to compete with Emirati oil money, Russian Oligarch money, etc etc. The top 6 all have stadiums seating 60,000 give or take, and unlimited reserves of cash to burn. This is now working its way down the division, with huge outside money at clubs like Bournemouth even.

It is not a lack of ambition that says "we are not going to break into the top 6". This is a golden time to be a Palace fan so enjoy it and stop whinging.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 22 Apr 19 3.18pm

Originally posted by midlandspalace

I wasn't at Hillsborough but I was at Stockport, waiting listening to the radio for the final whistle to go at Huddersfield.

For those who accuse me of "lack of ambition", as far as the top tier is concerned there is top 6 and the rest. there is currently a 15 point gap between 6th and 7th place. We are "the rest". Burnley finished 7th last season and almost got relegated this. Southampton finished 8th twice and have struggled since. Everton spent £150 million trying to break into the top 6 and ended up appointing Allardyce to stop them getting relegated.

It is impossible for a normal club to compete with Emirati oil money, Russian Oligarch money, etc etc. The top 6 all have stadiums seating 60,000 give or take, and unlimited reserves of cash to burn. This is now working its way down the division, with huge outside money at clubs like Bournemouth even.

It is not a lack of ambition that says "we are not going to break into the top 6". This is a golden time to be a Palace fan so enjoy it and stop whinging.

Don't deprive them of their fun because they just love whinging and moaning. Don't you know they know it all and would do a far better job than any Manager Parish could find.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

samprior Flag Hamburg 22 Apr 19 3.32pm

If I could wave a magic wand that'd guarantee us exactly the same results/performances as this season for the next 5 years then I would. It might not be pretty or exciting but it'd allow us to become a financially stable, fully established side with an improved stadium to boot. Sorry if that's aiming low but I'm in it for the long run.

 

midlandspalace Flag kidderminster 22 Apr 19 3.36pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Don't deprive them of their fun because they just love whinging and moaning. Don't you know they know it all and would do a far better job than any Manager Parish could find.

Except that skinflint Steve Parish would not be the Chairman would he, it would be some representative of Saudi Arabian petro dollars.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Modern CPFC. Would you have signed up for it?