You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tactics after 2 CMs signed. Macca backup winger?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tactics after 2 CMs signed. Macca backup winger?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
mattteo Flag 09 Aug 19 6.03am

Squad looks like this:

[Link]

I suspect Riedewald might stil go on loan to the Eredivisie, where the window hasn't closed yet.

There are 2 competing for RB: Ward and Kelly

4 CBs: Tomkins (curently injured), Sakho, Cahill, Dann

2 LBs (if we count Schlupp): PVA, Schlupp

4CMs: Milivojevic, Kouyate, Camarasa, McCarthy

4 offensive players centrally (as Roy likes to use Zaha there and there really aren't good options except for him): Zaha, Benteke, Jordan Ayew, Wickham

4 players remaining for the sides of the pitch: now if Andros and Schlupp are used to playing there, I can't say that these are the most usual positions for Meyer and Jimmy McArthur. They are more used to playing centrally.

But with 2 new central midfielders (Camarasa and McCarthy) coming in and Milivojevic and Kouyate still at the club, neither Meyer nor McArthur have room centrally anymore.

Even if you change formation and play a 3-4-3 or a different system (though the backline players don't seem to apply to that either), you still have too many central misfielders.

Do you guys think Macca and Meyer will be adequate the entire season in a side position or as backup for Townsend and Schlupp?

Edited by mattteo (09 Aug 2019 6.05am)

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 09 Aug 19 6.46am

Originally posted by mattteo

Squad looks like this:

[Link]

I suspect Riedewald might stil go on loan to the Eredivisie, where the window hasn't closed yet.

There are 2 competing for RB: Ward and Kelly

4 CBs: Tomkins (curently injured), Sakho, Cahill, Dann

2 LBs (if we count Schlupp): PVA, Schlupp

4CMs: Milivojevic, Kouyate, Camarasa, McCarthy

4 offensive players centrally (as Roy likes to use Zaha there and there really aren't good options except for him): Zaha, Benteke, Jordan Ayew, Wickham

4 players remaining for the sides of the pitch: now if Andros and Schlupp are used to playing there, I can't say that these are the most usual positions for Meyer and Jimmy McArthur. They are more used to playing centrally.

But with 2 new central midfielders (Camarasa and McCarthy) coming in and Milivojevic and Kouyate still at the club, neither Meyer nor McArthur have room centrally anymore.

Even if you change formation and play a 3-4-3 or a different system (though the backline players don't seem to apply to that either), you still have too many central misfielders.

Do you guys think Macca and Meyer will be adequate the entire season in a side position or as backup for Townsend and Schlupp?

Edited by mattteo (09 Aug 2019 6.05am)

Camerasa might well be used as a wideplayer, which would free up the central midfield. I suspect Meyer will be our main attacking central midfielder with Macca as sub? I believe Sakho is still injured

 

mattteo Flag 09 Aug 19 7.05am

Originally posted by Petereagle

Camerasa might well be used as a wideplayer, which would free up the central midfield. I suspect Meyer will be our main attacking central midfielder with Macca as sub? I believe Sakho is still injured

I don't think Camarasa has played more than 5 matches in his career on the wing. I don't think he can play there.

Meyer and Macca have had some success as left wing and right wing, but it remains to be seen in the long term.

The disruptive fact for the rest of the players on the pitch would be that they would deputise for Townsend and Schlupp, who are left footed players.

So, the strikers will be used to running in certain directions and spaces when the ball is at Townsend and Schlupp. They know that Townsend cuts in to the centre so the strikers might try a diagonal run towards the penalty box and they know that Schlupp is a more liniar player who will cross and will set themselves up for a cross

Having 2 right footed players like Macca and Meyer as their backups and sending them in during play (and even others like Zaha, Jordan Ayew) will mean that they will act totally opposite to Townsend and Schlupp. Meyer will be the one trying to cut inside from the left and Macca will be the liniar player.

That's disruptive for teammates.

And they can't really be moved around. Having 2 left ones (Townsend and Schlupp) and 2 right footed ones (Meyer and Jimmy Macca or Jordan Ayew) in the same position -either right midfileder or left midfielder- would have been more helpful than having one of different foot in each position.

But Schlupp can't really play as inverted winger on the right as he doesn't have the technique. Macca on the left is hard to. And Meyer on the right pretty much lacks the speed to be liniar, he's more a skillful player. Only one who can play on both sides is Townsend, both as inverted winger cutting in, dribbling and finding solutions with his technique and left winger with good crosses.

 

PatrickA Flag London 09 Aug 19 7.30am

It’s a conundrum as we have so many central midfield players.
Hodgson has favoured a narrow four man midfield with essentially 4 central midfield players in the past and I could see him doing this again.
The problem with this is that it doesn’t give Benteke any crosses to attack thereby negating his only real strength.
With the current squad it could be argued that the best balanced team would involve reverting to the Zaha/Townsend combination up front which Hodgson used in his first season.
The midfield 4 would be made up from four of Luka,McArthur,McCarthy,Camarasa,Schlupp,Meyer and Kouyate.
Not ideal but I just can’t see Benteke thriving without the crosses or fast deliveries to attack, and our approach under Hodgson tends to be methodical and pedestrian with only Zaha introducing an element of surprise.

 

mattteo Flag 09 Aug 19 8.15am

Even if Roy sends in 4 central midfielders will mean that they will strech across the pitch so 2 of them will occupy the wide positions, therefore making them wide midfielders

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 09 Aug 19 8.21am

Originally posted by PatrickA

It’s a conundrum as we have so many central midfield players.
Hodgson has favoured a narrow four man midfield with essentially 4 central midfield players in the past and I could see him doing this again.
The problem with this is that it doesn’t give Benteke any crosses to attack thereby negating his only real strength.
With the current squad it could be argued that the best balanced team would involve reverting to the Zaha/Townsend combination up front which Hodgson used in his first season.
The midfield 4 would be made up from four of Luka,McArthur,McCarthy,Camarasa,Schlupp,Meyer and Kouyate.
Not ideal but I just can’t see Benteke thriving without the crosses or fast deliveries to attack, and our approach under Hodgson tends to be methodical and pedestrian with only Zaha introducing an element of surprise.

The problem with playing 4 central midfielders is it relies on the full backs giving the width and overlapping, ok when you have AWB, not so good with Ward/Kelly, not replacing AWB our biggest mistake.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 09 Aug 19 8.28am

As a thought, could James Daly step up into the CF role. By all accounts had a good loan, albeit Kingstonian, but the lad seems to smash goals in wherever he goes.

Are there a couple of good full back prospects in the youth ranks also?

I only try an optimistic route as I just think there must be a plan b here, or a reason that the AWB money has pretty much been held back (or gone to pay stuff elsewhere). As a fan I cannot believe that SP would risk premier league survival, as that doesn’t make financial sense, so I just wonder if there’s a gem lurking at c/f and/or f/b that they feel could be the next WZ or AWB?

 

PatrickA Flag London 09 Aug 19 8.40am

My choice would be for Zaha, Benteke and Townsend to play high up the field in a 4-3-3 as under Allardyce.
I would have Meyer/ Camarasa as the attacking midfielder with Luka and one other as the two sitting midfield players.
However, Hodgson won’t do this and I have to acknowledge he has more experience than me.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 09 Aug 19 8.46am

Originally posted by mattteo

I don't think Camarasa has played more than 5 matches in his career on the wing. I don't think he can play there.

Meyer and Macca have had some success as left wing and right wing, but it remains to be seen in the long term.

The disruptive fact for the rest of the players on the pitch would be that they would deputise for Townsend and Schlupp, who are left footed players.

So, the strikers will be used to running in certain directions and spaces when the ball is at Townsend and Schlupp. They know that Townsend cuts in to the centre so the strikers might try a diagonal run towards the penalty box and they know that Schlupp is a more liniar player who will cross and will set themselves up for a cross

Having 2 right footed players like Macca and Meyer as their backups and sending them in during play (and even others like Zaha, Jordan Ayew) will mean that they will act totally opposite to Townsend and Schlupp. Meyer will be the one trying to cut inside from the left and Macca will be the liniar player.

That's disruptive for teammates.

And they can't really be moved around. Having 2 left ones (Townsend and Schlupp) and 2 right footed ones (Meyer and Jimmy Macca or Jordan Ayew) in the same position -either right midfileder or left midfielder- would have been more helpful than having one of different foot in each position.

But Schlupp can't really play as inverted winger on the right as he doesn't have the technique. Macca on the left is hard to. And Meyer on the right pretty much lacks the speed to be liniar, he's more a skillful player. Only one who can play on both sides is Townsend, both as inverted winger cutting in, dribbling and finding solutions with his technique and left winger with good crosses.

You over complicate the situation, 3 will play, and 2 will be on the bench

 

jeeagles Flag 09 Aug 19 9.02am

I’m not really sure if Roy knows what he wants and that lack of clarity from the leadership has affected recruitment.

Apart from Batshuyai, no player he has bought in has made it in the starting 11. He’s had 4 transfer windows now to do something.

He’s now signed 4 centre mids, a back up CB, resigned and released Sako, Sorloth and Ayew twice. He seems to have a complete reluctance to play to Benteke’s strengths, or to give Reidewald or Mayer a run in the team.

I’m not sure the board trust him with money.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 09 Aug 19 9.18am

Originally posted by jeeagles

I’m not really sure if Roy knows what he wants and that lack of clarity from the leadership has affected recruitment.

Apart from Batshuyai, no player he has bought in has made it in the starting 11. He’s had 4 transfer windows now to do something.

He’s now signed 4 centre mids, a back up CB, resigned and released Sako, Sorloth and Ayew twice. He seems to have a complete reluctance to play to Benteke’s strengths, or to give Reidewald or Mayer a run in the team.

I’m not sure the board trust him with money.

Roy is not happy, in his last interview he was complaining that we had no options with full backs, although he painted a picture of happiness yesterday, think its just a front

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 09 Aug 19 6.03pm

We’ve bought another attacking mid and Meyer should also be played in this position.

This leads me to believe either Meyer or Camarasa play and the other is back up.

Wilf and Andros wide front with Wickham in the middle

Luka and Kouyate holding mods.

4-2-3-1

Ward Cahil Sakho PVA

Luka Kouyate
Wilf Meyer Andros
Wickham

Then the new attacking mid to battle it out with Meyer for starting XI.
Benteke to challenge Wickham.

Apart front the RB that’s a good XI. IF Wickham can stay fit and find form.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 09 Aug 19 6.14pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Even if Roy sends in 4 central midfielders will mean that they will strech across the pitch so 2 of them will occupy the wide positions, therefore making them wide midfielders

I was interested that Kouyate played back four for Senegal at the recent Afcon.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Aug 19 7.02pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

As a thought, could James Daly step up into the CF role. By all accounts had a good loan, albeit Kingstonian, but the lad seems to smash goals in wherever he goes.

Are there a couple of good full back prospects in the youth ranks also?

I only try an optimistic route as I just think there must be a plan b here, or a reason that the AWB money has pretty much been held back (or gone to pay stuff elsewhere). As a fan I cannot believe that SP would risk premier league survival, as that doesn’t make financial sense, so I just wonder if there’s a gem lurking at c/f and/or f/b that they feel could be the next WZ or AWB?

We hope they an idea of a striker to loan in.

 


COYP

Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 Aug 19 7.14pm

Originally posted by mattteo

I don't think Camarasa has played more than 5 matches in his career on the wing. I don't think he can play there.

Meyer and Macca have had some success as left wing and right wing, but it remains to be seen in the long term.

The disruptive fact for the rest of the players on the pitch would be that they would deputise for Townsend and Schlupp, who are left footed players.

So, the strikers will be used to running in certain directions and spaces when the ball is at Townsend and Schlupp. They know that Townsend cuts in to the centre so the strikers might try a diagonal run towards the penalty box and they know that Schlupp is a more liniar player who will cross and will set themselves up for a cross

Having 2 right footed players like Macca and Meyer as their backups and sending them in during play (and even others like Zaha, Jordan Ayew) will mean that they will act totally opposite to Townsend and Schlupp. Meyer will be the one trying to cut inside from the left and Macca will be the liniar player.

That's disruptive for teammates.

And they can't really be moved around. Having 2 left ones (Townsend and Schlupp) and 2 right footed ones (Meyer and Jimmy Macca or Jordan Ayew) in the same position -either right midfileder or left midfielder- would have been more helpful than having one of different foot in each position.

But Schlupp can't really play as inverted winger on the right as he doesn't have the technique. Macca on the left is hard to. And Meyer on the right pretty much lacks the speed to be liniar, he's more a skillful player. Only one who can play on both sides is Townsend, both as inverted winger cutting in, dribbling and finding solutions with his technique and left winger with good crosses.

Roy has said now wants to play him in the position they bought him for, which, I hope, is not out wide

 

JohnB Flag 10 Aug 19 8.38am

I think we'll end up playing 4-2-2-2 and being very narrow this year.

.......Guaita


Ward..Cahill..Sakho..PVA

......Luka...McCarthy

....Camarasa....Meyer

...Townsend...Zaha

With Townsend and Benteke being interchangeable, McArthur and Kouyate swapping with Luka or McCarthy.

When we play the better teams, I imagine Meyer or Camarasa drop to the bench and we line up with Kouyate and McArthur coming in for them and sitting deep, getting the ball to Townsend and Zaha and hoping for the best.

It's going to be a long, hard season.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 10 Aug 19 10.23am

Ward has gone from back-up to an assured starter, while injuries to Tomkins and Sakho mean it is probably between Dann and Cahill as to who starts with Kelly. Given Dann's showing in pre-season and the end of last season I think Cahill may come straight in. PvA once again starts by default.

Midfield is where the only real questions sit. Meyer had a good pre-season and delivered some good crosses in from the left for Tekkers, which suggests he will start on the left of midfield. Luka always starts in the middle. Alongside him in the middle will probably be McArthur to begin with, as Kouyate is only just back from AFCON and McCarthy only arrived Wednesday; depending on James Snr's performances will probably decide if he keeps his starting place. Townsend starts on the right.

Personally, especially given the lack of a new forward, I think Zaha will play up top this season alongside Tekkers, Wickham or Camaraso, with the latter also an option further back if the rest of the midfield fail to perform.


Given Roy's general management of new signings, my prediction for the XI today is this, with Camarasa or Wilf replacing Ayew at the point at which Roy decides he's run around enough:


Guaita


Ward Kelly Cahill PvA


Townsend McArthur Luka Meyer


Bentenke Ayew

 

mattteo Flag 11 Aug 19 1.08pm

Meyer did play as left winger

 

YT Flag Oxford 11 Aug 19 1.45pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Ward has gone from back-up to an assured starter, while injuries to Tomkins and Sakho mean it is probably between Dann and Cahill as to who starts with Kelly. Given Dann's showing in pre-season and the end of last season I think Cahill may come straight in. PvA once again starts by default.

Midfield is where the only real questions sit. Meyer had a good pre-season and delivered some good crosses in from the left for Tekkers, which suggests he will start on the left of midfield. Luka always starts in the middle. Alongside him in the middle will probably be McArthur to begin with, as Kouyate is only just back from AFCON and McCarthy only arrived Wednesday; depending on James Snr's performances will probably decide if he keeps his starting place. Townsend starts on the right.

Personally, especially given the lack of a new forward, I think Zaha will play up top this season alongside Tekkers, Wickham or Camaraso, with the latter also an option further back if the rest of the midfield fail to perform.


Given Roy's general management of new signings, my prediction for the XI today is this, with Camarasa or Wilf replacing Ayew at the point at which Roy decides he's run around enough:


Guaita


Ward Kelly Cahill PvA


Townsend McArthur Luka Meyer


Bentenke Ayew

Damned close. Well done.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ger20 Flag London 11 Aug 19 3.24pm

I think This summer was the perfect opportunity to rebuild, an opportunity lost. It was a time to find replacements for Sakho and Dann, a back up LB and RB and a striker. Palace have the oldest bunch of players in the EPL

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tactics after 2 CMs signed. Macca backup winger?