You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Formation suggestion
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Formation suggestion


Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Oct 19 2.15pm

I know it hasn’t worked for us in the past, but as one of our strengths seems to lie with our centre halves then why not try this formation utilising Schlupp (or PVA) and Townsend as wing backs

Guaita

Townsend, Tomkins, Cahill, Kelly, Schlupp (or PVA)

McArthur, Milivojevic, Kouyate, Zaha

Ayew

Would the additional centre half cover the defensive weaknesses of Townsend and Schlupp? I don’t profess to know whether this would work with our personnel but on the basis we look devoid of different ideas when under the cosh, putting it out there as a plan B. Thoughts anyone?

 

aj36094 Flag Derbyshire 01 Oct 19 3.14pm

I see your thoughts and especially as none of our centre backs are particularly quick but our defence isn't too bad, so why put an extra player at the back and allow pressure?

Also the right side would be too slow for this to work

Ward - Too slow/ poor crosses
Townsend - less defensive and the counter will slow down when he cuts inside to cross

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Oct 19 7.47pm

Thank goodness Roy is the manager.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

LeftWing11 Flag Lee 01 Oct 19 8.19pm

Guaita

Ward, Cahill, Sakho, PVA

Milivojevic, Kouyate

Townsend, Camarasa or Meyer, Zaha

Ayew

This for me has always been our best formation. Roy would be happy as there are two holding midfielders and we’d have a little bit of flair going forward….just saying…

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Oct 19 9.02pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Thank goodness Roy is the manager.

That’s helpful! Thanks for your contribution

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Oct 19 9.05pm

Originally posted by LeftWing11

Guaita

Ward, Cahill, Sakho, PVA

Milivojevic, Kouyate

Townsend, Camarasa or Meyer, Zaha

Ayew

This for me has always been our best formation. Roy would be happy as there are two holding midfielders and we’d have a little bit of flair going forward….just saying…

That’s fine, but is that any different to the shape we already play, just a change of personnel. I agree about two holding midfielders but we do need a plan B and I never see a change of shape out on the pitch regardless of the score.

 

LeftWing11 Flag Lee 01 Oct 19 9.22pm

I think this allows us to get some creativity into the middle of the pitch instead of playing Meyer on the left wing as Roy did in the early games.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Oct 19 6.13am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

That’s helpful! Thanks for your contribution

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Oct 19 6.46am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Thank goodness Roy is the manager.

I'm not sure that you're really suited to a football fans' discussion forum and perhaps you should look for a cheerleaders' forum as you don't seem to be able to accept any criticism of any aspect of this football club

 

Aray Flag South London 03 Oct 19 1.08pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I'm not sure that you're really suited to a football fans' discussion forum and perhaps you should look for a cheerleaders' forum as you don't seem to be able to accept any criticism of any aspect of this football club

Ouch! But fair!

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 03 Oct 19 3.48pm

Milivojevic, Kouyate - holding midfielders ??

Both can break up play but neither can hold the ball for more than a second.

Meyer and Camarassa are the only two who can do this but won't be given much chance when the manager concentrates on not conceding many goals - although that plan went wrong against Spurs. If Brighton can beat Spurs on Saturday it will say much about our defensive tactics.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 03 Oct 19 7.37pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I'm not sure that you're really suited to a football fans' discussion forum and perhaps you should look for a cheerleaders' forum as you don't seem to be able to accept any criticism of any aspect of this football club

Who the hell are you to decide who is or is not suited to discuss Crystal Palace on this forum. For me to accept criticism of our club it has to be fair and constructive and not the whinging and moaning that is more prevalent on this forum than anything.

Edited by PZ Eagle (03 Oct 2019 7.39pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

LeftWing11 Flag Lee 03 Oct 19 10.20pm

Originally posted by Uphill

Milivojevic, Kouyate - holding midfielders ??

Both can break up play but neither can hold the ball for more than a second.

Meyer and Camarassa are the only two who can do this but won't be given much chance when the manager concentrates on not conceding many goals - although that plan went wrong against Spurs. If Brighton can beat Spurs on Saturday it will say much about our defensive tactics.

The idea is that they would win the ball back and give it to the creative 3 in front of them.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 04 Oct 19 6.56am

Originally posted by Uphill

Milivojevic, Kouyate - holding midfielders ??

Both can break up play but neither can hold the ball for more than a second.

Meyer and Camarassa are the only two who can do this but won't be given much chance when the manager concentrates on not conceding many goals - although that plan went wrong against Spurs. If Brighton can beat Spurs on Saturday it will say much about our defensive tactics.

Such a negatively selective viewpoint. We have conceded 7 goals this season -- joint second and only two more than Liverpool. But you pick as your yardstick the one game in which things went wrong against a side that shredded many in Europe last year. Also, remember we had a notoriously slow-to-get-match-sharp Sakho coming back.

And then you say if Brighton beat them that it defines our defence? What if it's 8-7?

C'mon. No.

Our defence isn't second best in the league but I'll wager we'll have fewer goals against come May than Brighton and many other sides. And that is what defines our defence.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 04 Oct 19 8.59am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Such a negatively selective viewpoint. We have conceded 7 goals this season -- joint second and only two more than Liverpool. But you pick as your yardstick the one game in which things went wrong against a side that shredded many in Europe last year. Also, remember we had a notoriously slow-to-get-match-sharp Sakho coming back.

And then you say if Brighton beat them that it defines our defence? What if it's 8-7?

C'mon. No.

Our defence isn't second best in the league but I'll wager we'll have fewer goals against come May than Brighton and many other sides. And that is what defines our defence.

Your post encapsulates exactly why I said earlier thank Gpd Roy is the manager.
t

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 04 Oct 19 11.48am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Such a negatively selective viewpoint. We have conceded 7 goals this season -- joint second and only two more than Liverpool. But you pick as your yardstick the one game in which things went wrong against a side that shredded many in Europe last year. Also, remember we had a notoriously slow-to-get-match-sharp Sakho coming back.

And then you say if Brighton beat them that it defines our defence? What if it's 8-7?

C'mon. No.

Our defence isn't second best in the league but I'll wager we'll have fewer goals against come May than Brighton and many other sides. And that is what defines our defence.

Are you calling foul the clearly logical equation (that I first came up with whilst at school) that because we were beaten 4-0 by Spurs and Spurs were beaten 7-2 by Bayern, that we would lose by at least nine goals to Bayern if we played them.

I don't understand why a game we're not involved in can't define us. If only RH were here to clarify.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

pieman203 Flag Hayes 04 Oct 19 4.18pm

Getting back to the formation for tomorrow Luka Mil is suspended anyway why put him in the team?

 

Painter Flag Croydon 04 Oct 19 5.03pm

Originally posted by Uphill

Milivojevic, Kouyate - holding midfielders ??

Both can break up play but neither can hold the ball for more than a second.

Meyer and Camarassa are the only two who can do this but won't be given much chance when the manager concentrates on not conceding many goals - although that plan went wrong against Spurs. If Brighton can beat Spurs on Saturday it will say much about our defensive tactics.

Not quite understanding this argument to include Camarassa in the team. He had one game against Colchester and didn't impress, what makes people think he can produce in the Premier. Being foreign doesn't make you a superstar.
Roy has found a use for Meyer, coming on in the last 10 mins, when opposition getting tired, then he has more space to perform.

 

beak Flag croydon 04 Oct 19 5.54pm

That is my evening prayer,how lucky we are to have a manager with such a wealth of experience.

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Thank goodness Roy is the manager.

 

syd snot Flag munich 05 Oct 19 7.43am

Pointless thread.
Next please

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Formation suggestion