You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rank our best centre backs
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rank our best centre backs


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Max1cpfc Flag London 14 Oct 19 3.53pm

It is fair to say we are spoilt for choice in the centre back position at the moment. But if you were to rank the 5 defenders, how would it look.

For me it goes:

1. Cahill
2. Tomkins
3. Kelly
4. Sakho
5. Dann

Anyone agree with me?

 

mars Flag Folkestone 14 Oct 19 4.56pm

1 Cahill
2 Kelly
3= Dann/Tomkins
5 Woods
6 Sakho

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 14 Oct 19 4.58pm

Cahill
The rest

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Bangell Flag Oxford 14 Oct 19 5.09pm

Sakho was an absolute beast when he first came to the club and was one of the best CBs we've ever had, but hasn't been so impressive since his injuries and probably won't be the player he once was. Let's hope the same doesn't apply to Tomkins.

Right now Cahill is the best without question. His partner will be Tomkins or Sakho depending on who recovers best, but right now we really have no way of knowing how good they still are.

 

DeanMiles Flag Telford 14 Oct 19 5.10pm

Originally posted by Max1cpfc

It is fair to say we are spoilt for choice in the centre back position at the moment. But if you were to rank the 5 defenders, how would it look.

For me it goes:

1. Cahill
2. Tomkins
3. Kelly
4. Sakho
5. Dann

Anyone agree with me?

I agree with that order. Anyone know what % of games Sakho has played since joining? Would have been a great signing if he wasn't always injured.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 14 Oct 19 6.13pm

I can't bring myself to put a name at the bottom of that list. At their best, they would all do a great job. The challenge for Sakho, Tomkins and Dann would be in forcing their way into that starting 11 and getting to the point where they're at their highest level. That's especially true for Dann who realistically could need 5-10 games that we would struggle to give him. But let's be clear...what a 5. Dann could easily get a championship club promoted. he has loads to offer.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Oct 19 7.02pm

Now, rank our five best strikers.

 


Red and Blue Army!

matthau Flag South Croydon 14 Oct 19 7.05pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Now, rank our five best strikers.

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 14 Oct 19 7.47pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Now, rank our five best strikers.

1. Cahill
2. Tomkins
3. Kelly
4. Sakho
5. Dann

 

Adamoc123 Flag Ennis 14 Oct 19 9.47pm

Originally posted by EagleinSF

1. Cahill
2. Tomkins
3. Kelly
4. Sakho
5. Dann


HAHAHAHA XD it's not even funny how true this is, although spare a thought for ayew he has been mustard this season so far.

 


The First 90 Minutes Are The Most Important!

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 14 Oct 19 10.57pm

Chris Coleman... Absolute beast of a centre half!!

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 15 Oct 19 6.38am

Seems like an ironic question. There really can't ever have been a time when we have had such a glut of decent centre-backs. We're very lucky.

Edited by bifffabazz (15 Oct 2019 6.39am)

Edited by bifffabazz (15 Oct 2019 6.40am)

 


Spirit of 1974

Plaistow Eagle Flag 15 Oct 19 7.21am

Originally posted by Bangell

Sakho was an absolute beast when he first came to the club and was one of the best CBs we've ever had, but hasn't been so impressive since his injuries and probably won't be the player he once was. Let's hope the same doesn't apply to Tomkins.

Right now Cahill is the best without question. His partner will be Tomkins or Sakho depending on who recovers best, but right now we really have no way of knowing how good they still are.

This..!!

Shame we don't have a right back to play wing back - then could look at playing 3 at the back with these three if fit and wing backs.

Although don't think Roy would go for it..!!

Whatever we as someone's said very lucky to have such a quality group of centre backs - think they will be the defining difference for us this year because as we all know the other end of the pitch is a different story..!!

COYP

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 15 Oct 19 8.07am

Originally posted by mars

1 Cahill
2 Kelly
3= Dann/Tomkins
5 Woods
6 Sakho

Woods better than Sakho, unbelievable

 

EddieMac Flag 15 Oct 19 8.36am

I feel sorry for Kelly as he has done nothing wrong but as soon as Sakho and Tomkins are back fit he will be back to the bench.

Cahill and Tomkins would be my first choice pairing but Roy will go with Cahill and Sakho because of Mamas left foot.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 15 Oct 19 9.00am

A fully fit Sakho is still top of the list for me. His ability to find a player with a 40 yard ground pass through traffic is what sets him apart. It is hard to relax when he plays though. Based on everyone being 100% match fit my list would go:

Sakho
Cahill
Tomkins
Kelly
Dann

To be honest though, any combination of those four is plenty good enough for the PL.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 15 Oct 19 10.33am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

A fully fit Sakho is still top of the list for me. His ability to find a player with a 40 yard ground pass through traffic is what sets him apart. It is hard to relax when he plays though. Based on everyone being 100% match fit my list would go:

Sakho
Cahill
Tomkins
Kelly
Dann

To be honest though, any combination of those four is plenty good enough for the PL.

This for me too. Some of y'all have short memories. Mama has been incredible for us for two seasons. ish. Cahill has had a handful of decent games. (Don't get me wrong - bloody impressive.)

Same list as above for me.

 

The_Aviator Flag Rochester 15 Oct 19 7.22pm

Slightly off topic, but am I the only one missing Scott Dann's contribution at corners?

We used to be pretty dangerous at corners when he was regularly in the team, nowadays I don't get too excited when we get one. I liked the moniker 'Scott Dann - Goal Machine'. Or was it just my mate and me using that expression?

But back on topic... We were definitely lucky to get Cahill (fortress Selhurst is surely linked?) and Sakho has contributed to quite a few of our goals since his arrival with some great incisive forward balls.

Cahill
Sakho
Tomkins
Kelly
Dann

Pains me to put Scotty at the bottom, but the others are all doing so well.

Edited by The_Aviator (15 Oct 2019 7.28pm)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 15 Oct 19 7.25pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Chris Coleman... Absolute beast of a centre half!!

Not when he was sulking.

 

deetee Flag 15 Oct 19 7.49pm

I agree with that though must say Kelly has really stepped up so far this season.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rank our best centre backs