You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Cahill our best ever centre back?
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Cahill our best ever centre back?


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 29 Feb 20 3.32pm

Grew up lucky enough to watch Cannon and Gilbert who I always considered to be our best ever centre halves.

Think I have to reconsider after this season.

Pretty much the complete player. Does the lot. Very composed, great in the air, brilliant positioning and excellent at marshalling defenders around him.

In my humble opinion I think he probably is.

What does everyone else think?

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

dave4343palace Flag Copthorne 29 Feb 20 3.45pm

Love him but you'll never beat Thorn and Young...

 


George Courtney, the World Cup referee, everyone is looking at him. When will he blow....?

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 29 Feb 20 3.53pm

Originally posted by dave4343palace

Love him but you'll never beat Thorn and Young...

Blyth and McCormick shouldn’t be overlooked along with Roger Hynd

 


Bring back Brolin

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 29 Feb 20 4.05pm

Cahill is very good - a great piece of business in the summer transfer window (as was Ayew).
The best ever? I only go back to the early days of Jim Cannon who was immense for us and still gets my vote.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 29 Feb 20 4.05pm

Don’t think any of the players mentioned above (I saw them all) are as good as Cahill who is still good enough to play for England. Cahill has played at the highest level and I would say he is the best I’ve seen in that position. How long he can last at 34 is another question? I would say if Sakho was fit they would be the best centre backs this club has had. I question if Sakho will ever play a full season alongside Cahill but Tompkins and then Dann and Kelly are top centre backs and slot in alongside Cahill well.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 29 Feb 20 4.06pm

Originally posted by dave4343palace

Love him but you'll never beat Thorn and Young...

But that’s a partnership.

Cahill got over 60 England caps. Thorn was never capped for England and Young only got 20 odd caps for Wales.

I know this is subjective but personally I wouldn’t take Thorne or Young over Cahill.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 29 Feb 20 5.09pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Don’t think any of the players mentioned above (I saw them all) are as good as Cahill who is still good enough to play for England. Cahill has played at the highest level and I would say he is the best I’ve seen in that position. How long he can last at 34 is another question? I would say if Sakho was fit they would be the best centre backs this club has had. I question if Sakho will ever play a full season alongside Cahill but Tompkins and then Dann and Kelly are top centre backs and slot in alongside Cahill well.

We are undoubtedly blessed in this position.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 29 Feb 20 5.23pm

A top draw CB at the end of his career and one the club did well to get the services of . Different eras bring different challenges and best ever contenders but yes hes up there with the best we have had .

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 29 Feb 20 5.33pm

He is good but he is no Claude Davis

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Casual Flag Orpington 29 Feb 20 5.41pm

To think that Arsenal needed a proper ball winning Center back , looked at Chelsea and took David Luiz. Ha ha. What a joke.

Cahill is mustard, in a two horse race for POTY with the keeper for me.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 29 Feb 20 5.58pm

Originally posted by Casual

To think that Arsenal needed a proper ball winning Center back , looked at Chelsea and took David Luiz. Ha ha. What a joke.

Cahill is mustard, in a two horse race for POTY with the keeper for me.

i love David Luiz in an Arsenal shirt. A cross between Norman wisdom and Basil Fawlty.

Cahill is an Eagle.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Feb 20 6.00pm

Originally posted by Ouzo Dan

He is good but he is no Claude Davis

No one ever will be.

 


Red and Blue Army!

chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Feb 20 6.29pm

I like the way he skippers too.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 Mar 20 2.20pm

I would agree that he probably is. Positional sense, decision making, organisation, ability to defend the six yard box a class above what we've generally seen despite his age. A case could be made for Sakho on his best form.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 01 Mar 20 2.29pm

I remember JC as more blood & guts defending, but Cahill has a lot more composure / class

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 01 Mar 20 2.42pm

Don’t know I loved “Gilly” - thought he was so unlucky not to have ever played for England..!!

But I agree Cahill has been “one hell of a signing”..!!

IMO - he is the difference between us being in the position of relative comfort as we are now to being in the relegation dog fight.

I agree get Sakho fit - them two playing together, could/would be our best Centre Half pairing ever - we haven’t had that opportunity too many times this season unfortunately.

So on from that what would be your best back 4 of all time?

For me;

AWB, Sakho, Cahill, Sansom - Sakho just nicked it ahead of ”Gilly”..!!

COYP

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 Mar 20 2.54pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Don’t know I loved “Gilly” - thought he was so unlucky not to have ever played for England..!!

But I agree Cahill has been “one hell of a signing”..!!

IMO - he is the difference between us being in the position of relative comfort as we are now to being in the relegation dog fight.

I agree get Sakho fit - them two playing together, could/would be our best Centre Half pairing ever - we haven’t had that opportunity too many times this season unfortunately.

So on from that what would be your best back 4 of all time?

For me;

AWB, Sakho, Cahill, Sansom - Sakho just nicked it ahead of ”Gilly”..!!

COYP

I think the depth we have in the centre back positions and quality of the goalkeeper have been the difference.

Your two centre backs and GK are the three most important players in any team. If they're no good then you're as good as down.

A lot of moans about the squad (with which I agree) but the strength here is the reason we've 36 points. Good management in fairness.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Mar 20 5.12pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

But that’s a partnership.

Cahill got over 60 England caps. Thorn was never capped for England and Young only got 20 odd caps for Wales.

I know this is subjective but personally I wouldn’t take Thorne or Young over Cahill.

There is no doubt of his experience, but unfortunately we got him in the twilight of his career. He isn't the best in the current crop of CBs.

 

pssguy Flag 01 Mar 20 5.37pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Cahill got over 60 England caps.

But not with us. If we signed Rio Ferdinand but he never made the squad would you call him our best ever centre back?

Could mention Alan Stephenson. He was sold for 80,000 in 1968 - a huge fee (maybe even a record) for a defender in those days

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 01 Mar 20 6.35pm

Originally posted by pssguy

But not with us. If we signed Rio Ferdinand but he never made the squad would you call him our best ever centre back?

Could mention Alan Stephenson. He was sold for 80,000 in 1968 - a huge fee (maybe even a record) for a defender in those days

But Cahill is still playing as good as ever and is as good / better as any of the centre backs presently playing for England. None of our centre backs in my time supporting Palace (since 196 have been as good (England class) as Cahill. Cannon was a great servant but not good enough for Scotland - Still a great Palace player, as was Gilbert, Young and Thorn but Cahill and probably Sakho are the best we have had at this level in my opinion. Sampson and Lombardo were also at this level whilst with us. Lombardo like Cahill was coming to the end of his career but class nevertheless.

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Cahill our best ever centre back?