You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your ultimate Palace dream team
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Your ultimate Palace dream team


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Bekken Flag 11 Apr 20 8.32pm

Choosing from all Palace squads from the year 2000 onwards, who would be in your dream team?

We will need to see your Manager and subs too!

Edited by Bekken (11 Apr 2020 8.57pm)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Apr 20 8.06am

Why don't you set the ball rolling with your dream team?

 

sprites Flag Auckland 12 Apr 20 8.53am

Oooo that's tough. Depends on whether we're talking who we like/sentimental vs the best player. Speroni vs Guiata, for example. Assuming we're talking about ability (and Lombardo not included as he finished 99), here's mine:

Guiata

Wan-Bissaka - Cahill - Sakho - Van Aanholt

Jedinak

Routledge - Cabaye - Ambrose - Zaha

AJ

SUBS:

Speroni
Clyne
Popovic
McArthur
Townsend
Gayle

MANAGER:

Sam Allerdyce

NOTABLE OMISSIONS:

Tomkins
Luka
Rihilahti
Freedman
Murray

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 12 Apr 20 9.03am

Why from 2000 onwards, I feel like we are missing out on some of our best players.

覧覧祐peroni

Clyne 覧Sakho猶oppovic覧Cole

覧�-Cabaye憂edi

Wilf覧Ambrose覧Bolasie

覧覧AJ

subs-
Andros
Davids
Luka
Murray
Freedman
Dann
Wan-Bissaka

Manager - Roy
Assistant- Millen

Obviously Davids was terrible for us and Cole was only here for half a season. But they are 2 of the greatest in their positions ever, I can稚 not include them.

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 12 Apr 20 9.26am

Really good idea for a thread!

Ok, from 2000...

Gk: Speroni - in terms of quality, Guiata and Matt Clarke were probably better, but for longevity, and emotional attachment, can only be one choice.

Rb: Wan Bissaka - probably toughest position to choose. Clyne was Rolls Royce, and Butts was a hero if only for that hat trick against Wolves. But AWB was superhuman, and will go on to be a world class right back.

Cb: Delaney and Tomkins - again, tough. Of course if you go on ability, Sakho and Leon Cort are elegant ball playing defenders. I went for Delaney because you need a real leader in there, and his ability to step up in the prem took us all by surprise. Tomkins has been phenomenally consistent for a few years now too. Not much would get past those two.

Lb: PVA - as tempting as it is to choose Clint Hill, PVA is on another level, don't think Clint had Pat's ability to knock goals in from 25 yards!

Cdm: Jedi - probably the position with the most controversy to it. I love Luka, but Jedi was an icon in that role, I can forgive his 5 yard passes in to the stands.

Cm: Derry and MacArthur- hard to remember us winning the midfield too often in the past two decades! Sorely lacked a glamorous number 8 who stuck around for long, so I've gone - in typical Palace tradition - for 3 defensive midfielders. Jimmy mac has been the definition of an unsung hero in the middle for years now, and Derry was a classy player who stepped up when needed most.

Front 3: wilf, Doug, Aj - pretty much picks itself. Clinton was electric in his first stint with us, but buggered off in his best years. Wilf is wilf, dougie was a gem of a player, and AJ basically got us promoted and nearly kept us up singlehandedly.

This side would obviously be different if I went on pure ability. But I've gone based on sentiment mainly, so f*** it.

Manager would be Roy, no doubt about it. We've had a mix of clowns, maniacs and dull as dishwater otherwise.

Subs: Guiata, clyne, Luka, clinton, aki, Murray, bolasie.

Edit! How did I forget Ambrose! I'd stick him in for MacArthur.

Edited by serial thriller (12 Apr 2020 9.28am)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 12 Apr 20 9.42am

Julian Speroni

Nathanial Clyne
Gary Cahill
James Tomkins
Clint Hill

Aki Riihilahti
Johan Cabaye

Wilfried Zaha
Andy Johnson
Clinton Morrison
Victor Moses

Subs, Guiata, Wan Bissaka, Gayle, Murray, Freedman, Hughes, Sakho

Manager: although my teams far too attacking, I壇 have Fat Sam

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 12 Apr 20 10.36am

Originally posted by monkey

Julian Speroni

Nathanial Clyne
Gary Cahill
James Tomkins
Clint Hill

Aki Riihilahti
Johan Cabaye

Wilfried Zaha
Andy Johnson
Clinton Morrison
Victor Moses

Subs, Guiata, Wan Bissaka, Gayle, Murray, Freedman, Hughes, Sakho

Manager: although my teams far too attacking, I壇 have Fat Sam


Think sentiment has played a part here Monkey.

Loved Clint Hill, but would you honestly pick him over AWB?

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 12 Apr 20 11.04am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


Think sentiment has played a part here Monkey.

Loved Clint Hill, but would you honestly pick him over AWB?

At Left Back,,,,,yes!!

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 12 Apr 20 11.47am

Ok. For clarification this selection is made on the basis that the player selected was at the peak of his game when wearing a Palace shirt(which may have been before 2000 in Freedman痴 case):

Guita
Boyce
Cahill
Sakho
PVA
Jedi
Cabaye
MacArthur
Freedman
AJ
Zaha


 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 12 Apr 20 11.53am

Speroni

Wan Bissaka Tomkins Cahill Van Aanholt

Jedi McCarthy

Ambrose

Zaha Murray Bolasie


Subs

Guaita
Ward
AJ
Cabaye
Townsend
Delaney
McArthur

Edited by ASCPFC (12 Apr 2020 11.55am)

 


Red and Blue Army!

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 12 Apr 20 12.30pm

Originally posted by monkey

At Left Back,,,,,yes!!

Ha ha

Fair point

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 12 Apr 20 12.37pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Speroni

Wan Bissaka Tomkins Cahill Van Aanholt

Jedi McCarthy

Ambrose

Zaha Murray Bolasie


Subs

Guaita
Ward
AJ
Cabaye
Townsend
Delaney
McArthur

Edited by ASCPFC (12 Apr 2020 11.55am)

Manager: Hodgson. Always support the current manager.

 


Red and Blue Army!

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 12 Apr 20 1.13pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Ha ha

Fair point

But to be honest, I make you right really, not exactly the best player we致e ever had, but I致e got so much love for Clint because he was such a warrior I had to have him in there

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 12 Apr 20 1.17pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Ok. For clarification this selection is made on the basis that the player selected was at the peak of his game when wearing a Palace shirt(which may have been before 2000 in Freedman痴 case):

Guita
Boyce
Cahill
Sakho
PVA
Jedi
Cabaye
MacArthur
Freedman
AJ
Zaha


Boycie!!! I forgot about him, although I wouldn稚 have him in there myself, he was excellent and one thing has become clear from this thread, we致e had plenty of good defenders over the last 20 years!!

 

sprites Flag Auckland 13 Apr 20 1.03am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Speroni

Wan Bissaka Tomkins Cahill Van Aanholt

Jedi McCarthy

Ambrose

Zaha Murray Bolasie


Subs

Guaita
Ward
AJ
Cabaye
Townsend
Delaney
McArthur

Edited by ASCPFC (12 Apr 2020 11.55am)

Paddy, right?

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 14 Apr 20 2.34pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Why from 2000 onwards, I feel like we are missing out on some of our best players.

覧覧祐peroni

Clyne 覧Sakho猶oppovic覧Cole

覧�-Cabaye憂edi

Wilf覧Ambrose覧Bolasie

覧覧AJ

subs-
Andros
Davids
Luka
Murray
Freedman
Dann
Wan-Bissaka

Manager - Roy
Assistant- Millen

Obviously Davids was terrible for us and Cole was only here for half a season. But they are 2 of the greatest in their positions ever, I can稚 not include them.

Davids was great over most of his career, but for us he was TERRIBLE, that's why he only played a handful of games

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 14 Apr 20 5.27pm

Speroni
AWB - Sorondo - Fonte - PVA
Wilf - Hughesy - Loftus-Cheek - Bolasie
Murray - AJ

Subs:
Guaita, Cahill, Routledge, Jedi, Clyne, Freedman, Morrison

Manager:
Party Pardew. Gung ho

Must admit that I don稚 remember much of Sorondo but remembering that he oozed quality during the few games he played for us.

Edited by Goal Machine (14 Apr 2020 5.31pm)

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 14 Apr 20 7.20pm

Guaita

AWB Cahill Sakho Cole

Cabaye Jedinak

Moses Ambrose Zaha

AJ

Subs:

Speroni
Clyne
Tomkins
Loftus-Cheek
Bolasie
Freedman
Murray

Manager: Sam Allardyce

At the height of its powers that team is pushing for Champions League based on who is around that space this season. 7 of that side has played Champions League. (AJ, Zaha, Ambrose (qualifier), Jedinak for those counting).

Notable exclusions:

Boyce, Butterfield, Delaney, Fonte, Dann, Hill, Derry, Hughes, Luka, Riihilahti, McArthur, Routledge, Townsend, Morrison....

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

chris123 Flag hove actually 14 Apr 20 7.24pm

Bill Glazier, Steve Kember plus nine.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Apr 20 9.46pm

Originally posted by sprites

Paddy, right?

I meant the current one but I like the sentiment. Reckon James McCarthy will be our best midfielder for a while. Would have put Cabaye but I used to get a bit frustrated with him sometimes and McCarthy looks good. Our type of player, full of effort and nice hard tackle, a decent passing range.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your ultimate Palace dream team