This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
The PENALTY ??
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
pieman203 Hayes 21 Sep 20 5.10pm |
|
|
I seem to be in the minority and a bit bias, but if that handball had been right on the line and prevented the ball crossing the line there would be no argument. Just because he didn't mean it does not stop it being handball. It certainly stopped the ball going forward so who is to say it would not have gone in, or even to a Palace player. Good decision ref IMO.
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Sep 20 5.53pm |
|
Originally posted by pieman203
I seem to be in the minority and a bit bias, but if that handball had been right on the line and prevented the ball crossing the line there would be no argument. Just because he didn't mean it does not stop it being handball. It certainly stopped the ball going forward so who is to say it would not have gone in, or even to a Palace player. Good decision ref IMO.
If you’re in the minority I’m with you.
It was an effort from what 7/8 yards away and it’s hit his hand. Hard luck for the defender but I’d still consider it a penalty.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
xomnea 21 Sep 20 5.55pm |
|
|
The arm is in an unnatural position and the ball hits it. It's handball.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 21 Sep 20 6.07pm |
|
|
The obvious thing is that if that had been at the other end, say Sakho had done it, it wouldn't have needed VAR: It would have just been given. So there is no reason for us to fret, Man U will get over it.
Red and Blue Army!
|
jeeagles 21 Sep 20 9.34pm |
|
Originally posted by xomnea
The arm is in an unnatural position and the ball hits it. It's handball.
From the FA website:
It is an offence if a player: deliberately touches the ball with their hand/arm, including moving the hand/arm towards the ball scores in the opponents’ goal directly from their hand/arm, even if accidental, including by the goalkeeper after the ball has touched their or a team-mate’s hand/arm, even if accidental, immediately: scores in the opponents’ goal creates a goal-scoring opportunity touches the ball with their hand/arm when: the hand/arm has made their body unnaturally bigger the hand/arm is above/beyond their shoulder level (unless the player deliberately plays the ball which then touches their hand/arm The above offences apply even if the ball touches a player’s hand/arm directly from the head or body (including the foot) of another player who is close.
Except for the above offences, it is not an offence if the ball touches a player’s hand/arm: directly from the player’s own head or body (including the foot) directly from the head or body (including the foot) of another player who is close if the hand/arm is close to the body and does not make the body unnaturally bigger when a player falls and the hand/arm is between the body and the ground to support the body, but not extended laterally or vertically away from the body
His arm was sticking out from his body making it unnaturally bigger. It’s a penalty. Would be helpful if the pundits checked he rules directly.
Although I’m not a fan of the rule about keepers not coming forward, and it doesn’t seem fair to change the penalty taker.
Edited by jeeagles (21 Sep 2020 9.38pm)
|
esox lucius Deal 21 Sep 20 10.01pm |
|
Originally posted by pieman203
I seem to be in the minority and a bit bias, but if that handball had been right on the line and prevented the ball crossing the line there would be no argument. Just because he didn't mean it does not stop it being handball. It certainly stopped the ball going forward so who is to say it would not have gone in, or even to a Palace player. Good decision ref IMO.
While I do agree it was a harsh decision the fact remains it was a shot at goal that was probably just about on target and Lindelof’s arm deflected it altering the flight of the ball.
|
coulsdoneagle London 21 Sep 20 11.45pm |
|
|
Definitely a pen, whose to say that it wouldn’t have gone in. What is bs is the retake. I hate that rule.
|
uncleneal Croydon 22 Sep 20 7.52am |
|
|
I would be fracking annoyed if that had been against us. it is never a pen.
The rules quoted above do not make it clear and Ayew is pretty near when he flicks it up. I just don’t see him being in an unnatural position or moving his hand to the ball.
The re- take is mega harsh and we should be seeing a large number of re- takes this season.
My only wish was that Ayew had also hand balled it and was offside - that would be the perfect Old Trafford goal.
VAR is a farce but at least it is now throwing out dodgy decisions for all rather than the home bias that the big boys always enjoyed.
If you went to the 3-0 loss at OT years ago, you would know what I mean (my head almost exploded).
Really enjoyed a bit of revenge
|
Goal Machine The Cronx 22 Sep 20 8.19am |
|
|
Total nonsense, was never a penalty. The rules are a joke and ruining the game. Same for the decision on the penalty retake. As the commentator said at the time, the refs need to apply common sense. I’d have gone mental if that was a decision against us.
However, we totally bossed United and perhaps deserved a bit of luck.
With the introduction of the linesman no longer flagging, what is the role of the linesman? Might as well get rid.
VAR is too involved and making football worse. Introduce 1 review per captain per game, ref gets 10 seconds to review it on a replay. If it’s a clear and obvious error they don’t need to look it at for 3 minutes from 8 different angles.
|
McPalace Carshalton Village 22 Sep 20 9.38am |
|
|
It is more of a penalty than the one that was given against Sakho against Villa last season. So enough said
|
Teddy Eagle 22 Sep 20 9.49am |
|
|
After the decade long stretch when penalties given there were rarer than Benteke hat tricks I’m quite happy with the decision.
[Link]
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 22 Sep 20 9.53am |
|
|
It was a penalty because the rules say it is, just as it was correct to retake due to the keeper being off his line. Both decisions were harsh but correct.
This is exactly what VAR should be there for, quite easy decisions for the VAR operators.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
Dubai Eagle 22 Sep 20 9.56am |
|
|
100% Agree with this.
Originally posted by ASCPFC
The obvious thing is that if that had been at the other end, say Sakho had done it, it wouldn't have needed VAR: It would have just been given. So there is no reason for us to fret, Man U will get over it.
|
Palace BANANA Ringmer, Lewes, East Sussex 22 Sep 20 10.07am |
|
Originally posted by uncleneal
I would be fracking annoyed if that had been against us. it is never a pen.
The rules quoted above do not make it clear and Ayew is pretty near when he flicks it up. I just don’t see him being in an unnatural position or moving his hand to the ball.
I've watched the incident a few times, as I'm sure many people have, and his hand definitely moves towards the ball, albeit minimal and NOT deliberate, which definitely changes the direction of the ball.. it is harsh but the rule is what it is, like it or not.. personally I don't like it but have seen many similar given against our boys and was totally p*ssed off.. some dodgy ones at ManUre too, so what goes around comes around..
|
taylors lovechild 22 Sep 20 10.38am |
|
|
If you apply the rules as they are now it's a penalty; whether that is considered fair is another matter. The same with the GK coming off the line. Personally, in their efforts to make these things clearer they've taken away the ability to interpret intention and whether it gave an advantage, but so long as they are the rules it was a penalty and the retake was legitimate. I will say that we have fallen foul to dubious penalty decisions against the big clubs in the past before the advent of VAR, so I have zero sympathy.
|
cpj Kent 22 Sep 20 11.17am |
|
|
Supposedly Zaha, as captain, said to Ayew to take the penalty as he had won it. Does that mean we did not have a designated penalty taker going into the match? If so that seems very amateurish.
|
pompeyeagle Relocated to Shropshire 22 Sep 20 11.27am |
|
|
I wonder if it would have been given if there were 75,000 fans in the stadium and the referee had Fergie glaring at him. I’m guessing not.
|
Goal Machine The Cronx 22 Sep 20 11.55am |
|
Originally posted by McPalace
It is more of a penalty than the one that was given against Sakho against Villa last season. So enough said
No, also a terrible decision. I believe that luck evens itself out over the course of a season, but your response misses the point.
We're going through far too many long winded reviews which is taking the enjoyment away for the fans. I've totally stopped watching VAR football now unless its Palace. I used to watch any game.
The rules have become too penal and VAR is massively overused. You can't celebrate goals anymore because you half expect that the goal will be disallowed for a deflection off someone's shoulder 30 seconds before the goal down the other end of the pitch.
What is a 'natural body position' when you're flying out to block a shot? When I used to play football I certainly didn't do it with my arms glued to my body or behind my back.
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 22 Sep 20 6.29pm |
|
Originally posted by cpj
Supposedly Zaha, as captain, said to Ayew to take the penalty as he had won it. Does that mean we did not have a designated penalty taker going into the match? If so that seems very amateurish.
I think Zaha said that Ayew asked him if he could take it and Zaha said yes, which infers either that Zaha, as captain, would decide who would take any pens or that Zaha was the chosen pen taker. It's possibly the latter given that Hodgson was urging Zaha to take the second attempt.
Edited by doombear (22 Sep 2020 6.30pm)
|
braunstoneagle the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 22 Sep 20 6.47pm |
|
Originally posted by McPalace
It is more of a penalty than the one that was given against Sakho against Villa last season. So enough said
funnily enough i thought as that time it evened out sakhos decision against villa.
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway
|