You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Scott Dann
November 16 2026 5.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Scott Dann


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 29 Sep 20 4.42pm

Didn't see a thread on Dann already, but do we cash in?

I can't imagine that our list of injured CBs would allow us to sell Dann at the moment, but these stories must come out of somewhere.

The irony is that Fulham have shipped 10 goals this season and I am certain Scottie is not the answer to that.

[Link]


 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 29 Sep 20 6.51pm

A fully fit Scott Dann for a season would greatly help Fulham. It's unlikely, but in the crapshoot of PL survival, it's not a daft idea for them.

The question is: do we have the confidence to cash in if we get a silly offer. In this regard, I would trust Roy's call.

Tomkins, Sakho, Kelly, Kouyate maybe Jairo, maybe Ferguson. We are not without cover.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 29 Sep 20 7.33pm

Would be an interesting call in any case, not easy!

I thought Dann was well on his way out last couple of seasons but recently he has performed well for us which has kept me happy as I certainly feel like he was our best player for a few seasons and one of the most underrated around.

Would be sad to see him go but will always think highly of him.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 29 Sep 20 7.45pm

He's by far the best header on the team (despite Kouyate's goal). I think you keep him.

There will undoubtedly be others on their way out in the next week.

 

jeeagles Flag 29 Sep 20 7.53pm

He's been a great servant to the club but it's a position we are over subscribed in.

Would rather we had an extra right winger or striker in the 25.

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 29 Sep 20 7.54pm

We do have a lot of back four players - you can again see why at the minute. If we want to shed one, Kelly might make more sense for us - I'm sure it said right side of back 3 /right back on the label when Jairo arrived. On the other hand who would expect to be an EPL squad defender and who'd be comfortably good enough to start at another club?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 29 Sep 20 8.13pm

Originally posted by Charles

We do have a lot of back four players - you can again see why at the minute. If we want to shed one, Kelly might make more sense for us - I'm sure it said right side of back 3 /right back on the label when Jairo arrived. On the other hand who would expect to be an EPL squad defender and who'd be comfortably good enough to start at another club?

Sorry mate, totally disagree. Kelly is our most versatile back given he can play at right back or both CB positions. Jairo is left footed so not sure why you refer to him as RB. Our CBs are Sakho, Tomkins, Dann, Kelly and Kouyate who is only now proving that CB may in fact be his best position. The youngsters we have can go, they are just not good enough.

 

The Dolphin Flag 30 Sep 20 10.08am

It will depend on the view off Tomkins and Cahill's fitness as well as whether Sakho is staying or going.
If Dann is allowed to leave then we can only assume that all is well elsewhere in the back line.
He can't play every week now anyway and is starting to suffer regular, niggling injuries so maybe he should go?
I really like him - he has been good for us and looks good even now so a shame but as always life goes on.

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 30 Sep 20 11.54am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Sorry mate, totally disagree. Kelly is our most versatile back given he can play at right back or both CB positions. Jairo is left footed so not sure why you refer to him as RB. Our CBs are Sakho, Tomkins, Dann, Kelly and Kouyate who is only now proving that CB may in fact be his best position. The youngsters we have can go, they are just not good enough.

Actually Ward has also started in every back four position including covering left back for Kelly who was signed to fill the position. Kelly seems to be last choice everywhere he can play at the moment; tbh I'm surprised he hasn't put in a transfer request. If we prefer a midfielder to him in his best position, who's to say we wouldn't prefer another in his second best position. Maybe he's not really fit enough at the moment; otherwise club and player don;t appear to be doing each other much good,

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 30 Sep 20 11.59am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

A fully fit Scott Dann for a season would greatly help Fulham. It's unlikely, but in the crapshoot of PL survival, it's not a daft idea for them.

The question is: do we have the confidence to cash in if we get a silly offer. In this regard, I would trust Roy's call.

Tomkins, Sakho, Kelly, Kouyate maybe Jairo, maybe Ferguson. We are not without cover.

Cahill as well. Also is Jach still around ? Think it depends where you place Dann in the pecking order. The above 4 and Dann have all played a part this and last season. So if we have the same amount of injuries he might be important. Whilst we have strengthened in attack still think our season will hinge on a good, solid defence. Hopefully not as much as last season.

Edited by Booted Eagle (30 Sep 2020 12.02pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 30 Sep 20 12.09pm

Our best CBs when all fully fit are Cahill, Tomkins and Sakho. I think Kelly could leave as we're now playing a CDM at CB and he's doing a good job at it. There's no real need for Dann now until you say we're in an injury situation like we are now, just typical luck for us!

 

BelfastEagle Flag 30 Sep 20 1.40pm

We have far to many sick notes at the centre back position. We need so many because we struggle to have even 2 of them fit at the same time. If we can get somebody young in who can play 75% of the season I would be happy to let Dann go.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 30 Sep 20 2.50pm

We absolutely, 100% certainly cannot go through a premier league season without being able to field two reliable, top flight centre backs in nearly every game.

Whilst big teams have four first team centre backs (plus utility men) for two positions to allow rotation and increase the pressure on each to perform, we retain four first team centre backs (plus utility men) because it is almost unheard of for more than two of them to be fully fit at the same time.

Selling Dann would only make sense if we felt confident that the other players in that position would be fit for 75-80% of the games, and they won't be.

Unless that changes, we should continue with the current, successful policy of eeking a seasons worth of appearances out of the four of them.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (30 Sep 2020 2.54pm)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 30 Sep 20 4.28pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

We absolutely, 100% certainly cannot go through a premier league season without being able to field two reliable, top flight centre backs in nearly every game.

Whilst big teams have four first team centre backs (plus utility men) for two positions to allow rotation and increase the pressure on each to perform, we retain four first team centre backs (plus utility men) because it is almost unheard of for more than two of them to be fully fit at the same time.

Selling Dann would only make sense if we felt confident that the other players in that position would be fit for 75-80% of the games, and they won't be.

Unless that changes, we should continue with the current, successful policy of eeking a seasons worth of appearances out of the four of them.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (30 Sep 2020 2.54pm)


It may be that with Kouyate showing that he's possibly a better CB than CDM, the club will be willing to let Dann go, especially if Ferguson is likely to be fit and up and running before too long, given that he can perform (apparently) in the CB role in an emergency.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 30 Sep 20 5.16pm

Originally posted by doombear


It may be that with Kouyate showing that he's possibly a better CB than CDM, the club will be willing to let Dann go, especially if Ferguson is likely to be fit and up and running before too long, given that he can perform (apparently) in the CB role in an emergency.

Personally I think Kouyate is a better midfielder than defender, and (perhaps more to the point) a better midfielder than the other players we have there.

There's not much in it between Kouyate, Luka, McCarthy (who has looked a steal this season having got a decent pre-season under his belt) and the evergreen McArthur, but for me Kouyate edges it as he gets around the pitch quicker, including from box to box.

If we sell Dann (or any other centre back) and play Kouyate at the back then we reduce the pool of first team centre midfielders down from four to three, which is a stretch too far.

We have four veteran centre halves and four senior centre midfielders. Leave well enough alone I reckon unless we sign a first team quality replacement, or a young player proves they are up to the task week in week out. Maybe Ferguson will, or Kirby, or Riedewald, but so far nobody has.

 

redshift Flag Toronto 30 Sep 20 9.34pm

This is just make-work journalism right? I can't see Scott Dann saving Fulham. They have so many problems he isn't going to fix. He could maybe go there but it's not going to put Fulham out of relegation danger on his own, they need so much more.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

redshift Flag Toronto 30 Sep 20 9.35pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Personally I think Kouyate is a better midfielder than defender, and (perhaps more to the point) a better midfielder than the other players we have there.

There's not much in it between Kouyate, Luka, McCarthy (who has looked a steal this season having got a decent pre-season under his belt) and the evergreen McArthur, but for me Kouyate edges it as he gets around the pitch quicker, including from box to box.

If we sell Dann (or any other centre back) and play Kouyate at the back then we reduce the pool of first team centre midfielders down from four to three, which is a stretch too far.

We have four veteran centre halves and four senior centre midfielders. Leave well enough alone I reckon unless we sign a first team quality replacement, or a young player proves they are up to the task week in week out. Maybe Ferguson will, or Kirby, or Riedewald, but so far nobody has.

I have to disagree only in that I think he's better in defense than in the midfield. And that's where we need him right now so I'm happy he's there.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

Pierre Flag Purley 30 Sep 20 11.21pm

We have a desperate need to trim the wage bill and also reduce the average age of the 1st team squad.
Dann to Fulham or anyone else at the moment sounds financially good sense, however how close are other long term injured central defenders from returning to fitness?
Sakho, although back and looking good does not have any long term durability!
I would say that without either of Tomkins or Cahill returning by the close of the window, we definatly need to hang onto Dann and wait until January.
Then potentially look to replace him/others going forwards with some younger players.

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 01 Oct 20 3.30am

Some good points on here.

I've always liked Dann. Hard as nails. There was a story about him equalising for Blackburn in the 71st minute (?) and realising only after 90 minutes that he had ruptured a testicle when he scored.

Back to the transfer, and Sky Pod Cast (what do they know) suggests that Scott Parker is also looking Foythe of Tottenham and Craig "GBH" Dawson at Watford among others.

If Fulham are looking for a a lot of bite, despite our views of him, I would want Dawson. He has been playing regularly compared to Dann and I think he gives a battling relegation side something more than Foythe can. He'd also been keen to get back to the PL.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Den1923 Flag 01 Oct 20 10.19am

I do hope we do not sell Scott Dann in this window, apart from being one of our best defenders we have long term injuries to both Tomkins & Cahill with no return dates and of course Furguson seems a long way off as well. We would be effective left with Sakho and for my money he more of liability than a good defender and has never really lived up to expectations.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Scott Dann