This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Bats or Watkins?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
HKOwen Hong Kong 05 Oct 20 10.24pm |
|
|
Would you rather we had bought Watkins thank loaned Bats?
Watkins is clearly good enough for PL
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
Palace 1979 Surrey 05 Oct 20 10.31pm |
|
|
And £28m more expensive with an unproven record.
He was very good last night and could be a gem, but we got Eze, Bats and Ferguson for less...
Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.
|
mattteo 05 Oct 20 10.32pm |
|
|
One could be brought on loan, for the other you'd have tp cough 25 million without the certainty that he could have made it. It appears now , after the Liverpool game, that he IS good enough for the money. But he was just a Championship center forward who had only played 1 full season as center forward, previously having been used as a winger.
On the other hand, Batshuayi was a certainty at international level, having played well for all Belgium, Borussia Dortmund, Chelsea and us. And if he doesn't accustom well this year, you can even chise not to pay the money.
So, the Batshuayi deal seems the better one.
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 05 Oct 20 10.51pm |
|
Originally posted by mattteo
One could be brought on loan, for the other you'd have tp cough 25 million without the certainty that he could have made it. It appears now , after the Liverpool game, that he IS good enough for the money. But he was just a Championship center forward who had only played 1 full season as center forward, previously having been used as a winger.
On the other hand, Batshuayi was a certainty at international level, having played well for all Belgium, Borussia Dortmund, Chelsea and us. And if he doesn't accustom well this year, you can even chise not to pay the money.
So, the Batshuayi deal seems the better one.
I’m actually inclined to agree here.
But knee jerk to start assuming Watkins is the next R9 after one performance and could still go one way or the other for me. I wish him luck though and can’t help but still admit a bit of jealousy. Equally, there’s every chance Bats could have a terrible season. Be interesting to see anyhow
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
Painter Croydon 05 Oct 20 11.10pm |
|
Originally posted by mattteo
One could be brought on loan, for the other you'd have tp cough 25 million without the certainty that he could have made it. It appears now , after the Liverpool game, that he IS good enough for the money. But he was just a Championship center forward who had only played 1 full season as center forward, previously having been used as a winger.
On the other hand, Batshuayi was a certainty at international level, having played well for all Belgium, Borussia Dortmund, Chelsea and us. And if he doesn't accustom well this year, you can even chise not to pay the money.
So, the Batshuayi deal seems the better one.
Also Watkins was never going to come here. Dean Smith helped develop him at Brentford, so believes in him, so obviously he is going to go to Villa.
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Oct 20 11.16pm |
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Would you rather we had bought Watkins thank loaned Bats?
Watkins is clearly good enough for PL
Ultimately it doesn't matter who we would prefer, it's about who we could afford.
Watkins or Eze is a more relevant question as we couldn't fund both.
Old, Ungifted and White
|
Jamesrichards8 06 Oct 20 1.03am |
|
|
Looked at prospectively, we made the wise choice. Retrospectively, we could have been a bit more adventurous and gone for Watkins, but you can't say it's a proven fact at this point--he could finish the season with 3 goals.
Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Oct 2020 1.03am)
When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...
|
Casual Orpington 06 Oct 20 6.44am |
|
|
Based o the few games this season , Bamford looks decent, where as our experience of him is that he is f*cking awful. Pukki started last season with a flying start, then went to s*it,
Watkins had one decent season in an attacking championship side and was an unknown quantity for defenders, as it was his first as a striker.
I’m not a particular fan of Batshuayi, he doesn’t work hard enough or even jump for headers to play in a system like ours. If you don’t score bundles at Chelsea with the quality balls that they can provide I struggle to see how he will be a success with us. I think the Bournemouth goals on the last day for us, improved his stats for us last time. I’d be happy if Batshuayi reached the same number of goals as ayew did last year, although I doubt he will add as much to the all round play as Ayew did.
Will have to wait and see. Wouldn’t be surprised if both do ok or sink without trace.
|
EddieMac 06 Oct 20 7.33am |
|
|
We never bid for Watkins and never had a chance to sign him so it makes no odds really to think what might have been.
|
deleted 25 06 Oct 20 8.42am |
|
Originally posted by Painter
Also Watkins was never going to come here. Dean Smith helped develop him at Brentford, so believes in him, so obviously he is going to go to Villa.
You are right there. We went to Villa near the end of last season and didn't put in a show. If we had beaten them and they went down then it's more of a possibility we could have signed him. I think the club were alerted to him by Clinton Morrison who played with him at Exeter. He is an intelligent technical player who is going to be a major premier league player. Villa are going to a top half team and above this season
|
KAOS In a tree 06 Oct 20 8.56am |
|
|
It's all very well spending 28 million on a striker but he has to be given regular chances ... and that's an area we fail in miserably over a season. We'll never score 7 in this league in a game as long as we're in it, let alone against a top 4 side. On this basis, Bats is a better deal for us ...
|
taylors lovechild 06 Oct 20 9.12am |
|
|
I think Bats and Zaha might actually work together. I don't personally think Ayew and Zaha does. That might change, but at the moment there doesn't seem to be any chemistry and they don't seem to be able to read each other's game. I do think it is because they are both wingers playing as forwards. The first game I saw Watkins in the PL he looked a bit lost and were it not for his pace I wouldn't have said he looked worth the money. And then he scored three past Liverpool. So much with strikers seems to be about confidence to the point that even Bamford can look like a footballer.
|
Pete53 Hassocks 06 Oct 20 9.33am |
|
|
I edge a bit toward Watkins. He's young and hungry to prove himself. Whilst Bats isn't exactly old, he hasn't really established himself and has floated along a bit for a couple of seasons.
He certainly has talent, but doesn't always seem to have that extra bit of drive to impose himself, or the work rate that will pay dividends. I always thought he was a bit of a show-boater and would sparkle when things are going well, but wasn't the sort of player you need when you have your backs to the wall.
|
deleted 25 06 Oct 20 10.05am |
|
Originally posted by Jamesrichards8
Looked at prospectively, we made the wise choice. Retrospectively, we could have been a bit more adventurous and gone for Watkins, but you can't say it's a proven fact at this point--he could finish the season with 3 goals.
Edited by Jamesrichards8 (06 Oct 2020 1.03am)
Football is all about opinions - anybody can backtrack and join the right opinion, but Clinton Morrison has been onto the club for along time about Ollie Watkins.
Bats will be lucky to get to half of Watkins total of goals this season. End of
|
orpingtoneagle Orpington 06 Oct 20 10.09am |
|
|
Does it matter? Whichever one would only ever be an unplayed substitute as Roy likes to stubbornly stick to the same 11 regardless of results.
|
pompeyeagle Relocated to Shropshire 06 Oct 20 10.47am |
|
|
That's surely a question that can only be answered at the end of the season. Batshuayi hasn't been given a chance yet to show what he can do and Watkins has had one good game against a goalkeeper who was suspect to say the least. I very much doubt he would have scored a hat trick if Allison had been playing.
|
Fatherken 06 Oct 20 11.44am |
|
|
Watkins for me . he runs with the ball and without it making positions for himself and can head the ball . none of which the batman can do
|
JohnB 06 Oct 20 11.52am |
|
|
Batshuayi for me. Genuine international striker. Proven.
Watkins has had one decent game and was pretty much gifted a hattrick. I'm not going to wet myself over 1 game and he was pretty anonymous in the other 2.
If we actually play Batshuayi, I reckon he will outscore Watkins.
|
Come to Daddy 06 Oct 20 12.10pm |
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
Watkins for me . he runs with the ball and without it making positions for himself and can head the ball . none of which the batman can do
So far he has only done that in the Championship & in one freak game with 9 goals. He has also played in 2 other games without contributing either a goal or an assist. Neither the hatrick nor the two blanks proves anything at this stage and he probably will be decent but, as mentioned, he cost £28m. Batshuayi has far more established pedigree and has scored at about a goal every other game when he has played in the Prem, Ligue 1 and the Bundesliga with a better ratio than that over 30 international games. For a player with sh1t movement and no heading ability, that’s not bad.
|
Fatherken 06 Oct 20 12.17pm |
|
|
if he can score that many goals [ every other game ] why did Chelsea let him go on loan
|