You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best starting XI
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Best starting XI


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Mugaman Flag 01 Sep 21 6.38pm

Ok I realise we have a few (long-term) absentees.. but if everyone was fully fit what's our best starting 11.

I'm thinking

VG

Ferguson Anderson Guehi Mitchell(?)

Gallagher Hughes(?) Macca

Eze Edouard Zaha

I have ? next to Hughes as unsure if Luca should be there (but only if he can become the player we initially signed). Kouyate - I feel will struggle playing the PV way. Mitchell I'm still yet to be convinced by - especially when it comes to his attacking ability and more importantly his passing ability.

Thoughts?

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 01 Sep 21 6.53pm

**********Guaita********

Clyne**Andersen**Guehi**Schlupp

**Gallagher**Hughes**Eze*******

****Olise***Edouard***Wilf*****

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Sep 21 9.38pm

3-5-2 (eventually)

Guiata

Andersen - Tomkins - Guehi

Clyne - Luka - Gallagher - Schlupp

Eze

Benteke - Zaha/Eduoard

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Sep 21 9.39pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

**********Guaita********

Clyne**Andersen**Guehi**Schlupp

**Gallagher**Hughes**Eze*******

****Olise***Edouard***Wilf*****

That's a waste of Eze, in my opinion. And harsh on Macca who's been a legend for us and started the season immensely. How can you possibly put Hughes in there ahead of him without seeing a minute of him playing.

 

TJ Flag Croydon 01 Sep 21 9.52pm

Guaita

Ward
Guehi
Andersen
Mitchell

McArthur
Gallagher

Olise
Eze
Zaha

Edouard

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 Sep 21 10.10pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

**********Guaita********

Clyne**Andersen**Guehi**Schlupp

**Gallagher**Hughes**Eze*******

****Olise***Edouard***Wilf*****

This is precisely my preferred XI and system too.

Although I am swayed a bit by sprites point about Hughes v McArthur, I disagree with him when he argues that Eze is wasted as one of the midfield three. The opposite is true in my opinion, he's wasted on the wing, and developed noticeably when playing in midfield at the end of last season.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (01 Sep 2021 10.11pm)

 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Sep 21 10.18pm

Originally posted by Mugaman

Ok I realise we have a few (long-term) absentees.. but if everyone was fully fit what's our best starting 11.

I'm thinking

VG

Ferguson Anderson Guehi Mitchell(?)

Gallagher Hughes(?) Macca

Eze Edouard Zaha

I have ? next to Hughes as unsure if Luca should be there (but only if he can become the player we initially signed). Kouyate - I feel will struggle playing the PV way. Mitchell I'm still yet to be convinced by - especially when it comes to his attacking ability and more importantly his passing ability.

Thoughts?

Strange to include 3 players, that you have never seen play for Palace, maybe 2 ever.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Sep 21 10.42pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

This is precisely my preferred XI and system too.

Although I am swayed a bit by sprites point about Hughes v McArthur, I disagree with him when he argues that Eze is wasted as one of the midfield three. The opposite is true in my opinion, he's wasted on the wing, and developed noticeably when playing in midfield at the end of last season.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (01 Sep 2021 10.11pm)

Sorry, you misunderstood me. Definitely not a winger, but I want him number 10 not on the left of midfield.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Sep 21 10.48pm

Originally posted by Painter

Strange to include 3 players, that you have never seen play for Palace, maybe 2 ever.

Totally agree. Whatever happened to having to earn your place. Madness to throw Hughes/Olise/Edouard into a ‘best 11’ without even seeing them.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 01 Sep 21 10.54pm

————— Guaita. —————-

Clyne - Tompkins - Gueye - Mitchell
———— McArthur ———-
Gallagher - Schlupp
Eze ————————- Wilf
—————- Benteke —————

I’ll reserve judgement on Eduard and Olise until they’ve played in the prem but both excite me. Hughes looks to be a good signing but I’m a big fan of Jeff and directness from midfield. I like Andersen too but feel that when Tompkins is fit he’s out best CB. Got to say the squad looks strong with lots of options. Once the team click, we could be a real handful.

Edited by Goal Machine (01 Sep 2021 10.56pm)

 

Fatherken Flag 01 Sep 21 11.15pm

I see that a lot of you are putting Edouard into your team without seeing him play .
He does come with a good scoring record but so did Mateta and he has not been able to cut it in the Prem .
Lets wait and see how good he is .

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 Sep 21 11.26pm

Originally posted by sprites

Totally agree. Whatever happened to having to earn your place. Madness to throw Hughes/Olise/Edouard into a ‘best 11’ without even seeing them.

I'd usually agree, and in fact I often make a similar point to those who suggest various youth players be selected for the first team, or making optimistic predictions about Fergusons ability.

In this instance I confess to picking my best XI based partly on what I hope Hughes, Olise and Edouard will do for us, but I've also considered what they did for their former teams, the hit and miss performances of the players they would replace (Ayew and benteke in particular), the better tactical fit my XI seems to have over the current XI, and finally, the younger average age (and therfore potential for growth and longevity) my XI offers.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Sep 21 11.32pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I'd usually agree, and in fact I often make a similar point to those who suggest various youth players be selected for the first team, or making optimistic predictions about Fergusons ability.

In this instance I confess to picking my best XI based partly on what I hope Hughes, Olise and Edouard will do for us, but I've also considered what they did for their former teams, the hit and miss performances of the players they would replace (Ayew and benteke in particular), the better tactical fit my XI seems to have over the current XI, and finally, the younger average age (and therfore potential for growth and longevity) my XI offers.

Don't come on here with your reasonable, well-measured responses.

Fair play mate.

 

ChicagoPalace Flag 01 Sep 21 11.52pm

This is a great exchange. I'll take a crack at it with the proviso that I think/hope this will be our best starting XI on 1 March:

Edouard

Zaha Eze Olise

Hughes Gallagher

Mitchell Andersen Guehi Clyne(?)

Guaita

Originally posted by sprites

Don't come on here with your reasonable, well-measured responses.

Fair play mate.

 

Palace Passion Flag Bromley, South London 01 Sep 21 11.56pm

Guaita

Clyne---Andersen---Guehi---Mitchell


Gallagher---Hughes


Olise-----Eze-----Zaha


Edouard

 


|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|||||||||||P|A|L|A|C|E|||||||||||
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||


***Oliver Glasner's RED BLUE ARMY***
Be loud.. Be proud.. Be PALACE!

staffie - missed but never forgotten 19/04/15

TheBigToePunt Flag 02 Sep 21 12.18am

Originally posted by ChicagoPalace

This is a great exchange. I'll take a crack at it with the proviso that I think/hope this will be our best starting XI on 1 March:

Edouard

Zaha Eze Olise

Hughes Gallagher

Mitchell Andersen Guehi Clyne(?)

Guaita


I thought you'd put Edouard in goal and Eze at sweeper for a minute, then I saw that we'd just changed ends!

The key is, as you say, that the team we have for the final stage of the season may be noticeably better than the one that started it, principally due to Eze returning.

 

ChicagoPalace Flag 02 Sep 21 1.10am

Haha!

I truly believe that the squad we roll out beginning in 2022 will be appreciably better than the one we have now. As long as we have seven or eight points through our first ten matches, we will be perfectly fine.

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I thought you'd put Edouard in goal and Eze at sweeper for a minute, then I saw that we'd just changed ends!

The key is, as you say, that the team we have for the final stage of the season may be noticeably better than the one that started it, principally due to Eze returning.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 02 Sep 21 1.26am

Unfortunately I doubt Eze and Gallagher will play more than a few games together. 10 if we're lucky.

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 02 Sep 21 4.14am

Best starting 11 is...

The team that wins us the most points. Good luck PV, at least there's something to work with (so long as we don't keep getting bitten by the injury curse)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 02 Sep 21 9.05am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

This is precisely my preferred XI and system too.

Although I am swayed a bit by sprites point about Hughes v McArthur, I disagree with him when he argues that Eze is wasted as one of the midfield three. The opposite is true in my opinion, he's wasted on the wing, and developed noticeably when playing in midfield at the end of last season.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (01 Sep 2021 10.11pm)

Yes, i agree McArthur and Hughes i suspect will play 50/50 if don't stay fit, definitely Eze in midfield not wide, the problem with McArthur is his age, which is obviously not his fault

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best starting XI