This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Frank de Boer
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Qwijibo Bournemouth 02 Sep 21 8.06pm |
|
|
After that first half against West Ham, I think there were a lot of people questioning whether we had another FdB situation. Whilst harsh, it's likely to be the go-to analogy for any manager struggling to immediately implement his ideas.
It's always struck me that losing 4 games isn't that bad. Being the first 4 of the season really magnifies it, but it's not as if Hodgson, Pardew, Holloway and others haven't had worse runs mid-season. My vague recollection is we were quite good against Burnley, but lost because of Lee Chung-Yong's shocking back pass and an inability to score.
So presumably there was more to it than merely poor form.
We're now four years on. What happened? And just how unimpressed were the players and directors with what they saw from him?
[Link]
[Link]
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 02 Sep 21 11.25pm |
|
|
That season 14 pts from last 6 games, them was the days
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
viveasheagle perth 03 Sep 21 5.51am |
|
|
Yes we did play well against Burnley but lost 3-0 at home to Huddersfield and 2-0 at home to Swansea before then. De Boer was also sacked early in his roles for Inter Milan and his national team. Difficult to know the reason's but i suspect player power might have something to do with his sacking at the time but in hindsight it was the right decision and Roy was able to keep us. The difference this time is that with so many out of contract players at the end of the season the management team have been able to bring in a lot of new players who can help the squad adjust to a new playing style quickly.
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 03 Sep 21 8.16am |
|
|
After Pardew was sacked, Fat Sam came in and blew the budget in order to keep us in the Premier League. It worked but it meant that we had nothing left in the kitty after Allardyce buggered off.
We then had the wrong type of players for the de Boer style to work. Football under Hodgson was similar to BFS football so he was able to work wonders on very little money and an aging squad.
Either through luck or foresight, a lot of players were coming to the end of their Palace career so Vieira has been able to bring in players that suit his style of play. It remains to be seen if they can integrate with the ones left from the last regime but the 2nd half at West Ham was certainly prommising.
There are few similarities between FDB and Vieira other than they are changing the style of football after a more pragmatic predecessor.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
southnorwoodhill 03 Sep 21 9.07am |
|
|
That clip of FdB doing press ups made me chuckle
|
CrazyBadger Ware 03 Sep 21 9.17am |
|
|
Always thought Fdb was not given enough time. Showed a lack of commitment/conviction from SP. Pre-season and 4 games was never going to be enough for what he was attempting. Thought the Performances showed Promise - especially the last game (can't remember which one that was!).
Saying that, a lot of talk about evolution not revolution but he seemed to go with revolution anyway.
Always felt that the board were unhappy with their decision and used the 4 losses as the perfect excuse to correct their mistake.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Sep 21 9.40am |
|
|
Obviously, I don't know FdB but the impression I've gained is that he's his own worst enemy. He seems to insist on doing things his way even when he doesn't have the tools,
It was noticeable in the Euros that he deliberately adopted his own system at the expense of the one traditionally associated with the national team.
I don't think FdB can do evolution, only revolution. That kind of attitude tends to lose the dressing room pretty quickly not to mention the fans.
Although Vieira is bringing revolution rather than evolution, it is very much with the blessing of SP (and presumably the rest of the board). It is clear from the way we got much of our business done early this window that Parish and Freedman had been tracking players who can play a more possession-based style of football. The running down of so many contracts at once was probably deliberate as it has enabled the club to bring in a sufficient number the right type of players to make it possible to adopt the new style from Day 1.
|
Goal Machine The Cronx 03 Sep 21 9.56am |
|
|
From an outsider looking in, FDB was trying to implement a style of football for which we simply didn't have the players for. He appeared too stubborn/not able to play any other way.
If he has his vision of playing Ajax champagne football, this is something which should have been gradually bought in over time. We should have stuck to what we're good (i.e. defend/counter attack) until we're safe and then slowly bring in the right players, 2/3 every transfer window and treat the the last 6 games of the season with pre-season as the transition period.
Too much too quickly, too stupid/arrogant. His record since leaving Palace has been dreadful which suggests we swerved a bullet.
PV has been fortunate that we're able to throw money at new signings. I think it's a fantastic opportunity for him.
|
Foxy0208 Blackpool 03 Sep 21 10.00am |
|
|
I think FDB was sacked over more than just the poor start.
There were lots of rumblings at the time about fallouts with senior players.
A big part of managing a team is about how you build a relationship with your squad and get your ideas across to them and reputation alone won't do it and above all else you need your senior players to be on board.
PV seems to be much better at this and the training ground clips seem to show a much happier ship.
To be totally fair to FDB he probably didn't get the backing in terms of bringing in players to implement his new style but I don't think he managed the players he had particularly well.
Its going to take time but the basic stuff seems to be in place so as long as everyone is patient and doesn't panic after every defeat, I think we have every reason to feel positive about the future.
Some people think football is a matter of life and death. I don't like that attitude. I can assure them it is much more serious than that.
|
Putitout Oxford 03 Sep 21 10.21am |
|
|
The one thing that stands out from the Frank de Boer, moment, is if the transfer policy of the next four years was to go by, he was expected to change our playing style with the players he had with very few additions. That’s what Hodgson , worked with, why would it have been any different for De Boer,? Frank, may well have not been the best choice anyway , but that was going to be a tall order whoever tried to do it. As it was under Hodgson,the playing style stagnated to some degree because of a lack of investment in players suitable for improving our style.and remain in the league.
|
Painter Croydon 03 Sep 21 11.34am |
|
|
Let’s just be honest, de Boer isn’t a very good as a manager and has very poor people skills. It’s as simple as that, as time has shown since he was sacked by Palace.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 03 Sep 21 11.37am |
|
|
I just can’t bring myself to care about him anymore. I think trying to teach Delaney a scissor kick volley into the top corner nearly got him a punch in the head. He has that type of face, doesn't he?
Red and Blue Army!
|
babylonjohn St Leonards-on-Sea 03 Sep 21 12.21pm |
|
Originally posted by Foxy0208
I think FDB was sacked over more than just the poor start.
There were lots of rumblings at the time about fallouts with senior players.
A big part of managing a team is about how you build a relationship with your squad and get your ideas across to them and reputation alone won't do it and above all else you need your senior players to be on board.
PV seems to be much better at this and the training ground clips seem to show a much happier ship.
To be totally fair to FDB he probably didn't get the backing in terms of bringing in players to implement his new style but I don't think he managed the players he had particularly well.
Its going to take time but the basic stuff seems to be in place so as long as everyone is patient and doesn't panic after every defeat, I think we have every reason to feel positive about the future.
I agree. FdB almost certainly lost the dressing room and the willingness and belief of the team to continue doing what he was asking them to do. That combined with the poor results left Parish with no choice. I see no such problem with the current set up. Even at this relatively early stage of our rebuild the progress on the pitch is plain to see. Exciting times.
|
Frickin Saweet South Cronx 03 Sep 21 12.41pm |
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
Always thought Fdb was not given enough time. Showed a lack of commitment/conviction from SP. Pre-season and 4 games was never going to be enough for what he was attempting. Thought the Performances showed Promise - especially the last game (can't remember which one that was!).
Saying that, a lot of talk about evolution not revolution but he seemed to go with revolution anyway.
Always felt that the board were unhappy with their decision and used the 4 losses as the perfect excuse to correct their mistake.
my thoughts as well. Although I heard that he'd lost the dressing room, so rightly or wrongly at that point you have to choose between the manager and the players. We weren't in a position to entertain the luxury of the latter.
|
Dubai Eagle 03 Sep 21 12.52pm |
|
|
I am ready to stand corrected but I seem to remember that not only did we lose the first 4 games without scoring a goal, we also didn't register a single shot on target for three of them - by the time we played Burnley (the 4th game) I think that the decision that he had to go was already pretty much taken.
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 03 Sep 21 1.13pm |
|
|
From memory there just wasn’t a positive enough shift. We went from having a good shape and hard to score against with little attacking threat, to open and easy to score against still with little attacking threat.
So whilst there was some evolution of play, the board likely thought that there was too much that needs fixing and the risk was too high.
Also whilst he did well at Ajax, started ok at Inter, and did ok in his first season at Atlanta, his managerial career is surely going to run out of steam soon. Sacked from Inter, sacked from Palace, sacked from Atlanta, sacked from the national team. I’d be very wary if I was a chairman.
This feels very different, we are more positive are holding the ball better and are starting to create some chances. It was always going to be a tricky start. Champions league winner, promoted team flying high and form team away. 2 points from that isn’t too shabby.
Edited by MrRobbo (03 Sep 2021 1.19pm)
|
Ginger Pubic Wig Wickham de L'Ouest 03 Sep 21 3.44pm |
|
|
The list of great players being terrible managers is enormous. Often it's average players with great mental strength and intelligence who do better.
It's insane how many managers get a good gig because of illustrious playing careers.
I'm convinced Zidane is a dud who has only succeeded because of the resources he's had at Madrid.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.
|
Mwncisee Middlesbrough 03 Sep 21 3.50pm |
|
|
I seem to recall SP talking about how FdB was not on the clubs radar at all and his interest in the job came out the blue. He was added to the shortlist and really only considered as an extreme outside chance to make up the numbers a little. what did it for FdB is he had really done his research into the Palace squad and made a presentation detailing how he could evolve the then squad into a team playing to his ethos (Like Ajax). This really turned the boards heads.
I think the reality was that it soon became apparent that what you say you can do in a presentation and what actually happened was very different. I always got the impression the board and SP felt somewhat hoodwinked by FdB and so it was always destined to be a very short affair.
|
deleted 25 03 Sep 21 5.11pm |
|
|
Liverpool were reportedly nterested in FdB sometime prior to him being appointed by us
I think that maybe he and Koeman lacked some people skills and have a slightly serious public image
Worth also considering that we lost all our first 7 games under FdB and Roy (4/3) and that we only won our first game once Zaha played his first game of the season v Chelski
Roy had a poor Euro, losing to Iceland and Palace didn’t have a plan for new manager. FdB was out of the blue. This time the club have backed Viera more fully with the change of playing style. You could say that what happened under FdB the club learned from
Edited by Vincehair (03 Sep 2021 5.15pm)
|
Foxy0208 Blackpool 03 Sep 21 5.58pm |
|
|
I think the club definitely learned some lessons and whilst I agree it seemed FDB was maybe not given enough time I am not sure it would ever have come right under him.
PV may yet fail but the start is more promising, he has been provided with some decent signings, his history will only bring him respect from his new charges and he seems like a very steady character who understands how to build a team spirit.
I would be happily surprised if we finished top 10 but would settle for retaining PL status and seeing some positive performances.
Some people think football is a matter of life and death. I don't like that attitude. I can assure them it is much more serious than that.
|