You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > squad transition ... job done!
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

squad transition ... job done!


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 12 Sep 21 11.27am

basically, everyone was concerned that it would take time for new players to settle in and play in a new more possession-based style - well, it took about three weeks didn't it? getting 4 or 5 points from our first ten matches and having to keep faith with PV till the new year? Nope, we've dodged that bullet. With Hughes and Eze to come! well done Dougie, but SP bringing in Textor is a masterstroke, and you can see why Favre nearly took the job - SP kept his nerve and could sense (it seems to me) that PV knows what he's doing - crisis over.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 12 Sep 21 12.23pm

Totally agree with you ex hib. Mr Parish first and foremost, Dougie and PV all made a massive impact. We look a completely different team this season in the way we're playing.

A lot of concerns expressed on here and in the media about how well, or even whether, we could adapt with so many changes in personnel and a new manager. It's pleasing to prove the doubters wrong.

Mustn't get carried away though, still very early in the season and, let's be honest, Spurs were awful yesterday. But, as you say we have Eze waiting in the wings and other newbies still to make a proper appearance. How exciting is that?

In recent times the words exciting and Palace have rarely been used in the same sentence! The Times They Are A'Changin' for sure.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Bearcage Flag Welling 12 Sep 21 12.26pm

Excellent start, but not yet done. I’m not sure we have genuine competition for places (so quality cover) in every position, so a couple more in Jan would be nice unless the youngsters in the U23 can step up in those positions.
I still think this season might be difficult, with a few rocky patches, but have confidence we’ll get it right and push on next season.

 

AERO Flag 12 Sep 21 12.27pm

Yes good posts and now just need the Ground redevelopments to get underway and we can look forward to a b.right future for the club

 

CP81 Flag Kent 12 Sep 21 1.29pm

Agreed.
So proud of the work the club has carried out throughout the summer. I actually gave up watching the final 18 months of RH's tenure, listening to the games on radio instead, as it was so painful.
Watching the new version of football we're playing has once again become exciting!
Still early doors, with improvements to be made. But as starts go, this fan is very optimistic.
Red and Blue army

Edited by CP81 (12 Sep 2021 1.35pm)

 


Palace 2 Charlton 0 1981

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Sep 21 2.43pm

Squad Transition....work in progress, not job done.

But certainly heading in the right direction.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

davehuggins Flag 12 Sep 21 2.46pm

We have without doubt done very well so far with some really decent talent coming in. The job is far from done as PV keeps saying, we need to work and become more consistent. COYP

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 12 Sep 21 2.46pm

Far too early to draw any positive conclusions, particularly when so much of the positivity is related to one game in which we played very well but spurs really didn't.

We will know how successful the squad / tactical / managerial change has been at the end of the season at the earliest. We can then compare our outlay for our points total and league placing (plus all the less empirical stuff like enjoyment, hope, worry and disappointment) with our previous top flight teams.

We should all enjoy yesterday of course (I watched it with my spurs supporting brother in law, so I certainly did!) but not read too much into it beyond that.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 12 Sep 21 4.00pm

We need to see how the younger players are developing, will Imray be good enough for RB next season, will wells-Morrison, Banks, be good enough to replace McArthur O´Brien, Baggypants, be good enough to replace kelly or tomkins, i think Rak-Sakyi will get game time this season, and the Mateta mystery is he ours or can we send him back if wanted, only the clubs know

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

BelfastEagle Flag 12 Sep 21 7.28pm

Good start but it’s work in progress certainly nowhere near job done…..long way to go.

 

beak Flag croydon 12 Sep 21 7.48pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Squad Transition....work in progress, not job done.

But certainly heading in the right direction.

My view exactly!

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 12 Sep 21 8.03pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Far too early to draw any positive conclusions, particularly when so much of the positivity is related to one game in which we played very well but spurs really didn't.

We will know how successful the squad / tactical / managerial change has been at the end of the season at the earliest. We can then compare our outlay for our points total and league placing (plus all the less empirical stuff like enjoyment, hope, worry and disappointment) with our previous top flight teams.

We should all enjoy yesterday of course (I watched it with my spurs supporting brother in law, so I certainly did!) but not read too much into it beyond that.

Agree 100% with this. Spurs are / were rubbish.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 12 Sep 21 8.55pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Far too early to draw any positive conclusions, particularly when so much of the positivity is related to one game in which we played very well but spurs really didn't.

We will know how successful the squad / tactical / managerial change has been at the end of the season at the earliest. We can then compare our outlay for our points total and league placing (plus all the less empirical stuff like enjoyment, hope, worry and disappointment) with our previous top flight teams.

We should all enjoy yesterday of course (I watched it with my spurs supporting brother in law, so I certainly did!) but not read too much into it beyond that.


Agreed it's too early to say 'job done'. Like even Lineker acknowledged, it's been a long time since we played as well as we did yesterday at Selhurst and so many of us are exhilarated by the performance. We gained 3 unexpected points (although I did predict a narrow 2-1 win), and that provides us with a temporary cushion above the drop zone.

The performance will no doubt have encouraged the players to continue to work hard to improve the system so as to produce more consistent performances but that will take time.

As for Spurs. Yes they didn't play well BUT much of that was down to our not letting them by getting in their faces early. Most of the early fouls were by our lads as they were determined to keep Spurs under pressure. Once we gained control of the game it was Spurs who were committing the fouls as they tried to stop us. Basically, we out-fought them, we out-thought them and we outplayed them.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 12 Sep 21 8.57pm

I have been watching the progress from pre season friendliest through to yesterday. So we started going down to the European champions. Then every game since we have played the league leaders. PV has got a great coaching team and with his undoubted experience it is starting to show. Yesterday we were really good and we made Tottenham look bad. All going to plan.

 

Mathers Flag 13 Sep 21 1.00pm

The squad rebuild has been exceptional. I had no arguments with letting go any of the 10 or so in the summer as they were all high earners and reaching the end of their careers. Every incoming player is an improvement to the squad and have the ability to double or treble their transfer value.

Once we have a fully fit squad, we will have an amazing squad that really should be pushing top 10. It will actually be a struggle to keep them all happy as we will have quality players on the bench.

All that being said, Spurs were very underpowered at the weekend and it showed. Tougher tests to come!

 

Ipswich Eagle Flag Ipswich 13 Sep 21 2.17pm

It's never a matter of "job done", but certainly it would appear the doom and gloom some talked about might be avoided.

For me I just pray to the Gods that we can avoid what I think is a pretty dire injury record as a team first and foremost. As stunning a performance as it was, we're still pretty threadbare in terms of depth, and the weekend still showed to me that some in the squad really aren't at the level we need.

However for me, I really can't remember a time when I've been was so excited to look forward to seeing us play as I am ahead of Eze's return (whenever that is). Tith Gallagher domineering box to box with Eze and Wilf out wide and Edouard upfront it could be just a joy to be a Palace fan.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 13 Sep 21 3.47pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

basically, everyone was concerned that it would take time for new players to settle in and play in a new more possession-based style - well, it took about three weeks didn't it? getting 4 or 5 points from our first ten matches and having to keep faith with PV till the new year? Nope, we've dodged that bullet. With Hughes and Eze to come! well done Dougie, but SP bringing in Textor is a masterstroke, and you can see why Favre nearly took the job - SP kept his nerve and could sense (it seems to me) that PV knows what he's doing - crisis over.

Yes , great squad and manager! If we continue with this form, maybe beating Liverpool, lets hope Arsenal get a thumping win, or they might just be sniffing around pv.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 13 Sep 21 3.48pm

Originally posted by AERO

Yes good posts and now just need the Ground redevelopments to get underway and we can look forward to a b.right future for the club

If you build it, they will come!

 

beak Flag croydon 13 Sep 21 5.42pm

The weaknesses are left back cover,another Centre Back those positions take the brunt of injuries and cards.We probably need a right winger.So three for January.

 

Aray Flag South London 13 Sep 21 7.19pm

Originally posted by beak

The weaknesses are left back cover,another Centre Back those positions take the brunt of injuries and cards.We probably need a right winger.So three for January.

Except for a specialist LB, I bet/guess that aint going to happen. We have Tompkins, Kouyate and Kelly (not as bad as some make out) who can play CB. And with Olise and Eze to come back, where would this winger play? Of course injuries could change things.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > squad transition ... job done!