You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Can you imagine if this was said today.
November 22 2026 7.22pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Can you imagine if this was said today.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Therealeaglestilidie Flag 29 Sep 21 12.37pm

and yet back in 1990 not even a flicker of a reaction in the studio.

[Link]

 


I'm so Palace I don't even know it

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Sep 21 12.44pm

Originally posted by Therealeaglestilidie

and yet back in 1990 not even a flicker of a reaction in the studio.

[Link]

He was right about Germany winning it though.

 


One more point

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 29 Sep 21 12.59pm

Of course there would be a massive over reaction from the lefty purists. There was no reaction from me I'm afraid - I grew up hearing this stuff all the time. Just everyday chat.

Nothing my old man liked more than prunes in his rice pudding. Ni***rs in a snow storm he called it. No more offensive than hearing rumours about new players on the jungle drums.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

dreamwaverider Flag London 29 Sep 21 1.33pm

It’s a generational thing. In that era and before we were free to say anything and no offence was shown. Nowadays everyone is reall y suppressed and the youngsters just accept that. But there are plenty whose thoughts are old school even though they contain it. The world has become so secretive and hypocritical driven largely by policial correctness and lies.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 29 Sep 21 3.39pm

it was an innocent remark, back in the days of Robertson's jam, b&w minstrels, eeny meeny etc and not having that in the lexicon anymore is progress, referring to people that way or using an outdated phrase are two completely different things, it was strange that Garth Crooks was next to him but it shows it was naivety from Sir Geoff, our Roy did something similar with Andros for England (feed the monkey) - it would be stupid to condemn Hurst in the same way as monkey chanters, but it is a good thing that phrases like that are unacceptable now. The PC mob are right in this case, I'm left leaning but I get the frustration with much of the tokenism and positive discrimination towards various minorities these days. Today's dogmatic left depress me - where are the Atlees, Gaitskills and Smiths? Labour offer either sixth form marxism or Blairism.

 

Noz Flag North Hampshire 01 Oct 21 3.08pm

I remember being in a meeting with colleagues back in 1999 (yes, a real meeting, not a digital one) and one of the attendees was black. Another attendee used this exact phrase, at which point there was a tumbleweed moment (for about 30 seconds). At which point said attendee was asked to leave the meeting, with their superior. They never returned.

I like to consider myself very aware of racist remarks, but it was only drawn to my attention recently that terms such as "cotton pickin'" and "sold down the river" also have negative racial connotations.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Oct 21 3.18pm

It is an unfortunate remark but seemingly innocent and generational.

It shows just how far the cultural shift has shifted and starkly shows just how correct Powell was when he said fifty years ago how the 'whip hand' would change.

Said now this national icon would be demonised and hated....led by the Twitter and corporate/political activists.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 3.20pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jeeagles Flag 01 Oct 21 3.38pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

It is an unfortunate remark but seemingly innocent and generational.

It shows just how far the cultural shift has shifted and starkly shows just how correct Powell was when he said fifty years ago how the 'whip hand' would change.

Said now this national icon would be demonised and hated....led by the Twitter and corporate/political activists.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 3.20pm)

Except the black man did nothing whilst a guy next to him made a racist comment. Hardly, a change in the whip hand. In fact, not a change at all.

It's staggeringly predictable how you try and spin this to make white people sound like a victim when a white man has just used racist language whilst sat next to a black man.

There's no lefties on here condemning what Hurst said. It was a dumb thing to say, but in 31 years times have changed. Nothing a quiet word in private couldn't resolve.

Powell wasn't right, he was sacked, and has been widely condemned ever since.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Oct 21 3.53pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Except the black man did nothing whilst a guy next to him made a racist comment. Hardly, a change in the whip hand. In fact, not a change at all.

It's staggeringly predictable how you try and spin this to make white people sound like a victim when a white man has just used racist language whilst sat next to a black man.

There's no lefties on here condemning what Hurst said. It was a dumb thing to say, but in 31 years times have changed. Nothing a quiet word in private couldn't resolve.

Powell wasn't right, he was sacked, and has been widely condemned ever since.


I said how Hurst would be treated if he'd said it today. If you think that's incorrect then quite frankly I think you're lying. So he would be demonised but in your world's that's obviously fine.

Most people understand that a 'racist' remark is only racist if it's intended to be. What Hurst said was unfortunate and as I said and came from his generation and the generations before that.

Now I don't think in your terms so if you want to demonise past generations as terribly racist that's for you. However, back in the adult world we understand that different eras contained different language. Instead what matters is what someone actually does....I'm not aware that Hurst ever did anything other than be a national icon.

As for Powell, the conservative elites sacked him....though he continued to be popular in the party. However as you also fail to recognise he had widespread public support....over seventy percent for what he said in the opinion polls at the time.

Whether Powell was sacked isn't important, unless you just want to display your elitist cuckoldry. What is important is was he accurate or not....you see the truth matters...even if it gets you sacked.

And once again, the Times ran a poll for best PMs we never had and he came joint third.....not bad for someone who died over twenty years ago and whom you dismiss.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 4.09pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jeeagles Flag 01 Oct 21 4.48pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I said how Hurst would be treated if he'd said it today. If you think that's incorrect then quite frankly I think you're lying. So he would be demonised but in your world's that's obviously fine.

Most people understand that a 'racist' remark is only racist if it's intended to be. What Hurst said was unfortunate and as I said and came from his generation and the generations before that.

Now I don't think in your terms so if you want to demonise past generations as terribly racist that's for you. However, back in the adult world we understand that different eras contained different language. Instead what matters is what someone actually does....I'm not aware that Hurst ever did anything other than be a national icon.

As for Powell, the conservative elites sacked him....though he continued to be popular in the party. However as you also fail to recognise he had widespread public support....over seventy percent for what he said in the opinion polls at the time.

Whether Powell was sacked isn't important, unless you just want to display your elitist cuckoldry. What is important is was he accurate or not....you see the truth matters...even if it gets you sacked.

And once again, the Times ran a poll for best PMs we never had and he came joint third.....not bad for someone who died over twenty years ago and whom you dismiss.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 4.09pm)

"Most people understand that a racist remark is only racist if it's intended to be". That's barely a sentence. It's a racist remark if if meets the definition of racist. There's no debate from anyone that Hurst made a racist comment. There's also no lefties screaming for him to be lynched or similar. They aren't even claiming he is racist, people are just saying it was a stupid thing to say. You're repeated obvious attempts to make yourself the victim isn't working.

Hurst has plenty of media commitments today and a twitter account. I'd be confident he wouldn't use that language today and would probably look back on the interview cringing at his former self.

You don't think in my terms, you just moan about how hard done by you are. An attitude of a failure. You've once again disingenuously claiming I'm demonising him, when all I said was needed was a quite word in private - along the lines of "don't say that again geoff, it's offensive". Then the matter would be dealt with. This is your victim mentality.

I've been pretty consistent in saying we should judge people in the past by today's standards.

We've all heard boring old farts bang on about Enoch Powel. They are the type of people that lack the emotional intelligence to realise that pretty much everyone around them is rolling their eyes waiting for throwback to stop talking so they can get on with their lives. What the boring old farts never realise is that they become the butt of all jokes as soon as they leave the room. No credible person would cite that speech now.

As for bringing up obscure polls from the past, you are really clutching at straws. People were claiming Marcus Rashford should be PM a few months ago. But trying to discredit the fact that he was sacked for his statement just shows how disingenuous you are.

I note you've started to throw round many little digs here and there as you repeatedly lose arguments. You just sound like a crybaby.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Oct 21 5.51pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

"Most people understand that a racist remark is only racist if it's intended to be". That's barely a sentence. It's a racist remark if if meets the definition of racist. There's no debate from anyone that Hurst made a racist comment. There's also no lefties screaming for him to be lynched or similar. They aren't even claiming he is racist, people are just saying it was a stupid thing to say. You're repeated obvious attempts to make yourself the victim isn't working.

Hurst has plenty of media commitments today and a twitter account. I'd be confident he wouldn't use that language today and would probably look back on the interview cringing at his former self.

You don't think in my terms, you just moan about how hard done by you are. An attitude of a failure. You've once again disingenuously claiming I'm demonising him, when all I said was needed was a quite word in private - along the lines of "don't say that again geoff, it's offensive". Then the matter would be dealt with. This is your victim mentality.

I've been pretty consistent in saying we should judge people in the past by today's standards.

We've all heard boring old farts bang on about Enoch Powel. They are the type of people that lack the emotional intelligence to realise that pretty much everyone around them is rolling their eyes waiting for throwback to stop talking so they can get on with their lives. What the boring old farts never realise is that they become the butt of all jokes as soon as they leave the room. No credible person would cite that speech now.

As for bringing up obscure polls from the past, you are really clutching at straws. People were claiming Marcus Rashford should be PM a few months ago. But trying to discredit the fact that he was sacked for his statement just shows how disingenuous you are.

I note you've started to throw round many little digs here and there as you repeatedly lose arguments. You just sound like a crybaby.

I have made my points and I don't wish to get involved in a pointlessly continual argument with the mentally low powered over what is and isn't reality.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 5.51pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jeeagles Flag 01 Oct 21 6.23pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I have made my points and I don't wish to get involved in a pointlessly continual argument with the mentally low powered over what is and isn't reality.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 5.51pm)

Awww resorting to insults before running away and playing the victim again.

If you don't want to want to get involved in pointless continual arguments, don't bore everyone by bringing up arguments what were resolved decades ago. You lost then, you're losing now, and your future is bleak.

Meanwhile, it sounds like myself, Wisbech, and DanH all have pretty good lives.

No matter how you dress it up, you're veiw point is obvious, and posts are predictable. They fill up these boards day after day, but interest no one. You could save yourself some time and just post "Stirlingsays doesn't like immigrants" after any issue.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Oct 21 6.37pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Awww resorting to insults before running away and playing the victim again.

If you don't want to want to get involved in pointless continual arguments, don't bore everyone by bringing up arguments what were resolved decades ago. You lost then, you're losing now, and your future is bleak.

Meanwhile, it sounds like myself, Wisbech, and DanH all have pretty good lives.

No matter how you dress it up, you're veiw point is obvious, and posts are predictable. They fill up these boards day after day, but interest no one. You could save yourself some time and just post "Stirlingsays doesn't like immigrants" after any issue.

Running away? How am I running away?

Your replies show that you're just a bit dim and much worse than that you bore me.

That's about it.

I've debated these issues with much brighter opposing minds, why repeat the process with a D minus who has Hitler stereotypes. If you were funny like Maine there would be a point.

You carry on your way, what you post won't make the slightest difference to me. But don't expect anymore replies as I know you want to turn the thread into a continual insult contest.


Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 6.39pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jeeagles Flag 01 Oct 21 6.53pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Running away? How am I running away?

Your replies show that you're just a bit dim and much worse than that you bore me.

That's about it.

I've debated these issues with much brighter opposing minds, why repeat the process with a D minus who has Hitler stereotypes. If you were funny like Maine there would be a point.

You carry on your way, what you post won't make the slightest difference to me. But don't expect anymore replies as I know you want to turn the thread into a continual insult contest.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 6.39pm)

Sooooooo predictable.

You're not debating the points. You're just resorting to name calling.

Even when you are claiming to debate you aren't, you are just boring everyone with dressed up monologs about how you dislike immigrants. There isn't a debate to be had with the likes of you any more, modern Britian has moved on.

It's not an insult contest, I haven't insulted you. Called you out. The insults are a one way street Stirlingsays and that tells me I know it makes a difference to you because you always start throwing your toys out the pram.

Have a lovely evening!


 

kuge Flag Peckham 01 Oct 21 7.19pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Running away? How am I running away?

Your replies show that you're just a bit dim and much worse than that you bore me.

That's about it.

I've debated these issues with much brighter opposing minds, why repeat the process with a D minus who has Hitler stereotypes. If you were funny like Maine there would be a point.

You carry on your way, what you post won't make the slightest difference to me. But don't expect anymore replies as I know you want to turn the thread into a continual insult contest.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 6.39pm)

Stirling's usual response when he is challenged is to say that he is bored. Perhaps in the same way that we are bored with him? His enthusiasm for Enoch Powell, a bright man who wasted his talents and is as relevant to modern politics as Lord North, suggest that he enjoys failure.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Oct 21 7.45pm

Originally posted by kuge

Stirling's usual response when he is challenged is to say that he is bored. Perhaps in the same way that we are bored with him? His enthusiasm for Enoch Powell, a bright man who wasted his talents and is as relevant to modern politics as Lord North, suggest that he enjoys failure.

Challenged?

I don't mind responding to you....as you are more dishonest than boring.

You think Powell was a failure? In truth he was more of a democrat and elitist than he was ambitious. He knew what he was doing when he made that speech, his IQ was off the page. If he had been more dishonest he could have tried for PM and then enacted his policies....but as he himself said, he just wasn't prepared to play the mucky game.

Powell wanted to draw a line in the sand and have it said officially and honestly what was happening and the road the elites were travelling the country down. He made it plain that this road was self destructive and madness for the continuance of heritage and ancestry. He made it explicit that it would end in the submission of, and the disowning of England/Britain's heritage via her replacement.

If failure is being correct in prophecy- then Powell failed most brightly.

But I've made it known previously that my enjoyment of these kinds of posts is lessening....I've kind of made my point and while I'll talk about certain topics if pressed my desire to go on and on in circle fashion with different posters is just less....that's just factual.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 7.49pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

BlueJay Flag UK 01 Oct 21 7.52pm

I'm rather nonplussed by what he said because as the saying goes 'it was a different time'. Nowadays someone would be very unlikely to drop this into a sentence, and as such its a self filtering process (as in the only people saying it would 99% of the time be nutters doing so with the intention of causing offence) so for all intents and purposes contextually he's not even saying the same thing.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Oct 21 7.59pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

I'm rather nonplussed by what he said because as the saying goes 'it was a different time'. Nowadays someone would be very unlikely to drop this into a sentence, and as such its a self filtering process (as in the only people saying it would 99% of the time be nutters doing so with the intention of causing offence) so for all intents and purposes contextually he's not even saying the same thing.

I regard today as far more nuts than Britain was in 68.

Today we have identity politics...well for some we have and it's a direct result of...well, frankly the path that Powell warned against all those years ago.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jeeagles Flag 01 Oct 21 8.00pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Challenged?

I don't mind responding to you....as you are more dishonest than boring.

You think Powell was a failure? In truth he was more of a democrat and elitist than he was ambitious. He knew what he was doing when he made that speech, his IQ was off the page. If he had been more dishonest he could have tried for PM and then enacted his policies....but as he himself said, he just wasn't prepared to play the mucky game.

Powell wanted to draw a line in the sand and have it said officially and honestly what was happening and the road the elites were travelling the country down. He made it plain that this road was self destructive and madness for the continuance of heritage and ancestry. He made it explicit that it would end in the submission of, and the disowning of England/Britain's heritage via her replacement.

If failure is being correct in prophecy- then Powell failed most brightly.

But I've made it known previously that my enjoyment of these kinds of posts is lessening....I've kind of made my point and while I'll talk about certain topics if pressed my desire to go on and on in circle fashion with different posters is just less....that's just factual.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2021 7.49pm)

A long pointless monolog about Powell on a thread about something Geoff Hurst said in 1990.

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 01 Oct 21 8.09pm

I don't know why people would bring this sort of stuff up from decades ago, unless, as seems to be their want these days, they need to find something to be offended by.

It was a different world back then.

Most of the offended seem to be younger people, who weren't even born back then and have no idea what the world was like. People weren't all looking to be offended like they are today.

Probably most of these youngsters would have laughed at programmes like 'Love Thy Neighbour' and 'In Sickness and in Health' because that was the times. I know I laughed at the black bloke calling the white bloke a H0nkey in LTN, and as for Marigold in Alf Garnett, his comebacks were cutting and hysterical. In fact the programmes usually ended up with the white person ridiculed or the black person gaining the upper hand/high ground.

I acknowledge that times have changed, and now everyone has to be a bit more careful, but the older generation are now living in fear of innocently slipping up just in case some poor little snowflake unnecessarily makes their life a misery on social media, just so they can get a few 'likes'.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Can you imagine if this was said today.