This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
I agree he always seems to inject some impetus when he gets on the ball. Ive always liked him and Ayew but they seem to get slated on here. COYP
|
|
|
|
|
|
Always been a big fan. Right up there for us. Fast skilful. Good tackle. Scores. Never moans. Very refreshing player.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
He is a great impact player and a solid pro, but he is not a central midfielder. He's slow to make decisions unless it is to just run at the goal and his passing range is not great. I like having him in the squad and if he is given simple instructions like "just get in the box" he comes up with the goods. It'll be interesting to see if club renew his deal. From what i've seen renewing his deal is an obvious yes! We have more impetus when he plays,unlike Wilf the whinger who slows everything down.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
He is a great impact player and a solid pro, but he is not a central midfielder. He's slow to make decisions unless it is to just run at the goal and his passing range is not great. I like having him in the squad and if he is given simple instructions like "just get in the box" he comes up with the goods. It'll be interesting to see if club renew his deal. Really good assessment. An instinctive player who often makes the wrong decisions around passes or positioning when playing in midfield - but stick him in the box and simplify his choices and he’ll come up with the goods on a regular basis. I hope he gets a new deal.
|
|
|
He needs more game time, which he will get now…
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Schlupp has been a good signing for us, but he is at a crossroads in his Palace career right now. If his contract expired tomorrow I'm not sure he'd get a new one. Firstly, he needs better luck with injuries. At his age they take more of a toll and the club will be less inclined to wait for him than they would for a younger player with eight or ten years of service left in them. Secondly, he needs to find a way to fit in to how we now play. Schlupp is a tremendous athlete with a powerful shot, and when playing on the right for Hodgson showed a gift for timing off-the-ball runs into the box. Vieira requires a totally different set of skills from his midfielders, who need to be able to use the ball efficiently in tight spaces. In that respect, Schlupp has been probably the least successful of the old guard in converting to the new style. Apart from Ayew and Mitchell, Vieira likes players to play on their 'wrong' side and cut inside, but playing Schlupp on the right of the midfield three seems not only unsuited to his strengths, but almost a showcase for his weaknesses. He struggles to play sharp, one and two touch stuff in small areas, and whilst the winger in him wants to run at players, the centre of the pitch is far more congested and when he gets to carry the ball forward he just bundles into crowds time and again. Schlupp isn't going to get in on the left wing ahead of Zaha, Edouard or Eze. He could be a good left back in our system (Mitchell surely can't play every single game), and is possibly worth keeping just for his flexibility, but to get the best out of him, Vieira would have to not only play Schlupp on the left side of the midfield three, but also allow him to be less involved in build up play and more focused on bursting into the box in the inside left channel. That's quite a shift in tactics and I'm not sure Schlupp is a good enough player to justify it. Back to the bench for Schluppy once everyone is available I'm afraid. No issues with that. Not everyone can start every week, and when everyone is fit we don't need him to. Keep himself fit and contribute when we need him is more than enough.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
He needs more game time, which he will get now… At Afcon?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.