This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
From one old geezer to another, I can see we are like birds on the same twig, as another old geezer on here has often said. I wrote yesterday saying that, whilst I agreed there was no penalty and Kevin Friend was wrong to award it, I thought folk were being too emotional about the decisions against us. Liverpool were all over us like a rash in the first half and deserved to be leading at half time. But we came back at them well and played some excellent football. Most of us expected to lose the game, but a draw would have felt like a win and was on the cards before the penalty decision. Their keeper was the difference. But, I have never read such an overwhelming amount of opinions as I have in this morning's papers that the referee's decisions and VAR were wrong. So, like you say, it should be beholden for them to apologise for the way yesterday's match was officiated. It would certainly be good to see, although Hell would freeze over first I suspect. You were right. Even if the penalty had not been given, you could not have it taken for sure that we would have equalised. So this wrong decision didn't cost us a point, it just took away our chance to get one. Regardless of this I've hardly ever seen such a wrong decision concerning pens especially with VAR.
|
|
|
Originally posted by WJK1960
I agree with all of the above and actually find the decision making for the second goal far more concerning than that for the penalty. Dermot Gallagher as an ex ref on Sky gave the impression that whether Firmino was 'active' in the lead up to the goal was a subjective opinion. Stephen Warnock completely refuted that view and said that any player in the penalty box is 'active'. Clearly Firmino drags Mitchell into a position where he has to get close to him, thereby leaving Oxlade Chamberlain free to have an unimpeded shot. For Craig Pawson not to understand that issue calls into serious question his capability as a ref - its really very worrying indeed. Thank goodness someone got his name right. I was originally baffled by the title of this thread ..
|
|
|
You do have to wonder if Palace were just a pawn sacrifice in the PL ratings race?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
There is something rotten to the core if you can watch that video over and over (and in slow motion) and still give the penalty. Is a keeper now meant to step out of the way when a striker is charging towards him? Absolutely. I honestly cannot believe that Friend can repeatedly look at the footage and not see what football fans, ex-players, managers, pundits and referees have seen. My impression is that he didn't have the strength of character to go by his initial decision and was in collusion with Pawson to award the penalty. What did they see that no one else has seen? The condemnation of the decision is across the board, and incidents like this bring the game into disrepute. Is the FA paying attention?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palacesince64
I see Dermott Gallagher (http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/fa_cup/2740043.stm) has said the penalty decision was wrong although he stopped short of agreeing the second goal shouldn’t have stood. Reckons that one is down to a subjective opinion! Personally I’d like my referees to be objective! He was off side and active. Mark Clattenberg (https://www.football.london/crystal-palace-fc/news/mark-clattenburg-palace-hoodoo-fans-1475015 We're yet to hear the name of a referee on this thread who hasn't in the past made a catastrophically poor decision against us in favour of a bigger team. Craig Pawson has only referred that decision because he was the VAR for the Newcastle City game where Fraser got wiped out (https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-10326253/Jamie-Redknapp-expresses-disbelief-Newcastle-werent-given-penalty-versus-Manchester-City.html) and no penalty was given and he was heavily criticised. At the time, they said 'it can't be a penalty as Fraser didn't have possession'. Fine. But neither did Jota?!?!?! And Ederson's involvement in that first one is clearly far worse than whatever Guaita is alleged to have done. The second goal is awful - there's no question Firmino is offside and interfering. Pawson surely has to be stripped of VAR responsibility going forward? It's error after error after error and they are all in favour of the title chasing team. Edited by ambrose7 (24 Jan 2022 1.53pm)
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by Palacesince64
I see Dermott Gallagher has said the penalty decision was wrong although he stopped short of agreeing the second goal shouldn’t have stood. Reckons that one is down to a subjective opinion! Personally I’d like my referees to be objective! He was off side and active. Mark Clattenberg says both decisions were wrong! I actually think the second goal was a worse decision becaue IMO and many, many others that is more cut and dried. A player in an offside position made an offensive move (or did he just jump in the air to keep warm?) whereas a penalty decision is usually subjective. Still was a pen though.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hannes
You were right. Even if the penalty had not been given, you could not have it taken for sure that we would have equalised. So this wrong decision didn't cost us a point, it just took away our chance to get one. Regardless of this I've hardly ever seen such a wrong decision concerning pens especially with VAR. No, but their clearly offside second goal might have. It can be true to say that both the ref and our bad start cost us. We looked terrible in the opening half an hour, but it is equally true that Liverpool were excellent. When you are playing against 13 men, it makes it all the harder. My opinion is that we have adopted the deep block too often against good footballing sides who play a high line when it would be better to press.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
No, but their clearly offside second goal might have. It can be true to say that both the ref and our bad start cost us. We looked terrible in the opening half an hour, but it is equally true that Liverpool were excellent. When you are playing against 13 men, it makes it all the harder. My opinion is that we have adopted the deep block too often against good footballing sides who play a high line when it would be better to press. 2-1 down with 5 minutes left, plus stoppage time; no-one on Earth can say how different the result would have been. Wasn't it only last week that Leicester were leading Spurs in the 94th minute only to lose? Whatever might or might not have transpired, the fact is that both decisions were completely wrong and not even 'borderline'. They clearly demonstrate that the whole system is rigged in favour of the big clubs - those clubs who a few months ago didn't even want to stay in this league! Edited by YT (24 Jan 2022 2.19pm)
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by WJK1960
I agree with all of the above and actually find the decision making for the second goal far more concerning than that for the penalty. Dermot Gallagher as an ex ref on Sky gave the impression that whether Firmino was 'active' in the lead up to the goal was a subjective opinion. Stephen Warnock completely refuted that view and said that any player in the penalty box is 'active'. Clearly Firmino drags Mitchell into a position where he has to get close to him, thereby leaving Oxlade Chamberlain free to have an unimpeded shot. For Craig Pawson not to understand that issue calls into serious question his capability as a ref - its really very worrying indeed. Terrible that we have to rely on support from two notorious ex-refs to make our case.
The right place at the right time |
|
|
The point of the post, apart from to prove that I can't spell Pawson, is that we can all take results based on bad luck or our bad play. We were poor for 30 mins and they were excellent and when we were excellent we were still a little short of ruthless finishers, often the difference at this level. Frankly 2 0 was more than OK as a score but it was not when all this money has been spent on VAR for f**k all purpose. Any result was possible in that game with its ebs and flows including a breakaway LFC goal at the end to make it....1-3. We came for a shootout. This is what we got from the match officials: [Link]
|
|
|
As Brian Clough said' if a player inside the penalty area is not active, what's he doing there'
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.