This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Not only him ... we were over-run in first 35 minutes Personally, if it is between Luka and him it is no contest, Hughes has constructive skill and puts it about. Luka has only the latter and is a rotten leader. Compare him with Ward as a Captain. What beats me is why we are now a 'second half team' - can anyone explain ? I can't, but I think pretty much one anyone would struggle to get close to that first half Liverpool performance - I think them tiring is more the reason we were able to get ourselves into the game 2nd half.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Not only him ... we were over-run in first 35 minutes Personally, if it is between Luka and him it is no contest, Hughes has constructive skill and puts it about. Luka has only the latter and is a rotten leader. Compare him with Ward as a Captain. What beats me is why we are now a 'second half team' - can anyone explain ? It was the same under Roy. Wrong starting line-up, too slow out of the blocks.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace chick
Playing Schlup alongside Hughes and Gallagher doesn’t help those two. We are missing Kouyate and/or Macca to play in that middle 3. I would have gone for Luka especially against Liverpool as the 3rd in the middle. The balance with Schlup in the 3 doesn’t work which is why Hughes and Gallagher haven’t been as good. Hughes seems to tire after 70 minutes and gets replaced nearly every match. Not sure if it is tiredness or Vieria changing it up. But anyway, I think Hughes has been a great buy for us and with returning players (Afcon/injury) will get better :-)
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace chick
Playing Schlup alongside Hughes and Gallagher doesn’t help those two. We are missing Kouyate and/or Macca to play in that middle 3. I would have gone for Luka especially against Liverpool as the 3rd in the middle. The balance with Schlup in the 3 doesn’t work which is why Hughes and Gallagher haven’t been as good. Hughes seems to tire after 70 minutes and gets replaced nearly every match. Not sure if it is tiredness or Vieria changing it up. But anyway, I think Hughes has been a great buy for us and with returning players (Afcon/injury) will get better :-) Agree with a lot of this, the balance is off and it isn't helping Gallagher or Hughes, with Hughes in particular having to play deeper. I think the selection is more a reflection of how Luka is thought of that a genuine idea that this 3 works - that West Ham performance perhaps finally being the straw that broke the camel's back. Looking forward to having Kouyate back. I still think the Hughes/Gallagher/Schlupp combo is better than any with Luka in it. Hughes has been great value. £6m for a 26 year old midfielder who looks comfortable in a mid-table side? No complaints, especially as he seems to have a bit of bite about him which we're short of. I don't think he or we started well against Liverpool but to give them credit, their one touch stuff to beat our press in that first 10 minutes was sublime. I don't think anyone outside the top 6 would have lived with it.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Regarding Hughes I think he has impressed since is has got in the team. Absolute bargain given what we paid for him
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
The second half performance by Schlupp was more down to him being switched to the left. Vieria then took Hughes off and put Schlupp back in the middle?
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Agree with a lot of this, the balance is off and it isn't helping Gallagher or Hughes, with Hughes in particular having to play deeper. I think the selection is more a reflection of how Luka is thought of that a genuine idea that this 3 works - that West Ham performance perhaps finally being the straw that broke the camel's back. Looking forward to having Kouyate back. I still think the Hughes/Gallagher/Schlupp combo is better than any with Luka in it. Hughes has been great value. £6m for a 26 year old midfielder who looks comfortable in a mid-table side? No complaints, especially as he seems to have a bit of bite about him which we're short of. I don't think he or we started well against Liverpool but to give them credit, their one touch stuff to beat our press in that first 10 minutes was sublime. I don't think anyone outside the top 6 would have lived with it. Spot on, particularly re Luka. I get the impression Vieira knows the balance is a little off with the current 3 but it’s the best option we’ve got for now. Luka shouldn’t be anywhere near a Premier League match these days and it seems like PV has worked that out as well.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by palace chick
Playing Schlup alongside Hughes and Gallagher doesn’t help those two. We are missing Kouyate and/or Macca to play in that middle 3. I would have gone for Luka especially against Liverpool as the 3rd in the middle. The balance with Schlup in the 3 doesn’t work which is why Hughes and Gallagher haven’t been as good. Hughes seems to tire after 70 minutes and gets replaced nearly every match. Not sure if it is tiredness or Vieria changing it up. But anyway, I think Hughes has been a great buy for us and with returning players (Afcon/injury) will get better :-) Good point. I think Jeff S has proved over the last few games he can't play central mid (other than the odd great moment). Assuming Conor plays in the advanced role that then puts pressure on Hughes to be the defensive midfielder and the one to collect the ball from the defence. He is ok at this, but not ideal. Against Liverpool i would have tried Luka next to Hughes too.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.