You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Zouma and the cat,,,,was it a criminal act?
November 21 2026 9.31pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Zouma and the cat,,,,was it a criminal act?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 10 Feb 22 8.06am

Does anyone know if based on the video he has committed a crime rather than just an act of stupidity and cruelty

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

YT Flag Oxford 10 Feb 22 8.19am

Animal cruelty is a crime.

Whether this incident is a crime will depend on whether 'the authorities' consider it a crime and then whether they pursue a fixed penalty or a criminal charge, and in the case of the latter whether they achieve a conviction.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Feb 22 8.31am

Criminally stupid. He should be got rid of from English football. We've enough stupid c***s as it is.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Feb 22 8.59am

It is in France apparently so his homecoming could be tricky.


[Link]

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Feb 22 10.38am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

It is in France apparently so his homecoming could be tricky.


[Link]

I bet when Zouma saw that he chat himself.

Aythankyou

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Feb 22 11.49am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I bet when Zouma saw that he chat himself.

Aythankyou

Indeed. Bet he let out a couple of tiddles himself.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 10 Feb 22 12.47pm

This is the pits. The use of the race card when debating violence against a dumb animal:

[Link]

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 10 Feb 22 1.12pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I bet when Zouma saw that he chat himself.

Aythankyou

Or Pepe Le Poo - ma chereee!

Edited by Slimey Toad (10 Feb 2022 1.14pm)

 

Grumbles 10 Feb 22 2.04pm

Zouma and the cat....is that a new Dr Suess book?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 10 Feb 22 2.22pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

This is the pits. The use of the race card when debating violence against a dumb animal:

[Link]

He's not debating violence is he? He's unequivocally condoned it.

I think it's very fair to question whether the fallout from this is proportionate to the severity of what Zouma has done.

Take racism out of it if it makes you happier; Marcos Alonso killed someone while drink driving, Ronaldo is heavily suspected of being a rapist... I don't see sponsors as willing to throw them under the bus or people calling for them to be sacked.

I think his point is fair, and it certainly is the pits to use phrases like 'the race card' when someone dares to question whether the fallout is a bit OTT.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 10 Feb 22 2.46pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

This is the pits. The use of the race card when debating violence against a dumb animal:

[Link]

I 100% agree that it's a ludicrous to dilute actual instances of racism by just crowbarring it as a distraction. Ultimately he was clearly looking for a way to defend a team mate but animal abuse is animal abuse. It likely wasn't of the gravity that it's going to be a career ender, but it's still gutter level beaviour.

edit: Oops, didn't look at the site section..


Edited by BlueJay (10 Feb 2022 2.58pm)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 10 Feb 22 3.01pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

I 100% agree that it's a ludicrous to dilute actual instances of racism by just crowbarring it as a distraction. Ultimately he was clearly looking for a way to defend a team mate but animal abuse is animal abuse. It likely wasn't of the gravity that it's going to be a career ender, but it's still gutter level beaviour.

I don't agree - I think the fallout is disproportionate, and that is Antonio's point, using racism as an example.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 10 Feb 22 3.05pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

I 100% agree that it's a ludicrous to dilute actual instances of racism by just crowbarring it as a distraction. Ultimately he was clearly looking for a way to defend a team mate but animal abuse is animal abuse. It likely wasn't of the gravity that it's going to be a career ender, but it's still gutter level beaviour.

edit: Oops, didn't look at the site section..


Edited by BlueJay (10 Feb 2022 2.58pm)

I agree and of course the cat couldn’t fight back.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Feb 22 3.24pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I don't agree - I think the fallout is disproportionate, and that is Antonio's point, using racism as an example.


I assumed the overriding sentiment pertains to the fact that Antonio may be using the Zouma offence to draw attention to his own interests which the situation does not merit and can come across as almost detracting, not defending, the animal abuse that has been perpetrated.

For me the correct response would therefore be that they could both be considered cowardly crimes however comparing one to another is neither here nor there in answering the original question regarding the animal abuse.

If someone asked me what my views on racism were, I wouldn't compare it to murder, for example. The resulting answer would neither have context to nor address the original question asides from creating a new debate around an imaginary moral barometer for crime. I therefore understand why it could be misconstrued as someone wishing to draw attention to their own vested interests which would by proxy distract from the point at hand.

It could well be the case, or said, that Antonio's point was to draw attention to the scale of the reaction to it as opposed to an equally condemnable crime. If I understand correctly that this is your point I do of course agree I just think it's a bad tactic/approach. Not a fan of the phrase 'race card' as it can be manipulated to disregard genuine, valid, important points so perhaps the wording around the arguments has disguised the sentiments.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 10 Feb 22 3.49pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91


I assumed the overriding sentiment pertains to the fact that Antonio may be using the Zouma offence to draw attention to his own interests which the situation does not merit and can come across as almost detracting, not defending, the animal abuse that has been perpetrated.

For me the correct response would therefore be that they could both be considered cowardly crimes however comparing one to another is neither here nor there in answering the original question regarding the animal abuse.

If someone asked me what my views on racism were, I wouldn't compare it to murder, for example. The resulting answer would neither have context to nor address the original question asides from creating a new debate around an imaginary moral barometer for crime. I therefore understand why it could be misconstrued as someone wishing to draw attention to their own vested interests which would by proxy distract from the point at hand.

It could well be the case, or said, that Antonio's point was to draw attention to the scale of the reaction to it as opposed to an equally condemnable crime. If I understand correctly that this is your point I do of course agree I just think it's a bad tactic/approach. Not a fan of the phrase 'race card' as it can be manipulated to disregard genuine, valid, important points so perhaps the wording around the arguments has disguised the sentiments.

Sure, but then I'd also ask what purpose a question like 'what do you think about animal abuse' serves anyway - no one is going to sit there and say 'I think it's great'. So the only real topic to discuss is what an appropriate punishment looks like, which is what I think Antonio is answering.

Fair enough you think it's a bad tactic - I probably agree, but can't agree it's 'using the race card' or 'diluting actual instances of racism' which were the bits I contested.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Feb 22 4.24pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Sure, but then I'd also ask what purpose a question like 'what do you think about animal abuse' serves anyway - no one is going to sit there and say 'I think it's great'. So the only real topic to discuss is what an appropriate punishment looks like, which is what I think Antonio is answering.

Fair enough you think it's a bad tactic - I probably agree, but can't agree it's 'using the race card' or 'diluting actual instances of racism' which were the bits I contested.

1. Exectly, this is why people/businesses hire PR professionals, it's a mundane question which does not provoke or seek to illicit an answer that is going to be remotely interesting, relative,
informative or helpful.

2. Perhaps I disagree with you on this one. Not saying Antonio is in the wrong, and noting I have already addressed my opinions on the usage of the phrase 'race card', I still would suggest that again whilst Antonio is making a perfectly valid point, the interpretation of what he has said or the motives for it, in the eyes of some, could be a reflection of the larger conversation around the approach to the battle against racism on a societal scale. I feel as though it can sometimes fall into the massively unhelpful domain of tedious white noise and rhetoric which could again possibly be considered to detract from more tangible solutions and the addressing of the problem, or other problems (animal abuse). The sentiment could therefore quite easily be interpreted as 'nothing else matters (animal abuse) asides from this which I feel obliged to constantly make noise about as it concerns me and not other beings and I will use every opportunity including the raising of other concerns to turn the focus back to my grievances (as they are more important)'.

Again, using my previous analogy, it could be the equivalent of:

Q. Do you think the serial rapist should be put to death?
A: Do you think my wife's murderer should be put to death? Because he wasn't! (Good opportunity for humour here but will keep it formal for now)

It could easily come across as 'I don't care about a serial rapist, he didn't kill anyone, or anyone I know, let's talk about me and my situation'.

Just an opinion BTW I am not claiming to have any answers or even be in the right here, always useful to see/listen to other perspectives.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 10 Feb 22 4.44pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

1. Exectly, this is why people/businesses hire PR professionals, it's a mundane question which does not provoke or seek to illicit an answer that is going to be remotely interesting, relative,
informative or helpful.

2. Perhaps I disagree with you on this one. Not saying Antonio is in the wrong, and noting I have already addressed my opinions on the usage of the phrase 'race card', I still would suggest that again whilst Antonio is making a perfectly valid point, the interpretation of what he has said or the motives for it, in the eyes of some, could be a reflection of the larger conversation around the approach to the battle against racism on a societal scale. I feel as though it can sometimes fall into the massively unhelpful domain of tedious white noise and rhetoric which could again possibly be considered to detract from more tangible solutions and the addressing of the problem, or other problems (animal abuse). The sentiment could therefore quite easily be interpreted as 'nothing else matters (animal abuse) asides from this which I feel obliged to constantly make noise about as it concerns me and not other beings and I will use every opportunity including the raising of other concerns to turn the focus back to my grievances (as they are more important)'.

Again, using my previous analogy, it could be the equivalent of:

Q. Do you think the serial rapist should be put to death?
A: Do you think my wife's murderer should be put to death? Because he wasn't! (Good opportunity for humour here but will keep it formal for now)

It could easily come across as 'I don't care about a serial rapist, he didn't kill anyone, or anyone I know, let's talk about me and my situation'.

Just an opinion BTW I am not claiming to have any answers or even be in the right here, always useful to see/listen to other perspectives.

Rape is an interesting analogy because the murder of someone is often treated in an 'entertaining' way (think Miss Marple, Midsomer Murders) yet imagine making dramas about a woman being raped in that manner?

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Feb 22 4.54pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

Rape is an interesting analogy because the murder of someone is often treated in an 'entertaining' way (think Miss Marple, Midsomer Murders) yet imagine making dramas about a woman being raped in that manner?

Thanks now I am just imaging Miss Marple being the victim of a sexual crime.

I wouldn't read to much into the analogy, I am no crime buff I for some reason just went to the far end of the scale which was the most deplorable crimes. There is at least another one of course but I consider it too distasteful to even write about it, especially in this context.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

beak Flag croydon 10 Feb 22 4.56pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

This is the pits. The use of the race card when debating violence against a dumb animal:

[Link]

It is lucky for Antonio that he plays football as he cannot fathom a complicated issue like right and wrong, it is wrong to mistreat a pet that you are meant to care for,no racial issues are involved.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 10 Feb 22 5.38pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

1. Exectly, this is why people/businesses hire PR professionals, it's a mundane question which does not provoke or seek to illicit an answer that is going to be remotely interesting, relative,
informative or helpful.

2. Perhaps I disagree with you on this one. Not saying Antonio is in the wrong, and noting I have already addressed my opinions on the usage of the phrase 'race card', I still would suggest that again whilst Antonio is making a perfectly valid point, the interpretation of what he has said or the motives for it, in the eyes of some, could be a reflection of the larger conversation around the approach to the battle against racism on a societal scale. I feel as though it can sometimes fall into the massively unhelpful domain of tedious white noise and rhetoric which could again possibly be considered to detract from more tangible solutions and the addressing of the problem, or other problems (animal abuse). The sentiment could therefore quite easily be interpreted as 'nothing else matters (animal abuse) asides from this which I feel obliged to constantly make noise about as it concerns me and not other beings and I will use every opportunity including the raising of other concerns to turn the focus back to my grievances (as they are more important)'.

Again, using my previous analogy, it could be the equivalent of:

Q. Do you think the serial rapist should be put to death?
A: Do you think my wife's murderer should be put to death? Because he wasn't! (Good opportunity for humour here but will keep it formal for now)

It could easily come across as 'I don't care about a serial rapist, he didn't kill anyone, or anyone I know, let's talk about me and my situation'.

Just an opinion BTW I am not claiming to have any answers or even be in the right here, always useful to see/listen to other perspectives.

Fair enough - it's an interesting take.

I interpreted his comments as 'lets put some perspective on what he's done' rather than not caring - he said he thought it was wrong within his first few sentences.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Zouma and the cat,,,,was it a criminal act?