You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Leaders in our playing group
November 16 2026 3.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Leaders in our playing group


viveasheagle Flag perth 27 May 22 3.39pm

I think in the Parrish era we have been fortunate to have a good spread of leaders in our squad. The likes of Delaney and Jedinak spring to mind and in our current group i feel the likes of McCarthur, Ward, Hughes & Milivojevic are some of the people who set the standards the group need to play to, possibly with the likes of Ayew and Zaha as well.
Problem i think we need to be aware of is as we strive to bring in younger players we needs some leaders in the people we recruit. I think the Guehi signing was particularly good in this respect but i am not putting Olise and Mateta in this catogary yet.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 29 May 22 6.11am

Originally posted by viveasheagle

I think in the Parrish era we have been fortunate to have a good spread of leaders in our squad. The likes of Delaney and Jedinak spring to mind and in our current group i feel the likes of McCarthur, Ward, Hughes & Milivojevic are some of the people who set the standards the group need to play to, possibly with the likes of Ayew and Zaha as well.
Problem i think we need to be aware of is as we strive to bring in younger players we needs some leaders in the people we recruit. I think the Guehi signing was particularly good in this respect but i am not putting Olise and Mateta in this catogary yet.

Guehi reminds me of Southgate in that he appears to have an old head on young shoulders. If we manage to hold onto him he could end up our captain for a very long time.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 May 22 6.34am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Guehi reminds me of Southgate in that he appears to have an old head on young shoulders. If we manage to hold onto him he could end up our captain for a very long time.

If McGuire was 80 million this chap is treble figures.
I’d take that if offered

 

sprites Flag Auckland 29 May 22 8.11am

Yep, tends to be the defensive players for some reason. Certainly Ward, Andersen, Guehi, Tonks, Macca, Luka and Kouyate for me - all have good leadership ability. Perhaps that's why we defend well but don't score enough goals...

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 29 May 22 9.33am

To defend well takes discipline, a leader within the midst of the defending unit to take responsibility, organise those around them & make sure they have the commitment from those other players, so its probably not a surprise that the majority of team captains come from the centre of defence or midfield - Additionally as we have seen said on here numerous times before, a leaky defence will get you relegated.

Originally posted by sprites

Yep, tends to be the defensive players for some reason. Certainly Ward, Andersen, Guehi, Tonks, Macca, Luka and Kouyate for me - all have good leadership ability. Perhaps that's why we defend well but don't score enough goals...

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 29 May 22 12.16pm

Originally posted by cryrst

If McGuire was 80 million this chap is treble figures.
I’d take that if offered

Another season of steady improvement and he could well be that figure and I tend to agree, we would be foolish to turn down such money given what we could do with it.

 

doi209 Flag Fighting for the weak and innocent... 29 May 22 1.24pm

A captain needs to be able to see the whole game.

All players generally see what is in front of them. Defenders see more from the back and can identify issues more easily than those running towards the goal.

However there are some captains that lead by example e.g. Harry Kane

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 29 May 22 1.40pm

I’ve always been biased towards CMs being captains as I think they’re best placed. Never been a fan of GKs or Forwards being captains and see that as only ceremonial.

IMHO you need to be tactically astute, lead by example, able to communicate and of course command the respect of your teammates.

I’d be strongly inclined to believe or agree MG has all of these.

I know he came from the rent boys, but he was somewhat unknown before us. I’d love to believe he sees Palace at home now and whilst he may deservedly have greater expectations I’d like to see what he can achieve here first and I think could very well do so as captain.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Uphill Flag Bedford 30 May 22 3.35pm

It beats me why Luka is mentioned as a good leader.

McArthur and Ward much better and both around to calm Zaha down
whereas Luka was never there.

Not only that but just seen a re-run of the Palace home match against Villa and his passing was awful and gave the ball away too often. Will be glad when he seeks pastures new ...

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 30 May 22 4.09pm

I think there is a wider variety of `styles` of captains than there used to be.

The likes of Keane and Pearce were fearsome in your face captains. I wouldn't have argued with them. However I think the game and attitudes have matured a bit and there is a generation of more `molly cuddling` captains. It's the same for managers now too. I think the likes of MG fit into this more modern iteration of a captain.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 30 May 22 10.40pm

Originally posted by Uphill

It beats me why Luka is mentioned as a good leader.

McArthur and Ward much better and both around to calm Zaha down
whereas Luka was never there.

Not only that but just seen a re-run of the Palace home match against Villa and his passing was awful and gave the ball away too often. Will be glad when he seeks pastures new ...

Because numerous players have come out and said he is, explaining how he communicates and drives everyone forward. Luka actually has come to Zaha's aid multiple times...but I realise it's fashionable to suggest otherwise.

Anyway, he's not the future. That's obvious. Guehi for captain.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 31 May 22 2.55am

I like the observation by doi209 about been able to "see the whole game". People like McCarthur in my opinion have this vision and so when they see say Zaha or Eze are not tracking back to cover the full backs they can have a word while still been able to concentrate on their own job. Similarly when defending set pieces there is someone who notices there is an unmarked player in the box that needs picking up. You need these type of players and i think Palace need to take this into account when recruiting. You look at teams like Watford who despite Roy's organisation skills were still leaking goals.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 May 22 7.14am

Guehi has a calm and commanding demeanour, on the pitch and in interview. He seems a natural choice as captain.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 May 22 10.25am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Guehi has a calm and commanding demeanour, on the pitch and in interview. He seems a natural choice as captain.


And he goes about his captaincy work on the field well. Any incident and you see him having a quiet word with the ref, making his point in support of our player calmly and you see the ref actually listening to what he's saying rather than urging him to go away.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 May 22 3.22pm

As others have said, most successful teams have half a dozen 'captains', and our best teams were no exception. Some of the interviews with the 1990 side are revealing in that respect. Wright, Bright, Thomas and Gray were very different characters, but they wanted the same thing very, very much, and wouldn't let a single teammate (including each other) off the hook if they were not producing. If that meant a changing room row, or even a fight, so be it.

I remember one game at Selhurst in the early 1990s, when Lee Sinnott (bless him) had been beaten by the opposition winger for the second time. Unfortunately for Sinnott, a three second lull in the noise from the stands coincided with the receipt of some 'constructive feedback' from Eric Young, who bellowed 'HOW MANY MORE f***ING TIMES SINNOTT?!!!' so loud that it echoed inside the main stand roof! 'Sinnott' not even 'Lee'. Poor sod.

I shudder to think what Wright would have said (and possibly done) to Benteke at times if they'd played together, or what Thorn and Young would've made of Van Aanholt pulling out of challenges, or what Thomas would've felt about Yohan '70 minutes at a push' Cabeye, especially given the wages the modern lot were taking home.

That's the main thing for me - leaders hold themselves to very high standards, and then forcibly hold others to them too. It's not always pleasant to experience, and it must be managed carefully, but it is potentially the most valuable asset a team has.

Based on the impression we get from watching him play (as opposed to knowing him personally) Guehi could be a pretty good choice for captain, but for me, he needs to get better at the day job first. He is very young for his position, seems to have a good attitude to his trade and the club, and is an asset. At the same time, he has just completed his first season of top-flight football and has been found wanting on a number of occasions, especially when facing crosses into his zone. How can he hold others to high standards when he has yet to attain them himself?

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Leaders in our playing group