You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rules is rules aren't they?
November 16 2026 3.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rules is rules aren't they?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 02 Oct 22 8.55am

Why is there any debate about yesterday's handball incident? Surely the ruling should leave no doubt either way. If a rule is open to interpretation, you will get controversy.

I'd have thought the rule book there to provide clear instructions for any given incident.

FWIW I'm not an expert on the rules myself

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

becky Flag over the moon 02 Oct 22 9.39am

There is no doubt it was a straight red offence - Alan Shearer said so in his first comment on the incident on MOTD last night

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Teddy Eagle Flag 02 Oct 22 9.42am

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

Why is there any debate about yesterday's handball incident? Surely the ruling should leave no doubt either way. If a rule is open to interpretation, you will get controversy.

I'd have thought the rule book there to provide clear instructions for any given incident.

FWIW I'm not an expert on the rules myself

There are a few rules which can be differently interpreted - active/non-active players, interfering with play, non-goalscoring body parts at offsides, obstruction, hand to ball or ball to hand, shirtsleeve handball, what constitutes a clear scoring opportunity, how much extra time should be played, etc.
Trying to avoid paranoia it's notable how some clubs seem to get the benefit of the doubt.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 02 Oct 22 3.15pm

Every rule seems to become more of a grey area the lower the club's annual income is. It's relatively black and white for the top six, foul against yellow card, foul committed, play on - blatant one look at again, say little. Blatant one against red card, penalty, ban.
Surely all written in the rules with PGMOL?

 


Red and Blue Army!

Croydon-Trucker Flag 02 Oct 22 3.57pm

I thought the rule was a deliberate hand ball was a red card no matter where on the pitch it was . Did it change ?

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 02 Oct 22 5.57pm

rules ARE rules UNLESS you play for Chelsea, Arsenal, Man City, Man U or Liverpool!

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 02 Oct 22 5.58pm

Its been quite obvious since VAR was brought in that the first thing it does is check the club badge .

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 02 Oct 22 6.01pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Its been quite obvious since VAR was brought in that the first thing it does is check the club badge .

I’m sure we’re all in no doubt, if Wardy or Guehi had done that at the other end, the red card would’ve been out in a flash

 

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 02 Oct 22 6.05pm

to be fair now I have calmed down a bit, its the goal scoring opportunity bit, think a bit further up the pitch it would have been a red, think silva with his experience expected to only get yellow.....

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

TheBigToePunt Flag 03 Oct 22 1.17pm

It wasn't a straight red.

Whether handball or a foul, the offence must deny a clear goalscoring opportunity for a red to be issued. Ayew and Silva were too far from goal for that to be the case.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 03 Oct 22 1.37pm

I would have gone more down the line of the fact that he handled the ball twice. Or that he fouled Ayew and then handled the ball just in case the referee played advantage.
I think it should have been a red card as it was fact-he was the last defender.
You cannot say whether Ayew would have scored or not but he sure deserved the opportunity to do so.
Didn't mean we would have won the game but Chelsea would have worked harder to hang on!
Cheating deserves to be punished!

 

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 03 Oct 22 1.48pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

It wasn't a straight red.

Whether handball or a foul, the offence must deny a clear goalscoring opportunity for a red to be issued. Ayew and Silva were too far from goal for that to be the case.

The problem is you'll see a similar foul given as a red at some point this season. And my bet would be it will be a player for a non 'big six' side.

Consistency is what we should all expect but rarely do we see it.

For what it's worth can anyone remember the back pass from Craig Dawson to Fabianski last season when we were chasing an equaliser against West Ham and it got waved away? Ward's was a lot less obvious on Saturday yet it was given straight away against us.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 03 Oct 22 6.12pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Every rule seems to become more of a grey area the lower the club's annual income is. It's relatively black and white for the top six, foul against yellow card, foul committed, play on - blatant one look at again, say little. Blatant one against red card, penalty, ban.
Surely all written in the rules with PGMOL?

Are Spurs in the top 6?

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 03 Oct 22 7.15pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

It wasn't a straight red.

Whether handball or a foul, the offence must deny a clear goalscoring opportunity for a red to be issued. Ayew and Silva were too far from goal for that to be the case.

if Wilf v City last season was DOGSO than Ayew's one definitely was. We were absolutely f***ed.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Oct 22 7.28pm

Originally posted by becky

There is no doubt it was a straight red offence - Alan Shearer said so in his first comment on the incident on MOTD last night

So we will Palace get an apology like Newcastle did? Don’t hold your breath.
Maybe I am being paranoid but with Parish forever winding up the authorities I do worry that there is a vendetta to manufacture our relegation

 

West Stand Flag Dorchester 03 Oct 22 9.47pm

The problem with the likes of Shearer he actually doesn’t know the laws as they are today nor importantly how the refs are directed to interpret them
Some years ago the international board added the word obvious to the bit about denying a goal opportunity and it’s the bit Gallagher talked about as to why he thought a yellow was correct and to be honest so do I

It was a significant distance from goal
The ball wasn’t travelling in the direction of the goal
There were several defenders close by which added to the subjectivity

For a handball to be given it has to in most circumstances be deliberate so he ain’t gonna get sent off for that(A handball doesn’t have to be deliberate if it immediately leads to another player scoring)
Getting two yellows could happen in the same phase of play but not for two non technical offences
VAR wasn’t any fall back because there really wasn’t a clear and obvious mistake by the on field official.


 

West Stand Flag Dorchester 03 Oct 22 9.48pm

Originally posted by West Stand

The problem with the likes of Shearer he actually doesn’t know the laws as they are today nor importantly how the refs are directed to interpret them
Some years ago the international board added the word obvious to the bit about denying a goal opportunity and it’s the bit Gallagher talked about as to why he thought a yellow was correct and to be honest so do I

It was a significant distance from goal
The ball wasn’t travelling in the direction of the goal
There were several defenders close by which added to the subjectivity

For a handball to be given it has to in most circumstances be deliberate so he ain’t gonna get sent off for that(A handball doesn’t have to be deliberate if it immediately leads to another player scoring)
Getting two yellows could happen in the same phase of play but not for two non technical offences
VAR wasn’t any fall back because there really wasn’t a clear and obvious mistake by the on field official.


 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 04 Oct 22 1.51am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

It wasn't a straight red.

Whether handball or a foul, the offence must deny a clear goalscoring opportunity for a red to be issued. Ayew and Silva were too far from goal for that to be the case.

Nonsense, when silva goes down, if he doesn't hand ball it, it's one on one with the keeper and the striker can either take a shot... score a worldie, or take on the keeper, draw him out etc, there was no evidence to suggest he be caught up in that moment...

 


This was once a quality forum....

West Stand Flag Dorchester 04 Oct 22 7.54am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Nonsense, when silva goes down, if he doesn't hand ball it, it's one on one with the keeper and the striker can either take a shot... score a worldie, or take on the keeper, draw him out etc, there was no evidence to suggest he be caught up in that moment...


As I pointed out it has to be a clear goal scoring opportunity the difference it has to be a clear not just an opportunity. The direction of the ball was away from goal and the argument would be that Chelsea had players in a position to cover. Chillwell for instance .

For me the subjective nature of the offence makes it the sort of call that you need to really drill down to what refs are told to factor in and distance alone from goal puts a big question mark into the equation but when you then factor in the direction the ball takes those two alone raise two big questions and unless the ref is 100% sure they simply won’t send a player off


 

southnorwoodhill Flag 04 Oct 22 7.58am

Originally posted by West Stand


As I pointed out it has to be a clear goal scoring opportunity the difference it has to be a clear not just an opportunity. The direction of the ball was away from goal and the argument would be that Chelsea had players in a position to cover. Chillwell for instance .

For me the subjective nature of the offence makes it the sort of call that you need to really drill down to what refs are told to factor in and distance alone from goal puts a big question mark into the equation but when you then factor in the direction the ball takes those two alone raise two big questions and unless the ref is 100% sure they simply won’t send a player off


As many fans have noticed, it also depends on which team the offender plays for.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rules is rules aren't they?