You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What's so badly wrong and what has to change?
November 16 2026 3.16am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What's so badly wrong and what has to change?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 07 Jan 23 3.51pm

I'm struggling to see any positives atm and would be inclined to ridicule any suggestion that 'all is fine/nothing's wrong'. Last year was a fantastic time to be a Palace fan and this season seems back to the very familiar feeling of being an awful one - a false dawn. Last season was the first ever time I felt as though I supported a 'steady, established' PL side.

Usually, there are several groups by my reckoning who bear the brunt of ire when things are in such a 2&8 but I'll concentrate on the following:

- The players
- The manager/coaching staff
- The Board

IMHO, I would suggest the following:

The players - Seems to be a real lack of fight and passion in the squad as things stand. Team also looks to be based around a few individuals with a lot of makeweights/squad fillers merely completing numbers. Cannot identify any leadership amongst them or a recognised, undisputed starting XI. Lightweight, boyish and often not good enough.

The manager - Was given a lot of new 'talent' (according to some anyway) however inherited an at least somewhat dogged and well-drilled Hodgson side. I am inclined to believe the combination of the aforementioned, plus his own 'brand' of football, inspired surely by the likes of Guardiola, looked very promising to begin with. This season however, it would seem as though any real substance is beginning to fade away. A cacophony of factors from underinvestment in the starting XI, lack of ability to galvanise team, loyalty to underperforming/not good enough players, bizarre substitutions, insistence on playing a particular way with players not able to do so (FdB anyone?) and poor tactical decisions seem to be costing us.

The Board - Seems to be a lot of PR which comes across as a smokescreen and attempted distraction from reality. Stadium not yet done although doesn't bother me as things stand, a squad only half regenerated (after desperately needing it) with no further investment on the horizon and a history of reactionary and occasionally poorly judged spending keeping us in a very similar position perennially.

In essence, for me, it is:

Lack of shrewd investment in playing staff and funds in general > Manager who needs this investment at the very least although my still fall short > A team short in first XI but depth too. Uninspired and unmotivated with a cast of older players well past their best (which may have been short anyway) and younger players who need real substance to support their style but mostly living off 'perceived potential' as opposed to current ability.

I'd love to shout 'off with PV/OR's heads' however I think we need further playing staff and time before making that call unless we already know we don't/won't have that. I am strongly suspicious this absolutely farcical shyte will continue for a while before PV is gone, probably some others with him, and we revert to type with a Pulis/Allardyce/Hodgson type coming in because as depressing as it sounds, that may be, once again short-term, what is needed for any chance.

Be interested for any other thoughts...

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 07 Jan 23 4.11pm

I agree !

Walking off the pitch everyone looked lost - looking into space like no one has a plan or idea what is going on

Current squad just has no passion no speed no drive but that “arrive in style” if you see CPFC Instagram site

We have hard games coming up - will be interesting

 


Forever Palace Proud

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 07 Jan 23 4.19pm

Originally posted by waddy

I agree !

Walking off the pitch everyone looked lost - looking into space like no one has a plan or idea what is going on

Current squad just has no passion no speed no drive but that “arrive in style” if you see CPFC Instagram site

We have hard games coming up - will be interesting

I have seen it Waddy, sick of seeing it, don't give a flying to be quite honest.

Interestingly all of my CPFC posts disappeared quite quickly after full time and all had about 5 million similar comment son them. Even stranger considering I only follow two people - CPFC and my tattoo artist who's insistence I get Instagram to communicate with him (about my tattoos) is the only reason I have it!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Vectis Flag 07 Jan 23 4.20pm

I think one of the most disappointing facts disclosed in the last few days was the data shown by Sky during the Tottenham game regarding the average total distance run by the players in each match. Now admittedly running around pointlessly is no good either, but it does give an indication of player fitness and/or effort being put in. Where are Palace this season? Bottom - 20th place!

Palace supporters have always been tolerant of players who may lack technical ability, but clearly put in 100% effort every minute of the game. Not sure we have too many prepared to do that at the moment. Or is it they are not fit enough compared to other teams?

It certainly doesn’t help when certain players lose the ball and then casually jog back. Think of how Morocco over-performed in the World Cup. Everyone putting in maximum effort all the time. The same probably true of league teams like Brentford. With the massive wages being paid not giving 100% all the time is just not acceptable. I cannot imagine the likes of Sammy Lee when he was assistant manager standing back and allowing it. Verbal rockets would have been firing off to any culprits to get their backsides into gear sharpish!

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 07 Jan 23 4.25pm

Too slow and predictable with the ball. Lazy without it. Same formation every week, and no bite in midfield. When we do win the ball in the middle we roll it backwards. That's why we cannot play against teams that sit in and play on the break - Forest, Fulham, Spurs and Southampton. We are so slow with the ball the opposition always have 10 men behind the ball.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 07 Jan 23 4.26pm

Originally posted by Vectis

I think one of the most disappointing facts disclosed in the last few days was the data shown by Sky during the Tottenham game regarding the average total distance run by the players in each match. Now admittedly running around pointlessly is no good either, but it does give an indication of player fitness and/or effort being put in. Where are Palace this season? Bottom - 20th place!

Palace supporters have always been tolerant of players who may lack technical ability, but clearly put in 100% effort every minute of the game. Not sure we have too many prepared to do that at the moment. Or is it they are not fit enough compared to other teams?

It certainly doesn’t help when certain players lose the ball and then casually jog back. Think of how Morocco over-performed in the World Cup. Everyone putting in maximum effort all the time. The same probably true of league teams like Brentford. With the massive wages being paid not giving 100% all the time is just not acceptable. I cannot imagine the likes of Sammy Lee when he was assistant manager standing back and allowing it. Verbal rockets would have been firing off to any culprits to get their backsides into gear sharpish!

Absolutely Vectis.

Again, where does that lie however? Manager/coaching staff or players? Probably both actually I'd imagine.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

MR100% Flag 07 Jan 23 4.32pm

Manger has to take a lot of blame, midfield set up changes all the time,as does the forward line.

No Jedinak /old Luca/KG/Ray Houghton/Geof Thomas etc to berate anyone who lets their heads drop

Find us a proper midfield captain

 

beak Flag croydon 07 Jan 23 4.37pm

Originally posted by MR100%

Manger has to take a lot of blame, midfield set up changes all the time,as does the forward line.

No Jedinak /old Luca/KG/Ray Houghton/Geof Thomas etc to berate anyone who lets their heads drop

Find us a proper midfield captain

I've found him ! He is in the physio room,a chap called McArthur, must be a general methinks.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 07 Jan 23 4.50pm

We dont have a manager or assistant, just a couple of blokes standing at the side of the pitch, in a state of bewilderment,
The Sweet got it right, Lyrics below

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 07 Jan 23 4.50pm

The transition to ball retaining attacking team doesn't work unless your scouting is great and you throw serious money at it.

IMO only three of the outfield players are true Premier League level - the two centre backs (albeit the modern ball playing type rather than penalty box players) and Zaha.

Edouard and Doucoure look really poor value for money and Eze and Olise can't be trusted as they only turn up every six or seven games.

The rest speak for themselves - mainly past it journeymen.

We have no height, pace or ability to go through the gears and raise the tempo so Vieira doesn't have the tools for plan B even if he had one.

The painful passing around at the back and lack of quality in midfield is pitiful. We've got ourselves into an absolute muddle and mess top to bottom.


Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (07 Jan 2023 5.16pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 07 Jan 23 5.33pm

The accepted wisdom before the enforced World Cup break was,
1) Palace would be beneficiaries having only 2 players at the World Cup so we should have fresh players post World Cup
2) Since we had a split training camp pre season the World Cup break would enable us to work on our collective team approach and fine tune our tactics
3) The break could also enable us to have more time to work on transfer targets for the January window .

From what I have observed, although to be fair it’s early days, we have not come back post World Cup in better shape.
We appear lethargic, lacking intent and apparently have the worst running stats in the Premier League.
Without wishing to go ‘all Roy Keane’ the players seem to lack desire and competitive spirit.
It’s fine having eye catching skill like Olise and Eze but you won’t get anywhere without the desire of a McArthur or Kouyate and these are the type of players we are sadly missing.
Vieira himself was a warrior in his playing days and must be concerned by the shortcomings in our approach.
Some will say he is at fault for not instilling this into our team, but part of me wonder if the players just don’t have it in their make up.

 

Vectis Flag 07 Jan 23 5.55pm

I think a major aspect of Vieira’s managerial struggles is that as a player he was always in top sides and surrounded by other top quality players. His vision for how the game should be played is great, but he cannot seem to adapt it to take account of the shortcomings of the players actually at his disposal. Most of them probably can’t do what he wants them to. Unlike say Pulis, Allardyce and Hodgson who were all used to relegation battles and compromising ‘style’ for efficiency in grinding out results

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 07 Jan 23 6.05pm

Agree with the posts above. I'd just like to say that our best manager during these past 10 seasons is for me Tony Pulis. Yeah, he's a bit of a cnut, but he inherited an average side and got 25% more out of them every game. Compare that set of players to this current bunch of unmotivated, comfort zone, gravy train riders and it becomes apparent that Vieira has a lot to answer for. The ground covered stat is completely damning and says a lot about training, the attitude of the players, and Vieira's inability to motivate them.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (07 Jan 2023 6.08pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jan 23 6.17pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Agree with the posts above. I'd just like to say that our best manager during these past 10 seasons is for me Tony Pulis. Yeah, he's a bit of a cnut, but he inherited an average side and got 25% more out of them every game. Compare that set of players to this current bunch of unmotivated, comfort zone, gravy train riders and it becomes apparent that Vieira has a lot to answer for. The ground covered stat is completely damning and says a lot about training, the attitude of the players, and Vieira's inability to motivate them.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (07 Jan 2023 6.08pm)

I have already articulated the short-comings in the squad.I am not holding a 'Vieira Out' banner at this juncture, however it appears that the animus towards PV is ever increasing amongst our supporters and there were loud rumblings of discontent after the game.

Maybe after more careful consideration and assessment, and results, I might conclude that in the interests of CPFC the manager should be shown the door.

Edited by Willo (07 Jan 2023 6.18pm)

 

NE14T Flag 07 Jan 23 6.18pm

PV is just too laid back for this at best average squad who need a rocket up their arses. Fitness, match effort and simple passing weight and accuracy all need to improve. Osian Roberts should be championing this but he looks like a shrinking violet and ‘yes’ man who probably finds it difficult to preach fitness and hard work.

Ward and Clyne are massive liabilities in most games they play and should be immediately put out to pasture. A loan player at right back must be first priority. PV also needs to stick with the Hughes, Doucoure partnership. I thought they were the only good thing today.

Of course a striker needs to be a close 2nd priority.

Edited by NE14T (07 Jan 2023 6.21pm)

Edited by NE14T (07 Jan 2023 6.26pm)

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jan 23 7.11pm

Every club goes through a 'Dip', our issue is that our loss of form has resulted in abject defeats to 2 promoted teams, a defeat to a bottom of the table team,3 home defeats in succession and when this is followed by a run of really challenging games this is a real cause for concern.

Our overall play has been deeply disappointing offensively and defensively and if this continues and we suffer a run of defeats which plummet us down the table into the relegation zone, I suspect the supporters calls for the removal of PV will be answered.

 

Jacey Flag 07 Jan 23 7.38pm

Originally posted by Willo

Every club goes through a 'Dip', our issue is that our loss of form has resulted in abject defeats to 2 promoted teams, a defeat to a bottom of the table team,3 home defeats in succession and when this is followed by a run of really challenging games this is a real cause for concern.

Our overall play has been deeply disappointing offensively and defensively and if this continues and we suffer a run of defeats which plummet us down the table into the relegation zone, I suspect the supporters calls for the removal of PV will be answered.

Thoroughly agree,Willo .We seem to be going downhill faster than Eddie the Eagle ever achieved!!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 07 Jan 23 7.48pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Thoroughly agree,Willo .We seem to be going downhill faster than Eddie the Eagle ever achieved!!

Coming in on loan allegedly.

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 07 Jan 23 8.18pm

Originally posted by Willo

Every club goes through a 'Dip', our issue is that our loss of form has resulted in abject defeats to 2 promoted teams, a defeat to a bottom of the table team,3 home defeats in succession and when this is followed by a run of really challenging games this is a real cause for concern.

Our overall play has been deeply disappointing offensively and defensively and if this continues and we suffer a run of defeats which plummet us down the table into the relegation zone, I suspect the supporters calls for the removal of PV will be answered.

Fairest assessment so far.
Not enough has been made of the lack of signings to boost the squad. It is common knowledge that Vieira is frustrated at the lack of financial support in his second season after Gallagher returned to Chelsea.

Heads up though. There are other teams in the division who look ropey. Saints were just less poor than us today and Guaita had a howler.
I don't like the idea of pulling the plug on the Vieira reign coming up to a tough run when we are quite far clear of relegation with a game in hand. Clearly this view will be seen as 'clueless' by certain persons on here, a word I don't like being associated with Vieira.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Elpis Flag In a pub 07 Jan 23 8.35pm

Originally posted by EaglesEaglesEagles

Fairest assessment so far.
Not enough has been made of the lack of signings to boost the squad. It is common knowledge that Vieira is frustrated at the lack of financial support in his second season after Gallagher returned to Chelsea.

Heads up though. There are other teams in the division who look ropey. Saints were just less poor than us today and Guaita had a howler.
I don't like the idea of pulling the plug on the Vieira reign coming up to a tough run when we are quite far clear of relegation with a game in hand. Clearly this view will be seen as 'clueless' by certain persons on here, a word I don't like being associated with Vieira.

I would agree .
I think whoever was in charge of contracts /buying players messed up big time last summer when not enough quaility replacements were brought in for those we lost especially in midfield where we are a poor immitation of past seasons .

The weak midfield has left our non tackeling defence exposed and put a burden on our 'flair' players they niether want not are capeable of .
As I have alluded elsewhere we may be just a couple of players short in the middle of the park that solves the current depression

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What's so badly wrong and what has to change?