You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace and the lingering threat of a Super League
November 16 2026 3.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace and the lingering threat of a Super League


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 20 Feb 23 5.51pm

One day, the big clubs will try to get a bigger slice of the PL money pie. Let's call their vision a super league that excludes clubs like Palace.

This is a huge problem. If we spend £100m on tarting up the Main Stand, and suddenly we get shunted back down the food chain, we are f***ed and our owners take an enormous financial hit.

How can we really invest when the gravy train might depart from platform 9 without us at any given moment?

Even if we do spend, we only get about 34k. We're still a small club with major impediments to growth.

People talk about investors who're willing to spend but it's just good money after bad.

It's a catch 22.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Feb 23 6.36pm

Other teams have had investment, notably Forest and Bournemouth. Historically Forest are pretty big, yet Bournemouth really aren't. Also no better stadium etc. Other teams have invested too or have recently got investors.
Really the question is: why not us?
Some kind of structural issue/ the board/ something in the ownership or share structure?
The other thing, I believe, rarely spoken about: is it share holder and bank debt? Surely other teams have similar? We are considerably in debt which we do service.
What else? Don't know.

 


Red and Blue Army!

YT Flag Oxford 20 Feb 23 7.53pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Other teams have had investment, notably Forest and Bournemouth. Historically Forest are pretty big, yet Bournemouth really aren't. Also no better stadium etc. Other teams have invested too or have recently got investors.
Really the question is: why not us?
Some kind of structural issue/ the board/ something in the ownership or share structure?
The other thing, I believe, rarely spoken about: is it share holder and bank debt? Surely other teams have similar? We are considerably in debt which we do service.
What else? Don't know.

Bournemouth have invested you say but also you say that they have no better stadium. What therefore have they invested in?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Feb 23 8.20pm

Originally posted by YT

Bournemouth have invested you say but also you say that they have no better stadium. What therefore have they invested in?

I'm not sure what's been promised but they certainly were willing to pay for transfers. A new owner isn't it? So they could be bought, or invested in but they're no bigger or better than us are they?

 


Red and Blue Army!

Elpis Flag In a pub 20 Feb 23 8.29pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

One day, the big clubs will try to get a bigger slice of the PL money pie. Let's call their vision a super league that excludes clubs like Palace.

This is a huge problem. If we spend £100m on tarting up the Main Stand, and suddenly we get shunted back down the food chain, we are f***ed and our owners take an enormous financial hit.

How can we really invest when the gravy train might depart from platform 9 without us at any given moment?

Even if we do spend, we only get about 34k. We're still a small club with major impediments to growth.

People talk about investors who're willing to spend but it's just good money after bad.

It's a catch 22.

Like an F1 racecar you need to be on the right tyres for the conditions . Being on the right tyres in the PL means investing in your team to keep them in the race even if your driving a Williams .
What might happen in the future is of little consequence

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 20 Feb 23 9.00pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

One day, the big clubs will try to get a bigger slice of the PL money pie. Let's call their vision a super league that excludes clubs like Palace.

This is a huge problem. If we spend £100m on tarting up the Main Stand, and suddenly we get shunted back down the food chain, we are f***ed and our owners take an enormous financial hit.

How can we really invest when the gravy train might depart from platform 9 without us at any given moment?

Even if we do spend, we only get about 34k. We're still a small club with major impediments to growth.

People talk about investors who're willing to spend but it's just good money after bad.

It's a catch 22.

This has been my take on things for a while and the reason why the likes of Harris and Blitzer have been linked with buying Chelsea, Liverpool and United.

Eventually there will be so much wealth and power behind it that it will be impossible to stop IMO.

There's no next level for us which is also why I think there's such a shift towards young players with sell on value and the academy.


 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 21 Feb 23 6.46am

I should clarify that the investment I refer to is the stadium.

We can, to a point, invest in players. But if all else is equal, then over time a stadium's ability to generate revenue is the main differentiator between one club and the next.

As a revenue generator, Selhurst must be second bottom (to Bournemouth) or possibly third bottom (also Brentford) in the division.

I appreciate Brentford is far smaller but I'm guessing it has good corporate as recently built.

That creates a long term gravitational pull.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Feb 23 7.37am

Maybe 10 years ago the size of the stadium seating capacity / bums on seats was super important, these days the league you play in & the TV money it generates is more the pot of gold that everyone is chasing (in relation to Palace) because it dwarfs stadium revenue at the top end of the game, if your in the PL & you can add a European competition to your seasons activities then so much the better / increased TV money - this all helps with your global brand / merchandising sales - so if / when Super league comes there will be an increase in TV / overall revenue for those directly involved, probably a reduced TV money for those left behind (like us) & then the stadium capacity will become important to us again because we will be on that lower tier -

Pretty much every PL club has sell out season ticket sales every season these days - whether that will remain to be the case when Super league comes your guess is as good as mine, most clubs left behind will be trading the games against the top 7 PL sides for more competitive & probably more exciting fixtures against teams they have more chance of a result against -

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I should clarify that the investment I refer to is the stadium.

We can, to a point, invest in players. But if all else is equal, then over time a stadium's ability to generate revenue is the main differentiator between one club and the next.

As a revenue generator, Selhurst must be second bottom (to Bournemouth) or possibly third bottom (also Brentford) in the division.

I appreciate Brentford is far smaller but I'm guessing it has good corporate as recently built.

That creates a long term gravitational pull.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Feb 23 8.44am

There's no chance of this happening in the near future. The competitiveness of the premier league is a major selling point, the big English clubs ain't worried about us, we are miles behind. Its the other big European clubs, which the gulf just continues to get greater and greater. They need a European super league just to have any real chance of competing with the prem. UEFA will end up awarding 6 places in the champions league to the English clubs. Which will suit the big 6.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Feb 23 10.58am

You may be right - I dont follow the champions league but I did see a few articles several weeks ago talking about an increased number of clubs participating in the European Cup(s) Whether thats CL or the Europa thingy ( or whatever variations are in play these days)

Originally posted by rikz

There's no chance of this happening in the near future. The competitiveness of the premier league is a major selling point, the big English clubs ain't worried about us, we are miles behind. Its the other big European clubs, which the gulf just continues to get greater and greater. They need a European super league just to have any real chance of competing with the prem. UEFA will end up awarding 6 places in the champions league to the English clubs. Which will suit the big 6.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Feb 23 11.14am

If a Super League were to come into existence I would expect it would have the same ramifications for all (other) clubs financially.

Personally, and hopefully without sounding too much like a moany old b@stard, I think it would separate the glory hunting, entertainment seeking fans from the 'actual' or let's say 'original' football fans. I think those who would suffer most would be those in the latter category who just happen to support a now big club.

For this reason, I think it would be a short-lived and commercially challenging prospect. By very nature of football it does rely on those who commit to it religiously even if there are still wooden seats, overpriced food and rarely goals from open play I would expect the super league to have a short lived but frantic spell before a massive fallout as most fans would continue watching their own teams within the traditional structure. If anyone questions my insight, research, general intelligence or expertise behind such comments and prophecies don't bother, you won't find much if anything

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 21 Feb 23 11.28am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

If a Super League were to come into existence I would expect it would have the same ramifications for all (other) clubs financially.

Personally, and hopefully without sounding too much like a moany old b@stard, I think it would separate the glory hunting, entertainment seeking fans from the 'actual' or let's say 'original' football fans. I think those who would suffer most would be those in the latter category who just happen to support a now big club.

For this reason, I think it would be a short-lived and commercially challenging prospect. By very nature of football it does rely on those who commit to it religiously even if there are still wooden seats, overpriced food and rarely goals from open play I would expect the super league to have a short lived but frantic spell before a massive fallout as most fans would continue watching their own teams within the traditional structure. If anyone questions my insight, research, general intelligence or expertise behind such comments and prophecies don't bother, you won't find much if anything

It could be true - but I think the point of the super league is not the average fan at all. It's like they want a whole new shiny Chinese, African, American and Arab fan - paying for TV rights in a replica shirt. Us old, beardy, balding, beery fans are no longer required.
My own take is - leave them to it. I'd rather a league without all the megabucks. It would be more competitive and, frankly, I'd like to see players earning less and lower transfer fees. Our youngsters would definitely get a chance too.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Feb 23 11.43am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

It could be true - but I think the point of the super league is not the average fan at all. It's like they want a whole new shiny Chinese, African, American and Arab fan - paying for TV rights in a replica shirt. Us old, beardy, balding, beery fans are no longer required.
My own take is - leave them to it. I'd rather a league without all the megabucks. It would be more competitive and, frankly, I'd like to see players earning less and lower transfer fees. Our youngsters would definitely get a chance too.

Sorry ASCPFC but that was definitely (intended as) the general sentiment behind what I was saying.

I'd soon rather watch 'our lot' playing against 'them lot', including all their fans, in the nation's league system, dirty burgers, p!ssing down with rain et al than the Emirates Reds playing the Yank Blues with Popcorn and hog roast seat delivery service in a state of the art arena.

I'm not saying that's correct by any stretch just my preference and I'd hold no grudge against those who choose or prefer the other.

'Let them 'av their Super League'. More 'Good riddance' than 'Oh no' from me.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Feb 23 11.57am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

You may be right - I dont follow the champions league but I did see a few articles several weeks ago talking about an increased number of clubs participating in the European Cup(s) Whether thats CL or the Europa thingy ( or whatever variations are in play these days)

I'm pretty sure they're changing the champions league format next season to some shady league format with seedings that basically mean UEFA get to show more games between the big clubs early on in the competition, yet ensuring they still give the big clubs the best possible chance of qualifying for the knockout stages.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Feb 23 12.14pm

Does anyone else think that the words, shady, seedings & UEFA go very well together in the same sentence -

Originally posted by rikz

I'm pretty sure they're changing the champions league format next season to some shady league format with seedings that basically mean UEFA get to show more games between the big clubs early on in the competition, yet ensuring they still give the big clubs the best possible chance of qualifying for the knockout stages.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 21 Feb 23 12.15pm

Originally posted by rikz

I'm pretty sure they're changing the champions league format next season to some shady league format with seedings that basically mean UEFA get to show more games between the big clubs early on in the competition, yet ensuring they still give the big clubs the best possible chance of qualifying for the knockout stages.

Yes, I believe there's a full league format with the top eight to fight it out. There are going to be too many games but, hey, not my problem.

 


Red and Blue Army!

YT Flag Oxford 21 Feb 23 1.00pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Does anyone else think that the words, shady, seedings & UEFA go very well together in the same sentence -

Yes (although UEFA isn't a word )

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Isley46 Flag Sanderstead 21 Feb 23 3.18pm

Originally posted by YT
Bournemouth have invested you say but also you say that they have no better stadium. What therefore have they invested in?

Bournemouth are in the middle of building a brand new training complex on the outskirts of the town to encompass both the first team and all the academy structure - Pushing for the Academy to be at least Cat 2 and possibly even move to a Cat 1.

I drove past recently - space and available land doesn't seem to be an issue.

 

est1905 Flag 21 Feb 23 5.16pm

I think its quite pessimistic as well as actually unrealistic for anyone to think a Super League is inevitable. Yes the top 6/7 have a lot of power but collectively so do the remaining 13/14 clubs in the league. Not to mention the other 72 EFL clubs that will fight it, the fans (of ALL clubs) as well as the FA, the Premier League, UEFA, FIFA as well as governments of the world will fight against this type of selfish greed.
Of course greedy men at the top such as Levy, the Glazers, Stan Kroanke, etc will look at ways to get a bigger slice of TV money. Levy even had the nerve to tell all PL member cubs that Spurs attracts a bigger TV audience therefore should get more money recently. Yet it was the owners of Chelsea (Ken Bates, Palace (Ron Noades), & Man United (Martin Edwards) who not only thought up the idea of the Premier League but were the only club chairmen at the time to back the idea with their money. Spurs owner at the time (Irving Schollar) was actually against the idea.
People will always be greedy. Its the way of things. Greed rarely wins when there is so much opposition to it and so few will prosper from their plans.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 21 Feb 23 5.37pm

You may be right. I can be pessimistic and sometimes unrealistic too.

But my central expectation is that the big clubs are saying they make the Premier League, not the likes of Palace. And as such, in their view, should get a much bigger share of its riches.

I further expect they will act in concert to achieve this end.

In a sense though, the issue doesn't need to be its creation. The true issue, from an investing standpoint, is the very real threat that it happens.

Do you want to plow £150 million into Selhurst on that basis?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace and the lingering threat of a Super League