You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > If it ain’t broke don’t fix it
November 16 2026 3.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

If it ain’t broke don’t fix it


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
PatrickA Flag London 30 Apr 23 9.07am

I’m coming around to Roy staying on next year.
This is not a knee jerk reaction to a few good results and performances, but based on solid evidence.
As far as I can see the only reason not to extend his stay is his age.
However, this in itself is not an issue in isolation with his robust health and unbridled enthusiasm for the game.
Football is like breathing to him and I’ve heard or observed nothing from him to suggest that he wouldn’t accept another year.
In some ways it’s a no brainier for the club too.
The club want to remain in the Premier League first and foremost and retain some form of continuity with a settled staff and there’s nothing to suggest that this wouldn’t be achievable with Roy, Ray and Paddy at the helm.
I’m also at cognisant that we’re nearly in May , not far from pre season planning and decisions on players etc.
To bring in a new manager brings in the uncertainty of upheaval with him wanting his own staff and players potentially unsettling the chemistry that is successful at present and looks like it could be in the future.
Some will say keeping Roy is only postponing the inevitable as he will have to go at some point, but is that in itself sufficient reason to make a change in the summer?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 30 Apr 23 9.24am

I posted on another thread it all depends on the boards spending plans. I suspect we will have another poor transfer window as the issues for the previous ones have not been resolved.

If that is the case then Roy is a safe pair of hand.

However if the board do decide to invest then we should go for a new manager.

 


One more point

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 30 Apr 23 9.31am

This post really fits into 'Next Manager' doesn't it Patrick? But I agree there would appear to be a strong case for Mr Parish to retain the current management setup, especially with Paddy continuing to gain experience in his support role.

I also believe Ray Lewington has more influence than he gets credit for and is about 10 years younger than Roy so what's not to like about him taking over the lead role?

There's little doubt in my mind that the existing management is a far better bet than trying to mould an 'outsider' into the Palace family.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

slubglurge Flag welling 30 Apr 23 9.38am

I think giving Roy another year will give SP the perfect opportunity to not spend any money because Roy will be happy to work with a restricted budget.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 Apr 23 9.52am

Although Roy does seem to being enjoying himself and looking nice and relaxed during what is ostensibly a brief interim fill-in role I am not so certain that he is the way forward for next season and it poses the questions: What about the season after that? Where's the planning for 3 years down the line and bringing through the best of the Academy? Does Roy want to retire someday? This is not to say Roy isn't adept at his role here, he certainly knows the club and how to work successfully within the parameters set out thus far: avoid relegation / mid table / small spend.
That said, I think Parish may be tempted to offer him another year as Roy offers a safe pair of hands.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 30 Apr 23 10.17am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m coming around to Roy staying on next year.
This is not a knee jerk reaction to a few good results and performances, but based on solid evidence.
As far as I can see the only reason not to extend his stay is his age.
However, this in itself is not an issue in isolation with his robust health and unbridled enthusiasm for the game.
Football is like breathing to him and I’ve heard or observed nothing from him to suggest that he wouldn’t accept another year.
In some ways it’s a no brainier for the club too.
The club want to remain in the Premier League first and foremost and retain some form of continuity with a settled staff and there’s nothing to suggest that this wouldn’t be achievable with Roy, Ray and Paddy at the helm.
I’m also at cognisant that we’re nearly in May , not far from pre season planning and decisions on players etc.
To bring in a new manager brings in the uncertainty of upheaval with him wanting his own staff and players potentially unsettling the chemistry that is successful at present and looks like it could be in the future.
Some will say keeping Roy is only postponing the inevitable as he will have to go at some point, but is that in itself sufficient reason to make a change in the summer?

Precisely, it's extremely obvious to me to keep Roy and Ray for next season and allow Paddy to listen and learn, it's important for a club like ours to keep hold of Paddy.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 Apr 23 10.26am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Precisely, it's extremely obvious to me to keep Roy and Ray for next season and allow Paddy to listen and learn, it's important for a club like ours to keep hold of Paddy.

Do you see him as our future manager?

 

esox lucius Flag Deal 30 Apr 23 10.27am

The sun is shining, everything in the garden is rosy at the moment, however when we go again next season a lot of people could be on Roy’s back if thing aren’t working very well.

The club have to move forward. Every season we are where we are now, round about 10/12 position, in the 10 years we have been in the prem we have probably spent no more than a few weeks in the top half.

In the premiership treading water is the equivalent of going backwards.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 30 Apr 23 10.36am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Do you see him as our future manager?

Yes of course, why not? I see no reason why Mr Hodgson needs to go anywhere, we should highlight the obvious mistakes that are constantly being made with managers being brought in.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 30 Apr 23 10.38am

Originally posted by esox lucius

The sun is shining, everything in the garden is rosy at the moment, however when we go again next season a lot of people could be on Roy’s back if thing aren’t working very well.

The club have to move forward. Every season we are where we are now, round about 10/12 position, in the 10 years we have been in the prem we have probably spent no more than a few weeks in the top half.

In the premiership treading water is the equivalent of going backwards.

Investment, it all about that.

 

davehuggins Flag 30 Apr 23 10.45am

We will have to change sooner or later, RH has vast experience and proves the point if you give a good manager/coach a decent set of players this is what can be achieved. PV lost his way after a very good start, just follows what happened with him in the past. Whatever is decided we can be certain SP will be doing his best to fill the role RH style. As a side issue we need to build on this base of talent we have with the hope the academy will produce a new Wilf or two!! COYP

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 30 Apr 23 10.46am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Although Roy does seem to being enjoying himself and looking nice and relaxed during what is ostensibly a brief interim fill-in role I am not so certain that he is the way forward for next season and it poses the questions: What about the season after that? Where's the planning for 3 years down the line and bringing through the best of the Academy? Does Roy want to retire someday? This is not to say Roy isn't adept at his role here, he certainly knows the club and how to work successfully within the parameters set out thus far: avoid relegation / mid table / small spend.
That said, I think Parish may be tempted to offer him another year as Roy offers a safe pair of hands.


I think you're right on both counts. It is one thing for Roy to come on board for 10 games to ensure our continued PL status - quite another to expect him to do a full season, pre-season and all.

It's almost as if the last month has been a nice holiday for him doing the things he loves doing. He bats away awkward questions about the next manager, Wilf etc., by stating his limited brief was to keep us up. Turn it into a one-year contract for next season and would be back to serious work etc.

As to Parish, it's not just that Roy is a safe pair of hands, he's shown he can work with what's there - very tempting for a man who has limited resources for player recruitment.

Edited by doombear (30 Apr 2023 10.47am)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Apr 23 10.54am

I think we have to be careful not to get too carried away. PV got exactly the same number of points from these games in the reverse fixtures (13pts) this season (albeit the performances were not as good in some of the games). We have for the last four or five years done fairly well against teams around us with a win ratio varying between the 50-66% mark. What we haven't and won't see during Roy's new tenure is games against tougher opposition (do Spurs count as tough?), or how he'll respond during the periods where we inevitably have a tougher run of results.

I have every confidence Roy would keep us up I'm just not so confident over a whole season he'll bring out the best in the attacking players and may increasingly burden them with defensive rigidity and shape. I think he is the safe option, but personally I would hate to see us fail to make the most of the attacking talent we have. Weirdly, the performances Roy is delivering are not just highlighting PV was the wrong man for the job, but also that Roy is, if that makes sense. His post-match comments even in victory point towards a desire for a more pragmatic approach which could curtail the freedom that Olise and especially Eze seem to thrive on.

Of course I'd love to be wrong and we carry on playing such a free-flowing and entertaining style under Roy next season, with Paddy taking over the mantle when he's ready. I just worry that we have the luxury to play the way we are now and that it won't last when games start to matter again. For now though I'm just going to enjoy the ride as we all know the good times never seem to last for long as a Palace fan.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 30 Apr 23 11.14am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Although Roy does seem to being enjoying himself and looking nice and relaxed during what is ostensibly a brief interim fill-in role I am not so certain that he is the way forward for next season and it poses the questions: What about the season after that? Where's the planning for 3 years down the line and bringing through the best of the Academy? Does Roy want to retire someday? This is not to say Roy isn't adept at his role here, he certainly knows the club and how to work successfully within the parameters set out thus far: avoid relegation / mid table / small spend.
That said, I think Parish may be tempted to offer him another year as Roy offers a safe pair of hands.

I don't think it makes sense for PL clubs to do this with a manager as a key part of it any more. It's 50/50 whether any PL manager survives the season, which makes it 1/4 that they'd survive 2 seasons.

The one way it makes sense to do that with a manager is the style they're able to play. The style Hodgson is employing is exactly the style that suits the squad - high press, bit of flair in attack, reasonably solid base. I can see how a 1 year contract could be tempting all round.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

PatrickA Flag London 30 Apr 23 11.27am

I started the thread not as an emotional response to a few good results, but based on an objective analysis of where we are.
In fact I wasn't a huge fan of Roy last time around and I'm not swayed by the fact that he's a local boy or that he supposedly supported the club as a boy.
The choice for the owners is whether there is a better option in the summer.
Some will refer to the need for long term planning and that Roy is not the future.
However, the nature of football now is that the average tenure for a manager is less than 2 years.
It's not that long ago that Vieira was seen as the future.
Furthermore, if Vieira had exceeded expectation this season he may well have been poached anyway.
In an ideal world it would be great to have a 5 year plan, but the stakes are so high that the first priority has to be to avoid relegation on a year by yewr basis.
If I was in the fortunate position of being one of the owners I would be asking myself is who is the best current qualified candidate to achieve this aim.
It's difficult to look beyond Roy if only based on maintaining continuity and because the chemistry betwwen the coaching team and the players is self evidently so strong.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 30 Apr 23 4.55pm

Originally posted by PatrickA


Some will refer to the need for long term planning and that Roy is not the future.

It's not that long ago that Vieira was seen as the future.
Furthermore, if Vieira had exceeded expectation this season he may well have been poached anyway.

In an ideal world it would be great to have a 5 year plan, but the stakes are so high that the first priority has to be to avoid relegation on a year by year basis.

It's difficult to look beyond Roy if only based on maintaining continuity and because the chemistry between the coaching team and the players is self evidently so strong.

These are all valid observations Patrick and I too am beginning to see the merits of keeping the status quo. One of the most significant factors for me is the commercial, short term nature of PL performance. Managers are the cannon fodder, sacrificed if things are not going well so, to bang on about 5 year plans, whilst creditable in theory, seems irrelevant in a successful structure such as we currently have.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

VinceHilaire Flag London 30 Apr 23 5.16pm

The other issue is that whoever does come in, their performance will be compared to Roy and his team….which actually could add pressure to the management position.

In all honesty, taking over from someone who has recently led the club to playing attractive, successful football could be quite daunting.

So perhaps there is a lot of sense by adding a further year of stability to the club by not changing too much?!?!

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 30 Apr 23 6.45pm

Sticking with Roy...

Aug/Sept and Apr/May in the Premier are very different games. The poor teams are actually quite good and the newly promoted are tearing it up. This fantastic rush for the finish line will be replaced by more caution and pragmatism. Roy ball. And it has to be as i suspect we will once again be the lowest net spenders. However the fans will whine to the rafters wondering why we aren't dominant like we are now and screaming for a new manager.

But we will still be safe with games to spare if we run the course.

 

Dixie Eagle Flag Chatham 30 Apr 23 7.25pm

I think Roy should go at the end of the season on a high and with a warm pat on the back. If we stays on, he will inevitably go back to some brain numbing, boring football he gave us during his last 2-3 seasons.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 30 Apr 23 8.12pm

Originally posted by Dixie Eagle

I think Roy should go at the end of the season on a high and with a warm pat on the back. If we stays on, he will inevitably go back to some brain numbing, boring football he gave us during his last 2-3 seasons.

What grounds do you have for thinking that Dixie? I was not enthralled by some of the games we watched last time round either, but I'm prepared to believe Roy can utilise the quality players he now has available in a much more attractive and attacking style, much as we have witnessed of late.

Clearly we're not looking at a long term arrangement, but if I were Parish, I'd give the idea very serious consideration.

Of course there is one issue which needs to be addressed, which is; does Roy want to do it? As far as I'm aware he has so far sidestepped the question.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > If it ain’t broke don’t fix it