You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Paddy ‘the manager’ McCarthy
November 16 2026 3.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Paddy ‘the manager’ McCarthy


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 04 Jul 23 8.12pm

Feel like it is constantly coming up so worthy of own thread.

I love Paddy, his screaming face at Hillsborough a cult image for me. Was a commanding CB who performed consistently, Irish (both my parents are) and a Palace hero when we needed one.

The idea of him becoming our manager off the back of his long connection with the club is very romantic however I am a romantic and would love to see it but of course only if it works out. He’s apparently done his badges, helped with the youth set up and been part of the coaching team a while now.

I do question however whether this is even remotely realistic for a couple of reasons:

1. Does the romantic notion and a bit of management of junior levels qualify him for a PL job? Almost certainly not.
2. Given our always precarious and absolutely necessary (financially) PL existence would the board take such a gamble? You’d think not, especially with our reappointment of Roy and the lack of finance to buy some further guarantee.

I almost feel like I am ‘out of the know’ given it’s frequency in suggestion so maybe there is more to it however I’d genuinely be beyond shocked were it to happen. The only way I can see it is if Roy does bring a real healthy stability come end of this season and Paddy is seen as both the cheaper and easier, if not only, option for the board. Have to say it would raise an eyebrow from me at the very least albeit I’d throw my usual full support behind him.


 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ta11berg Flag birmingham 04 Jul 23 9.09pm

I remember hearing a short conversation with Dougie Freedman, shortly after George Burley had gone and we were without a manager Dougie's name had not come up. But his words, I can't remember now, made sense and were persuasive and I wondered immediately if you he could be the one. It proved right and laid the foundation for the present team. More recently I heard similar from Paddy speaking to a youth team, he too was persuasive and made good points, a man who can reach footballers. Just saying

 

EddieMac Flag 04 Jul 23 9.18pm

Still only 40 years old. Feels like he’s been around forever.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 04 Jul 23 9.41pm

Originally posted by ta11berg

I remember hearing a short conversation with Dougie Freedman, shortly after George Burley had gone and we were without a manager Dougie's name had not come up. But his words, I can't remember now, made sense and were persuasive and I wondered immediately if you he could be the one. It proved right and laid the foundation for the present team. More recently I heard similar from Paddy speaking to a youth team, he too was persuasive and made good points, a man who can reach footballers. Just saying

Insightful!

I’m not saying there’s no merit in it whatsoever I think I’ve just been trying to distinguish between any actual substance and mere ‘fan’ pipe dream!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Casual Flag Orpington 04 Jul 23 10.44pm

If he wasn’t an ex player , he wouldn’t be in anyone’s top 500th choice for our next premier league manager

 

sprites Flag Auckland 04 Jul 23 11.15pm

Originally posted by Casual

If he wasn’t an ex player , he wouldn’t be in anyone’s top 500th choice for our next premier league manager

Nail on head.

 

GorBlimey Flag Surrey 05 Jul 23 12.01am

Originally posted by Casual

If he wasn’t an ex player , he wouldn’t be in anyone’s top 500th choice for our next premier league manager

Nope, he's obviously viewed as part of the future of Palace along with youth in the team.

We tried to re-invent the wheel with FdB and Vieira and it didn't work.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 05 Jul 23 5.04am

Ive known quite a few companies who, when someone has come up through the ranks / spent quite a few years in one environment
(branch / office / facility - call it whatever you like) when the time comes for them to be Manager, they transfer them to a new facility / environment to re establish employee / Manager standing, in both the previous & new environment.

I guess what I am saying is that although Paddy has his coaching badges, has been U18 manager, under 21 Manager & is no doubt learning on the job under Roy / Ray at a certain point in time it may be sensible for him to either leave the club for his first managerial position or transfer to another one of the Eagle football clubs in the group to establish himself as a Manager in that environment.

Whether he returns couple seasons later / further down the road obviously remains to be seen but I feel its kinda like a Steven Gerrard thing where if one day he becomes Liverpool manager, with his background with the club no one will be surprised.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 05 Jul 23 6.25am

Like Nick I really hope its the plan and that it works out ,Paddy leads us into the glory years and we all die happy men .

Its a bit of a leap though taking charge of a premier league club ,Id go for it but wouldn't be suprised if it went tits.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 05 Jul 23 6.35am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

He’s apparently done his badges, helped with the youth set up and been part of the coaching team a while now.

There is a huge difference between coaching and managing. My preference would be to appoint an outside manager who would bring his own coaching team with him and Paddy to leave and get a job as manager at a lower level then after two or three years come back to us

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 05 Jul 23 7.07am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

There is a huge difference between coaching and managing. My preference would be to appoint an outside manager who would bring his own coaching team with him and Paddy to leave and get a job as manager at a lower level then after two or three years come back to us

I think you could also say that there’s a massive difference between managing a L1/2 team and a PL team so if he was successful there it still wouldn’t tell us much. Has any manager made that leap? If he had a couple of good seasons in the top half of the Championship that would tell us a lot more but then how do you get an ambitious Championship team to take him now? I think he needs more time to build his managerial skills out in the real world first.

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 05 Jul 23 7.18am

The thing is our Paddy knows our club as much as we do. You can't be here as long as he has and not get it. We are a family based club forever fighting way above are financial reality. If you want silverware glory euro nights best you try else where. But if you want a rollercoaster ride with your family and your mates strap yourself in

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 05 Jul 23 7.43am

Originally posted by johnmcormick8

The thing is our Paddy knows our club as much as we do. You can't be here as long as he has and not get it.

What does that have to do with his ability to manage in the Premier League

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 05 Jul 23 7.44am

Originally posted by johnmcormick8

The thing is our Paddy knows our club as much as we do. You can't be here as long as he has and not get it. We are a family based club forever fighting way above are financial reality. If you want silverware glory euro nights best you try else where. But if you want a rollercoaster ride with your family and your mates strap yourself in


Couple of rollercoaster rides in the news this week, one broke and another everyone got stuck upside down.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 05 Jul 23 8.50am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Ive known quite a few companies who, when someone has come up through the ranks / spent quite a few years in one environment
(branch / office / facility - call it whatever you like) when the time comes for them to be Manager, they transfer them to a new facility / environment to re establish employee / Manager standing, in both the previous & new environment.

I guess what I am saying is that although Paddy has his coaching badges, has been U18 manager, under 21 Manager & is no doubt learning on the job under Roy / Ray at a certain point in time it may be sensible for him to either leave the club for his first managerial position or transfer to another one of the Eagle football clubs in the group to establish himself as a Manager in that environment.

Whether he returns couple seasons later / further down the road obviously remains to be seen but I feel its kinda like a Steven Gerrard thing where if one day he becomes Liverpool manager, with his background with the club no one will be surprised.


I know where you are coming from with this but in other company/enviroments it is not always possible for someone to move locations to re-establish their position. Players get loaned out to continue their development and in some ways this maybe what is needed for Paddy but it is not going to happen at manager level due to the conflict's of interest that would be involved.
I think he is going to make a really good manager (as i think James McCarthur will) but it will take a big leap of faith for the board to appoint him at Palace as his first full time managerial role.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 05 Jul 23 9.03am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

What does that have to do with his ability to manage in the Premier League

Yeah I of course love our club and I do actually think the way it is run is much preferable to many other models. You have to balance this with business and footballing sense however and again the assertion that we are some sort of complete unicorn, managed through some sort of mystic, Mormon-esque community that can nurture former players into PL managers ready to compete with the best in the world on an inferior budget is just a bit too out there for me.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Jimmy Doyle Flag Butterworth 05 Jul 23 9.23am

I think Paddy has been put in the position of understudy to Roy. To be sure I wouldn't be surprised to see him step into the hotseat for the 24/25 season.

 

imashed Flag surrey 05 Jul 23 9.45am

I think we are more spinning tea cups now days at Palace.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Jul 23 10.03am

My gut says its madness to even think it.

But, being pragmatic for a moment.

This isn't a Lampard/Gerrard situation, he's had a youth gig, now a 1st team assistant.

He's learning his trade under the most experienced manager in world football. That's not a bad place to start.

There are other managers (e.g. Arteta) to come straight in to a PL job and do well (after learning under a great).

Parish is risk adverse, he's not going to risk it all if there isn't a general agreement that he's ready etc.

For his faults, with FdB and Vieria, Parish has shown that he's brave enough to make a change if needed. So if Paddy is struggling, Parish wont let him take us down


 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 05 Jul 23 10.07am

I think it is Roys job not to train him up, but to observe Paddy, and give an honest report to Parish in the new year whether he is good enough to be No1, whatever your opinion of Roy i dont think anyone can doubt his honesty.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Paddy ‘the manager’ McCarthy