You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Guaita Refusing to Play
November 16 2026 2.44am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Guaita Refusing to Play


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 08 Aug 23 5.11pm

Roy has said that Guaita is unhappy with being forced to compete with Johnstone and has refused to play in our friendlies so far.

“He (Sam Johnstone) is the only choice at the moment because Guaita is disenchanted with the club and has said he would like to move on. A complication is that he has a year’s contract. It’s up to the club to decide, not him. He’s made it clear to everybody he doesn’t want to be here and compete with Sam Johnstone. So Sam Johnstone is No 1 and Remi Matthews is No 2.”

Have always loved Vicente so a very disappointing end to his time at the club if that proves to be the case.

[Link]

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Aug 23 5.13pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Roy has said that Guaita is unhappy with being forced to compete with Johnstone and has refused to play in our friendlies so far.

“He (Sam Johnstone) is the only choice at the moment because Guaita is disenchanted with the club and has said he would like to move on. A complication is that he has a year’s contract. It’s up to the club to decide, not him. He’s made it clear to everybody he doesn’t want to be here and compete with Sam Johnstone. So Sam Johnstone is No 1 and Remi Matthews is No 2.”

Have always loved Vicente so a very disappointing end to his time at the club if that proves to be the case.

[Link]

Well he can f*** off then. It’s not all about him !

 

highbury eagle Flag Islington 08 Aug 23 5.14pm

From the horses mouth

 


Life is the same as it always will be,
Easy as picking foxes from a tree.
M Bolan

Part Time James Flag 08 Aug 23 5.18pm

I was nervous the first time Johnstone started but from game 1 I felt like he was a much better shot stopper. It's always difficult to have two similar standard goalies in a squad and with Johnstone edging it you can understand Guaita beint upset to be downgraded to (narrowly I imagine) second place. But he's a grown up doing a job, a player with heart would've tried to re-prove himself during the pre-season to give Hodgson a dilemma. Petulance isn't going to endear him to anybody. See ya later.

 




Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 08 Aug 23 5.26pm

I always liked him, good goalie, seemed a good character and well within his right to desire the no.1 spot but if that’s his attitude he can fu€k off quite frankly, shame.

Could always just stick him on a goal line by the bench and he’d never be inclined to move from it!

Edited by Nicholas91 (08 Aug 2023 5.26pm)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 08 Aug 23 5.50pm

To be honest I’ve always thought he was a bit overrated, Sam Johnstone is a much better all round keeper imo, and maybe deep down Guaita probably knows it. But if he doesn’t want to man up and fight for his place back, then get him gone as soon as possible

Just shows why everyone loved Julian Speroni, not only a great keeper, but you didn’t see him throwing his toys out of the pram when the going got tough or he lost his place in the team

 

PatrickA Flag London 08 Aug 23 5.55pm

I may be in a minority here , but for me Guiata is still the best keeper at the club.
He’s proven over a number of years for us, has been incredibly consistent and I can only recall one or two incidents where it would be fair to say his mistakes have cost us goals.
This is not to condone his behaviour if he has refused to play, but I would be inclined to reserve judgement until the full facts emerge.
Johnstone has done well over a dozen or so games and deserves his chance, but I would contend that Matthews is not serious competition at Premier League level.

It hasn’t been a great summer so far in terms of news.
Zaha off, Olise injured and then confirmation that clubs are ‘circling,’ speculation around our better players and now the Guiata issue.
The player we sign with tremendous fanfare , Franca, is injured and then there are the injuries to Hughes and Mitchell.
The squad looks stretched.
Roy says he very optimistic that the club will address this by the end of the window, but it sounds that it may go to the wire.
It may be that the fees for the likes of Gray and Adams will come down towards the end of the window and we will wait until the time suits the club.

However, I doubt that the squad at the end of the window will be as strong as the one that finished last season.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 08 Aug 23 5.59pm

When he picked up his injury last season and Johnstone came in he performed so well that he was impossible to drop really. I can only remember Johhnstone having one little howler against Wolves away but apart from that played superbly.

Such a shame he's decided to act like this purely because he has to compete for a place. He's been a good servant for us but we don't need hissy fits and bad attitude in the squad so let's hope we can move him on.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

aashman12 Flag 08 Aug 23 5.59pm

Well what a way to tarnish a reputation and relationship,see ya VG

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 08 Aug 23 6.15pm

You just knew he was out of here days after the end of the season. He made that tweet saying he’d always be an eagle…you say that on the way out.

I’m disappointed it ends like this. He’s been a good GK for us. His kicking was atrocious, and Sam is certainly miles better in that regard. We are going to need to look after Sam very well until we get a back up.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 08 Aug 23 6.23pm

Doing us a favor, not a bad keeper good shot stopper but that's about it, one of the worse no 1s in the division, wouldn't get in any other prem team. Was always a position we could improve on anyway.

 

cROYdonrogers Flag Leamington Spa 08 Aug 23 6.24pm

This is a no brainier.Sell him. We paid nothing, so it’s a win. Sometimes there’s the odd keeper kicking around after the transfer window closes. Otherwise it’s Remi.
Shame to end this way.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 08 Aug 23 6.25pm

Why is Hodgson going to the media with this? Couldn't it be dealt with behind closed doors? A bit snide.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Aug 23 6.33pm

This is a pity because Guiata has given us good service and was happy at Palace.
Unfortunately, injuries, age and good performances from Johnstone mean that he has lost the certainty of starting. That's football.

It's not easy for second choice keepers, but I don't think that he should through his toys out just yet. I'd have thought that he would still be a valued asset.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 08 Aug 23 6.41pm

In that case, he'll be off and we'll be joining the goalkeeper merry go round.

The current merry go round seems to be the Raya one. Raya -> Arsenal, Turner & Henderson -> Forest, Forest have too many goalkeepers.

Ethan Horvath, who was Luton's No.1 last season, would be the displaced goalkeeper and a clear number 2 for us.

Other clear number 2s: Steffen at City, Timo Horn (free agent), Danny Ward at Leicester, Krul at Norwich.

Luton are apparently about to sign John Ruddy who Kiely worked with at Norwich - could hijack that deal.

There was chat about Soria wanting to leave Getafe. We could always send Guaita back in that direction and chuck in a few million to make it worth their while. Soria would be strong competition for Johnstone though.

Fairly weak pickings unless we go out and poach a current number 1 or look abroad.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

TheBigToePunt Flag 08 Aug 23 6.44pm

Whilst I generally prefer Palace to do things behind closed doors, I like Roy's openness on this. What else is he supposed to say that doesn't involve lying?

I can understand Guaita wanting to leave rather than be no2 at his age, and of course we don't know what conversations have taken place between club and player up to now, but he shouldn't be downing tools.

We would never get a fee for him at his age, and we would want two good goalies for the season, so worth trying to talk him round if possible.

 

Robk Flag 08 Aug 23 6.46pm

Soria would be an excellent choice with Vicente going the other way... I think Roy’s interview has brought it to a head... a decision shortly....very strange that he didn’t want to stay and fight for it....

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 08 Aug 23 6.48pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

In that case, he'll be off and we'll be joining the goalkeeper merry go round.

The current merry go round seems to be the Raya one. Raya -> Arsenal, Turner & Henderson -> Forest, Forest have too many goalkeepers.

Ethan Horvath, who was Luton's No.1 last season, would be the displaced goalkeeper and a clear number 2 for us.

Other clear number 2s: Steffen at City, Timo Horn (free agent), Danny Ward at Leicester, Krul at Norwich.

Luton are apparently about to sign John Ruddy who Kiely worked with at Norwich - could hijack that deal.

There was chat about Soria wanting to leave Getafe. We could always send Guaita back in that direction and chuck in a few million to make it worth their while. Soria would be strong competition for Johnstone though.

Fairly weak pickings unless we go out and poach a current number 1 or look abroad.

There is a case for saying Soria is better than Johnston. If he adapted to the league, he could be better.

They want €12m for Soria, which is his buy out clause. I bet they won’t pay much for having VG back either. I don’t think Palace wanted to spend that much on a GK this summer. This might be why we tried to get the keeper from Germany at the last minute. I’m sure the club can find someone to be a no.2 for a year. One thing is certain, it can’t be Remi Mathews…we’d be in trouble.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 08 Aug 23 6.49pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Well he can f*** off then. It’s not all about him !

Correct, i hope we have fined him appropriately, and put him up for transfer, dont let him walk for nothing, thats what he wants.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Plaistow Eagle Flag 08 Aug 23 6.52pm

For me symptomatic of the current state of football - players believe they hold all the cards..!!

So VG - you were/are a great shot stopper - but commanding of your box and catching is iffy at best..!!

Someone else has come in and at this moment in time has proven that they are better than you..!!

Choice is yours do you a; work on your game or b; throw your toys out of the pram like a petulant child..!!

If you go for b the frailties will always be there.!!

Bottom line grow up..!!

COYP

 

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Guaita Refusing to Play