This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by rikz
Keep reading posts saying how we should be bringing through youth, we've invested in the academy, we're cat A ect. Defending the clubs transfer strategy, instead of wasting money use the academy and produce players. 5% of players playing in the Premier league come through Premier league academies, that's about 25 players. On average, players in the prem are probably between 18-34 so that's every Premier league club producing 1.3 players a season between them. You're living in dream world if you think we're going to be consistently producing players to a Premier league standard. Its the best league in the world, full of the best players in the world, so already you have a population of 70 million competing against 8 billion. Mathematically its impossible. You could chuck 100 million a year at the academy, it won't make a difference. I think you'd need to define what you mean by 'consistently producing' - I don't think anyone is expecting 5 first teamers a year, but I don't think it's living in dream world to think we can produce a player capable of contributing to our squad every year or two. Assuming the 5% statistic is in relation to debutants - ie. there will be roughly 25 debutants this season from academies. The volume of players currently playing in the Premier League who have come through academies is obviously significantly higher than that - nearly every English or British player in the division is going to have come through a PL or EFL academy. If every club is giving more than one academy player a year a debut, I don't think there's anything unrealistic in thinking you can supplement your squad with these type of players. In terms of the 'why'; for me it's one of the most enjoyable parts of supporting a club; watching a young kid who has come through the ranks make it to the top level is hugely satisfying.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think you'd need to define what you mean by 'consistently producing' - I don't think anyone is expecting 5 first teamers a year, but I don't think it's living in dream world to think we can produce a player capable of contributing to our squad every year or two. Assuming the 5% statistic is in relation to debutants - ie. there will be roughly 25 debutants this season from academies. The volume of players currently playing in the Premier League who have come through academies is obviously significantly higher than that - nearly every English or British player in the division is going to have come through a PL or EFL academy. If every club is giving more than one academy player a year a debut, I don't think there's anything unrealistic in thinking you can supplement your squad with these type of players. In terms of the 'why'; for me it's one of the most enjoyable parts of supporting a club; watching a young kid who has come through the ranks make it to the top level is hugely satisfying. All good points. Also, can't remember the statistic, but a massive proportion of PL players came within a small radius of SE London. We're right in the middle of that talent pool and as a stable PL club (surely the plan) would be foolish not to tap into it. It's an investment hoping to pay long term dividends. I can probably easily rattle off a number of signings we've made in the past decade who have jointly cost more than the academy yet have probably made less of a contribution to the first team than I serve by shouting from the stands all these years. I am a massive pessimist and inclined to scorn people when they rave about x, y and z as though we have ready made Zidane, Pele or Maradona's to walk into the team but it seems a wise business move that certainly holds the potential to bear fruit.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think you'd need to define what you mean by 'consistently producing' - I don't think anyone is expecting 5 first teamers a year, but I don't think it's living in dream world to think we can produce a player capable of contributing to our squad every year or two. Assuming the 5% statistic is in relation to debutants - ie. there will be roughly 25 debutants this season from academies. The volume of players currently playing in the Premier League who have come through academies is obviously significantly higher than that - nearly every English or British player in the division is going to have come through a PL or EFL academy. If every club is giving more than one academy player a year a debut, I don't think there's anything unrealistic in thinking you can supplement your squad with these type of players. In terms of the 'why'; for me it's one of the most enjoyable parts of supporting a club; watching a young kid who has come through the ranks make it to the top level is hugely satisfying. Well let's look at players we've produced, not sure where every academy player in the prem is from but the England squad is usually made up of about 50% of players from London. So we're fairly good at producing players and have the benefit of being a London club. Over the last 20 years, players who can perform at this level. Moses, Clyne, Wilf, awb and Mitchell, 3 had the luxury of developing in the championship and one Is just good enough. That's 1 player every 4 years. In the championship having a good academy gives us a massive advantage but when you've got fans moaning at the manager to give the youngsters a chance. The fact is 99.9% are not and will never be good enough to play at this level.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
All good points. Also, can't remember the statistic, but a massive proportion of PL players came within a small radius of SE London. We're right in the middle of that talent pool and as a stable PL club (surely the plan) would be foolish not to tap into it. It's an investment hoping to pay long term dividends. I can probably easily rattle off a number of signings we've made in the past decade who have jointly cost more than the academy yet have probably made less of a contribution to the first team than I serve by shouting from the stands all these years. I am a massive pessimist and inclined to scorn people when they rave about x, y and z as though we have ready made Zidane, Pele or Maradona's to walk into the team but it seems a wise business move that certainly holds the potential to bear fruit.
The figure quoted in 2016 was that 14% of Premier League players came from South London. Our catchment area has a good chance of producing players and with the way transfer fees are increasing that has to be a good thing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
The figure quoted in 2016 was that 14% of Premier League players came from South London. Our catchment area has a good chance of producing players and with the way transfer fees are increasing that has to be a good thing. Cheers and well done Teddy. Yep, and we should certainly hold a financial and attraction advantage over our neighbours for a bigger slide of that cake.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Cheers and well done Teddy. Yep, and we should certainly hold a financial and attraction advantage over our neighbours for a bigger slide of that cake. A slide of cake with our injury record? It's madness I tell you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
A slide of cake with our injury record? It's madness I tell you. -.-' I was thinking in Neil Shipperley sized portions! Is it OK to mention him anymore or are we in dangerous territory there? Brolin a better option perhaps?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by rikz
Well let's look at players we've produced, not sure where every academy player in the prem is from but the England squad is usually made up of about 50% of players from London. So we're fairly good at producing players and have the benefit of being a London club. Over the last 20 years, players who can perform at this level. Moses, Clyne, Wilf, awb and Mitchell, 3 had the luxury of developing in the championship and one Is just good enough. That's 1 player every 4 years. In the championship having a good academy gives us a massive advantage but when you've got fans moaning at the manager to give the youngsters a chance. The fact is 99.9% are not and will never be good enough to play at this level. We’ve only had an elite academy set up for a short time - I don’t think the last 20 years are particularly relevant. If anything, the fact we’ve still produced international standard footballers despite very poor infrastructure and facilities is testament to how possible it is. Of course the majority aren’t going to make it to this level; that doesn’t mean it’s not worth trying - the upsides are enormous when you do find a gem; see Wilf in terms of owning a player far superior to anything you’d be able sign, and see AWB in terms of the huge commercial benefit.
|
|
|
A long time ago of course when the ethos and available money were very different but the so-called Team of the Eighties were almost all home produced players.
|
|
|
In the last ten years how many 1st team players have we produced?
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
In the last ten years how many 1st team players have we produced? Regular players...Two?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
A long time ago of course when the ethos and available money were very different but the so-called Team of the Eighties were almost all home produced players. There lies an interesting question Teddy. How would our team of home grown players from the 80’s got on against our current strongest 11? Is buying foreign more hype than reality and should we be bringing on more of our homegrown players?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Regular players...Two? I can't even think of any that are regulars in the lower leagues other than the two.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
London is an absolute hotbed of talent and we are now a stable, well run Premier League club with an outstanding academy. There is no reason that young players shouldn't choose us over the likes of Arsenal, Spurs or Chelsea for their development but the caveat is that we have to offer a pathway to professional football. I agree with the original poster in that we shouldn't use the academy as an excuse for not spending on players. However, there is also absolutely nothing wrong with the idea that the academy can't produce players for us to either use or sell for profit. Look at Trevor Chalobah for example. He's come through the Chelsea academy and only played about 40 odd games for them and they're now asking for about £40m for him. It might take a couple of years for the new academy to bear fruit but there's no reason we can't start doing that too. Worth saying as well that I absolutely think we've got the wrong manager for this. Someone like Steve Cooper or (I can't believe I'm about to say this) Gareth Southgate with a track record of trusting young players would be ideal for this strategy. Edited by Canterbury Palace (04 Nov 2023 9.32am) How about the legend Patrick Vieira ? Visual evidence and rumour have suggested that his relationship with some of the younger players was strained and I'm pretty sure Eze made the point of saying how much he enjoyed playing for the current manager. Southgate has been continually criticized for selection of his "favourites" such as Maguire and Henderson.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.