You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why did Palace sign Henderson?
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why did Palace sign Henderson?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Zaha127 Flag 14 Nov 23 10.12am

Did anyone else scratch their head at this signing? Johnstone has done well last season when he played and so this season he has been decent.

It makes sense to have Whitworth as no 2 he is a capable number 2. But the Henderson signing did not make sense considering how well Johnstone is playing.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 14 Nov 23 10.24am

Originally posted by Zaha127

Did anyone else scratch their head at this signing? Johnstone has done well last season when he played and so this season he has been decent.

It makes sense to have Whitworth as no 2 he is a capable number 2. But the Henderson signing did not make sense considering how well Johnstone is playing.

Been said on other threads what is going on spending £40m on Henderson and Franca, no sign of either of them playing. We had a great window when we signed Guehi, Anderson but since then all very underwhelming. Common theme on here is we are doing the best we can with the financial constraints we’ve got. Well I don’t agree with that.

 

Plumpton eagle Flag East Sussex 14 Nov 23 11.21am

Or, looking at it another way - why did Henderson sign for us?

Reportedly, he is on big money (£100k per week) so that must be a factor. But he must surely also have expected to be playing week in, week out? He has England ambitions and is a very well thought of keeper. I can't believe he joined us expecting to back up keeper.

Maybe, Johnstone's form has surprised the "powers that be". I think he has been outstanding for us this season and when he played last season.

Henderson may have been thought of as an investment. That his value would go up whilst playing for us and becoming an established England international. But that can only happen if he starts regularly for us.

Even if they were both fit, I would not start him ahead of Johnstone at the moment. I don't know how far away from being fit to play Henderson is but it could be a while.

I guess one of them will leave at the end of the season. If it is Henderson then I doubt it will be for a profit.

I would really like SP or DF to offer an insight but that is very unlikely to happen.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 14 Nov 23 11.33am

Originally posted by Plumpton eagle

Or, looking at it another way - why did Henderson sign for us?

Reportedly, he is on big money (£100k per week) so that must be a factor. But he must surely also have expected to be playing week in, week out? He has England ambitions and is a very well thought of keeper. I can't believe he joined us expecting to back up keeper.

Maybe, Johnstone's form has surprised the "powers that be". I think he has been outstanding for us this season and when he played last season.

Henderson may have been thought of as an investment. That his value would go up whilst playing for us and becoming an established England international. But that can only happen if he starts regularly for us.

Even if they were both fit, I would not start him ahead of Johnstone at the moment. I don't know how far away from being fit to play Henderson is but it could be a while.

I guess one of them will leave at the end of the season. If it is Henderson then I doubt it will be for a profit.

I would really like SP or DF to offer an insight but that is very unlikely to happen.

This is a good possibility, or maybe with Sam seeming to have cemented his place as England 3rd choice again, we might have been expecting an offer we couldn’t refuse for him from another club

Edited by monkey (14 Nov 2023 11.34am)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Nov 23 11.49am

As good as Sam has been I do think that when fully fit Henderson is the better keeper, plus he's a few years younger. Whether we need two excellent keepers is the question though, especially when we didn't replace Zaha, need to invest in new fullbacks and have questionable strikers. Holding seemed an even stranger signing to me though. £4 million to make up numbers in training.

 

Zaha127 Flag 14 Nov 23 11.54am

Franca I think could come good needs more minutes. Time will tell how he fits in. What is strange is that Franca is not a LW he is an attacking midfielder he can play as an 8 or number 10.

Eze will not be benched when Palace play 4-2-3-1 he will be the CAM. Even when Palace play 4-3-3 it is hard to see where Franca will fit if Eze plays as an 8 Doucoure will be the DM and the other 8 would probably be Hughes or Lerma.

Olise will play RW. So unless Franca can play LW or a false 9 it is hard to see where he fits in .

Agree instead of Henderson needed a new RB someone like Sacha Boey or Max Aarons.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Nov 23 11.56am

Henderson Holding Franca. Three very strange signings for all the reasons already well covered on other threads here.

When we really needed two wing backs and another striker.

Nearly all our budget spent (which we never really had) on these three.

Very very odd........

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 14 Nov 23 11.57am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

As good as Sam has been I do think that when fully fit Henderson is the better keeper, plus he's a few years younger. Whether we need two excellent keepers is the question though, especially when we didn't replace Zaha, need to invest in new fullbacks and have questionable strikers. Holding seemed an even stranger signing to me though. £4 million to make up numbers in training.

This reflects my thinking and I'd add that I still perceive Henderson as filling two roles in being an alternative/competitive option in goal (on the assumption he'd be fit) and the fact that there may be some ROI with his acquisition.

Holding for me is very much the 'filling' in the squad I've alluded to previously.

The general gripe I have seen, and align with, is that the first team is lacking and money has been spent on squad fillers and players perhaps with potential ROI but not providing immediate solutions. When we all watch us play, and we do not do well, those obvious gaps in the first XI will be the main source of grievance.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Nov 23 12.09pm

The concerning thing is that this season teams seem to have cottoned onto the fact that our fullbacks are probably the weakest area and so have on occasion ruthlessly targeted them by creating overloads. If Gala don't make it through their CL group then I say throw money at them and try and get Boey. He's going to be a star.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 14 Nov 23 12.19pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

The concerning thing is that this season teams seem to have cottoned onto the fact that our fullbacks are probably the weakest area and so have on occasion ruthlessly targeted them by creating overloads. If Gala don't make it through their CL group then I say throw money at them and try and get Boey. He's going to be a star.

I've been impressed with what I've seen, reminiscent of Reece James.

Also, I honestly thought for a moment, after arriving at 'Gala' when reading, you were going to propose bringing (back) another Galatasaray players to perform at RB TL!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Nov 23 12.33pm

Ha, yeah, Wilf at right-back, Bolasie at left-back.

Getting the band back together! (this is a joke before anyone takes me literally)

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 14 Nov 23 12.36pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Henderson Holding Franca. Three very strange signings for all the reasons already well covered on other threads here.

When we really needed two wing backs and another striker.

Nearly all our budget spent (which we never really had) on these three.

Very very odd........

I think holding was just desperate, a body through the door type signing, we needed numbers and it wouldn’t have been too hard to sign him I should imagine

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 14 Nov 23 12.39pm

When you look at the price tag its not to bad for England keeper and someone who would still have many years left in the game.

Even if we was to sell him I expect we could get back what we paid or even if he was loaned out it would cost another club few mil for that.

He appears to have attitude Palace like as well and already friends with few other players.

The issue is we already have England keeper who is now given a chance which at one stage Roy didnt want to again another forced change allowed someone else to shine otherwise he would have rotted.

Do you take keeper out who is on form and being selected for country NO

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

AERO Flag 14 Nov 23 12.48pm

One rumour was Johnstone was going to leave and it didn't materialise So got Henderson. But who knows ?

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 14 Nov 23 12.54pm

whether right or wrong i think the logic is

1. Henderson - SJ had a release clause in his original contract and with VG forcing a move Palace felt they were short in this position.
With the price for Henderson quite competitive - comparable with the inexperienced Trafford at Burnley

2. Holding - there is clearly interest in both MG and Andersen. If either goes we need decent cover. Tomkins was slightly bizarrely extended with this in mind, however, he keeps picking up injuries so further cover was required

3. Franca - seen as a longer term Eze replacement, just as Eze was maybe bought in case Wilf left a few years ago. Will need time, but Eze was never going to leave before next summer so this year was always a free pass.

All expensive, but there was some logic to each

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 14 Nov 23 1.57pm

1 I Think Holding for 4m is a decent 4th CD
2 Once Hendersen is fit one of them will leave Problably Johnstone for around 30m, then will could by Butland as a backup
3. I think Franca once he has a few good games at U21 level he will get a chance, hopefully a hat-trick tonight, but i think he is destined for CF, all the stuff on you tube (which isn't a lot) shows he makes good runs into the box and is very good in the air, he is only 19, we have him for 5 years, in 3 he could be the new Ronaldo, lets hope so.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Robk Flag 14 Nov 23 1.59pm

You can say that about other sides too why did Arsenal sign Raya.... why have Brighton got two decent keepers... West Ham also... there was a rumour that Johnstone was possibly going to Wolves, maybe that was the case... Franca is completely early days and I’m expecting good things...

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Nov 23 4.27pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

1 I Think Holding for 4m is a decent 4th CD
2 Once Hendersen is fit one of them will leave Problably Johnstone for around 30m, then will could by Butland as a backup
3. I think Franca once he has a few good games at U21 level he will get a chance, hopefully a hat-trick tonight, but i think he is destined for CF, all the stuff on you tube (which isn't a lot) shows he makes good runs into the box and is very good in the air, he is only 19, we have him for 5 years, in 3 he could be the new Ronaldo, lets hope so.

I really hope you right, I really do.
Ronaldo was terrorising defences for Man Utd before and played Champions league before he was 19. So it's a tall order, but you never know and you have a good eye. Look at Eze.

Edited by dreamwaverider (14 Nov 2023 4.28pm)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 14 Nov 23 5.18pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I really hope you right, I really do.
Ronaldo was terrorising defences for Man Utd before and played Champions league before he was 19. So it's a tall order, but you never know and you have a good eye. Look at Eze.

Edited by dreamwaverider (14 Nov 2023 4.28pm)

Many thanks for your comments, i normally get slagged off

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

southnorwoodhill Flag 14 Nov 23 5.54pm

The club f***ed up. It's the only explanation that fits the circumstance. Of course they won't admit it.

"How are we going to recoup £20m on a keeper who gets injured with his first meaningful kick of the ball Dougie?"
"No idea Steve. whose bright idea was it to sign him in the first place?"
"Yours Dougie..."
"Ah."

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why did Palace sign Henderson?