This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
100pc
|
|
|
I thought your thread title was Roy’s new training MO.
|
|
|
We all know there’s an option 4……stay exactly as we are and hope we scrape enough points to stay up, which is the more likely
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I don't think Roy responds patricularly to being under pressure and scrutiny.
On the latest post-match presser when asked what message he had for his players after the Arsenal fiasco, it was that they should keep working on what they practice in training. Clearly what they bare doing in training isn't working as is evidenced by our results since October.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
A lot of discussion at the moment is around the blame game. Looking at it objectively over the course of the last calendar year, 2023, both our results and performances were poor other than for a brief period at the end of last season. This season we’ve failed to score in 36% of our games . Going forward we have a number of choices. 1)Bring in some genuinely transformational players to make a difference - unlikely because of the cost. 2) Change the tactics to play more progressively and hope that Eze and Olise stay fit - a risk because of their fitness records and Roy seemingly unable to find a way of carrying a threat in their absence. 3)Change the manager to create a new impetus and remove the air of stagnation and staleness which runs through the team and the performances- this assumes there is a good manager available and willing to take over at this stage of the season. At the moment 3 looks the most realistic option to me. This is not to suggest that Hodgson is a bad manager, but sometimes a change is necessary to inject fresh impetus and create a positive environment where all the players start with a clean slate desperate to prove themselves. I think 1) can be addressed. We’ve all known for some time that as little as 3 or 4 players could transform this team into a highly competitive unit and yet we’ve ignored the holes and spent poorly for numerous windows. The secret to success at our level is to identify players who are not at their peak yet and are therefore more affordable. We did it with Olise and Eze. We missed out on players such as Toney, Bowen, Gyokeres, Hamer, Walker-Peters, and a whole host of others that were low to mid priced. We could have got Gyokeres at around £20m and he now has an £80m plus buy out clause which Chelsea are apparently considering having scored something like 20 goals in 23 games. The whole França situation stinks to me. Olise and Eze were known quantities both having excelled one league down. Franca is an unknown quantity and yet we have risked more on him than both of our young stars. We then buy a keeper and a centre half that we didn’t really need and when we looked in the cookie jar, surprise surprise it is empty. As good as Dougie has done in bringing Johnstone, Anderson, Doucouré, Guehi, Eze and Olise to the club, we’ve made some errors and failed to address important areas of the squad, the main two being the full back positions and a proper Zaha replacement, a creative midfielder also wouldn’t go amiss.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I don't think Roy responds patricularly to being under pressure and scrutiny. When Roy accepted the job last summer I'm sure he didn't envisage being in his current position. So it's not surprising that we are seeing a side to him that we haven't seen before. I feel sorry for him. He looks like somebody that just wants to be put out of their misery. Unfortunately for him, I don't think Parish has an escape plan. We'll see. In terms of playing style and finding ways to win etc., it's been said before. Roy is not that man. You might as well tell Leonardo DiCaprio to only date older women in future. Andersen and Guehi are now struggling under the pressure of carrying a team that has become too easy to play against. I understand the experiment of Richards as a CDM, but it ain't working.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I think 1) can be addressed. We’ve all known for some time that as little as 3 or 4 players could transform this team into a highly competitive unit and yet we’ve ignored the holes and spent poorly for numerous windows. The secret to success at our level is to identify players who are not at their peak yet and are therefore more affordable. We did it with Olise and Eze. We missed out on players such as Toney, Bowen, Gyokeres, Hamer, Walker-Peters, and a whole host of others that were low to mid priced. We could have got Gyokeres at around £20m and he now has an £80m plus buy out clause which Chelsea are apparently considering having scored something like 20 goals in 23 games. The whole França situation stinks to me. Olise and Eze were known quantities both having excelled one league down. Franca is an unknown quantity and yet we have risked more on him than both of our young stars. We then buy a keeper and a centre half that we didn’t really need and when we looked in the cookie jar, surprise surprise it is empty. As good as Dougie has done in bringing Johnstone, Anderson, Doucouré, Guehi, Eze and Olise to the club, we’ve made some errors and failed to address important areas of the squad, the main two being the full back positions and a proper Zaha replacement, a creative midfielder also wouldn’t go amiss. I'll call this post for what it is, ridiculous observation. You can't just buy players, they have to want to actually come to the club and for a certain wage and to wsnt to play for a manager. Lordy, if it was as easy as buying something off the shelf it'd make our lives easier. As for the goalkeeper thing, yes it was a silly purchase but the irony is we did need a goalkeeper in the end as Sam.J had an injury and Guaita had buggered off. DF has done a decent job and Franca hasn't actually been given a chance unless the teams already lost or hes played out of position. Same for Ahemada. You've picked such a basic principal of player acquisition that I find it baffling. I mean you have to be able to retain those players also, Olise being a prime example. You can buy all the great players but keeping them is a battle and fans will have to face the fact that Palace needs to sell assets to buy more assets(in terms of players.) I highly doubt DF has not bothered with enquiring about players, there's a whole scouting team behind it. If you were a player, would you be enticed by the stadium, manager, type of tactics used, team position? I highly doubt it. So, what has it got going for it? High wages which affect us buying more players, a chance to prove yourself and use Palace as a stepping stone.
|
|
|
Originally posted by fish mitten
Leeds, Leicester and Southampton tried option 3 last season and didn't have as much success as we did with it. Board has to invest in new players. They failed to invest in the correct players in the summer as well as the two windows before that. Personally whilst the football may be dire under Roy, we take a real gamble if we change manager and don't bring in several new players (perhaps 2 permanents and 2 loans - for positions we need) I don't think that will happen. At best 1 loan in. I think SP will sack Roy, appoint Paddy on an interim basis as it will be the cheap option and whether we stay up will be dependent if players can stay fit, and Olise and Eze can produce a few bits of magic. Will also be dependent upon three teams being worse and/or significant points deductions for Forest and Everton again. Personally if we get new players in and keep Roy I reckon we have a 80% chance of survival. Sack him and get no one in I reckon 50% at best. You’ve missed out the other alternative scenario - don’t get new players in and keep Roy. Which is where we are now and it ain’t working. Olise is clearly key to picking up some points. If he’s playing it doesn’t matter who the manager is. The defence is a worry now. Can’t be any worse under another manager.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1
I'll call this post for what it is, ridiculous observation. You can't just buy players, they have to want to actually come to the club and for a certain wage and to wsnt to play for a manager. Lordy, if it was as easy as buying something off the shelf it'd make our lives easier. As for the goalkeeper thing, yes it was a silly purchase but the irony is we did need a goalkeeper in the end as Sam.J had an injury and Guaita had buggered off. DF has done a decent job and Franca hasn't actually been given a chance unless the teams already lost or hes played out of position. Same for Ahemada. You've picked such a basic principal of player acquisition that I find it baffling. I mean you have to be able to retain those players also, Olise being a prime example. You can buy all the great players but keeping them is a battle and fans will have to face the fact that Palace needs to sell assets to buy more assets(in terms of players.) I highly doubt DF has not bothered with enquiring about players, there's a whole scouting team behind it. If you were a player, would you be enticed by the stadium, manager, type of tactics used, team position? I highly doubt it. So, what has it got going for it? High wages which affect us buying more players, a chance to prove yourself and use Palace as a stepping stone. Ridiculous comments yourself. So how come we have been able to attract Johnstone, Guehi, Anderson, Olise, Eze and Doucoure to the club in the first place? The very model that you describe as basic has been followed by Brighton for the last few years, identifying under the radar players, attracting them to the club, bringing them on and turning big profits on them. It ain’t rocket science ffs but you obviously think it is. I haven’t even mentioned the onward sale of players which is of course a vital part of keeping finances on an even keel and I have advocated previously that selling one star player per year and replacing with a couple of decent improving youngsters is vital for a club our size. The very thing that you see as impossible to achieve has been successfully achieved by many clubs over the years. I find your intransigence to the simple idea of buying low and selling for more baffling myself. It is how all forms of investment work and you are either good at it or you are not. I would say we are pretty average and we certainly need to improve on the sales side of things.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Ridiculous comments yourself. So how come we have been able to attract Johnstone, Guehi, Anderson, Olise, Eze and Doucoure to the club in the first place? The very model that you describe as basic has been followed by Brighton for the last few years, identifying under the radar players, attracting them to the club, bringing them on and turning big profits on them. It ain’t rocket science ffs but you obviously think it is. I haven’t even mentioned the onward sale of players which is of course a vital part of keeping finances on an even keel and I have advocated previously that selling one star player per year and replacing with a couple of decent improving youngsters is vital for a club our size. The very thing that you see as impossible to achieve has been successfully achieved by many clubs over the years. I find your intransigence to the simple idea of buying low and selling for more baffling myself. It is how all forms of investment work and you are either good at it or you are not. I would say we are pretty average and we certainly need to improve on the sales side of things. Ok let's go through the list of our players first before hitting your other sweeping statements. Guehi - youth of Chelsea wasn't getting any game time No top tier there much like Franca. It's a hit or miss. Brighton -they were lucky enough to have a scouting system that found and sold players for a decent profit within the first year to buy in and sell more players. We have sold a MASSIVE - Wan Bissaka and who else? Wan Bissaka covered a loan we previously had. So you want Palace to buy these players you've named which were already somewhat known entities which you think we missed out on, disregarding another factors apart from they are mid to low costing. At the same time you think Franca (an unknown player of ability) was a bad transaction. Brighton buy in quite a few players that don't make it, they've been fortunate that Chrlsea have bought loads off them. Not to mention that comparing Brighton to cpfc is a whole different subjective topic but small observation would show they have a giant stadium, in a great affluent area that's also close enough to London if the player wants to live in the capital. Simon Jordan has also mentioned the differences between the clubs recently. How do you feel Palace can address areas of the squad like Brighton if we don't sell any of the good players that make up the squad? To be like Brighton, Palace will need to sell some of them and most likely Olise and Guehi. DF isn't always going to hit the nail on the head with buying in good players. If its that easy to do, why aren't you a chief scout like Dougie? Seeing as it's easy to buy low and sell high? Safe to say it isn't that easy.
|
|
|
Not to detract from the rest of your post but we bought Eze from QPR (Where he did have a loan spell at Wycombe Wanderers but returned to feature in the QPR first team) so I guess in many respects it would be akin to discovering Olise'. Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1
Ok let's go through the list of our players first before hitting your other sweeping statements. Guehi - youth of Chelsea wasn't getting any game time No top tier there much like Franca. It's a hit or miss. Brighton -they were lucky enough to have a scouting system that found and sold players for a decent profit within the first year to buy in and sell more players. We have sold a MASSIVE - Wan Bissaka and who else? Wan Bissaka covered a loan we previously had. So you want Palace to buy these players you've named which were already somewhat known entities which you think we missed out on, disregarding another factors apart from they are mid to low costing. At the same time you think Franca (an unknown player of ability) was a bad transaction. Brighton buy in quite a few players that don't make it, they've been fortunate that Chrlsea have bought loads off them. Not to mention that comparing Brighton to cpfc is a whole different subjective topic but small observation would show they have a giant stadium, in a great affluent area that's also close enough to London if the player wants to live in the capital. Simon Jordan has also mentioned the differences between the clubs recently. How do you feel Palace can address areas of the squad like Brighton if we don't sell any of the good players that make up the squad? To be like Brighton, Palace will need to sell some of them and most likely Olise and Guehi. DF isn't always going to hit the nail on the head with buying in good players. If its that easy to do, why aren't you a chief scout like Dougie? Seeing as it's easy to buy low and sell high? Safe to say it isn't that easy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
Not to detract from the rest of your post but we bought Eze from QPR (Where he did have a loan spell at Wycombe Wanderers but returned to feature in the QPR first team) so I guess in many respects it would be akin to discovering Olise'. I appreciate the correct information. I wasn't sure, so I made a mediocre search for information.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1
Ok let's go through the list of our players first before hitting your other sweeping statements. Guehi - youth of Chelsea wasn't getting any game time No top tier there much like Franca. It's a hit or miss. Brighton -they were lucky enough to have a scouting system that found and sold players for a decent profit within the first year to buy in and sell more players. We have sold a MASSIVE - Wan Bissaka and who else? Wan Bissaka covered a loan we previously had. So you want Palace to buy these players you've named which were already somewhat known entities which you think we missed out on, disregarding another factors apart from they are mid to low costing. At the same time you think Franca (an unknown player of ability) was a bad transaction. Brighton buy in quite a few players that don't make it, they've been fortunate that Chrlsea have bought loads off them. Not to mention that comparing Brighton to cpfc is a whole different subjective topic but small observation would show they have a giant stadium, in a great affluent area that's also close enough to London if the player wants to live in the capital. Simon Jordan has also mentioned the differences between the clubs recently. How do you feel Palace can address areas of the squad like Brighton if we don't sell any of the good players that make up the squad? To be like Brighton, Palace will need to sell some of them and most likely Olise and Guehi. DF isn't always going to hit the nail on the head with buying in good players. If its that easy to do, why aren't you a chief scout like Dougie? Seeing as it's easy to buy low and sell high? Safe to say it isn't that easy. Jeez, you’re arguing with yourself here. All those points you are making about those players totally proves my point that we have identified players at low value and they are now high value. They are not the only players in the world that are undervalued and it is Dougies job to continue to identify them. You are arguing points that I didn’t even make. I’ve always advocated selling to buy, but not selling to line shareholders pockets. Your last comment is a typical straw man argument that gets peddled on here far too often and which I’ll choose to treat with the contempt it deserves.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1
Ok let's go through the list of our players first before hitting your other sweeping statements. Guehi - youth of Chelsea wasn't getting any game time No top tier there much like Franca. It's a hit or miss. Brighton -they were lucky enough to have a scouting system that found and sold players for a decent profit within the first year to buy in and sell more players. We have sold a MASSIVE - Wan Bissaka and who else? Wan Bissaka covered a loan we previously had. So you want Palace to buy these players you've named which were already somewhat known entities which you think we missed out on, disregarding another factors apart from they are mid to low costing. At the same time you think Franca (an unknown player of ability) was a bad transaction. Brighton buy in quite a few players that don't make it, they've been fortunate that Chrlsea have bought loads off them. Not to mention that comparing Brighton to cpfc is a whole different subjective topic but small observation would show they have a giant stadium, in a great affluent area that's also close enough to London if the player wants to live in the capital. Simon Jordan has also mentioned the differences between the clubs recently. How do you feel Palace can address areas of the squad like Brighton if we don't sell any of the good players that make up the squad? To be like Brighton, Palace will need to sell some of them and most likely Olise and Guehi. DF isn't always going to hit the nail on the head with buying in good players. If its that easy to do, why aren't you a chief scout like Dougie? Seeing as it's easy to buy low and sell high? Safe to say it isn't that easy. Wow, those mentioned are worlds apart form Franca. Guehi - Over 50 champ appearances, Won U17 WC, in team of the WC, runer up in the U17 Euros Anderson - 31 prem appearances,110 appearance across Europe's top leagues, full international Olise - PFA team of the year, Champ young player of the season, champ team of hte season Doucoure - full international, 4 full seasons in League 1 Eze - Know your background better, clearly from QPR. Was their player of the season and in the PFA team of the year They were all calculated, not huge risk in any of them really.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Jeez, you’re arguing with yourself here. All those points you are making about those players totally proves my point that we have identified players at low value and they are now high value. They are not the only players in the world that are undervalued and it is Dougies job to continue to identify them. You are arguing points that I didn’t even make. I’ve always advocated selling to buy, but not selling to line shareholders pockets. Your last comment is a typical straw man argument that gets peddled on here far too often and which I’ll choose to treat with the contempt it deserves. True. One of our main problems is that we have hardly ever raised finance through the sale of players, money to re-invest in the playing side. Parish has offered many a past it duffer another year's contract to save the effort and fees of actually getting out there and scout some fresh blood. These players munch up funds through exorbitant salaries, have no resale value, and offer very little on the pitch. I think it's to do with making us look as though we have a full squad of 25.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.