You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta - humble pie.
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mateta - humble pie.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
sprites Flag Auckland 19 Feb 24 9.38pm

It's important in life to admit when you're wrong.
I was wrong about Mateta.
I've been a critic of his, once even labelling him a drunk Giraffe on roller skates.

But he's been top draw recently. His link up play, the way he holds the ball up..his work rate...and he's shown he can finish too.

Not sure he's the long term answer to our striker problem...but he's making a bloody good fist of it right now.

Kudos JPM. I eat my words.

 

eagleheath Flag Burgess Hill 19 Feb 24 10.24pm

Agree with this. Massive improvement with Boom Boom. He was superb tonight

 

Fanofzhiyi Flag Kent 19 Feb 24 10.34pm

Originally posted by sprites

It's important in life to admit when you're wrong.
I was wrong about Mateta.
I've been a critic of his, once even labelling him a drunk Giraffe on roller skates.

But he's been top draw recently. His link up play, the way he holds the ball up..his work rate...and he's shown he can finish too.

Not sure he's the long term answer to our striker problem...but he's making a bloody good fist of it right now.

Kudos JPM. I eat my words.

Agreed. His work rate, hold up play and link up play has improved enormously. He deserved his place in the team. Hopefully Glasner can find a way to get more players feeding off of him in attack

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 19 Feb 24 10.47pm

Everton seemed to always have three or four fellas hanging out of Mateta.......that is respect indeed.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Glazier#1 Flag 19 Feb 24 11.02pm


Yup.

Three times the player who started the season. I used to roll my eyes to the heavens whenever he came on.

Not now.

 

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 19 Feb 24 11.18pm

To me it's noticeable that when he tires we lose a lot of cohesion in our play, such is his ability to hold the ball up in attacking areas and bring others into the game.

Could do with some better service in front of goal but I'm mindful we're missing our best crosser in Olise.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 19 Feb 24 11.58pm

His first touch seems so much better (most of the time) and his work rate has definitely improved, fair play to him tonight. Played a big part in our goal too.

Just a shame he couldn’t release Ayew? when we won back possession at 1-0 up. Our attacker would've been clean through and 2-0 would have sealed it for us the way Everton were playing.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 20 Feb 24 9.16am

Originally posted by sprites

It's important in life to admit when you're wrong.
I was wrong about Mateta.
I've been a critic of his, once even labelling him a drunk Giraffe on roller skates.

But he's been top draw recently. His link up play, the way he holds the ball up..his work rate...and he's shown he can finish too.

Not sure he's the long term answer to our striker problem...but he's making a bloody good fist of it right now.

Kudos JPM. I eat my words.

I dont think you were wrong. He used to be sh1te!

To be fair to him, he's really improved. And has understood, and seams to be relishing, what we need of him.

He wins more than his fair share of hte battles, and his link play is pretty decent at times

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Feb 24 9.58am

Originally posted by sprites

It's important in life to admit when you're wrong.
I was wrong about Mateta.
I've been a critic of his, once even labelling him a drunk Giraffe on roller skates.

But he's been top draw recently. His link up play, the way he holds the ball up..his work rate...and he's shown he can finish too.

Not sure he's the long term answer to our striker problem...but he's making a bloody good fist of it right now.

Kudos JPM. I eat my words.


Good of you, Sprites to admit this. I've said on several occasions that Mateta was never given a decent run of games to show what he could do.

Having said that it's clear that he's also improved significantly in both his hold-up and his link-up play, both of which were highlighted in his assist for the goal last night. I'm not sure he would have shown this improvement had he been given a decent run of games in previous seasons but we'll never know.


 

snytaxx Flag London 20 Feb 24 10.13am

I've always preferred him over Édouard yet always found the crowd to be very unforgiving to him in the sense that the slightest mistake would always get someone in the crowd screaming his name in exasperation even when it was often the result of a poor ball etc.

Glad he has won some of his critics over.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 20 Feb 24 10.29am

Jean-Phillipe has improved immeasurably. He does however need to work on his stamina/game management. He seems to run out of steam after about 65 minutes.
Could be a genetic issue re heart size to body as he is a very big lad.
Good to see him throwing his weight about and winning.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 20 Feb 24 10.35am

We've seen him improve in leaps and bounds this season.
Infinitely preferable to Edouard up front.
It'll be interesting to see what Glasner can do with him.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 20 Feb 24 10.39am

JPM has become the striker I hoped he would. He's never a 20 goal a season man but my criticism was he's lack of work rate and not using his physical attributes.

This season he's becoming a real nuisance for the defenders, he is holding the ball up and winning his personal battles.

Now if we can only find a striker to feed off of him.

Edited by Badger11 (20 Feb 2024 10.40am)

 


One more point

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 20 Feb 24 10.41am

Way more energetic and more of a handful for the opposition than Édouard. He just needs to be supplied with more crosses (and then get on the end of them) than he is now to become a bigger threat.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 20 Feb 24 11.25am

Originally posted by Badger11

JPM has become the striker I hoped he would. He's never a 20 goal a season man but my criticism was he's lack of work rate and not using his physical attributes.

This season he's becoming a real nuisance for the defenders, he is holding the ball up and winning his personal battles.

Now if we can only find a striker to feed off of him.

Edited by Badger11 (20 Feb 2024 10.40am)

As we saw last night getting players closer to him was a good start .

 

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 20 Feb 24 11.33am

He looks really sharp and energetic. I’m so glad we didn’t flick him in January only to watch him flourish elsewhere.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 20 Feb 24 11.48am

For a while JP and Edouard seemed to be neck and neck as to who was the biggest disappointment. However, JP seems to have found his mojo and is now a valuable member of the team.

 

beak Flag croydon 20 Feb 24 12.47pm

Originally posted by sprites

It's important in life to admit when you're wrong.
I was wrong about Mateta.
I've been a critic of his, once even labelling him a drunk Giraffe on roller skates.

But he's been top draw recently. His link up play, the way he holds the ball up..his work rate...and he's shown he can finish too.

Not sure he's the long term answer to our striker problem...but he's making a bloody good fist of it right now.

Kudos JPM. I eat my words.


I think you were correct but he has improved (with a run in the side) beyond all recognition.

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 20 Feb 24 1.06pm

He is winning us all over with his improved work rate, incredible ability to hold the ball and his athleticism.

Game time + confidence = Better Mojo!!

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 20 Feb 24 1.33pm

i want to see him with that killer instinct. No Bull.

Mateta the Matador.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta - humble pie.