You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are release clauses worth the pain?
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are release clauses worth the pain?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 10 Jul 24 12.17pm

It is hugely frustrating to finish last season on such a high only to see Olise and possibly Eze move on by activating release clauses. Could this have been avoided? Probably not. Both were successful in the Championship, obviously talented, and clearly ambitious. Release clauses gave them control over their future and I doubt they would have signed for us without them. We find ourselves in a catch 22 . Players of their ability won’t sign for us without a release clause or stay at Palace unless we qualify for Europe, but without them Europe is beyond our grasp. It’s a measure of where we are as a club currently.

We need DF to find new gems each season, the academy to produce our own young talent, and most of all Oliver Glasner to build a successful top half team using both if we are to move to “the next level”, which for us is being in the hunt for Conference and Europa League places each season. Meantime we will have to get used to losing our best players each summer. How well we spend the money that generates will determine our future success. You only have to look at the Weed to see how precarious being in this position can be.


Edited by Palacesince64 (10 Jul 2024 12.26pm)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Jul 24 12.32pm

Originally posted by Palacesince64

It is hugely frustrating to finish last season on such a high only to see Olise and possibly Eze move on by activating release clauses. Could this have been avoided? Probably not. Both were successful in the Championship, obviously talented, and clearly ambitious. Release clauses gave them control over their future and I doubt they would have signed for us without them. We find ourselves in a catch 22 . Players of their ability won’t sign for us without a release clause or stay at Palace unless we qualify for Europe, but without them Europe is beyond our grasp. It’s a measure of where we are as a club currently.

We need DF to find new gems each season, the academy to produce our own young talent, and most of all Oliver Glasner to build a successful top half team using both of we are to move to “the next level”, which for us is being in the hunt for Conference and Europa League places each season. Meantime we will have to get used to losing our best players each summer. How well we spend the money that generates will determine our future success. You only have to look at the Weed to see how precarious being in this position can be.

Yep, it can feel very frustrating.

The alternative for me however is spending £50mil plus on Sakho and Benteke and getting perhaps one decent season out of the two of them whilst we're financially hamstrung by their cost & wages and still continually fighting relegation lest a nutty billionaire or consortium buy the club and spend ridiculous amounts of money which may completely f**k us in the long run.

It needs to be a full circle, recycling process and therefore can possibly be undone by a couple or even a single bad transfer window. We have to hope the club are able to continue identifying the talent we need, at lower prices.

Do that with any success and they'll keep the business financially healthy whilst producing results on the pitch that keep us at the top level and potentially more. We may well see some success with individuals whilst they're here, which will improve our ability to retain and attract talent in the first instance, but if/when they do leave we'll not be on the bitter end of the deal.

The one thing which may further help this process of course is if we have a manager who can employ a footballing philosophy which makes us less reliant upon individuals. Step forward Oliver Glasner...

I'd suggest not getting too upset by individual instances, though it is hard not too, and focussing on the bigger picture. I suspect the likes of Parish do.

COYP

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 10 Jul 24 12.40pm

They are seemingly a necessary evil to convince these types of players to pick us over more successful clubs.

As gut-wrenching as it was to see Olise leave for that fee, ask yourself when we signed him whether you'd accept three brilliant seasons and a £30m+ profit at the end of it. The answer is surely yes.

The trick is that we need to push on ourselves, move up the table, try and get into a European competition and therefore we become a more attractive proposition automatically and our bargaining position becomes stronger.

Easier said than done but we have a good manager and a head of recruitment in place, if that is backed up with the required investment (it hasn't always in the past) we can keep moving up.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 10 Jul 24 12.46pm

Yes,

I'd rather have had 3 seasons of Olise then nothing at all

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 10 Jul 24 12.50pm

We are stuck in a bit of a catch 22 situation right now.

Big enough to almighty at be an established Premier League side with the attraction that goes with it. Certainly big enough to lure players from abroad and the lower leagues and to be attractive enough to a younger player at one of the bigger sides where they struggle for game time.

But not a huge fish in the pond so when we do unearth these nuggets someone else is always watching and will come in and pick off the best.

Having a release clause is part of that an indicator that we will not stand in a players way when the big clubs come knocking. This probably gives is an edge in attracting the talent.

Big trick is keeping finding the players but as we do sell on at profit we have the opportunity to re invest.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Jul 24 12.58pm


It's a cliché but the only way we can sign good players is by including a buy out clause and the only way we keep them is by getting better and the only way to get better is to keep good players. Or sign those no one else wants.
Things are compounded by the Bosman ruling - if we're going to lose players a buy-out clause is better than nothing.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Jul 24 1.19pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


It's a cliché but the only way we can sign good players is by including a buy out clause and the only way we keep them is by getting better and the only way to get better is to keep good players. Or sign those no one else wants.
Things are compounded by the Bosman ruling - if we're going to lose players a buy-out clause is better than nothing.

It all depends who inserts a buyout clause. If it’s done by the club, no problem, we are protecting our interest . If the player does, not good, as they are protecting themselves with a view to move on.

No other player at the club has a buyout clause, unless someone has hard proof they have and who’s favour is it in.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Jul 24 1.30pm

Originally posted by Painter

It all depends who inserts a buyout clause. If it’s done by the club, no problem, we are protecting our interest . If the player does, not good, as they are protecting themselves with a view to move on.

No other player at the club has a buyout clause, unless someone has hard proof they have and who’s favour is it in.

Hard to see why the club would want to have a release clause which precludes a bidding war for an in demand player.

 

PatrickA Flag London 10 Jul 24 1.31pm

By the same token, nobody on here can prove that players’ contracts don’t include such clauses in the absence of the visibility of the contracts.

I’m not in favour of them in principle , even though I understand the counter arguments .

If we have to have them ,it seems preposterous that Olise has been able to leave almost before the ink on his long term contract is dry.

Perhaps, to avoid running the risk of losing a few at the same time the clauses should be staggered to avoid such upheaval e.g Olise kicks in this summer, but Eze’s couldn’t be triggered until next summer , Wharton’s the following summer (unless the clu choose otherwise).
This assumes there are such clauses in contracts of other players.

At least that way the club retains some sort of control over future planning.


Originally posted by Painter

It all depends who inserts a buyout clause. If it’s done by the club, no problem, we are protecting our interest . If the player does, not good, as they are protecting themselves with a view to move on.

No other player at the club has a buyout clause, unless someone has hard proof they have and who’s favour is it in.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 10 Jul 24 2.23pm

Olise's was an odd one because we somehow persuaded him to extend his contract for a bigger salary and a higher release clause. When that deal was done, he was already arguably worth more than say £55m, but in my opinion, Parish did very well getting that as the figure.
His injury record isn't great. At the time of signing the new contract he was still in rehab from a hamstring operation the future of which was unknown. It is remarkable that he has recovered as well as he has.
Everything considered, I felt the contract was very fair. The fact that he performed as well as he has since recovering is the ultimate upside which left it looking like he went cheap.
If his progress continues as well at Bayern, who knows what his future holds. As one of the world's most elite clubs it is probable he will stay put especially when you look at the talent playing in his position at the other few elite clubs in Europe.

 

est1905 Flag 10 Jul 24 3.26pm

It isn't a 100% certainty that each young prospect we bring in has to have a release clause. It really depends upon a number of circumstances. Often when a player is plucked from the Championship he is so keen on the move that he will agree to no release clause if the buying club wont agree to one. Wharton is an example. The club also added a layer of protection to his value by signing him to a 5 year contract. With Wharton's potential he he likey to be highly sought after in the first three years of that contract. Thats when you offer him a new deal (without a release clause/with one that's stupid money). He accepts and its happy days. If he rejects it the club will be in a Marc Guehi situation. Reluctantly selling him but on the club's terms and for his true value.
Olise and Eze (IF true-we do not know for sure he has a release clause, only media speculation)are isolated cases. The club probably knew Olise certainly was looking for a stepping stone. Somewhere to learn and improve before he moved to a top club but did not want to be tied to hard to that club. This is a business at the end of the day and the arrangement suited both parties. Lets not forget he had the opportunity to walk a year ago but decided he was still happy where he is and in exchange for a higher release figure agreed to stay put.
There will undoubtedly be more cases like this in the future but I dont believe they will become the rule but will remain the exception.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Jul 24 3.46pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Hard to see why the club would want to have a release clause which precludes a bidding war for an in demand player.

Because, they want to keep the player on their terms. Barcelona have put a billion euro buyout clause in Yamals contract ( the kid, that scored Spain’s wonder goal ). Nobody is going to trigger it, but Barcelona have the player for the length of his contract.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Jul 24 4.22pm

Originally posted by Painter

Because, they want to keep the player on their terms. Barcelona have put a billion euro buyout clause in Yamals contract ( the kid, that scored Spain’s wonder goal ). Nobody is going to trigger it, but Barcelona have the player for the length of his contract.

Yes but buy outs are compulsory in Spain and Barcelona are big enough to set them where they like. If there's no clause can't the club just refuse a transfer offer?

 

YT Flag Oxford 10 Jul 24 4.33pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Yes but buy outs are compulsory in Spain and Barcelona are big enough to set them where they like. If there's no clause can't the club just refuse a transfer offer?

Of course they can. In a free market, which Spain clearly isn't, there is no justification whatsoever for a club to insist on a buyout clause.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

eaglesdare Flag 10 Jul 24 11.04pm

If I was in the players position I would definitely have a release clause. Likes of Zaha never had one and could have gone when arsenal came in with a 50 million bid. He resented us ever since imo.

It's a smart thing to do when a player inserts a release clause and im sure we will see more of them.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Jul 24 11.24pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

If I was in the players position I would definitely have a release clause. Likes of Zaha never had one and could have gone when arsenal came in with a 50 million bid. He resented us ever since imo.

It's a smart thing to do when a player inserts a release clause and im sure we will see more of them.

Or he could have let his contract run down and not accept a pay rise every 18 months for a three year extension.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Jul 24 8.24am

In answer to the OP's question - yes they are if you're getting a player like Olise.

We lifelong fans will support our team whatever BUT it's magic when we're entertained in the process by rare talents like Michael. We took full advantage of the release clause in his Reading contract and I didn't hear anyone complaining about us getting him so cheaply. Whilst his injuries deprived us of seeing him more, what we have seen from him got us off our seats on so many occasions.

For clubs at our level in the PL (or clubs lower down the football pyramid for that matter) release clauses are inevitable where there's a player who has the talent. Do you think Reading would have agreed to a release clause if they didn't think Olise was a rare talent?

Edited by doombear (11 Jul 2024 8.25am)

 

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 11 Jul 24 11.05am

as mentioned we got olise by paying his release clause, bayern did it to us, much rather we get the release clause money rather then have a player sulking and then going for next to nothing a few years later.

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

palace99 Flag New Mills 12 Jul 24 10.31am

Olise's agent was quite switched on and got a release clause inserted at Reading, when he had barely kicked a ball so it was pretty obvious he would do the same at Palace.

The contract renewal last year was clearly controlled by the agent and although the release clause was increased it was still set at a reasonable level. The fact that both the previous and this release clause were pretty well known indicates the agent was touting his player around to clubs.

Other than Olise i think it is only Eze who has one and this seems to be on the back of Olise's renewal.

I'm not sure they make too much difference to be honest. If a player wants to go there is not a lot a club can do about it. If you keep an unhappy player his performances will deteriorate and it will affect the whole squad (see Zaha for the season after the Arsenal move fell through).

Look at the Marc Guehi situation. Signed a 5 year contract and has been a model professional for 3 seasons. He appears less keen on extending so with 2 years left Palace are left with a dilemma. Do we cash in now or let the contract and his value run down. No release clause in sight.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 12 Jul 24 2.32pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

If I was in the players position I would definitely have a release clause. Likes of Zaha never had one and could have gone when arsenal came in with a 50 million bid. He resented us ever since imo.

It's a smart thing to do when a player inserts a release clause and im sure we will see more of them.

My remebrance is he did have one the season before but the club bought it out with a massive pay rise. He claimed at the time of the Arsenal bid that SP had agentleman's agreement with him he would be sold if suitable offer came in. Arsenals was not suitable as we were not willing for staged payments and wanted higher figure on staged payments.

A lot of players will have release clauses but we probably hear nothing about them until a club wants to purchase. There is also of course lots of situations where players are sold below release clause.

Olise in some ways was a special case He had the release clause which Chelsea tried to trigger but we claim that they broke rules in doing so. They backed off , cancelled loan of young left back who went to Newcastle and Olise signed a new contract giving him more money and us higher release clause. I think he would have stayed another season but Bayern's offer was too good for him so he decided to go and good luck to him.

Reports on Eze and Geuhi leaving are all over clickbate and the former may have a release clause (or possibly an agreement that above a certain figure he can talk to other clubs). It is all conjecture but neither will move unless they are guaranteed first team football. The clubs that are reported to be interested already have players in their position who they are unlikely to drop so will either be interested? Will both be better signing a new contract with a release clause set around £80 million which comes into operation at end of next season (possibly wit a stipulation it is voided if we get into Europe)

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are release clauses worth the pain?