You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rak-Sakyi Loan
November 16 2026 2.04am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rak-Sakyi Loan


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Palace in the Blood Flag 19 Jul 24 9.52pm

Click bate is full of discussion about him being allowed to leave on Loan. Most of championship seem interested plus Southampton. There are rumours we have turned down later who wanted to include option to buy.
I wonder if we can learn from other sides like Chelsea villa etc. Loan him fee 4 million with obligation to buy at 35 million if they are not relegated next season. Sell on clause of 20% and right to match any offers and a relegation clause for 5 years after sale. What do people think?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Jul 24 6.03am

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood


I wonder if we can learn from other sides like Chelsea villa etc. Loan him fee 4 million with obligation to buy at 35 million if they are not relegated next season. Sell on clause of 20% and right to match any offers and a relegation clause for 5 years after sale. What do people think?

I think that will ensure that no-one bothers and he won't get the experience that we want for him

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 20 Jul 24 9.23am

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

Click bate is full of discussion about him being allowed to leave on Loan. Most of championship seem interested plus Southampton. There are rumours we have turned down later who wanted to include option to buy.
I wonder if we can learn from other sides like Chelsea villa etc. Loan him fee 4 million with obligation to buy at 35 million if they are not relegated next season. Sell on clause of 20% and right to match any offers and a relegation clause for 5 years after sale. What do people think?

35 million?? He’s really not as good as that, the fact that he made his debut for us 3 years ago and has had no impact in our first team should tell you that. Other clubs are fine with taking him for a season with no major commitment, but as midland said, they won’t exactly be queuing up with the sort of money you’re talking about. They might give us your 4 million for a permanent transfer, and even that would be pushing it for a player with hardly any first team experience

Edited by monkey (20 Jul 2024 9.23am)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 20 Jul 24 9.39am

One thing is for sure is he needs regular football as his development has stalled a little. Wherever he goes the best place will be a fine balance between guaranteed regular playing time and playing at the highest level possible. I imagine this will end up being to a championship side. As for setting a high fee for obligation to buy, feels unfortunately fanciful for a player who has produced one good season in League 1 two years ago.

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 20 Jul 24 11.00am

He needs game time at a higher level than Charlton. Had to be Championship ideally to a team that plays attacking football with a high press and has an experienced coach who can improve his game. I don’t watch enough Championship football to know who that might be but Farke at Leeds or Wilder at Sheffield United seem reasonable options.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 22 Jul 24 9.49am

Southampton have offered 7 million, i'd say hes worth atleast 20 but saying that his goal against charlton was top draw so maybe give him a chance in the first team? could save us a lot of money

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Jul 24 10.27am

The fact that Glasner barely played JRS once he was fit again suggests he's not shown enough in training to convince him, but the cameo against Charlton may have caught his attention. The issue is that as it stands we haven't replaced Olise, and until we do can the club risk letting JRS leave, even on a loan? The idea of us kicking off the season with Schlupp on the right fills me with dread. Ideally, we get in one or two additions to fill Olise's boots and then find the best loan possible for JRS to develop.

 

The groover Flag Danbury 22 Jul 24 10.27am

We can play him in the Carabao cup before the window closes.

If he looks good keep him for the bench.

Leeds are in for a loan as well.

Don't sell as once he fills out he will be a real talent.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 22 Jul 24 11.04am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

The fact that Glasner barely played JRS once he was fit again suggests he's not shown enough in training to convince him, but the cameo against Charlton may have caught his attention. The issue is that as it stands we haven't replaced Olise, and until we do can the club risk letting JRS leave, even on a loan? The idea of us kicking off the season with Schlupp on the right fills me with dread. Ideally, we get in one or two additions to fill Olise's boots and then find the best loan possible for JRS to develop.

Ayew plays right & Schlupp left. Tho they did swap for the Charlton game, why, only OG knows. Perhaps he was wanting to see if JS can play like MO & cut inside onto his left foot.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

mileend Flag East London 22 Jul 24 2.11pm

The Guardian report that Southampton have made a £12m bid for Rak-Sakyi - but Palace only want a loan out

[Link]

underneath the worrying main story about Eze and Man City

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 22 Jul 24 3.01pm

Originally posted by mileend

The Guardian report that Southampton have made a £12m bid for Rak-Sakyi - but Palace only want a loan out

[Link]

underneath the worrying main story about Eze and Man City

Would be amazed if Southampton offered £12m. If so, we should accept that.

To me he looks well short of Premier League quality. The best we can hope for is a full season on loan in the Championship with game time to see if he can cut the mustard. If he can, fantastic. He needs to earn his place in the team. Promoting good championship players has worked well for us in recent years.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 22 Jul 24 3.15pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Would be amazed if Southampton offered £12m. If so, we should accept that.

To me he looks well short of Premier League quality. The best we can hope for is a full season on loan in the Championship with game time to see if he can cut the mustard. If he can, fantastic. He needs to earn his place in the team. Promoting good championship players has worked well for us in recent years.

i'd have to agree. I like him, but not sure he is Prem ready.

£12m for an untried talent is reasonable business.

My slight concern is that the £12m no doubt includes potential add on, so is probably £6m upfront, £3m with appearances and maybe £3m if Southampton stay up.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 22 Jul 24 3.24pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Would be amazed if Southampton offered £12m. If so, we should accept that.

To me he looks well short of Premier League quality. The best we can hope for is a full season on loan in the Championship with game time to see if he can cut the mustard. If he can, fantastic. He needs to earn his place in the team. Promoting good championship players has worked well for us in recent years.

Well, he would do, only having 10 apps in 3 years whilst being in the U18's & U21's.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 22 Jul 24 4.17pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Well, he would do, only having 10 apps in 3 years whilst being in the U18's & U21's.

Well, yes. Hence why we should take £12m if offered as he doesn't appear good enough. If he was, he'd have played more.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 22 Jul 24 4.46pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Well, yes. Hence why we should take £12m if offered as he doesn't appear good enough. If he was, he'd have played more.

Err, you do realise he also spent a whole season on loan to give him better experience, so no, i don't think the club should accept any permanent offer, yet.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Jul 24 4.55pm

I think it's too early to sell Rak Sakyi, I have my doubts but I think a year in the championship and we will know.

As somebody else said it's unlikely Southampton have offered £12m
without any performance clauses. So even if he fails in the loan his value wont drop that much.

On the other hand if he comes back PL oven ready we could be looking at big money.

Find him a decent championship club that has a similar style to ours and let's see.

 


One more point

Jacey Flag 22 Jul 24 6.29pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I think it's too early to sell Rak Sakyi, I have my doubts but I think a year in the championship and we will know.

As somebody else said it's unlikely Southampton have offered £12m
without any performance clauses. So even if he fails in the loan his value wont drop that much.

On the other hand if he comes back PL oven ready we could be looking at big money.

Find him a decent championship club that has a similar style to ours and let's see.

Injured for large part of last season and never given an opportunity under Roy.
Did stunningly well at Charlton and a loan to a top Championship team will give us an opportunity to analyse his performances,rather than an unnecessary sale.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Jul 24 8.15am

Originally posted by Jacey

Injured for large part of last season and never given an opportunity under Roy.
Did stunningly well at Charlton and a loan to a top Championship team will give us an opportunity to analyse his performances,rather than an unnecessary sale.


Agreed. There is a very good reason why he's only had 10 PL games in 3 years:
- 1st year: he wasn't ready
. 2nd year: he had his very successful loan at Charlton where despite being our player he won their player of the season award
- 3rd year: Roy wouldn't let him go on loan because of the Olise injury but then wouldn't give JRS meaningful game time. JRS was then injured for a large part of the season.
JRS showed in his brief cameo against Charlton last week that he can make a difference. I think he still needs more self-confidence and a loan to a good Championship club should enable him to attain that and come back ready for some serious first team action with us.

Let's not forget he's still only 21 so IMO far too early to write him off.

 

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 23 Jul 24 10.18am

He’s one of those players who if we sold we’d regret the decision when he gets better and better.

I’d loan him out for another year to a team like QPR or West Brom. I know it’s a bit of a luxury but it’s not as if we’re short of cash at the moment I think it will pay off in the near future.

Edited by XKudu (23 Jul 2024 10.22am)

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 23 Jul 24 11.11am

Sky reporting he wants to leave, the saints are willing to increase offer as he is keen to play under Martin?

Edited by DANGERCLOSE (23 Jul 2024 11.12am)

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rak-Sakyi Loan