You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Tom Ince All Hype ?
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Tom Ince All Hype ?


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
james03 Flag Bangkok 05 Mar 14 8.35am

Good player that is not in doubt.

That he adds an extra dimension and goal scoring threat is also not in doubt.

However, I am very concerned to see all of these soundbites from him every day - it just seems odd. It is like he is Lionel Messi dropping in for a few months to help us out. He is most certainly NOT that good.

Yes I am aware the press are likely all over him but it is surely easy enough to say 'sorry chaps no comment I am too busy." There have been four times more quotes from Ince in the past three weeks than all our other players combined.

I want him to do his talking on the field not come off like some sort of puffed up ambassador of football who is looking to lay the table for whichever club will be buying his next meal.

Edited by james03 (05 Mar 2014 8.36am)

Edited by james03 (05 Mar 2014 8.37am)

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 14 8.58am

Quote james03 at 05 Mar 2014 8.35am

Yes I am aware the press are likely all over him but it is surely easy enough to say 'sorry chaps no comment I am too busy." There have been four times more quotes from Ince in the past three weeks than all our other players combined.

Probably because the 'Press' have paid him much more attention than some of our other players ! If he merely said "No comment" etc etc he might be deemed aloof, uncorporative and other negative things (I can think of some !). He is perhaps only trying to be honest and open, merely answering questions and not dismissive of those who approach him.

 

deano77 Flag guildford 05 Mar 14 11.03am

I do like ince but I feel after zahas exploits last season he's always gonna be compared to those high standards , but he was playing for a poor team in Blackpool but did score goals!! The prem is a lot higher standard , I think hel help us stay up but think hel be off in the summer , prefer him more central than wide right though

 


liverpool 3 palace 4 1990 fa cup semi final!what a day

Mstrobez Flag 05 Mar 14 11.11am

Quote james03 at 05 Mar 2014 8.35am

Good player that is not in doubt.

That he adds an extra dimension and goal scoring threat is also not in doubt.

However, I am very concerned to see all of these soundbites from him every day - it just seems odd. It is like he is Lionel Messi dropping in for a few months to help us out. He is most certainly NOT that good.

Yes I am aware the press are likely all over him but it is surely easy enough to say 'sorry chaps no comment I am too busy." There have been four times more quotes from Ince in the past three weeks than all our other players combined.

I want him to do his talking on the field not come off like some sort of puffed up ambassador of football who is looking to lay the table for whichever club will be buying his next meal.

Edited by james03 (05 Mar 2014 8.36am)

Edited by james03 (05 Mar 2014 8.37am)


That is such an exaggeration. Get off the lads back, whether or not he is Messi - he has still been consistently impressive at his age and I think he desereves credit for NOT doing a Wilf and going to a big prem side before his time.

We shouldn't discourage our young talents and we need to get fully behind them, so they feel welcome. And I would much prefer to have a young talent who speaks to the press a bit, then no Ince at all.

I guarantee he will prove a lot of people wrong for the duration of the season and alot of the people telling him what he can or can't do will be singing his praises.

GET OFF THE LADS BACK

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

james03 Flag Bangkok 05 Mar 14 11.52am

Quote Mstrobez at 05 Mar 2014 11.11am

Quote james03 at 05 Mar 2014 8.35am

Good player that is not in doubt.

That he adds an extra dimension and goal scoring threat is also not in doubt.

However, I am very concerned to see all of these soundbites from him every day - it just seems odd. It is like he is Lionel Messi dropping in for a few months to help us out. He is most certainly NOT that good.

Yes I am aware the press are likely all over him but it is surely easy enough to say 'sorry chaps no comment I am too busy." There have been four times more quotes from Ince in the past three weeks than all our other players combined.

I want him to do his talking on the field not come off like some sort of puffed up ambassador of football who is looking to lay the table for whichever club will be buying his next meal.

Edited by james03 (05 Mar 2014 8.36am)

Edited by james03 (05 Mar 2014 8.37am)


That is such an exaggeration. Get off the lads back, whether or not he is Messi - he has still been consistently impressive at his age and I think he desereves credit for NOT doing a Wilf and going to a big prem side before his time.

We shouldn't discourage our young talents and we need to get fully behind them, so they feel welcome. And I would much prefer to have a young talent who speaks to the press a bit, then no Ince at all.

I guarantee he will prove a lot of people wrong for the duration of the season and alot of the people telling him what he can or can't do will be singing his praises.

GET OFF THE LADS BACK

I am NOT getting on his back. I am merely suggesting that the number of press releases we have from him is out of proportion to his status in our team.

He is with us to gain experience at this level of football NOT learning how to handle the mdeia. I understand they all want a piece of him but sometimes less is more.

I support him and our signing of him 100% but I really do not believe that a guy who has been here five minutes, has no experience at this level and is very much learning his trade should be giving interviews every day.

I just want him to learn his craft and put in some decent performances between now and the end of the season - he can then sit and talk to the media non stop for three months if he so chooses, just NOT now.

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 05 Mar 14 1.31pm

Quote Plane at 04 Mar 2014 3.42pm

Quote Donnveronica at 04 Mar 2014 3.29pm

Parr & Murray let their football do the talking for them..NOT the media ..

Do they have very famous and prominent father?

I didnt realise they were brothers.....

 


All good. Nothing bad.

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 05 Mar 14 8.42pm

Haven't read the posts, but surely we can only judge Ince in games where Pulis deems us good enough to be allowed to attack, like against West Brom. Against Man Utd and Swansea he deemed us not good enough to risk going forward and deployed him as an auxiliary full back. Will be interested to see us actually go for teams and see just what we are capable of. I mean the worst that can happen is relegation, but the World will still be turning and life will go on.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 05 Mar 14 10.14pm

Quote Dangermouse at 05 Mar 2014 8.42pm

Haven't read the posts, but surely we can only judge Ince in games where Pulis deems us good enough to be allowed to attack, like against West Brom. Against Man Utd and Swansea he deemed us not good enough to risk going forward and deployed him as an auxiliary full back. Will be interested to see us actually go for teams and see just what we are capable of. I mean the worst that can happen is relegation, but the World will still be turning and life will go on.

Exactly, Dangermouse. If peeps don't like what this young man is doing on the pitch, blame TP. If they don't like what he's doing of the pitch...well that's his private life..who cares.... don't read it. Its people who read this nonsense that encourage the papers to print all this irrelevant rubbish.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 07 Mar 14 11.56am

Quote Donnveronica at 03 Mar 2014 10.12pm

He seems to talk the talk but is he really as good as his reputation or is it all hype ?
I was impressed with his performance against WBA , but against UTD he was mediocre , & yesterday I think he was poor to say the least.

What do you mean he talks the talk? Are you trying to suggest he's arrogant and egotistical? Because he is very far from that.

 

barrie2301 Flag crystal palace 09 Mar 14 3.59pm

YES.. had a first good game for us but has done nothing since. looks totally out of his depth whilst defending and does very little going down the wing.

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 09 Mar 14 4.12pm

He needs to play just behind the striker, He did that against West Brom and looked brilliant. We haven't used him like that again in that position since, which is beyond me. Ince just behind Murray could be brilliant.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 09 Mar 14 4.13pm

Has not even been given a chance yet. The only game we've attacked in he's looked good, but agree he's not a very good extra fullback. Didn't realise we had bought him in to do that job though.
Also why does doing an interview have an adverse affect on his football?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Stirlingsays Flag 09 Mar 14 4.33pm

Blimey, what a load of moaning about something we can do nothing about.

Judging someone so quickly is just foolish....I remember the same nonsense rushed judgements about Jedinak.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Eaglesnut Flag Waterford 09 Mar 14 6.39pm

As has been said...give the bloke a chance.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Tom Ince All Hype ?