You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Homelessness
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Homelessness


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
johnfirewall Flag 26 Feb 16 3.35pm

I have heard people suggest that those who want British homeless to have priority over refugees, never actually cared about the homeless prior to the current crisis.

Maybe they didn't but I'd say starting to give a fcuk now is a pragmatic approach rather than having nothing more than a dream of everyone being looked after.

But really what of the current homeless when it comes to new arrivals getting homes, Nick?

A friend recently expressed her disenchantment over her work for a homeless shelter when she calculated half the residents were eastern European. It echos the obvious question of why people came (or stayed, assuming they lost jobs while over here) without work. wouldn't be surprised if a few were still working.

I know you'd like to say it was due to bedroom tax but it's important to work out why people become homeless, English or otherwise. Realistically how many on the streets were kicked out of their properties?

Having a home falls under either owning, renting or living with family. Any of us could easily deviate from those categories and sofa surf for example. This would be by choice, likely due to market forces rather than any specific government policy. Hopefully the new taxes on buy-to-lets will lower prices though.

Edited by johnfirewall (26 Feb 2016 3.36pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 26 Feb 16 3.47pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

I have heard people suggest that those who want British homeless to have priority over refugees, never actually cared about the homeless prior to the current crisis.

Maybe they didn't but I'd say starting to give a fcuk now is a pragmatic approach rather than having nothing more than a dream of everyone being looked after.

But really what of the current homeless when it comes to new arrivals getting homes, Nick?

A friend recently expressed her disenchantment over her work for a homeless shelter when she calculated half the residents were eastern European. It echos the obvious question of why people came (or stayed, assuming they lost jobs while over here) without work. wouldn't be surprised if a few were still working.

I know you'd like to say it was due to bedroom tax but it's important to work out why people become homeless, English or otherwise. Realistically how many on the streets were kicked out of their properties?

Having a home falls under either owning, renting or living with family. Any of us could easily deviate from those categories and sofa surf for example. This would be by choice, likely due to market forces rather than any specific government policy. Hopefully the new taxes on buy-to-lets will lower prices though.

Edited by johnfirewall (26 Feb 2016 3.36pm)


[Link]
Some reasons for homelessness from shelter. The main one is relationship breakdown for men and escaping sexual/domestic violence for women. I'm pretty sure it's not through 'their choice' as stuk stated earlier.

I've never understood why people would come from abroad to be homeless here, it ain't for the weather!

 

johnfirewall Flag 26 Feb 16 4.03pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


[Link]
Some reasons for homelessness from shelter. The main one is relationship breakdown for men and escaping sexual/domestic violence for women. I'm pretty sure it's not through 'their choice' as stuk stated earlier.

I've never understood why people would come from abroad to be homeless here, it ain't for the weather!

Several of my mates left stable homes in their teens just because they could get their own place without having to work even though it was just a bedsit so I've a lot of sympathy for anyone ending up homeless upon fleeing abuse. This was under Labour so I guess as with some other Tory policies to reduce the number of scroungers this has resulted in the baby being thrown out with the bathwater.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 26 Feb 16 4.11pm

My solution

We should round up everyone off the streets.

Those who are economic migrants be sent home (as happened a couple of years ago)

Those who are on hard times and or have mental issues but in one of the many now empty army camps. Give them a six month deal.

In that time they are fed and watered and paid a basic wage. 50% they get weekly the other is saved for when they leave.

During the six months (or however long), they receive vocational training (if appropriate), PT, heath care, psychiatric help, etc.

They are free to leave at any time but they forfeit the 50% salary (there could be exceptions e.g. reunited with estranged family)

Towards the end of their time they are helped to find work and released into a hostel.

Might not be perfect but I reckon it would help with a lot of them

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (26 Feb 2016 4.12pm)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Stuk Flag Top half 26 Feb 16 4.24pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

My solution

We should round up everyone off the streets.

Those who are economic migrants be sent home (as happened a couple of years ago)

Those who are on hard times and or have mental issues but in one of the many now empty army camps. Give them a six month deal.

In that time they are fed and watered and paid a basic wage. 50% they get weekly the other is saved for when they leave.

During the six months (or however long), they receive vocational training (if appropriate), PT, heath care, psychiatric help, etc.

They are free to leave at any time but they forfeit the 50% salary (there could be exceptions e.g. reunited with estranged family)

Towards the end of their time they are helped to find work and released into a hostel.

Might not be perfect but I reckon it would help with a lot of them

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (26 Feb 2016 4.12pm)

I'd agree with doing all of that but you know what you would still have at the conclusion of it? Homeless people.

It's not something you could ever stop, even if they made it into the most illegal thing you could do.


Edited by Stuk (26 Feb 2016 4.25pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 16 4.28pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

My solution

We should round up everyone off the streets.

Those who are economic migrants be sent home (as happened a couple of years ago)

Those who are on hard times and or have mental issues but in one of the many now empty army camps. Give them a six month deal.

In that time they are fed and watered and paid a basic wage. 50% they get weekly the other is saved for when they leave.

During the six months (or however long), they receive vocational training (if appropriate), PT, heath care, psychiatric help, etc.

They are free to leave at any time but they forfeit the 50% salary (there could be exceptions e.g. reunited with estranged family)

Towards the end of their time they are helped to find work and released into a hostel.

Might not be perfect but I reckon it would help with a lot of them

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (26 Feb 2016 4.12pm)

The biggest problem for the homeless is getting a stable basis from which to rebuild as basis for a life. Systems in place to help the homeless are absurdly complex for anyone who lives on the street to make use of. Over the last 20 years the rules regarding benefits have increasingly created 'holes' in the safety net which leave homeless largely at the mercy of charities.

Unsurprisingly, alcoholism and addiction play a role in some becoming homeless, but more often in keeping them homeless. Sleeping rough is hard, drugs and booze can help with that. Similarly whilst people with mental health problems end up on the street, more develop problems because of their situation.

Friend of mine is currently homeless. Groups like Shelter, St Mungos etc have absurd requirements necessary before they can 'provide assistance' whilst the council are largely useless (referring people to charities, to whom they outsource their responsibility).

Without an address, its impossible to claim benefits and get out through that route. Whilst charities demand that they find 'each homeless' person three times before even registering them. Hostels tend to be limited in their ability to assist (and of course if you're in a shelter you can't 'be found' by charities). Changes in the law also mean that people cannot provide an address for a homeless person to claim from either.

The system basically has abandoned the homeless and has failed to provide a basis of people to escape from what is a terrible experience, whilst homelessness in the UK seems to be rising. Whilst some people may have made decisions that lead to their situation, who among us hasn't made bad decisions in life.

Ultimately though, the welfare system was developed to secure the most vulnerable and desperate among society, and that clearly is those who live and sleep rough.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Feb 16 4.32pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I'd agree with doing all of that but you know what you would still have at the conclusion of it? Homeless people.

It's not something you could ever stop, even if they made it into the most illegal thing you could do.


Edited by Stuk (26 Feb 2016 4.25pm)

I think a degree of homelessness in society is inevitable, the problem is how to create a reasonable basis to assist people from recovering from homelessness and protect them from exploitation, abuse and violence in society.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 27 Feb 16 10.59am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

My solution

We should round up everyone off the streets.

Those who are economic migrants be sent home (as happened a couple of years ago)

Those who are on hard times and or have mental issues but in one of the many now empty army camps. Give them a six month deal.

In that time they are fed and watered and paid a basic wage. 50% they get weekly the other is saved for when they leave.

During the six months (or however long), they receive vocational training (if appropriate), PT, heath care, psychiatric help, etc.

They are free to leave at any time but they forfeit the 50% salary (there could be exceptions e.g. reunited with estranged family)

Towards the end of their time they are helped to find work and released into a hostel.

Might not be perfect but I reckon it would help with a lot of them

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (26 Feb 2016 4.12pm)

A plan that seems to have a lot of merits.

You are correct that it is not the perfect solution, but might help a good few and that would be a good thing.

at least you've tried to find a solution rather than just accepting there will always be homeless people.

 

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Homelessness