Quote Old Chap at 02 Oct 2015 4.22pm
So the answer is more guns!
The NRA argued after the cinema shooting if everyone had been armed then the nutter would have been shot before he killed as many as he did. Can you imagine a cinema full of people, in the dark, all blasting away
What age do you allow school children to carry guns to school - 16? 14? How about 5 - I'm sure there are "baby" guns on sale for toddlers
In many of the broadly publicised mass shootings there has been one or more bystanders packing a gun themselves. From what I've read, mostly they have chosen not to pull their gun so as not to appear to be part of the attack and get targeted themselves by one of the other gun-carrying bystanders. At the Tuscon mall shooting, one bloke told reporters that he was this close to shooting the hero who actually took down the gunman.
This is the hero-fallacy on which the NRA bases its entire pro-gun argument: the only thing to stop a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun. It's bulls***, of course.
Meanwhile, the mostly toothless assault weapons ban that was allowed to expire in 2004 (I think) did at least ban over-sized magazines. In the cases where the shooter has been taken down by citizens, it's almost entirely the case that it happens when stopping to reload.
The NRA will show you a video of a trained and practiced gun expert speed-loading his hand gun. But he only does it once, and it's not in a stressful situation...and he's been practicing and may have had multiple takes to get it right. Also, he reloads only once, not 5 times like the Sandy Hook shooter, or not at all like the Aurora movie theatre shooter who had a 100-round butterfly mag.
Then, even though the Sandy Hook shooter was not taken down by outside forces, a dozen kids managed to run out of one classroom while he fumbled to reload. How many more kids would have survived if he'd had to reload, say, 15 times to fire his 150 rounds (actually 151, the last one being into his own brain from his handgun once he'd emptied all his assault rifle mags) instead of 5 times with his 30-round mags? How many fewer victims in all these shootings if the shooter had to reload every 5 or 10 shots?
There are things that can be done that do not impinge on the right to bear arms: eliminating the gun show loophole and having universal background checks, even for private sales; banning assault rifles; limiting magazine sizes (obviously); micro-imprinting bullets so we know from what gun they were fired; and registering every f***ing gun so when they pull a bullet out of someone, they can trace the gun to its owner.
You already can't buy certain types of "arms", like fully-automatic weapons, so there are already limits to how far the 2nd amendment goes; we're just debating the margin, that's all.
Edited by Ray in Houston (07 Oct 2015 10.51pm)
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.
|