This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
UK Population to hit 74 Million by 2039
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Goal Machine The Cronx 02 Nov 15 10.32pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 31 Oct 2015 12.02am
Quote leifandersonshair at 30 Oct 2015 6.12pm
Immigration is not the main problem. It is a contributory factor, true, but the main problem is an aging population. UK population may rise to 74 million by 2039- by 2030 average UK life expectancy will be over 85 for men, and over 87 for women. THIS is a much bigger problem. Essentially, a much larger number of people will be drawing state pensions and using the NHS more frequently for a much longer period.
Not sure where the answer to this lies, barring some sort of Logan's Run style carousel for the over 75's...
They won't be drawing pensions the like of anything you see today mate.....I'm quite sure of that.
A basic grasp of economics and population percentage tells you that.
State pension will gradually be phased out over the next 40/50 years, hence the introduction of auto-enrolment pensions (compulsory for both the employer and employee to contribute to a pension). The government recognise that the ageing population is becoming too much of a burden on the state and this will help combat the issue.
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 03 Nov 15 9.53am |
|
Quote Stuk at 02 Nov 2015 2.43pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Nov 2015 2.21pm
Is it immigrantion causing a problem for public services - After all most if not nearly all of the immigration deficit is working migrants, who pay tax and NI. What happens to all that tax being paid by them? There is an issue in that they keep wages low and encourage corporations to avoid having to attract workers from the traditional work pool (the unemployed UK citizens), but those migrants are also paying for those public services as well.
Or is it the cuts in funding, and continued cuts in Corporation tax that are the problem?
I suspect the later.
Adding more users (wherever they come from) to the existing number of services will always cause a problem with public services.
Immigrants who pay tax and NI might cover their own running costs as such, but they have contributed nowt to the initial/existing costs of everything.
Even if 75% of all immigrants are adults, and 90% of those get jobs contributing tax and NI that leaves a third who are contributing nothing and simply drawing from the system. This is before you factor in the cost of any benefit they may receive before becoming a contributor.
Indeed, but the issue I was getting at is that austerity cuts and cuts in corporation tax have reduced revenue, and that the government has increased pressure on the public systems and infrastructure, and not increased spending to account for that (in fact for most areas its the same or less (when you account for inflation).
Which has far more of an impact than just the increase in numbers. Blame the symptom, not the problem tends to be how the last three governments have turned the UK into a corporate state, rather than a democratic one (and Corbyn is himself a symptom of that, just as the rise of the Far Right has been).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
| Hoof Hearted 03 Nov 15 10.00am |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Nov 2015 2.21pm
Is it immigrantion causing a problem for public services - After all most if not nearly all of the immigration deficit is working migrants, who pay tax and NI. What happens to all that tax being paid by them? There is an issue in that they keep wages low and encourage corporations to avoid having to attract workers from the traditional work pool (the unemployed UK citizens), but those migrants are also paying for those public services as well.
Or is it the cuts in funding, and continued cuts in Corporation tax that are the problem?
I suspect the later.
Jamie (and others)..... FFS forget about the economic argument... it's effect is largely equal in terms of good and bad.
The real harm of immigration is the effect it has on the infrastructure which only gets worse with each and every influx.
If we are struggling to cope now with these levels, imagine the UK with 10 million more inhabitants!
|
The Sash Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 03 Nov 15 10.15am |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Nov 2015 2.21pm
Is it immigrantion causing a problem for public services - After all most if not nearly all of the immigration deficit is working migrants, who pay tax and NI. What happens to all that tax being paid by them? There is an issue in that they keep wages low and encourage corporations to avoid having to attract workers from the traditional work pool (the unemployed UK citizens), but those migrants are also paying for those public services as well.
Or is it the cuts in funding, and continued cuts in Corporation tax that are the problem?
I suspect the later.
I suspect the answer is both.
More 'net' people puts strain on public services and housing + a government that is swinging a huge axe at those services year on year + huge corporates keeping a very low wage structure, zero hours contracts and poor working T&C'S that only new immigrants can take = f*cked
Edited by The Sash (03 Nov 2015 10.16am)
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|
chris123 hove actually 03 Nov 15 10.21am |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Nov 2015 9.53am
Quote Stuk at 02 Nov 2015 2.43pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Nov 2015 2.21pm
Is it immigrantion causing a problem for public services - After all most if not nearly all of the immigration deficit is working migrants, who pay tax and NI. What happens to all that tax being paid by them? There is an issue in that they keep wages low and encourage corporations to avoid having to attract workers from the traditional work pool (the unemployed UK citizens), but those migrants are also paying for those public services as well.
Or is it the cuts in funding, and continued cuts in Corporation tax that are the problem?
I suspect the later.
Adding more users (wherever they come from) to the existing number of services will always cause a problem with public services.
Immigrants who pay tax and NI might cover their own running costs as such, but they have contributed nowt to the initial/existing costs of everything.
Even if 75% of all immigrants are adults, and 90% of those get jobs contributing tax and NI that leaves a third who are contributing nothing and simply drawing from the system. This is before you factor in the cost of any benefit they may receive before becoming a contributor.
Indeed, but the issue I was getting at is that austerity cuts and cuts in corporation tax have reduced revenue, and that the government has increased pressure on the public systems and infrastructure, and not increased spending to account for that (in fact for most areas its the same or less (when you account for inflation).
Which has far more of an impact than just the increase in numbers. Blame the symptom, not the problem tends to be how the last three governments have turned the UK into a corporate state, rather than a democratic one (and Corbyn is himself a symptom of that, just as the rise of the Far Right has been).
I think that revenues have gone up and not reduced at all.
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 03 Nov 15 10.24am |
|
Quote chris123 at 03 Nov 2015 10.21am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Nov 2015 9.53am
Quote Stuk at 02 Nov 2015 2.43pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Nov 2015 2.21pm
Is it immigrantion causing a problem for public services - After all most if not nearly all of the immigration deficit is working migrants, who pay tax and NI. What happens to all that tax being paid by them? There is an issue in that they keep wages low and encourage corporations to avoid having to attract workers from the traditional work pool (the unemployed UK citizens), but those migrants are also paying for those public services as well.
Or is it the cuts in funding, and continued cuts in Corporation tax that are the problem?
I suspect the later.
Adding more users (wherever they come from) to the existing number of services will always cause a problem with public services.
Immigrants who pay tax and NI might cover their own running costs as such, but they have contributed nowt to the initial/existing costs of everything.
Even if 75% of all immigrants are adults, and 90% of those get jobs contributing tax and NI that leaves a third who are contributing nothing and simply drawing from the system. This is before you factor in the cost of any benefit they may receive before becoming a contributor.
Indeed, but the issue I was getting at is that austerity cuts and cuts in corporation tax have reduced revenue, and that the government has increased pressure on the public systems and infrastructure, and not increased spending to account for that (in fact for most areas its the same or less (when you account for inflation).
Which has far more of an impact than just the increase in numbers. Blame the symptom, not the problem tends to be how the last three governments have turned the UK into a corporate state, rather than a democratic one (and Corbyn is himself a symptom of that, just as the rise of the Far Right has been).
I think that revenues have gone up and not reduced at all.
Then spending should be rising to meet demand
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 03 Nov 15 10.26am |
|
Quote The Sash at 03 Nov 2015 10.15am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Nov 2015 2.21pm
Is it immigrantion causing a problem for public services - After all most if not nearly all of the immigration deficit is working migrants, who pay tax and NI. What happens to all that tax being paid by them? There is an issue in that they keep wages low and encourage corporations to avoid having to attract workers from the traditional work pool (the unemployed UK citizens), but those migrants are also paying for those public services as well.
Or is it the cuts in funding, and continued cuts in Corporation tax that are the problem?
I suspect the later.
I suspect the answer is both.
More 'net' people puts strain on public services and housing + a government that is swinging a huge axe at those services year on year + huge corporates keeping a very low wage structure, zero hours contracts and poor working T&C'S that only new immigrants can take = f*cked
Edited by The Sash (03 Nov 2015 10.16am)
That's pretty much how I see it, the failure of successive governments, including Labour, to fix minimum wage to a decent living wage, and allow cheap migrant labour to fill vacancies, served a corporate driven agenda, rather than the best interests of society (or even migrants who also suffer from the impact on infrastructure, despite also paying tax and NI).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
chris123 hove actually 03 Nov 15 10.36am |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Nov 2015 10.24am
Quote chris123 at 03 Nov 2015 10.21am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Nov 2015 9.53am
Quote Stuk at 02 Nov 2015 2.43pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Nov 2015 2.21pm
Is it immigrantion causing a problem for public services - After all most if not nearly all of the immigration deficit is working migrants, who pay tax and NI. What happens to all that tax being paid by them? There is an issue in that they keep wages low and encourage corporations to avoid having to attract workers from the traditional work pool (the unemployed UK citizens), but those migrants are also paying for those public services as well.
Or is it the cuts in funding, and continued cuts in Corporation tax that are the problem?
I suspect the later.
Adding more users (wherever they come from) to the existing number of services will always cause a problem with public services.
Immigrants who pay tax and NI might cover their own running costs as such, but they have contributed nowt to the initial/existing costs of everything.
Even if 75% of all immigrants are adults, and 90% of those get jobs contributing tax and NI that leaves a third who are contributing nothing and simply drawing from the system. This is before you factor in the cost of any benefit they may receive before becoming a contributor.
Indeed, but the issue I was getting at is that austerity cuts and cuts in corporation tax have reduced revenue, and that the government has increased pressure on the public systems and infrastructure, and not increased spending to account for that (in fact for most areas its the same or less (when you account for inflation).
Which has far more of an impact than just the increase in numbers. Blame the symptom, not the problem tends to be how the last three governments have turned the UK into a corporate state, rather than a democratic one (and Corbyn is himself a symptom of that, just as the rise of the Far Right has been).
I think that revenues have gone up and not reduced at all.
Then spending should be rising to meet demand
Well that's a seperate issue - I was pointing out that what you'd said was incorrect.
|