This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well yes, the man in question clearly was mentally ill, and a known schizophrenic, who had been monumentally failed by the psychiatric care system. That said, your argument presumes that human life has more value, it doesn't argue the case. Humans are animals. Obviously we favour our own species over others, that's a biological imperative though, not an ethical argument. I have no qualms about saying a human life is inherently more valuable. I believe that whole heartedly. We are Capable of higher functions, quite how someone could argue an animal life has equal merit baffles me!
|
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
I have no qualms about saying a human life is inherently more valuable. I believe that whole heartedly. We are Capable of higher functions, quite how someone could argue an animal life has equal merit baffles me! Whether you value human life more or not there is arguably too many humans on the planet. The same can not be said of certain animals, this being one of them. Our higher functions should tell us this but religion and poverty, in the main, cause humans to procreate far too much.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
I have no qualms about saying a human life is inherently more valuable. I believe that whole heartedly. We are Capable of higher functions, quite how someone could argue an animal life has equal merit baffles me! Different functions. Its important to remember that its humans who believe that they're higher functions - and those functions are also exhibited by all primates and mammals to an extent. The thing that really separates us is the capacity for language, which is unique to a human evolutionary development, in the position of the voice box. The human brain arguably lacks specialisation of a degree seen in many other animals. Which requires a lot of neural functionality. For example a dogs capacity for smell or a cats capacity for hearing, is a much higher function than that of humans. I think we're arrogant in believing ourselves superior to any other species, and its this kind of hubris that ultimately undermines humanity.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
And it happens again............ How ferkin stupid are that kids parents? Florida is renowned for Alligators. Letting a 2 year old kid paddle in water or even be close to the edge of a lake/lagoon is more or less inviting the Alligator to have him. Sad, tragic, but easily avoidable. Can't blame the kid, he didn't know the dangers, but the parents did. No signs stating the Alligators were there, just ones saying dont swim. I don't really blame the parents only takes a few seconds for a kid to run off if you dont keep an eye on them, its happened to us all. What i find utterly stupid is Disney, a place predominately populated with young kids has a family beach for kids and families to play on that goes into a lagoon that they know has Alligators in it, surprised something hasn't happened sooner, Truly tragic.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JacksonEagle
No signs stating the Alligators were there, just ones saying dont swim. I don't really blame the parents only takes a few seconds for a kid to run off if you dont keep an eye on them, its happened to us all. What i find utterly stupid is Disney, a place predominately populated with young kids has a family beach for kids and families to play on that goes into a lagoon that they know has Alligators in it, surprised something hasn't happened sooner, Truly tragic. You don't really need them in Florida, and certainly not if you are an American. Having a beach around the lagoon is stupid though, as is killing 5 alligators afterwards to see if they'd eaten him.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| Hoof Hearted 16 Jun 16 12.18pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by JacksonEagle
No signs stating the Alligators were there, just ones saying dont swim. I don't really blame the parents only takes a few seconds for a kid to run off if you dont keep an eye on them, its happened to us all. What i find utterly stupid is Disney, a place predominately populated with young kids has a family beach for kids and families to play on that goes into a lagoon that they know has Alligators in it, surprised something hasn't happened sooner, Truly tragic. There's no signs in Australia about crocodiles, or spiders under the toilet seats either. You've gotta be pretty naive to let your kid paddle in water unattended anywhere.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
There's no signs in Australia about crocodiles, or spiders under the toilet seats either. You've gotta be pretty naive to let your kid paddle in water unattended anywhere. Normally of course I would agree, But at a theme park for kids on a beach for kids... As i said i struggle to see how Disney thought it would be a good idea to have give access to kids to a beach that they know is populated by alligators, then not have the appropiate signage or some sort of divide. I heard one witness said the whole thing happened within 30 seconds... scary You couldn't imagine a theme park in the UK with a lake inhabited by crocs that would allow access to people as well.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JacksonEagle
Normally of course I would agree, But at a theme park for kids on a beach for kids... As i said i struggle to see how Disney thought it would be a good idea to have give access to kids to a beach that they know is populated by alligators, then not have the appropiate signage or some sort of divide. I heard one witness said the whole thing happened within 30 seconds... scary You couldn't imagine a theme park in the UK with a lake inhabited by crocs that would allow access to people as well. It's not in the theme parks, this is a resort near to them. Even if the kid hadn't entered the water he could have been taken that quickly from the beach. They have a good turn of pace.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
It's not in the theme parks, this is a resort near to them. Even if the kid hadn't entered the water he could have been taken that quickly from the beach. They have a good turn of pace. Ahhh my mistake, i thought it was in the park (should read things properly)
|
|
|
Originally posted by JacksonEagle
Ahhh my mistake, i thought it was in the park (should read things properly) I did too initially. You hear Disney and just presume it's the parks, I was expecting it to be the Animal Kingdom.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
There's no signs in Australia about crocodiles, or spiders under the toilet seats either. You've gotta be pretty naive to let your kid paddle in water unattended anywhere. the kid was attended. like 2 inches of water. there's water and sand - kids will go dip their toes in. i have 3 little guys - little ba#tards run off all the time. takes 2 secs for me to be distracted and i've lost site for 10-15 secs. so easy to happen. that sandy beach shouldn't be there if they didn't want kids in the water. it's basically inviting people to go there and dip a toe in. awful.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
I did too initially. You hear Disney and just presume it's the parks, I was expecting it to be the Animal Kingdom. That was precisely my thinking, jumped the gun! Either way absolutely tragic!
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Evolution innit.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
No weakest per se, Evolution doesn't specifically filter out the weakest or weakness, or genes, its about their adaptability and suitability to the environment. The key, of course here is that being a man with mental illness is of no survival benefit when faced with two lions. That said, without mental illness the outcome is pretty similar. Evolution kills the strong too, as exampled by the rise of mammals, due to an environmental change. Its worth remembering that mental illness has increased over the centuries, not decreased, so its not evolutionally speaking disadvantageous (and could even be beneficial). ..the understanding of mental problems has increased, eventually every single human alive will be informed of the mental issues they have.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Inapickle
..the understanding of mental problems has increased, eventually every single human alive will be informed of the mental issues they have. mental issue does not = mental illness. the same as that i can't jump very high does not mean that i have a medical problem. being aware of my jumping restrictions is nice in case i get into a scrape with a kangaroo but it doesn't mean i am classified with a medical problem.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.